Star Trek Into Darkness: 10 Things That Make No Sense
Its finally here. After months of drip-fed trailers and clips; smokescreens and speculations about the plot and villain, Star Trek: Into Darkness has been released with mixed to positive reviews.
Star Trek: Into Darkness has been anticipated by most people since the credits started rolling at the end of the 2009 reboot. Who is the villain going to be? Will the writers use the Original Series for inspiration for their story or will they take the franchise in a new direction? Will we see any familiar faces from the original Star Trek? These are some of the questions that fueled the build-up for what is going to be one of the biggest releases of 2013.
It is much better film than the 2009 movie and it's something that you need to watch in IMAX 3D. However, it's also not the amazing second coming that some may be expecting, it has many of the problems that plagued the 2009 reboot So looking beyond the hype, here is a breakdown on everything that made no sense in Star Trek: Into Darkness. It goes without saying that this will contain some MAJOR SPOILERS, so it might be a good idea to watch the film first before reading this analysis.
If you are ready, press Next and lets see if Star Trek: Into Darkness was worth the wait.10. Under The Sea
Arguably the best part of the 2009 Star Trek movie was the opening sequence. As Nero crippled the USS Kelvin, Kirk was born within the carnage and his father crashed the Kelvin into Neros vessel so the rest of the crew could escape. It was dramatic, full of emotion and a great way to start a film.
Star Trek: Into Darkness begins with another action packed opener. We see the Enterprise crew in the middle of a mission to save a planet and its inhabitants from an erupting volcano. Kirk and McCoy distract the locals while Spock is lowered into the volcano to set off a device that will cool the angry eruption. The scene is well paced and fun. It has the spirit of the Original Series even if it lacks the punch of the opener in 2009. However, there are some elements that make no sense.
This scene was part of the preview attached to the beginning of The Hobbit. Watching it at the time, one bit bugged me and it continues to do so. Kirk hides the Enterprise under water so that the primitive locals dont see it and in turn contravene the Prime directive, the Starfleet rule that forbids interference in the natural evolution of a species. So to avoid that happening, Kirk orders the Enterprise to be concealed underwater while they go about saving the planet.
The thing I don't understand is why would he go to the trouble of hiding the ship underwater? The inhabitants of the planet are at the stage where they would worship a firework if it went off in front of them, so why not leave it in orbit? It makes zero sense to take the ship down and then go to all the trouble of concealing it under the ocean. When I saw the preview, I was hoping that in the final cut of the film, there will be a logical reason for why the Enterprise was underwater but sadly no.
The image of it rising out of the water did look amazing; like all the special effects in this movie, that was impressive and full credit to ILM for putting it together, but it seems aesthetics is the only reason for putting the Enterprise underwater. You can imagine that the idea of the Enterprise rising from the depths of the ocean was mentioned during a script meeting and they ran with it. No reason given, its underwater.
First time I watched this sequence, it did leave me worried about the rest of the film, the 2009 movie was full of illogical inconsistencies and the worry was that this film would too. Enterprise underwater aside, Im happy to say Into Darkness had less dumb shit than its predecessor but the focus of creating great looking effects and action sequences at the expense of a logical structure in the script was clearly evident. They didnt expect the average cinema-goer to question why the Enterprise is underwater because they think the average popcorn muncher is a moron who isnt worried about small details like this. But this being Star Trek, a franchise that used to pride itself on creating a believable vision of the future, Kirk ordering the Enterprise to be hidden underwater sticks out like a sore thumb and will undoubtedly confuse and annoy long term trekkies.
9. Prime Directive
The second thing that doesnt make much sense in the opening scene is Spock and the Prime Directive. Having got himself trapped in the middle of the volcano, Spock argues that he should be left to die because the natives might see the Enterprise and it would violate the Prime Directive. He is hell bent on the fact that he shouldnt be rescued, there is no way around the Prime Directive, it mustnt be violated.
Of course, Kirk ignores him and the Enterprise rises up from the ocean and goes to the rescue. Rather bizarrely, Mr Scott claims that if the volcano fully erupts, the Enterprise might not be able to stand the heat. Considering a volcano eruptions generates heat anywhere from 1000C to 1500C, it's considerably less heat than what would be generated by a ship entering a planets atmosphere, and that is even before we bring the Enterprise shields into the equation. But back to the point.
Once Spock is rescued, he still cant get over that Kirk violated the Prime Directive to save his life. Clearly Starfleets rule No.1 is very important to the Vulcan who finds it difficult to bend the rules.
