After a nine-year wait and fan anticipation at its highest, the sequel to 2005's Sin City has nearly arrived. With several new yarns being spun taking place before, during and after the events of the original film, the door has been left wide open for a number of actors to reprise their characters, even if some of them hadn't made it out alive in the first go-round. While fans look forward to seeing what series newcomers like Eva Green and Joseph Gordon-Levitt bring to the table, the idea of seeing old faces return is exciting. Audiences will also be experiencing how actors take over characters from previous actors, either by behind the scenes circumstance, such as Dennis Haysbert's inheritance of Manute from the late Michael Clarke Duncan, or by storytelling choice, such as Josh Brolin's take on an earlier version of Clive Owen's Dwight. With quite a lot to look forward to in A Dame to Kill For, let's take a look ahead to see which characters we're most excited to see pop up again in the seedy town of Basin City. Though this article will mostly refrain from spoilers about the graphic novels, be warned that it will contain spoilers about the first film.
10. Goldie & Wendy
Goldie's murder in the original film kicked off Marv's excellent "The Hard Goodbye" and her twin sister Wendy went on to play the role of misguided enemy turned ally to Marv. Actress Jaime King may not have been able to make a huge impression solely due to the fact she spent nearly all her time in the shadow of Mickey Rourke's performance, but her looks and ability to slip adeptly into the tone of the film made her a vital cog in the machine that helped it all work smoothly. With the titular story of the film taking place long before the events of "The Hard Goodbye," expect to see Goldie alive and well alongside her sister at the top of the food chain in Old Town. Though not many are likely chomping at the bit to see the pair again in comparison to the other new and returning characters, the presence of both is a nice link back to the original film and will effectively serve in keeping everything tightly connected.
9. Bob
As the first casting replacement on this list, it's hard not to wonder about the reasoning behind Michael Madsen's departure from the role. As it stands, the character who betrayed John Hartigan in "That Yellow Bastard" will now be played by Jeremy Piven, who audiences have yet to get a solid look at in any of the promotional footage that's been released. With the "A Dame to Kill For" story section of the film taking place after "That Yellow Bastard," fans will likely see the effect that Hartigan's death may have had on him due to his expressed regret in the first film upon collecting Hartigan from prison. Partnered with the great Christopher Meloni as Mort, Bob's beefed up presence in the tangled web of Eva Green's Ava Lord is bound to leave him with a major headache. While we're already missing Madsen in the role, if even just for continuity's sake, we can only cross our fingers that Piven brings enough energy to the role to quickly get fans past it.
8. Manute
Unlike the relatively mysterious recasting of Bob, the need for someone new to step into the hulking Manute's shoes was inevitable after the passing of actor Michael Clarke Duncan in late 2012. Though his presence is undeniably a hard one to match, Pedro Cerrano himself, Dennis Haysbert, has stepped up to the plate and already feels like a natural, solid replacement for Duncan. Though Manute died during the events of "The Big Fat Kill" in the original film, he'll be alive, well and -- for a little while, at least -- the proud owner of two eyes at the start of "A Dame to Kill For". With a bit more to do this time around as a light is shed on his pre-"Kill" history in Basin City and his hatred of the ladies of Old Town, we're certain Haysbert will easily manage to make the role his own and turn each moment he's coming into conflict with our heroes into some of the film's coolest.
7. Miho
Due to a little thing called pregnancy, original actress Devon Aoki was unable to return to the role of Old Town's silent, badass assassin. Fortunately, the easy on the eye Jamie Chung is a more than suitable replacement to bring the graphic novel's fan favorite character back. Like everyone else on this list so far, she will definitely be playing a role in the "A Dame to Kill For" section of the film as her history with Dwight pulls her headlong into the fray. Fans' graphic novel knowledge of the story's events and the character's role in them aside, the glimpses of Deadly Little Miho in the footage seen so far have easily poised her to be an inevitable scene-stealer with a handful of standout moments much like the first film.
6. Gail
Rosario Dawson hasn't seemed to age a day since the release of the last film. As the sexy and dangerous Gail, Dawson did a great job in making herself stand out in "The Big Fat Kill" even when surrounded by an entire film of other great and memorable characters. Returning for her part in the "A Dame to Kill For" section of the sequel, we're excited to see Dawson don the leather ensemble again and be given the chance to play with the character's relationship to Dwight far in advance of the events of "Kill". With her natural charm and appeal unchanged over the years, Dawson's bound to bring her A game yet again and give every scene she's in just that much more sizzle. With the film's stories "The Long Bad Night" and "The Fat Loss" being original, it's entirely possible that Gail and the other characters so far on this list could show up at any point and time, if even for a cameo. With all of them a lock for the "A Dame to Kill For" section, we can only hope that Gail and/or the others can manage to get at least a few more minutes of screen-time outside of "Dame" to give fans just a little more time to spend with them.
