Star Wars: 10 Massive Plot Holes The Sequels Stupidly Created
Bringing balance to the Force, or confusion to the films?
While the Prequel Trilogy was lambasted by fans and critics across the board for its flat characterisations, over reliance on underdeveloped CGI and bland dialogue, Episodes I, II and III are still praised to this day for fleshing out the Star Wars franchise from a simple reframing of ancient good/evil myths in space into a complex and developed liveable universe, full of established lore and culture.
The Sequel Trilogy, in an attempt to remove itself from the Prequels, reverted back to the bare bones that made the Original Trilogy so well loved in the first place: tangible props, a Light Side/Dark Side dualism, and the mystification of the Force. In trying so hard to recapture the spirit of the franchise's first three movies, however, The Force Awakens, The Last Jedi and The Rise Of Skywalker took a very insular look on the franchise, expounding on concepts introduced in the first three movies while not really adding anything new to the mix.
By being so focused on pre-existing mythos and well-known and well-loved characters, perhaps it was inevitable that the Sequel Trilogy would stumble across a few inconsistencies along the way.
What many fans didn't predict, though, was that the movies would retroactively introduce plot holes into the franchise, questioning why some things happened or didn't happen in the first six films.
10. The Chosen One Narrative
In The Phantom Menace, it was revealed that there would be a so-called "Chosen One" who would "bring balance to the Force", ridding the galaxy of evil. Qui-Gon Jinn, and subsequently the Jedi Council, came to realise that a certain boy from Tatooine by the name of Anakin Skywalker was this Chosen One.
Though Anakin seemed to have lost his way in the third movie of the then six-part saga (turning into a Sith Lord would do that, all right), he eventually redeemed himself at the end of Return Of The Jedi, becoming once again Anakin and killing The Emperor, ridding the galaxy of evil before dying.
Turns out, Anakin Skywalker was the Chosen One after all and, after a couple of decades on hiatus from his destiny, he eventually fulfilled the prophecy, bringing balance to the Force and ridding the galaxy of the Sith.
Until, of course, The Force Awakens. While Supreme Leader Snoke and Kylo Ren weren't technically Sith (the latter belonging to the Knights of Ren, an organisation whose purpose still hasn't really been explained), it was clear from the start of Episode VII that the Force didn't seem to be in "balance", after all. Luke's Jedi Order had disbanded, and an Empire-like organisation quickly swept in to re-take control of the galaxy.
This tarnishing of Anakin's legacy and the prophecy took another stride forward when The Rise Of Skywalker revealed that Emperor Palpatine had orchestrated the rise of the First Order, and had been pulling strings for years. So if Palpatine was alive, does that mean that ... Anakin didn't bring balance to the Force?
Disney tried to resolve this by having an Anakin Skywalker Force Ghost tell Rey to "bring balance to the Force, as I did", but come on - if this "balance" only lasts for a few years, is it really balance at all? This begs the question: who exactly was the Chosen One?
9. What Did Palpatine Actually Want?
Though the Original Trilogy presents the Emperor as little more than the manifestation of evil, the Prequels transformed good old Sheev into a three dimensional character, even if his motivations amounted to little more than using a series of badass Force-sensitive henchmen to help him gain complete control of the galaxy.
Revenge Of The Sith added another layer of depth to the character, as it transpired Palpatine was also after the secrets of eternal life, enlisting Darth Vader to help him gain immortality.
But at the end of Return Of The Jedi, Palpatine taunts Luke to strike him down, presumably to get Vader to duel his son in an attempt to convert Luke to the Dark Side of the Force. Or maybe, knowing full well the Rule Of Two, which states there can only ever be two Sith Lords in existence at a time, Palpatine really was hoping Luke would kill him, convinced that Vader and Luke would form a stronger Sith team than himself and the Jedi formerly known as Anakin Skywalker.
Of course, the Emperor does eventually die (...apparently), at the hands of Darth Vader. Turns out he did manage to figure out some secrets of immortality before his demise, though, as he makes a miraculous return in the opening scenes of The Rise Of Skywalker.
Just when it's starting to seem Palpatine's wish of immortality finally came true, he starts begging Rey to kill him, just as he taunted Luke to do the same at the end of Return Of The Jedi. It's implied that by doing so, Rey would give Palpatine free reign to essentially possess her, becoming one with her soul and living through Rey's body. Which, of course, just opens up more questions: why didn't Palpatine possess Vader at the end of Episode VI? Did Palpatine want eternal life for himself, or for his spirit to live through another?
Add this to the fact that Palpatine's puppet Snoke was trying to orchestrate Rey's death throughout Episode VII and VIII only for the Emperor to tell her "I never wanted you dead" in Episode IX, and Palpatine's motivations just seem, well, all over the place, with no consistency throughout the saga.