But Spock didnt seem too worry about the Prime Directive as he was cooling the volcano and changing the destiny of the planet. None interference does not mean keeping technology away from primitive species; it also means that you dont change the natural evolution of planet and its inhabitants, even if by not interfering it causes their death. Spock seems quite happy to pick and choose how he applies the Prime Directive. On one side he cant fathom breaking the Prime Directive, even if it means him roasting in a volcano; on the other side, he is quite happy to drop an ice cube into the volcano and in turn save a planet that would have otherwise perished.
Even has Captain Pike is giving Kirk and Spock a dressing down for breaking the Prime Directive, Spock is still unaware that he is flip-flopping on the idea of what none interference actually means.
Apart from being an exhilarating opening scene, this was written to build the friendship between Kirk and Spock. Its unfortunate that that it had so many logic-holes that distracted from the drama on screen.
8. I Believe In You
The wacky Starfleet promotions are still a common occurrence in Into Darkness. You think the writers would have learnt from the criticisms about the last film that field experience appears to count for nothing and you could be promoted to Captain on the whim of any commanding officer.
In this film, the Enterprise has 6 captain changes. First Kirk is the captain, he then loses command and Pike takes over. Spock is transferred off the Enterprise before being transferred back where Kirk is in command again. After a short stint where Sulu gets to be Captain, Kirk passes command to Spock before taking back the captaincy at the end of the film. It is a wonder that the Enterprise crew can keep up with all the changes, it must make it really difficult to built a stable framework based on loyalty when the person in charge changes with every course correction.
Pike also saves Kirk from going back to the Academy by telling the Admirals that he would like him to be his first officer because he believes in him. Kirk screws up almost everything he is sent to do but Pike keeps telling us that he sees greatness in him and that he believes in him.
As an audience, are we supposed to take him at his word that he sees greatness in Kirk? Kirk hasnt demonstrated any greatness, he seems arrogant and not ready in anyway to be the Captain of a ship. But like some sort of devote evangelist Pike believes in him, and that is all it takes to convince Starfleet that Kirk deserves another chance. I might try that if I ever end up in court.
7. Khan
Undoubtedly, Benedict Cumberbatch is the breakout star of Star Trek: Into Darkness. The man has a tremendously deep voice that most men would kill for and he makes each line sound like a hot knife cutting through butter. He commands the screen every time he is in front of the camera and Im sure that his Hollywood career is about to skyrocket. Im no Cumber-Bitch (the term used by fans of the sinister one) but his acting credentials are plainly clear for everyone to see.
That being said, the build up for Into Darkness had much speculation about his characters identity. No one believed that he was John Harrison and it turned out he wasnt. The big reveal was that he was Khan Noonian Singh, the genetically engineered dictator.
It is sad that JJ Abrams was unable to find an actual Indian to play Khan. Yes, Ricardo Montalban was Hispanic but at least he looked like he could be from the Indian continent. Also Khan made his first appearance in the 60s TV show so you can understand why they went for the easy route and got a Mexican to pretend they were Indian. JJ Abrams was under none of those constraints and could have got a number of Asian actors to play Khan. My feeling is that he went to the Simon Cowell school of casting; in the same way Cowell puts his finger in the air to see who is popular and picks them to be a judge on X-Factor, Abrams picked Cumberbatch for the same reason.
Lets look past the fact that Khan is supposed to be of Indian decent and Cumberbatch looks like he grew up on the mean streets on Middlesex rather than northern India. And lets ignore that when he announces his name is Khan, it comes across as believable as an Indian call center worker trying to convince you that their name is George or Barry. The main problem is that Khan is pretty much wasted in this film and his motivations are from the same school that Red Matter came from.
Khan needs no introduction, he is easily one of the most memorable villains from Star Trek and that is thanks to Ricardo Montalban doing an amazing job playing him. Anyone who cares about Star Trek wanted to see Khan handled right, they got the acting ability but dropped the ball on pretty much everything else.
Khan in Into Darkness is being used by Admiral Marcus (Peter Weller) to design and build technology that can be used to increase Starfleets strength. The threat from the Klingons is on the horizon and Admiral Marcus wants to make sure Earth is protected. Since finding them frozen in space, Admiral Marcus holds Khans 72 co-super people as a bargaining chip to force Khan into doing what he wants. That is the main reason why Khan is so angry with the Admiral.
