George Lucas has been having a moan about The Force Awakens. His criticism? It wasn't how he would have done it. That's hardly surprising, but it's a tad ungrateful considering the Rancor-sized sack of money he received for signing over the rights to Disney. Somewhat inevitably, fans have queued up to take potshots at the bearded wonder, mainly focusing on his prequel trilogy and about people in glass houses throwing stones. However, should Episodes I - III be consigned to history? Can these huge chunks of the property be written off entirely without thought? In short no, because there are some redeeming elements that actually belong among the best moments of the franchise. The definitive scenes of Star Wars are already well-documented, but is it really fair to judge the saga solely on Eps IV - VII? It's wrong to ignore the fact that the entire thing has an embarrassment of riches, and to a certain extent the better moments of the prequels have been wiped out thanks to blinkered wholesale hatred. There are parts of those films that deserve to be recognized as essential components of the mammoth legacy. So take your opinions out of lightspeed and let me take you on a tour of what the fanbase might be missing out on (with a guest appearance from the least-liked chapter of the classic trilogy for good measure)...
10. Watto Zings Jedi - The Phantom Menace
One of the advantages Lucas saw in resurrecting Star Wars in the late Nineties was the freedom afforded him by CGI, enabling him to create characters who wouldn't have been possible a decade previously. One of the major new additions was Watto, the Gonzo-esque scrap dealer who owns young Anakin and his mother in Episode I. Whilst the likes of young Jabba fell flat with the diehards, Watto was a small but pivotal part of the action, with a great vocal performance by Andy Secombe. He's not reviled like Binks, but he doesn't get his share of the credit either, so here he is fluttering into the Top 10 for a crowd-pleasing sequence. Lucas's attempts at humour were generally about as funny as a lightsaber through the nutsac, but he got it right with Watto. A perfect example of this is when smug Jedi Qui-Gon Jinn (Liam Neeson) attempts to waft his mystical charms in the Toydarian's direction, only to be rebuffed by the miniature, mind-trick reistant hoodwinker. Not only is it genuinely amusing, it also sees the franchise creator mocking his nest egg and illustrating that maybe this wasn't quite the world we were looking for...
9. Blowing Up The Death Star... Again - Return Of The Jedi
Let's blow up the Death Star! It worked so well in Episode IV that it made sense to try and repeat the trick with a new world-pulverizing planet in Episode VI. This time around the main heroes were tied up. Luke was facing off against Darth Vader and the Emperor. Han, Chewy and Leia were helping the Ewoks nobble Scout Troopers. So it fell to Lando Calrissian and friends to get a piece of the action at the controls of the Millennium Falcon. It's easy to apply the law of diminishing returns and claim this was a case of more of the same. But if fans hadn't been so distracted by the Ewoks would the thrilling attack sequence on Death Star 2 have been a bigger deal than it seemed at the time? The final confrontation between Luke and Vader was the main event, though you could hardly call Calrissian's mission a side issue. Most importantly it gave minor characters their moment in the sun, showing that resistance to the Empire was a team effort and it wasn't all about the big guns. The spectacular special effects, combined with the creature work on such memorable allies as Admiral Ackbar and Nien Nunb, made this one of the mothers of all galactic dogfights and an element that helped bring the classic trilogy to a close so successfully.
8. Worm Front - Attack Of The Clones
The prequels are characterized by their wobbly acting and obsession with green screen, yet despite this they remain distinctive in their vision and imaginative in their execution, especially when it came to the assorted battles and skirmishes. Natalie Portman's Queen Amidala was a decidedly proactive royal who didn't see her role as simply sitting back and letting the men do the work. There came a time however when she really needed the services of a saber-swishing Jedi, and that was in her bedchamber of all places. After a hard day dealing with Jar Jar Binks you just want to get your head down, right? Unfortunately a peaceful night became the last order of business for Portman, as an unusual assassination attempt interrupted her Naboo nap time. Everyone's had a spider in their room, or a moth seemingly obsessed with landing on your face. The Trade Federation went one stage further by releasing two worm-like kouhuns to kill the snoozing lovely. Luckily Anakin and Obi Wan intercepted the dastardly plot, carried out by two-faced female gun for hire Zam Wesell. The sequence was a great example of how Lucas's much-criticized political plots received a shot in the arm via the strange and eye-catching aliens who were involved. The last thing people expected from the prequels was a talky thriller vibe. Though scenes like this definitely made the waffle worth it.