8. Why Didn't Force Ghost Anakin Stop Kylo?
Despite his thirty year, erm, indiscretion, Return Of The Jedi clearly showed that Anakin Skywalker was able to materialise his spirit into a Force Ghost after death, even reverting back to his pre-turn to the Dark Side persona.
It makes absolutely no sense, then, that Anakin's Force Ghost stayed silent for years when his grandson Ben Solo started getting a bit too obsessed with his Dark Side persona, Darth Vader. After feeling genuine regret and remorse at the end of Return Of The Jedi, would Anakin really have just allowed to let his grandson follow him down the same path? After decades of suffering, did it not occur to him once to tell his grandson that turning yourself over completely to the Dark Side of the Force might not be the best idea?
Of course, this can be dismissed quite easily by the assumption that Palpatine prevented Anakin's Force Ghost from appearing to Kylo while acting as a voice inside his head, but similar problems pop out throughout the rest of the Sequel Trilogy.
Yoda finally turns up near the end of The Last Jedi to show Luke the error of his ways, telling his old student that maybe he should let go of the rigid old ways of the Jedi Order which inadvertently led to the rise of the Empire in the first place.
You'd think, though, that a Jedi as wise as Yoda was supposed to be would have thought of putting a word in before Luke started his Jedi Order -- especially when it became clear he was making exactly the same mistakes the Jedi of old had made.
7. Why Even Bother With A Droid Army?
As well as expanding the Star Wars universe in numerous other ways, the brilliant Clone Wars TV show made one thing clear: it is very, very expensive to maintain a droid army.
Given this great cost, and the rather ineffectual nature of droid soldiers (which can easily, easily be deprogrammed or just sliced through by Jedi or more advanced troops), it's surprising that the Separatist Army ever considered a droid army in the first place.
The Sequel Trilogy questions this logic even further, as the First Order proceeds to train legions of kidnapped children to form the backbone of their army. Even without actually having to pay these slave soldiers, presumably the cost of maintaining and feeding organic beings would be far higher than the production of identikit, not too technologically advanced, droids.
The First Order, rising from the ashes of the Empire and operating for the first few years of its existence in the shadows, would presumably have had quite a few resource problems, especially when compared to the near-infinite wealth of the Separatists considering their allegiance with the banking clan.
If it was easier and cheaper to find better soldiers than completely disposable droids, this begs the question: why did the Separatists even bother with a droid army at all? The adoption of a flesh-and-bone army after the creation of the Empire demonstrates that, out of all the options for beefing the military, droids were probably the worst of all.
6. Did The Rebels Actually Win The War?
Return Of The Jedi, supposedly the final film of the franchise for a number of years, ended triumphantly, with our heroes celebrating victories big and small on the forest moon of Endor as the galaxy at large erupted with glee, happy that the evil Empire had finally fallen to its knees.
Except... did it? While the destruction of the Second Death Star and the apparent death of Emperor Sheev Palpatine technically marked the end of the Empire, its outposts continued to thrive after the end of the Galactic Civil War, eventually gathering enough strength to become a potent military and political force of its own, the First Order.
The New Republic's reign was so short lived, in fact, that it was simply a blip or footnote in the history of the galaxy before being obliterated by this new Order, which proceeded to pick up where the old Empire left off.
Even though the Rebels did indeed defeat the figurehead of the Empire, can this defeat really be classed as a victory when it is clear that the new Senate was seemingly disinterested in ridding the galaxy of individuals who kept the ideology of the Empire alive?
It seems that the New Republic let the old Empire roost itself back to strength in the background, and the Sequels never give audiences any indication of what our old heroes had been doing to truly and utterly vanquish this shadowy foe.
5. Why Has No-One Used Force Healing Before?
Although Force Healing has been a staple in Star Wars video games for what seems like forever, the ability has only actually been used five times within the canonical series: twice in The Mandalorian, and a whopping three times in The Rise Of Skywalker.
It's a neat ability, one which allows a Force User to transfer some of their life energy to another living being, even able to (as Ben Solo demonstrates at the end of Episode IX) bring others back from death: the very power Palpatine seemed so desperate to find in Episode III.
Of course, Rey used it twice earlier in the movie, once on a weird big remember-this-is-a-Star-Wars-movie! snake thing and the other time on Kylo Ren himself. Presumably, Rey and Ben would have learnt the ability from somewhere, but where? Most likely from Leia or Luke, but they could have only learnt the power from Yoda or Obi-Wan, two characters who have never been seen to use the ability before.
If Obi-Wan knew how to use Force Healing, it was pretty selfish of him to just watch his old master Qui-Gon Jinn die at the hands of Darth Maul, rather than trying to revive him at the end of The Phantom Menace. Admittedly, Obi-Wan was still young in that movie, and hadn't developed all of his powers, but surely the ancient and almost all-powerful Yoda would have found a use for it when he found himself surrounded by dozens of dead Padawans at the end of Revenge Of The Sith?
