Spider-Man: Homecoming Vs Spider-Man 2 - Which Is Better?

Tobey or Tom? It's time to decide.

By Jack Pooley /

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Spider-Man: Homecoming has enjoyed considerable critical and commercial success since its recent release, and most importantly, it's restored audience confidence in the web-slinger after his last three solo movies were, well, not so great.

Advertisement

Opinion seems somewhat divided, however, on exactly where the movie stands, some deeming it the best Spider-Man movie to date, while others attest it's not quite as good as what's commonly regarded as the best Spidey movie, 2004's excellent Spider-Man 2.

By examining every aspect by which these films can be judged, from direction to acting and even the music, it's time to figure out which one truly is the king of the Spidey movies.

Advertisement

Does Sam Raimi's superhero classic still stand tall, or has Homecoming's witty update made it feel thoroughly old-hat? Is Tobey Maguire still the definitive Spider-Man, or has Tom Holland managed to wrestle it away from him?

12. Direction

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Spider-Man 2 is, of course, directed by the terrific Sam Raimi, who effortlessly one-upped his admirably goofy direction of the first film with a bigger, more visually engaging sequel that pretty much saw the director at the top of his game.

Advertisement

Homecoming, meanwhile, was the big break for indie director Jon Watts, who admirably rose to the occasion and made an impressive leap from $5 million indies to this $175 million tentpole.

Winner: Watts puts in a rock solid effort, but his work is just a little lacking in personality compared to Raimi's more effervescent approach, which feels more like the work of an auteur rather than a filmmaker forced to work to a studio's "house style".

Advertisement

11. Narrative

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Spider-Man 2 isn't just your quintessential superhero sequel: it's an ambitious expansion of the original's scope and ambition, depicting the personal toll being Spider-Man is taking on Peter, and his brief attempt to live a normal life.

Advertisement

On the other hand, Homecoming is a fairly radical diversion from the typical Spider-Man movie, fashioned more as a John Hughes-esque high school comedy that just so happens to also be a superhero movie.

Winner: This is a really tough one because they're both pretty successful here, but Spider-Man 2 overall is just much more emotionally and viscerally powerful, whereas Homecoming didn't bring much in terms of gravity or weight, and arguably felt a little too light for its own good.

Advertisement

10. Peter Parker

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Tobey Maguire is the original movie Spider-Man, and he brought an undeniable charm to the table that evolved into something more mature and compelling in Spider-Man 2, as the script required him to visit some more challenging and conflicted places.

Advertisement

Tom Holland won the part of the MCU's Spider-Man, a much younger actor who is, for once, pretty close to the character's supposed age, and like Maguire had to balance the character's inherent goofiness with the legitimate threat of the Vulture.

Winner: Both performances are great, but Holland just feels that much more natural and convincing as a high schooler, whereas Maguire was close to 30 years of age when Spider-Man 2 was filming, and never really escapes the "adult playing a child" Hollywood stereotype.

Advertisement

9. The Villain

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Alfred Molina did an absolutely fantastic job making Doc Ock both terrifying and sympathetic in Spider-Man 2, if perhaps a little on the familiar side because, yes, he's the oh-so-typical well-meaning scientist who is turned wayward by his own creation and, of course, sacrifices himself in a grand act of redemption.

Advertisement

Homecoming's main baddie is the Vulture, played with restrained relish by the brilliant Michael Keaton. One of the best things about his villain is that his economic motivation is easy to relate to and doesn't require lazy sentiment. Also, he doesn't have a redemptive sob story, and the twist with him being Liz's father was superbly executed, especially that awkward car ride.

Winner: Molina and Keaton both did exemplary work here, so this is really tough, but Doc Ock just feels so much more statuesque and entertaining as a villain, whereas Vulture is undermined a little by Homecoming's general lack of emotion.

Advertisement

8. Fun Factor

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Sam Raimi probably couldn't make a movie that wasn't at least a little bit fun even if his life depended on it, and while Spidey 2 certainly has an array of dead-serious moments, it smartly doesn't allow them to overwhelm the thrilling, giddily enjoyable spectacle of the iconic superhero saving the day.

Advertisement

Homecoming, with the aforementioned John Hughes inspiration, is easily the funniest Spider-Man film to date, with a laser-trained focus on hilarious one-liners and amusing visual gags that lean into young Peter's inherent awkwardness.

Winner: They're both immensely fun films, but Homecoming takes this one, because it clings to every laugh it can wring out of the script, and in sacrificing a good deal of its emotional potential, at least delivers a breezy, lightly enjoyable superhero romp.

Advertisement

Raimi's film was more earnest and goofy, but Homecoming's punk rock tone has a decidedly more infectious charm to it.

7. Music

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Danny Elfman returned to provide the score for Spider-Man 2, though he clashed so harshly with Sam Raimi during production that he famously declared, "I would rather go back to waiting tables than to do Spider-Man 2 again."

Advertisement

The main criticism of the movie's score is that it's too derivative of the first film, and fair though that is, the Doc Ock theme is all kinds of awesome, and the score is certainly nothing if not incredibly memorable overall.

The brilliant Michael Giacchino provided the score for Homecoming, and while it's certainly not his best score this year (that'd be War for the Planet of the Apes), his spirited orchestral rendition of the classic Spider-Man cartoon theme is especially excellent.

Advertisement

The score definitely peaks with its first theme and never quite recaptures the same brilliance, but it's solid work all the same.

