Spider-Man 4: What Really Happened?

Unravelling a tangled web.

By Danny Meegan /

11th June, 2010.... the day Deadline broke the internet with news that director Sam Raimi and star Tobey Maguire would not be returning for Spider-Man 4 and that Sony would be pushing ahead with a reboot that would see Peter Parker return to high school.

Advertisement

To put this news in today's context, it would be something similar to Disney announcing that Robert Downey Jr would no longer be playing Tony Stark and future movies involving the rebooted, re-cast character would begin with his pre-Iron Man days.

It's easy to forget how big a deal Spider-Man 3 was. Back in 2007, the MCU was still a year away from kicking in and only Batman Begins had been released from the newly minted Dark Knight franchise, leaving the Spider-Man movies as the undisputed king of superhero movies, in much the same way The Avengers movies are today.

Advertisement

Spider-Man 3 broke all kinds of box-office records on release, grossing $890.9 million worldwide at a time well before hitting $1 billion mark was an annual event. And though Spider-Man 3 wasn't as well-received as the prior two movies, this was a saga that fans were heavily invested in and wanted to see continue.

Sony Pictures

Spider-Man was about to tread into unprecedented waters. Fans were rabid for a fourth movie when sagas don't usually have the legs to carry past a third installment.

Advertisement

In development for around three years before its cancellation in early 2010, Spider-Man 4 is one of the most high-profile, canned sequels in movie history. It's also one of those rare cases where the story of what happened to the movie is (mostly) out there for all to read up on, from confirmed villains to scripting problems, confusing rumours to cold hard truths.

This is the story of what really happened to Spider-Man 4...

Advertisement

5. Injecting Spider-Man With A Lethal Dose Of Venom...

Marvel Comics

Spider-Man 4's troubles would actually start with the previous movie Spider-Man 3, when the inclusion of a popular villain caused a big disagreement between Raimi and the studio... the inclusion of Venom.

Advertisement

Originally, he wasn't even meant to appear in the film. Raimi (along with his brother, Ivan) had conceived a story for Spider-Man 3 they were happy with, one that revolved around Peter, Mary-Jane, and Harry Osborn, with the Sandman and The Vulture teaming up as his two enemies this time around (in 2007 EW reported that Ben Kingsley was considered for the latter role).

Here's an early storyboard from the film's pre-production, which would have seen Vulture helping aid The Sandman's prison break in the first act;

Advertisement
Sony

It was only when Sony producer Avi Arad began pushing for Venom's inclusion, a character who had exploded into pop culture lore in the 90s and early 2000s through frequent comics storylines, the animated TV show and as antagonists to several video games - that Raimi felt choked into submission, and despite his interests in the Spider-Man character only being the classic creations Stan Lee and Steve Ditko conceived, the director complied and Venom was thrust in.

Vulture's role in Spider-Man 3 would be sacrificed to accommodate Venom. Not only that but Arad wanted another love interest for Peter Parker and the inclusion of Gwen Stacy was hastily added to the Spider-Man film universe for the first time, as portrayed by Bryce Dallas Howard...

Advertisement
Sony Pictures

Ultimately, this concoction of different ideals and agendas would be the biggest reason for why Spider-Man 3 didn't work as well as the first two. This was a movie born out of two competing films. On the one hand, you had the story that Sam Raimi was interested in telling which can be seen in all the Sandman moments (arguably the parts of the movie that work the best) and the one Sony wanted to be told involving Venom and Gwen Stacy's arcs (which clearly didn't work so well).

Another victim in all this was the tragic arc of Harry Osborn following into the Green Goblin footsteps of his father, his subplot getting stuck in the middle of these two warring factions and itself being a major let down after his villainous turn had been well built up over two prior movies.

Advertisement
Sony

Besides the blatant story and pacing issues that stemmed from this inclusion of too many villains, Raimi's heart just clearly wasn't 100-percent in it, a dejection from the material that clearly translated directly to the screen.