On the subject of Revenge Of The Sith, wasn't Anakin's fall to the Dark Side largely predicated on his premonitions of Padmé's death? If only there had been someone to teach him this ability...
4. The Destruction Of The Second Death Star
Return Of The Jedi culminates in the utter destruction of the Second Death Star, which is blown to smithereens after an aerial assault spearheaded by Lando Calrissian.
In the iconic shot from Episode VI, it looks like the Death Star is annihilated completely.
In The Rise Of Skywalker, however, it becomes apparent that not only did parts of the exterior shell of the Death Star survive the explosion, landing in tact into the sea of Kef Bir, the entire Empire's throne room was undamaged despite its proximity to a massive shaft leading right down to the space station's core. In fact, the Death Star was so well preserved after the explosion that it even managed to generate a secrete hidden room where Rey could face a Dark Side version of herself, despite the room not existing at all in the Original Trilogy. Right....
The Dark Side of the Force may be "a path to many abilities some consider to be unnatural", for sure, but there isn't much that can explain how such a significant part of the structure survived that explosion.
Even more head scratch inducing is the fact that the Blade of Ochi somehow managed to point Rey directly to the Emperor's throne room, its accuracy despite the wreckage floating in water being beyond comprehension.
3. Why Didn't The Force Ghosts Do Anything?
In A New Hope, Obi-Wan taunted his old apprentice Vader to strike him down, claiming that "I shall become more powerful than you can possibly imagine." Without batting an eyelid, Anakin killed his old master, watching his body instantaneously become one with the Force.
Turns out, Obi-Wan's new "power" was nothing more than his his ability to interact with the living, as the old master proceeded to train Luke Skywalker from beyond the grave as though he simply were a YouTube fitness tutorial.
During The Last Jedi, it became apparent that as well as being able to communicate with the living, Force Ghosts were actually able to interact with the corporeal realm, demonstrated by Yoda summoning Force Lightning from the sky to destroy the old Jedi Temple on Ach-To.
So, why didn't Obi-Wan or Yoda demonstrate some actual power and help defeat Vader and the Emperor in Return Of The Jedi or earlier, presumably saving thousands of lives? In Return Of The Jedi, they tell Luke he must face Vader alone as they cannot help him -- but they never tell Luke why.
For that matter, why did Palpatine even bother cloning himself as a contingency plan, when he could have just learnt the Jedi powers of immortality and continue ruling the galaxy as a Force Ghost, his ghostly omnipresence presumably making him more powerful than he ever could have been in his half-melted body.
2. What Happened To Luke Skywalker's Lightsaber?
One of the biggest enigmas introduced in the mystery box-fuelled Force Awakens was that of Luke and Anakin's lightsaber, which was last seen falling from the sky into nothingness at the end of The Empire Strikes Back.
This mystery was, in true Disney Star Wars fashion, swept away by a simple throwaway line, as Maz Kanata helpfully declared that that's "a good question, for another time."
Safe to say that this "other time" never actually came about, and the mystery of Luke's lightsaber was not brought up again at all throughout the Sequel Trilogy. The iconic prop was even casually tossed away by the old Jedi master on Ach-To as though it was yesterday's newspaper, rather than a heavily-symbolic weapon he hadn't seen in thirty-odd years.
If the lightsaber was so easy to retrieve from the surface of Bespin, why did Luke opt to construct an entirely new weapon instead of his old one?
Maybe Luke Skywalker just got used to misplacing his lightsabers over the years -- after all, his iconic green blade is only seen in flashbacks in the Sequels.
1. The Undoing Of Han's Character Arc
Admittedly, the retreading and repetition of Han Solo's character arc is by this point a staple in the Star Wars Universe.
In A New Hope, the once self-centred smuggler turns good after realising that selfishness isn't always great, joining the Rebellion's assault on the Death Star, becoming a hero.
After three years spent working closely with the Rebellion, Han decides at the start of The Empire Strikes Back that he is a self-centred smuggler once again, doubling back on his character arc in the first movie --- only to realise once more that selfishness isn't always great, becoming, once again, a hero.
In Solo ... well, you get the point.
After seeming to run away from the good fight only to become a hero not once, not twice but three times, it seemed certain that Han had eventually settled on his path, realising his destiny lay with fighting authoritarian regimes rather than looking after himself.
But during The Force Awakens, audiences are re-introduced to a disenfranchised Han who not only ran away from the New Republic and the Resistance, but also his family, giving up on redeeming his son Ben and leaving his long-term partner Leia to deal with her grief alone.
Of course, Han does eventually re-join the good fight (again), even sacrificing himself in a futile attempt to save his son in perhaps the most emotional scene in the entire Saga. Still, it's a little disorientating that the Sequel Trilogy picks up Han's story arc from seemingly the midpoint of A New Hope, rather than its heroic conclusion at the end of Return Of The Jedi.