7. We're Off To Gungan City (Glug Glug) - The Phantom Menace
Having encountered Jar Jar on Naboo, Qui-Gon Jinn and Obi Wan needed a place to hide from the infernal and racially-questionable Trade Federation. Mr Binks opted to take them to his home city, and its location was a dramatic departure from the typical alien landscapes of the franchise. In a first for the series, our heroes had to swim to a striking glass complex below the surface. There they were to meet Jar Jar's leader Boss Nass to ask for his help and bear witness to such legendary dialogue as "You in big doo-doo this time." That said, several things mark this sequence out as a classic. An underwater sequence in a space-bound movie? It was immediately different and intriguing. It was one of those times when everything really came together during the prequels, where the fan in me stopped analyzing and just stopped to admire the craft. This marked the story out as a visual deviation from what we'd seen in the original films. The canvas Lucas was painting on became much broader and more opulent. It's interesting to compare his approach to the one he had with the original trilogy, where the tale mushroomed into a generation-spanning behemoth in his head, but he didn't have the technical know-how to get it out there. Striking moments like this showed he could let his imagination fly.
6. Jango-1 Obi-Nil - Attack Of The Clones
Boba Fett had been a man of few (and rather muffled) words during his time on Episodes V-VI. So it was a surprise to fans when Lucas decided to present Boba as a child, ushering in Jango his Kiwi father, whose role in the creation of the Empire entered into history. If Boba had been a bad ass, Jango was the bad ass tree his bad ass had fallen from. Casting surly hard nut Temuera Morrison as Dad meant there was probably a hell of a confrontation lined up, and we were treated to just such a dust-up when Obi Wan arrived on the tidal planet of Kamino, where the grizzled gunsmith was holed up assisting the clonemakers with their Stormtrooper project. You could tell from the off that these two guys were going to lock horns and their brief but memorable face off in the stinging spray is everything a good Star Wars fight sequence is made of. Aficionados may have been a bit "meh"ed at the time, but I urge them to go back and reassess this section. It's good quality action cinema. The best bit was you got to see a Fett jet pack working properly, with Jango taking to the air to launch a major assault on the fresh-faced Jedi Master. This was opposed to the pesky bit of kit that sent Fett Jr spiralling down into the belly of the Sarlacc Pit, to be digested for all eternity like a Greggs pasty.
5. Things Get Grievous - Revenge Of The Sith
A fearsome foe who came and went during the course of the prequels was General Grievous. A multi-limbed droid with freaky organic eyes, he should perhaps have passed immediately into the Intergalactic Hall Of Fame, alongside the franchise's most hissable villains. That he isn't widely praised is more a comment on fans' disappointment with Episodes I - III than a lack of ingenuity on the designers' part. Darth Maul had his double-ended lightsaber, but with Grievous you had four assassins in one. Even the humbug-faced Maul would've struggled against the twirling blades of this cutthroat customer. Indeed, the bronchial bad guy hoarded sabers like trophies, giving the finger to the powerful Jedi Council and adding insult to injury. Obi Wan had a few tussles with the General in the first half of Episode III, leading to an epic showdown on rocky planet Utapau. This sequence not only depicted Grievous at his most deadly, it showed us Kenobi at the full height of his powers - an encounter you could well imagine Alec Guinness looking back on with a twinkle in his eye.