Fearing for the lives of the 72 people he loves, Khan hides their cryo-tubes in 72 torpedoes he designed. We are not told how he managed to hide them in the torpedoes and how exactly it will save them considering the Admiral is quite aware they are hidden in there, but fair enough, Khan hid them in the torpedoes. However, if Khan was able to gain access to the frozen bodies and go to the trouble of hiding them, then why didnt he just revive them all? Why bother hiding them? Just bring them out of cryogenic sleep and teach the Admiral a lesson. The bit where Khan sheds a tear to show us how much he loves his people and how hurt and angry he is at Admiral Marcus lost some of the punch when halfway through his monologue I was asking, why didnt he just wake all of his frozen friends when he had the chance? It made no sense.
Another point is that Khan in this film is almost the support villain; the real bad guy is Admiral Marcus. Khan is not even formally introduced until half way through the film and he even helps Kirk stop the Admiral and save the Enterprise. We know he cant be trusted and he is only helping Kirk as a smokescreen to escape at the first chance he gets but not only is it weird to see Khan and Kirk working together and helping each other, it also makes his full villainous turn not have the impact it should.
In this film, Khan is also a full on Superman. A close combat expert, he can take down a whole garrison of Klingons on his own. Spocks nerve pinch has no effect and repeated punches to the face dont faze him. Even when Uhura bizarrely beams down (on her own???) and fires repeated stun shots into his chest, it takes a while for him to go down. So with it established that he is superhuman, why is he running from Spock at the end of the film? Why does he look so panicked? Surely he should be arrogant enough to think he can handle one Vulcan. It makes no sense.
There is a chance that Khan will make a return in a future Star Trek film but it now runs the risk of being a repeat of this film. Even if this film was Space Seed and his next appearance (maybe in Star Trek 3) will be Wrath Of Khan, then that would mean that three films have had revenge as a theme. If they were going to use Khan, then they should have given him the whole film. Here he shares villain duties with Admiral Marcus and Cumberbatchs awesome acting is let down by shabby writing in another script by Orci, Kurtzman and Lindelof.
Some are calling Cumberbatch-Khan the greatest Star Trek villain of all time, he is very far from that.
6. The Moron
Thomas Harewood (Noel Clarke) is the father who is forced into bombing the Section 31 instillation in return for Khan saving his daughters life. It raises questions about morality and the lengths parents will go to for their children. Its well acted and the attack on London is full of emotion but it also left me scratching my head.
Harewoods daughter is in hospital with some sort of illness, we know its serious by the concerned look on the parents faces. Khan turns up out of nowhere and informs Harewood that he can save her. We then see Khan preparing the cure and Harewood administers the concoction. As Khan said, it saves the daughters life and now its up to Harewood to fulfill his part of the deal. He goes to work and blows himself up, killing himself and the people he works with and sending a message to Starfleet.
The issue with this sequence is that Harewood is a Starfleet officer. Once he got the cure and saved his daughters life, why didnt he just report what Khan was planning to do? His daughter was saved; Khan had no more bargaining chips so go inform Starfleet that this guy wants you to commit a terrorist attack. On top of that, your daughter wont grow up without a father and have to live with the stigma that her dad was responsible for a terrorist attack that killed a lot of people.
Instead, like an idiot, Harewood walks into his place of work and kills himself and all his friends, even though he didnt have to. It makes no sense.
5. The Klingons
We finally got to see what the Klingons look like in JJ Abrams version of Star Trek. So far they had been hidden behind a mask, a mask that looked quite awesome actually, very cool and aggressive. We already saw Romulans with tattooed faces so how would Abrams re-imagine the Klingons?
The Klingons in this timeline have the ridges and they appear to have a passion for facial piercings, but they also look like a species-of-the-week we might have seen on Star Trek: Voyager. We only saw one Klingon but if they are all like this, then they are a lot less interesting than the Klingons from the original timeline. But at least they still speak the same language.
Looks are not the only way the original Klingons are better, JJs Klingons appear to be crap at a lot of things including detecting long distance transports to their home planet and unauthorised ships entering orbit.
Yes Khan transported into an uninhabited area of Kronos but Klingons have the ability to build ships and conquer planets. Would a mysterious long distance transport not be detected? If for some reason they missed that, how did they not spot a mysterious vessel travelling near Kronos, an area that should be full of Klingon ships? It makes no sense; we have the ability now to detect anything alien that might enter Earths atmosphere. It was one too many leaps of faith for any of these events to seem plausible.