"I tried to make it work, but I didn’t really believe in all the characters", he told Nerdist (via Collider).

Advertisement
Sony Pictures

Of course, despite all this, the movie as we've said made Sony a ton of money and even though it cleary exists as the weakest of the trilogy, with a 63% fresh Rotten Tomatoes rating and a B+ CinemaScore, fans were still invested and willing to forgive Spider-Man 3 for its indiscretions.

They weren't ready to give up on this saga yet...

Advertisement

4. Spider-Man 4: The Problematic Script

Sony

Plans for Spider-Man 4 would continue at a rapid pace. Sony were keen to make more and negotiations were well underway for the returns of Sam Raimi in the director's chair and leads Tobey Maguire and Kirsten Dunst in talks for a fourth outing as Peter Parker and Mary-Jane Watson, respectively.

Advertisement

Maguire and Dunst had only signed a 3-movie deal and sadly for Sony their pay demands for fourth and fifth outings were particularly high (though Dunst has confirmed recently that she was paid less than her male co-stars). Rumours from the time suggested that Maguire was seeking $50m for the two movies plus a profit share deal on both movies and time off in early mornings and evenings to spend time with his younf daughter Ruby. That's a lot of money and time to sink into one star, let alone a group of returning ones.

To try and deal with that, Sony had tentative plans to shoot Spider-Man 4 back to back with a Spider-Man 5 over a six-month shoot to save costs and also making sure to get as much mileage out of Maguire and Dunst before they became too old to convincingly play these roles.

Advertisement

On the surface though, all seemed content and ultimately money and Raimi's new opportunity at delivering a fresh Spider-Man movie that would wash away the frustrations he felt with the previous entry had kept the proposal of a fourth movie on the right track.

But things just didn't go the way anyone had hoped.

Advertisement

Screenwriter David Koepp - who penned Maguire's first outing in 2002 - had been tapped to write the script for Spider-Man 4 but a writers' strike in late 2007 would soon throw a major spanner in the works and he reportedly hadn't completed the script in time.

Seth Wenig/AP

Spider-Man 4 was in a difficult position. Talks with Koepp broke down and just mere days before the strike was due to take place - EW (via MovieWeb) reported that another writer, James Vanderbilt (Zodiac), had been hired to script the movie. He wouldn't be allowed to work on it during the strike (which ended in February 2008), but he could still think of ideas or draft loose concepts down on paper.

Advertisement

After the strike, Vanderbilt completed his draft, but then - in October 2008 - a different writer, David Lindsay-Abaire, was tasked with doing some script work on the project. It wasn't clear whether Lindsay-Abaire had been hired to rewrite Vanderbilt's draft or create one of his own, but with this being the third writer associated with Spider-Man 4 in a short period of time, the state of the project started to come into question.

Was putting together a fourth Spider-Man movie an impossible task? Had the creative justices of the Spider-Man character been left in disarray after Spider-Man 3?

Advertisement

Fans were starting to fear the worst as no release date for a fourth entry was forthcoming, despite having the cast, director and writers in place.

Sony

There was still more problems to come. In mid-2009, Hunger Games director Gary Ross was brought on to rewrite a draft of the script, something acknowledged by Raimi later that year (via MTV):

Advertisement
"He's working on a draft... I just gave him some notes and he's doing a rewrite right now."

Again, there was no clarity about whose script this was - was it Vanderbilt's? Lindsay-Abaire's? Either way, the movie still didn't have a finalised script after two years of writing, which is indicative of some major behind-the-scenes issues.

It was becoming more and more evident that the studio had its own ideas on what Spider-Man 4 should be, and Raimi had his. The two parties couldn't agree on a story, so they cycled through screenwriters trying to find a compromise.

Advertisement

Was fate striking twice here? Was Spider-Man 4 going the same way as Spider-Man 3?

3. Too Many Villains? (Again)

Marvel Comics

At this point in the Spider-Man 4 production timeline, it's late 2009: the movie has a director, several other crew members including a production designer and some visual effects supervisors, and stars Maguire and Dunst are back on board. While the script wasn't yet finished, everything was seemingly in place, aside from a release date.