5. John Hartigan
Bruce Willis fit the role of Hartigan like a glove in the first film. His suicide at the conclusion of "That Yellow Bastard" was a grim conclusion to a hero who deserved a lot better, but in the world of Basin City, it was the only logical way for him to win against the scheming Senator Roark. Unlike many of the other major characters, Hartigan doesn't pop up throughout the graphic novels again, chiefly due to his extended incarceration as well as the fact that his death and the final events of his story took place long in advance of stories like "A Dame to Kill For" and "The Hard Goodbye". With the original story "The Big Fat Loss," Robert Rodriguez and Frank Miller haven given themselves the opportunity to explore what happened to Nancy after the events of "That Yellow Bastard," bringing Hartigan back into the mix as a recurring vision for her in the process. Though fans are waiting to see whether Hartigan's presence leans more towards the chatty Harry Morgan from Dexter side of the spectrum rather than just being a silent apparition, the idea of seeing Hartigan again, though not alive and well, in a wholly original, anything-can-happen yarn is a neat one.
4. Senator Roark
As the original film's leader of the villainous Roark clan, the return of Powers Boothe as Senator Roark for the original stories "The Long Bad Night" and, in particular, "The Fat Loss" is curious. After losing his son Junior, that yellow bastard, at the hands of Hartigan and his brother, Cardinal Roark, to Marv in "The Hard Goodbye," seeing where the despicable Senator has ended up without a legacy in place is interesting territory that went unexplored in the graphic novels. With Joseph Gordon-Levitt's Johnny and Jessica Alba's Nancy out to get him this time around, we're itching to see if one or both can finally bring the man himself down once and for all. Boothe is more than capable of oozing both charm and malice, which he did to excellent effect in the original film, and since he's one of the few pre-existing characters being sent into uncharted story territory, it's hard not to be excited to see Roark get more to do and for Boothe to continue savoring a role he played with such relish once before.
3. Nancy Callahan
As stated earlier, Nancy Callahan is taking center stage in the revenge-fueled original story "The Fat Loss". No longer the little girl/damsel in distress that Hartigan gave his life -- in more ways than one -- to protect, Nancy's out to make Senator Roark pay, with Marv along for the ride. At the risk of sounding repetitive, what makes Nancy's return in "The Fat Loss" so exciting is that her story post-"That Yellow Bastard" goes relatively unexplored in the graphic novels beyond a cameo here and there. Alba seems game for whatever Rodriguez and Miller have to throw at her and it's hard to believe that her story will end quite as depressingly as Hartigan's. Being able to watch her transformation from the one being saved to the one doing all the ass-kicking is likely to be one of A Dame to Kill For's most compelling aspects and we're already digging her new look, from the new fashion choices to the battle scars present on her face. Should she get the opportunity to watch the life drain from Senator Roark's eyes, fans will be just as satisfied for and with her.
2. Dwight McCarthy
Long before he had Clive Owen's face, Dwight looked like Josh Brolin and was caught up in the alluring web of Ava Lord. Owen did a solid job of bringing Dwight to life in the original film, even if his story was sandwiched between the arguably more interesting "The Hard Goodbye" and "That Yellow Bastard," but Brolin is a great actor who will undoubtedly help ensure that the title story won't be entirely eclipsed by the strengths of the others. The appeal of seeing Dwight alongside Mickey Rourke's Marv and more time being spent on his relationship with the ladies of Old Town, particularly Gail and Miho, is high, though fans are simply just excited to see the story finally play out on-screen after a near decade of waiting. Though we have a feeling Owen might step back into the role near the end of the story since this isn't a complete recasting of the character in the same vein as, say, Bob -- for reasons you'll just have to wait and see if you haven't read the graphic novels -- we're still looking forward to seeing what Brolin brings to the table. Dwight is one of Sin City's most important protagonists and we're glad that he's back in full force for a Round 2 that will shed some light on "The Big Fat Kill" and retroactively make watching it all the more fulfilling.
1. Marv
Let's just get it out of the way: Marv was, for many people, the first film's best character. As both the spark for Mickey Rourke's Hollywood comeback as well as a showcase for the man's talents, Marv cast a big shadow in "The Hard Goodbye" that the rest of the film's characters in the following stories had to crawl out of. Since Rourke's career rocketed back uphill after the release of the original film, he could have easily turned down the offer to reprise the character. Fortunately for audiences, he's back in full swing as the character he owes quite a bit to, alive and well long before "The Hard Goodbye" to take part in both the titular story and "The Fat Loss," as well as leading his own smaller-scale yarn "Just Another Saturday Night". Even as he smashed, tortured and maimed his way through the seedy underbelly of Basin City and lamented his own perceived lack of intelligence, Marv's wit, smarts and moral compass helped make him largely the beating heart and soul of the original film. As the sequel is giving him the chance to spend time dealing with many of the other characters, including Dwight, Manute, Nancy and more, the idea of more Rourke as Marv is the most thrilling carryover from the original. With so many characters returning from the original film to fight to stand out alongside the sequel's host of new characters, fans are bound to have their own favorites and things they're looking forward to. Feel free to share which characters, new and old, you're most excited to see below as we wait out the clock for A Dame to Kill For to finally arrive.