The war with the Klingons looks set to be a big part of Star Trek 3. Judging by their short appearance in Into Darkness, Starfleet doesn't have much to worry about, they seem quite inept. It makes you wonder why Admiral Marcus was so worried about the Klingons; they cant even adequately protect Kronos very well so taking them out shouldn't be too hard.
4. The Women
The female characters in this movie are pretty much redundant. Im not saying that Abrams had to write a beefy role for the lady members of the cast as some sort of positive discrimination, but in Into Darkness, Uhura is annoying cliché girlfriend and Carol Marcus feels tacked on because the character was in The Wrath Of Khan.
Apart from where Uhura tries to communicate with the Klingons and a bit in the climax where she bizarrely beams down to fight Khan on her own, she did nothing other than be Mrs Spock. She was the concerned girlfriend, she was the moody girlfriend or she was the angry girlfriend, whichever role she was playing, she was Spocks girlfriend.
Some reviews have said that the banter between Spock and Uhura was hilarious. Believe me, there was nothing funny about watching Spock play the misunderstood boyfriend who keeps doing the wrong things to keep his woman happy. There is no spark between the two; the whole thing feels artificial. Spock is unlikable and the whole relationship plays out like the worst type of rom-com.
Alice Eve faired no better. Apart from being attractive, she was totally unbelievable as a scientist. She will be Kirks love interest at some point and Into Darkness was her introduction to the audience, thats assuming they remember anything about her apart from that we saw her in her bra and panties.3. Admiral Marcus
The casting of Peter Weller as Admiral Marcus won a lot of points with me, the guy can do no wrong in my book and he was brilliant in this, just like he was in the two part Star Trek: Enterprise episodes Demons and Terra Prime. Saying that, there were a couple of things about his character that bothered me.
Marcus is a top level Admiral in Starfleet and also the man responsible for using Khan to design advanced weaponry. He is worried that Earth is not defended properly and that he is the only one who is taking the danger seriously. The Klingons are on Starfleets doorstep and Marcus feels that the organisation is under prepared. So that is why he forces Khan to work for him while holding 72 of Khans people as frozen hostages. He needed Khans aggression and superior mind to produce superior weaponry so Khan helps him build the USS Vengeance, a beast of a starship designed purely to fight.
You can believe that the Admiral deeply cares about Earth and its people, which is what motivates him to go behind Starfleets back. A misguided hero who feels his short-term unethical actions will secure Earths long-term future. But when he turns into a full on bad guy, then his character starts to make no sense.
Firstly he is prepared to start a war with the Klingons. He wants the Enterprise to fire the 72 advanced torpedoes that contain Khans people at the Klingon home world. Not only will it deal with the Khan issue but it would also make the Klingons think that Starfleet launch a preemptive strike on the Klingon home world. He also arranged for the Enterprise to break down in Klingon space so that the Klingons would find the Enterprise and destroy her. Admiral Marcus would have tied up all the loose ends, be free to make up whatever story he wanted and save his own ass.
But for a man who is going to such lengths to make sure Earth is safe, what would starting a fight with the Klingons actually achieve? If he thinks that Starfleet is not ready and he only has one Dreadnought Class starship, the USS Vengeance, isnt he just asking for trouble?
Later in the film, Admiral Marcus takes the USS Vengeance to destroy the Enterprise. After a short fight near the moon, the Enterprise is crippled and Kirk pleads with Marcus to spare the crews life. But now that Marcus is the movies bad guy, he coldly thanks Kirk for the offer but informs him that he has no intention of sparing the Enterprise or its crew. Has he always been a mass murdering psychopath? There is no regret in his action, he is almost relishing seeing hundreds of innocent people die. Where have his Starfleet ethics gone?
There must be something in the Replicators on the Vengeance because Admiral Marcus is not the only murdering nut job on the ship. The USS Vengeances human crew are also happy to have the blood of innocents on their hands. Identified by Scotty as private security, we are supposed to believe that Admiral Marcus has hired this group of people and they will do whatever he asks, even kill a starship full of people. Do they work for Starfleet? Are they part of Section 31? Who are they and why are they blindly doing whatever Admiral Marcus orders?
Also, how exactly has Admiral Marcus managed to hide Khan and build the USS Vengeance within the Solar System without the rest of Starfleet finding out what he is doing? Its not like his facility around Jupiter has top-notch security, Scotty managed to enter the facility in a Shuttlecraft without being detected. Scotty even managed to disable the USS Vengeance and make unauthorised communications to the Enterprise without the Vengeance internal sensors picking it up.