4. Sand In Your Saber - The Phantom Menace
Darth Maul (Ray Park) was very much the spectre at the feast of Episode I. He took the role of the guy you were watched to see what he was going to do. Huskily muttering at the Emperor in his first scene, he then made for Tatooine, where he stalked Qui-Gon Jinn and his companions. When he showed his moves he did so in brief but eye-popping fashion. Zooming toward the fleeing Jedi on his Maulmobile, he somersaulted off and ferociously engaged Liam Neeson's bland, bearded sage in lightsaber combat. The skirmish got cut short, but it was as obvious as Jabba The Hut at a Weight Watchers convention that the fight had only just begun. This sequence became the first glimpse of a proper Jedi/Sith face-off, in the ninja-esque manner you might have imagined the old order to have conducted itself. The classic trilogy was slack by comparison, a bunch of blokes standing about swishing their glowsticks. Maul Vs Jinn on the other hand? An acrobatic mini-masterpiece of burning blades. Abrupt it may be, but you can't dismiss this revealing sliver of Star Wars history.
3. We're Rescuing This Guy Who's Clearly Not Evil - Revenge Of The Sith
Episode III opened with a sequence that was epic enough to close any previous instalment of what had gone before. Yet the rescue of Supreme Chancellor Palpatine, the wise, respected, wizened and totally sinister podium jockey at the heart of the Republic, administered a visual vitamin shot to the viewer before Anakin Skywalker's closing chapter got fully underway. Aside from the dazzling display of starships opening fire on each other across the cosmos, there were the goings-on aboard General Grievous' vessel. CGI gave George Lucas immense scope in the way he constructed his prequel series, and while some thought the results a bit antiseptic you couldn't help but marvel at some of what he managed to get onscreen. Most memorable was the sight of our protagonists (and one antagonist) having to run across the floor of the see-sawing ship as it rocked from nose to thrusters, buffeted by enemy blasts. A strange variation of Titanic played out as the group tumbled one way then the other, a feat that simply wouldn't have been doable under Industrial Light & Magic in the Eighties.
2. The Senate Awakens - Revenge Of The Sith
Yoda had already produced one of the craziest and most inspired battle scenes in the Star Wars canon, when he switched on his lightsaber to take on the late Christopher Lee's Count Dooku in Attack Of The Clones. Around the world millions of fans held their breath and thought: "Could they...? Would they...?" And they did, as the little green man par excellence unleashed hell on the Count in a flurry of ears and electricity. It was a mix of the hilarious and the death-defying. Lucas repeated the trick toward the end of Episode III, when the forces of good and evil came to blows in the quiet surroundings of the Senate. Yoda battling Dooku was good, and Lee's presence lent it no small degree of gravitas. But this was the greatest confrontation of Yoda's hoodie-wearing career - Jedi Master meets Sith Sorceror. The pair quite literally tore the place apart in pursuit of victory. It was also a point of release for Star Wars addicts, who'd found the political wranglings underpinning the prequels to be drier than a Tusken Raider's unmentionables. The debating chamber played host to a colossal level of mayhem... and about time! Instead of going to see The Force Awakens for the eighty-eighth time, stick this in your player and relive a truly epic Star Wars moment... then go and see The Force Awakens for the eighty-eighth time.
1. Getting A Mauling - The Phantom Menace
Episode I contains what I think to be the most underrated action scene in the franchise's history. It certainly thrilled audiences at the time, but got unjustly drowned out by the reactions to the cutesy pre-Stormtooper droids and of course the flailing antics of Jar Jar. Darth Maul's fleeting set-to with Qui Gon-Jinn was just the warm up for an exciting and innovative lightsaber fight that injected undiluted War directly into the throbbing vein of Star Wars. Maul wasn't just a bad guy with a deadly weapon. He packed a double-ended saber for Yoda's sake! J.J.Abrams devised a laser sword with a hilt for The Force Awakens, but that was gimmicky compared to this development. Two blades meant of course that the red and black renegade could fend off two attackers. And what attackers they were, in the forms of Jinn and Obi Wan. Apart from the choreography you had the way Lucas assembled the sequence, cleverly breaking up the frenetics with a forcefield that separated the characters, most notably just after the slaying of Jinn. This meant Ewan McGregor had to do his best angry teddy bear face in the run up to the barrier coming down, allowing him a pop at his mentor's murderer - outstanding drama! Combine that with John Williams' heart-pummelling score and you've got enough oomph to detonate a dozen Death Stars. Do you agree with this list? Are these sequences underrated, or is the writer talking out of his main thruster? Let us know in the comments section...