Winner: This is a tough one to call, but Elfman still pulled off iconic work in spite of the behind-the-scenes troubles, while a big chunk of Giacchino's score doesn't really touch the sides. Elfman clinches it, but admittedly not by a whole lot.

Advertisement

6. Romance

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Spider-Man 2 sees Peter struggling to deal with the fact that Mary Jane has moved on from him, even though she does ultimately return to him at the end of the movie. Of course, MJ ends up being a pawn in Doc Ock's scheme, and he has to rescue her. And don't forget about Peter's landlord's cute daughter Ursula who was totally into him...

Advertisement

Homecoming has a much more subdued romantic subplot than any of the Raimi movies, with Peter getting to know academic decathlon teammate Liz, only for this love story to get promptly derailed at the end of the movie when Liz moves away to Oregon.

The seeds are planted for Peter and the new MJ, Michelle, to get together in the future, but there's no guarantee that will actually happen.

Advertisement

Winner: The Spider-Man 2 romance definitely felt much more melodramatic and soap opera-esque, and making MJ into a damsel-in-distress once again definitely felt a little tired.

Homecoming on the other hand didn't overdo the romance and so it actually played better as a result. Plus, neither Liz nor Michelle were kidnapped by Vulture, even if Liz was temporarily put in danger at the Washington Monument, albeit along with a group of other kids.

Advertisement

Homecoming's more restrained approach easily wins out here.

5. Supporting Cast

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Spider-Man 2's more memorable supporting players include the aforementioned Alfred Molina as Doc Ock, James Franco's Harry Osborn, Rosemary Harris as Aunt May, J.K. Simmons' brilliant J. Jonah Jameson, Dylan Baker's under-utilised Curt Connors, Elizabeth Banks as Betty Brant, and a number of memorable cameos, especially Bruce Campbell as a toolbag theater usher.

Advertisement

Aside from the occasional presence of Robert Downey Jr's terrific Tony Stark, Homecoming plucks a host of names from the indie cinema and comedy world, such as Donald Glover, Tony Revolori, Hannibal Buress, Bokeem Woodbine, Michael Chernus, Angourie Rice, Abraham Attah and Martin Starr to name just a few.

They may not be household names for the most part, but they're used exceptionally well, if sparingly, for easy laughs. And how can you not love Peter's show-stealing confidante Ned, played superbly by Jacob Batalon?

Advertisement

Winner: Spider-Man 2 has the star power, but Homecoming has the charm, and thanks to its greater focus on comedy, manages to deliver more entertaining work from its ensemble.

Both movies get great performances from their supporting casts, but Homecoming just felt more creative and unexpected by making use of so many on-the-rise talents.

Advertisement

4. Action Sequences

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Spider-Man 2 is full of iconic action sequences, specifically the train set-piece which so brilliantly demonstrates the physical toll Spidey's "job" can take, not to mention the bank fight, and of course, the final battle against Doc Ock.

Advertisement

Homecoming's action feels a little more conventional for the superhero genre: the Washington Monument sequence, the Staten Island Ferry and the plane finale are all competently-assembled sequences, though lack the visceral appeal to really make them truly memorable or impactful.

Winner: Spider-Man 2 and it's not even close. The action has aged incredibly well, has real weight to it and has endured for well over a decade. It's hard to imagine many still talking about Homecoming's action in another 15 years.

Advertisement

3. Pacing

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Spider-Man 2 clocks in at a relatively lean 127 minutes and does a fantastic job packing a lot into its run-time, both in terms of character development for Peter and the aforementioned riveting action sequences. There's just enough downtime between set-pieces, and Raimi nails the balance perfectly.

Advertisement

Homecoming runs 133 minutes long, mercifully a little shorter than some of the other recent MCU movies, and for the most part flies by thanks to its hilarious script and fast-moving plot.

There is a slight lull in the middle once Peter has his suit taken away, but it's only barely significant, and soon enough the third act surges into full gear.

Advertisement

Winner: Both do well here, but Spidey 2 clinches it just because pretty much every scene feels important and interesting, while Homecoming does over-extend itself ever-so-slightly in the second act.

2. Standalone Appeal

Columbia & Marvel Studios

Spider-Man 2 can certainly be watched in isolation, though it naturally plays better if you're seen the previous film, which cements Peter's love for MJ and Harry Osborn's inner turmoil regarding his father's death. For the most part, though, it's easy to watch as a single movie.

Advertisement

Homecoming is fashioned as a kinda-origin story of sorts, so it has an easy advantage here, having links to the wider MCU with Tony Stark's presence, but also operating extremely well as an introduction to the character.

Winner: A tough call, but Homecoming introducing so many characters makes it naturally feel more standalone, even if it's always within the context of the MCU.

Advertisement

1. Overall

Columbia & Marvel Studios

With all these things considered, it's time to take a tally and determine the overall victor. Which is truly the best Spider-Man movie ever?

Advertisement

Winner: Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 2 has six wins while Homecoming lands a close-but-no-cigar five, ensuring that the 2004 classic's status as one of the all-time best superhero movies remains untouched.

It's entirely possible that Homecoming's sequel could end up beating out Raimi's film, but for now Spider-Man 2 remains the almost impossibly high benchmark for Spider-Man movies, and indeed all comic book movies, to aim for.

Advertisement

Which Spider-Man movie did you prefer? Has Sam Raimi's classic finally been dethroned in your opinion? Shout it out in the comments!