Well that just happened. The Oscar nominations have been announced and Seth MacFarlane has shown off a sample of what will probably be his hosting shtick for the evening in question. As past hosts will tell you, this isnt an easy gig. You have to work with your writers to make sure you fill a 3+ hour show with fresh gags, quick pacing, and middle of the road humor. Since these are all areas Mr. MacFarlane has had problems landing consistent success in, perhaps nows a good time to evaluate whether hell end up on the Billy Crystal (Legendary) or David Letterman (NEVER AGAIN!) side of the Oscar Hosting Spectrum. (Patent Pending.) That said, Mr. MacFarlane prepare yourself for a compliment sandwich...Oscar Style.
5. Hes Quick With A JokeBut His Jokes Sometimes Come Off Flat
From the beginnings of Family Guy, all the way out to his recent success with Ted, Seth MacFarlane has always been fast on his feet. You can tell that he rules the writer's room on his various shows, or at the very least he has a very influential role in said rooms. The pacing on his shows has always been fast with jokes going off left and right, and the quantity of the jokes usually overrides the quality. (This is also common in Chuck Lorre sitcoms, the advantage being MacFarlane's because of his slightly higher brow.) Whether you like it or not, you'll end up laughing a couple times during the night. MacFarlane's command of the room will help inject his unique voice into the proceedings. However, this is The Oscars, where the length is at least six times that of a sitcom. So unless MacFarlane is planning on writing a couple episode's worth of material with a complete through-line, he's going to have to learn how to play the host. He's done SNL and a Friar's Club Roast, which are both good practice runs, but he needs some more experience with working "on a leash". Jon Stewart has done a few awards shows, and he knows how to work on a leash. Chris Rock did a decent job when he hosted on Oscar's leash as well. James Franco...the less said about him and/or Bruce Villanch, the better. The point remains, MacFarlane has a narrow line to toe with this gig: he can be edgy like he is on Family Guy, but he has to realize that this both the medium and the industry he chiefly likes to make fun of. He can poke fun at them, but he needs to dial it down for the older folks.
4. Hes Comfortable With Musical Numbers.But They Can Sometimes Be Self Indulgent
Another trick in the Seth MacFarlane arsenal is "use a musical number from an classic and/or obscure musical show/film to move things along". Shows and films he's used in the past include, but aren't limited to, On The Town, The Music Man, and The Conway Twitty Show. Anyone who's watched the Oscars knows that they LOVE musical numbers and tribute montages, especially if they were present for the year Hugh Jackman hosted. MacFarlane is a natural showman with his singing talents, and one could safely assume that the dancing isn't too far off, which makes him a natural for these sorts of segments. The problem is, much like a Family Guy episode, it's these segments that weigh down the running time and slow the proceedings down. Awards shows, like comedy, need to be "1, 2,3,A,B,C, Good Night!" You can tell some jokes, you can crack wise and monologue, but you need to ultimately move it along. Young Film Geeks need their sleep for school, Older Film Geeks need to get to work, and everyone at the show is waiting to drown their sorrows or live like world royalty at the after parties. Musical numbers aren't a bad thing, but they aren't easy to set off without a hitch.
3. Hes Got Enough Characters To Switch BetweenBut Theyre A Bit Recycled
If you scan through all three of his television shows, you will see that MacFarlane has a reliable stable of character formulas involved. The great thing about this is he has an already diversified portfolio of angles and aspects he can consider when he writes a gag. On top of those fresh perspectives is a personality and a voice unique to its own, which will make it easier for him not only to write for himself but also for presenters. Further more, as if to seal the proverbial deal, his caricatures of celebrity royalty will be of better use when some of those people actually perform the role of themselves. Imagine Seth MacFarlane's Jack Nicholson caricature brought to life by Joker Jack himself! However, his portfolio is also a troubling aspect as he's abused its contents through three separate shows. Family Guy, American Dad, and The Cleveland Show all have that same set of characters with diverse perspectives and angles. All of them interact with each other in the same way as they would on any one of his other shows, and they offer little to nothing new to the table. Family Guy mocks The Simpsons, American Dad mocks The Right, Cleveland mocks the other two in equal part and throws in some Southern Racial Tension humor. If this is any indication of MacFarlane's "variety", be prepared for the same sorts of gags over and over and over again for three hours.
2. He Plays Towards A Younger CrowdThat Doesnt Watch The Oscars
Seth's second greatest asset to his hosting gig is one that Oscar has been puzzling over for years: the kids LOVE him. Sure, Billy Crystal's a hysterical singer. Of course, Steve Martin is dry and witty, sometimes bringing the audience in on the gag. Naturally, Whoopi Goldberg will divide the audience, but in the end bring it on home for the cheap seats as well as the Mezzanine and the Orchestra. But they aren't popular with the kids. You can practically hear it in the boardroom when they pitch the next year's show. "It's the kids, Marty! Something's gotta be done about the kids!" Hugh Jackman didn't work, Jon Stewart and Chris Rock worked to a limited extent, and the Hathaway/Franco pairing is STILL ingrained in our minds as half of a train wreck and half of a good time. (I'll let you decide which is which.) The MacFarlane Machine has the kids all sewn up, simply because that's his target audience and he speaks their language. But the cold hard fact still remains, as Reel Big Fish once put it, "The kids don't like it". It's not "cool" to watch an awards show by time you get to the key Oscar demographic. Kids are bombarded with Teen Choice and People's Choice and MTV's Choice awards that frankly, they're over it. The kids that like the popular stuff won't watch because it's not nominated, and the kids that like quirky things won't watch because they're jaded due to the kids awards show favoring dreck like Twilight. This limits your audience to cinephiles, awards show junkies, and older people who still care about the Oscars. THIS is the audience you should be playing to. MacFarlane can bring the kids, but the real trick is can he make them stay?
1. He's Eager...But He's Still Somewhat Unprepared
Overall, Seth MacFarlane's most valuable asset is his own natural likability. He's got a natural smile and wit about him, as if he's eternally at a Cocktail Party. What's more, the man cleans up well, and he seems like the type of guy you'd want to hang out with, if only to help him revive the bygone era he revels in. Not many people can be up for 5:30 in the morning and form coherent sentences, much less improv punchlines with something as mundane as an awards nomination. Seth MacFarlane is the type of guy that it not only seems natural for, but it seems like something he enjoys doing. Just because he enjoys it and is eager to do so, doesn't mean he's all that good at it. If this morning's press conference is any indication, he's going to shoe horn at least one Hitler joke in as the night goes on, and it won't be a funny one. Also, his humor is the type that straddles the line between smug and just really self assured. This line is something he's yet to master the balance of, and this could lead to frustration if he blows even one gag. I don't know the man, but knowing the art of Comedy in as limited a capacity as I do, it's safe to say that the frustration of a gag unsuccessful will ruin further gags after that. The impulse to keep pushing in the same direction is something that needs to be resisted. Any good comedy act who's been around knows that, and MacFarlane simply hasn't been in the game long enough to earn that knowledge. The point of this whole exercise isn't to bring Seth MacFarlane down. On the contrary, it's to help him build a better arsenal. These next couple of weeks are going to be murder, and every minute will count. The MacFarlane Machine is still a viable commodity, and you can just ask anyone who's seen Ted about the improvements he's made between the nadir of his Television efforts and that film. In the end, I wish all of the best to Seth and I hope he can finally bring this show back to the status of something worth watching on TV again. It's the Oscars guys, not the Golden Globes. These actually count, so let's make the show count as much, ok? Best of luck, Seth.