Advertisement

One other big question also still remained on the lips of fans: what would the film actually be about?

Despite going through writers quicker than Fox goes through bad Fantastic Four movies, Spider-Man 4 suffered surprisingly few trustworthy plot leaks over the many years it was in development. But one area of the film that did see a lot of media attention was its villains.

Advertisement

Spider-Man 3 received a lot of hate for the amount of baddies it shoehorned in, so it was genuinely surprisingly to hear that so many members of Spidey's rogues gallery were associated with Spider-Man 4. An early report arrived in March 2007, when CinemaBlend stated that Morlun - a vampire-like being - was under consideration.

And the rumours didn't stop there.

Advertisement
Marvel Comics

One villain who was widely expected to appear was The Lizard.

"The Lizard is probably one of my favourite characters", Raimi told MTV in 2007. Grant Curtis, producer of the first three Spidey films, said "it's hard to beat The Lizard" in an interview with IFMagazine.

Advertisement

Curt Connors (Lizard's human alter-ego) had already been established in the Raimi-verse as Peter's professor, and actor Dylan Baker wanted to suit up. It seemed like a sure bet.

Sony Pictures

A background player in the series so far, he would need very minimal screen-time to advance into villain territory...

Advertisement

But in that same MTV interview, Raimi stated that he'd love to see Electro, Vulture or The Sinister Six appear in the film, and after all this chatter, speculation and conjecture continued for several months, we were still no closer to finding out who the villain of Spider-Man 4 would actually be.

Marvel

Fortunately, a pair of frontrunners soon emerged. In December 2009, Movieline sources stated that John Malkovich and Anne Hathaway were in talks to portray the Vulture and Felicia Hardy, respectively. While Hardy usually becomes Black Cat in the comics, this version of the character would reportedly end up being the Vulturess, an all-new superpowered antagonist.

Advertisement

Hathaway's character was also rumoured to be Vulture's daughter. In a possible plot outline published by Vulture (the site, not the winged dude) Felicia and Peter enter into a relationship after he breaks up with Mary-Jane, and Peter would also kill Vulture. As you'd expect, Felicia rejects Peter after discovering he killed her father. This story has never been confirmed, however.

Neon

What has been confirmed is that Hathaway was indeed in negotiations to star in the film, after Raimi - chatting with Vulture in 2013 - mentioned her work on it, saying: "I loved what she was doing with the auditions for Spider-Man 4." But crucially, whether she was going to play Black Cat or Vulturess wasn't discussed. On the Malkovich side of things, he was confirmed as Vulture by the actor himself in an interview with /Film.

Advertisement

So if Spider-Man 4 had gone ahead, it seems like Vulture was a lock, as was Hathaway as either Vulturess or Black Cat (or maybe even both?). But the movie's villains didn't stop there.

2. Spidey Versus All The Bad Guys

Planet Henderson

A couple of years ago, artist Jeffrey Henderson shared several storyboards from pre-production work he conducted on Spider-Man 4 via his website, some of which gave us a great look at Vulture and Spidey in action, again confirming the villain's involvement in the film and some clues to how the film would have turned out.

Advertisement

A few of the images depict a mid-air showdown between the two, with Spidey slinging a gargoyle at Vulture and the villain being chased down by a helicopter. The design of Vulture is incredibly comic-book-accurate, with the furry neckpiece and tight suit, but it's always possible the character's look hadn't been fully locked down at this stage.

Planet Henderson
Planet Henderson

There are also some rather interesting shots of Peter passionately kissing a mystery woman. Since Henderson never confirmed who this is, there's a strong possibility that it's Felicia Hardy. If so, these images prop up that aforementioned story rumour about Felicia and Peter hooking up after he breaks up with Mary-Jane.

Advertisement

Or, this woman could be Mary-Jane, and that plot could be bogus. Take a look and decide for yourself.