Towards the end of the film, Admiral Marcus is all over the place, his character starts to make less and less sense. On one hand he keeps talking about how he is the only one who can save Earth but on the other hand, the only people he seems to care about are himself and his daughter. How did a psycho like this make it to the rank of Admiral?
And the fight between the Enterprise and the Vengeance that takes place near Earth. Where are the other Starfleet ships? Why is no one concerned that there is a fight going on near the Moon? Why is no one in Starfleet command wondering where the USS Vengeance came from? The fight is taking place near Earth and you dont even see a Shuttlecraft come up and have a look.
There were a couple of unintentional comedy moments in the scenes on the Vengeance. The security guard that catches Scotty messing around with the airlock controls must go down as the worst security guard in the history of Star Trek. He just stands there pointing his phaser at Scotty and asking him what are you doing? Even when he hears Uhura talking over the communicator, he still just stands there and does nothing.
The second bit I found it hilarious was when Kirk confronts Marcus on the bridge of the Vengeance. Kirk and Khan have stunned/killed all of the Vengeance crew but for some reason, Kirk wont stun Admiral Marcus in front of his daughter in case it upsets her. Why not? Are the feelings of Carol Marcus so important that Kirk will risk the safety of the rest of the crew? Just silliness and more bad script writing.
2. Crash
Before Into Darkness was released, we were teased with the image of a ship that resembled the Enterprise, crashing into San Francisco. It turns out that the ship in question was actually the USS Vengeance.
With a rather awesome trick by Spock, Khan is tricked into beaming onboard 72 live torpedoes that explode and cripple the Vengeance. The ship slowly falls to Earth and destroys a considerable area of San Francisco. Not only are innocent citizens who might be enjoying a sandwich near the bay killed, the ship flattens skyscrapers that must be full of people before it finally comes to a stop. The death toll must be in the tens of thousands, the Vengeance is a huge ship and its impact with San Francisco would have had major consequence for the poor people on the ground.
Not that you would know though, not only does Khan survive the whole thing without messing up his uniform, the people walking around San Francisco dont seem too bothered about the starship that flattened half of the city. They seem more shocked by Spock beaming down with a phaser than the disaster that's occurred a few blocks down from them.
In-fact, so little attention is given to the mass death of innocent civilians, the Enterprise crew make no comment about it and are more concerned that Khan might have survived the crash. Spock and the crew might be upset that Kirk is dead, but screw the tens of thousands who just died because you let off a bunch of torpedoes inside the Vengeance.
1. Conclusion
It might sound like I hated the film but for all the faults, I did enjoy it. It was a much better film than the 2009 reboot and it had a tighter script, even if it fell apart by the end. Some bits felt like an Original Series episode (which was nice to see) but the shameless plagiarism of The Wrath Of Khan was unnecessary.
Spock was still too emotional; it made the scenes where we are supposed to be surprised by his display of emotion mean very little because he is always having some sort of outburst. Spock comes across as a jerk with no social skills, rather than a Vulcan suppressing his emotions. Spock worked better as an alien who was embarrassed by his emotions and denied them even though you could see them festering below the surface. Quinto-Spock smirks, smiles, cries and shouts throughout Into Darkness, he has lost the thing that made him unique and the only difference between him and the other characters in that he has pointed ears.
On the other hand, apart from the frat boy like attitude to every woman he sees, Chris Pine looked more comfortable as Captain Kirk. There were even moments of Shatnerism that were missing in the 2009 movie.
I also liked the way the Enterprise was shot in this film, we saw more of the ship and it looked great on the screen. The warp effect was also much better with the blue particle effect looking stunning in IMAX; you got a real sense of speed as the ship went to warp. It appears the Enterprise will get a slight redesign in Star Trek 3, the warp nacelles look more in proportion and they look less like hair dryers, so that might win around some people who hated the new look.
The introduction of Khan was badly handled and Orci, Kurtzman and Lindelof still keep making the same mistakes in their scripts that have damaged all the films they have penned. But it was fun to watch; it looked great in 3D on the IMAX screen. Its just sad that there were so many holes that acted like stumbling blocks and kept taking me out of the action on the screen. JJ Abrams has succeeded in making Star Trek into nothing but a special effects bonanza. It might make an enjoyable trip to the cinema but by alienating the legion of old school Trekkies in favour of quick ticket sales, this version of Star Trek will not have the legs to create a 50 year legacy like the original Star Trek did.