Planet Henderson

In another shot on Henderson's page, we see a woman who definitely does look like an Anne Hathaway-type stood in a crowd of people, glaring at something (or someone) just off camera.

Advertisement

Again, Henderson never confirmed who this is, but it certainly looks like Hathaway and it's almost certainly Felicia Hardy.

Planet Henderson

If that is the case, then again, these images support that rumoured plot; if Felicia discovered that Peter killed her father, then she'd absolutely be staring at him with that disapproving look. Peter is a photographer, so whatever event Felicia is attending here, there's a good chance he's there too, stood in the direction of her gaze.

Advertisement

Vulture and Felicia aside, the most curious storyboards show Spidey carting Mysterio - who, apparently, would've been played by Bruce Campbell (on the backs of his mischievous cameos in the prior 3 films) - off to the authorities.

Planet Henderson

Henderson told io9 that the opening of the film would have shown Spidey battling a roster of D and C-list villains including Prowler, Rhino, Mysterio and Shocker in a quick montage, and reiterated that Vulture was the primary antagonist of the piece:

Advertisement
“[the beginning of the film featured] a montage of C and D-list villains that we knew would never be used as main antagonists: Mysterio, the Shocker, the Prowler, the old school-onesie-wearing version of the Rhino, maybe even the Stilt Man, etc."

However, only Mysterio - both masked and unmasked - is shown in the storyboards Henderson chose to post.

Planet Henderson

So what's the deal with all these villain characters, both confirmed and speculated?

Advertisement

Earlier rumours like Morlun were possibly remnants of one of the many drafts of Spider-Man 4's script, or maybe they were studio suggestions. Perhaps all this back-and-forth with villains could be interpreted as Raimi (who, let's remember, had already been at odds with Sony over the whole Venom situation) being in constant disagreement with the studio over the direction of the film.

Based on the reports that followed, this scenario seems highly likely.

Advertisement

1. A Spider Is Flushed

Sony Pictures

At the start of the last entry we mentioned how things seemed to be coming together for the film, and the possible additions of Hathaway and Malkovich to the cast only reaffirmed that belief. While talking about Gary Ross, Raimi even told MTV that he hoped to start shooting in March 2010.

Advertisement

But at some point between late 2009 and early 2010, things fell apart in a big, big way.

On 5 January 2010, Deadline published an article stating that Spider-Man 4 had "script problems" (shocker), quoting an email that'd been sent out to the movie's special effects team the previous December:

Advertisement
"We were just notified that our schedule is pushing. We will NOT be starting as planned. I’m terribly sorry for this news, and I hope this email reaches you in time to find other options. We do not know how long we are pushing, and we will not know until mid-January. By mid-January, we will be told how long the push is, whether it be 2 weeks, 2 months, or something else. The studio has every intention of making the movie, but we no longer have a confirmed start date."
"Again, I’m terribly sorry, but Sam Raimi has story issues [that] need to be resolved before we are ready to shoot."

The article also contained an interesting, yet predictable nugget for anyone who'd been following this messy production: Raimi was fed up with all those script problems:

"...the Spider-Manfranchise director who also is helming the 4th installment had huge problems with the script that has run through screenwriters Jamie Vanderbilt, David Lindsay-Abaire, and Gary Ross. I’m even told Sam Raimi had been very vocal inside Sony that he 'hated' it. Now Raimi and Sony are anxiously waiting for still another version from screenwriter Alvin Sargent, who wrote Spidey 2 & 3 ..."

Yep, that's right! The movie had attracted yet another screenwriter in Sargent, who may have been forced to start from scratch considering Raimi hated everything that came before.

Advertisement

The takeaway from all of this is that Spider-Man 4's story was of the utmost importance to Raimi, and he simply wasn't willing to make the film unless it was great. In an industry fuelled by money, having the artistic integrity to say "we're not doing this yet" to quite possibly a billion-dollar blockbuster takes some balls, and he should be commended for that.

But Raimi's dislike of the script (and the struggle to actually complete it after all these years) had ramifications: Sony didn't want to wait around. And this led to what happened six days after Deadline's article went live.

Advertisement
Sony Pictures

On 11 January 2010, Deadline reported that Spider-Man 4 had been officially cancelled, stating that Raimi felt he couldn't hit the film's proposed May 2011 release date while maintaining "creative integrity".

Or, to put it another way, he didn't want to crap something out.

Advertisement

Instead of a fourth film, Sony instead announced that they would reboot the property using a script by - get this - James Vanderbilt. And judging by the press release the studio provided to Deadline, this script had already been completed before Spider-Man 4 was even cancelled:

"Columbia Pictures and Marvel Studios announced today they are moving forward with a film based on a script by James Vanderbilt that focuses on a teenager grappling with both contemporary human problems and amazing super-human crises."

Vanderbilt had been working on a reboot script for months, well before Spider-Man 4 was canned, and all while Raimi was hard at work on his sequel. It sounds like the studio grew tired of repeatedly trying to crack the script for the fourth movie, and prepared reboot plans as a backup.

Advertisement

Now, Raimi was aware of these plans (whether he was told upfront or whether he found out some other way), and it's possible that the notion of Sony preparing for a different Spider-Man movie without him made the director even more displeased with his current situation.

Hell, Marc Webb was unveiled as the reboot director literally days after Spider-Man 4 was scrapped; it's almost like Sony just wanted to get Raimi out of the way so they could make their announcement quickly and crack on with making the movie.

Advertisement
Gregorio Borgia/AP

Regardless of how it all went down, here's what Raimi had to say about the subject (via Vulture):

"It really was the most amicable and undramatic of breakups: It was simply that we had a deadline and I couldn't get the story to work on a level that I wanted it to work. I was very unhappy with Spider-Man 3, and I wanted to make Spider-Man 4 to end on a very high note, the best Spider-Man of them all."
"But I couldn't get the script together in time, due to my own failings, and I said to Sony, 'I don't want to make a movie that is less than great, so I think we shouldn't make this picture. Go ahead with your reboot, which you've been planning anyway.' And [Sony co-chairman] Amy Pascal said, 'Thank you. Thank you for not wasting the studio's money, and I appreciate your candor.' So we left on the best of terms, both of us trying to do the best thing for fans, the good name of Spider-Man, and Sony Studios."

In reality it really could have been a friendly parting of the ways, but Raimi's hatred of the script(s), Sony crafting a reboot behind his back, and his desire to not replicate the Venom situation all paint a picture of a creator dissatisfied with the entire project - an artist who just couldn't get things to work with his corporate overlords, a man struggling to craft a story that ticked every box.

Advertisement

All things considered, cancelling Spider-Man 4 was probably for the best.

And considering the financial strain potentially placed on Sony with the inflated wage bill of Tobey Maguire in particular (and the possibility of him taking more than the 7.5% of profits on the back-end he'd taken for Spider-Man 3), it's no surprise that they'd worked hard on their contingency plan. Particularly when it allowed them to hire Andrew Garfield to replace him for just $500k (which was admittedly likely to have been increased for the sequel. Comparing $25m plus a slice of profits to that sort of deal can only lead to one winner. And that's without the contract demands of Kirsten Dunst, JK Simmons and any other returning actors.

Advertisement

Once things had settled, Sony marched ahead with their reboot - blew it - and rebooted again in 2016, with Tom Holland's Spider-Man now a part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, arguably the best version of the character we've ever seen.

Marvel Studios

And as for Spider-Man 4 overall? It'll go down as the biggest, most exciting comic-book movie we never got to watch.

Advertisement

Raimi had something to prove coming off Spider-Man 3, and it's truly a shame that we didn't get to see him unleash his creative vigour on one more wallcrawler movie.

-

Advertisement

What do you think about Spider-Man 4's troubled production and subsequent cancellation? Let us know in the comments below!