I know what you're thinking. "Wait, did Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace have a Special Edition?" Well, the answer is yes, sort of; there hasn't been a massive fanfare about it (unlike the original trilogy, I doubt we'll be celebrating its twentieth anniversary with a high-profile re-release), but George Lucas has slyly made several changes to the first prequel since the movie's release in 1999. The first alterations came with the 2001 DVD release, which were then furthered by the 2011 Blu-Ray, the most commonly version available today. The other prequels has some other home release tinkering (Jango now tries to start his jetpack as Mace Windu attacks in Attack Of The Clones and Vader's "Noooo" was shockingly shortened for Revenge Of The Sith), but The Phantom Menace has now had enough alterations that the version you can buy now to pretty much counts as a completely different cut to the original, theatrical film. What this means is that most people who constantly demonise Episode I haven't actually seen its theatrical release, and those who have won't in well over a decade. I'm not saying that without these additions and changes that Lucas' no-holds-barred prequel is some bastion of cinema, but what they do is exacerbate some of the more potent criticisms of the film (or are so pointless it's obscene someone had to actually waste their time on it). Unlike the branded Special Editions, which at least in their earlier iterations were conceived as honest improvements to the film, all of the changes here are changes for the sake of changes; they're either so minor they're worthless or so extraneous they only further hurt the film and, as we'll see, were all done primarily out of laziness. Of course, few seem to care because of the movie's lesser quality, but that shouldn't really matter; The Phantom Menace was a highly-anticipated movie that defined the rise of internet film commentary, and knowing of and being able to see it in its original form is incredibly important. And so, in honour of respecting Episode I's place in film history, today let's take a look at the stupidest changes made to it since release.
8. Force Speed Blur
During the opening fight on the Trade Federation cruiser, Nute Gunray manages to get the upper hand on the encroaching Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon by unleashing droidekas, destroyer droids that with their rolling capabilities, shield generators, machine laser guns and sci-fi "face" couldn't be more engineered to be a toy. These are too much for the Jedi (because toys) and they use Force Speed to get away, the only time in the movies this pretty useful skill is used. For the Blu-Ray, this scene was deemed so important it was altered; there was some motion blur added to the Force Speed, allegedly to make it look more realistic. How this one shot clearly irked George more than any other, necessitating a change, is beyond me; there's no later uses of the powers to make this a continuity adjustment. But here's the kicker; it's not even that much better. The Jedi move at the same speed and they look to have just been touched up by a very sensitive blur tool. If anything, the high blur makes it look less realistic than before.
7. The Extended Pod Race Opening
Ah, the pod race. A high-tech contest featuring a whole host of colourful faces; Anakin, Sebulba, Ben Quadrinaros (he has quad engines because name equals personality), erm... spindly armed woman... three-eyed fella... was Nein Numb there? OK, they're not as instantly iconic characters as the parallel cantina from the original, but George Lucas tried to get them across to fans. Well, eventually; for the 2001 DVD he massively extended the character introductions at the start of the pod race, not just highlight Anakin and Sebulba (y'know, our main characters in all this), but anyone else even minorly involved later on - from Gran Mawhonic to Oddy Mandrell's super duper pit crew - gets a shout out. Out of all the changes, this is probably the worst; each intro has a lengthy attempt at expanding these characters beyond cool creature design, which usually just means throwing out tech jargon to describe their racer while the CGI model pulls a face. The result is jarring even in this film, especially as the model-shading and green-screening is noticeably ropey.
6. "Be Safe"
Shimi Skywalker isn't shown as the best mother in The Phantom Menace; she allows her nine-year-old son to risk his life in a sport he's repeatedly had near-death experiences in because some old guy he brought home said it might be a good. She doesn't even have the decency to have a kind word with Ani before the race. So it's a good thing that in amongst all the shoddy CGI Lucas chose to add in a scene of her wishing her son luck, telling him to "be safe". Or it would be if it wasn't a failed take - Pernilla August is bland and Jake Lloyd is more stilted than usual - poorly integrated into the movie with the music and general background sound dropping. The scene was clearly cut the first time because it just didn't work - it sticks out and, if this is indeed the best take, the actors really weren't trying - but there's nothing to justify it being re-added. So why use it? Well, as with most of this pod race sequence, any additions seem to have been done simply because they'd been originally removed so late in the day that all the special effects were finished. That's it; less effort, less expenditure.
5. The Padded Pod Race Second Lap
The pod race goes on too long. That may be one of the most recurrent problems raised about the prequels that isn't an obviously repacked point from the Mr Plinkett reviews (when someone can criticise the characterisation in Episode I without actively asking you to describe the characters, I'll be impressed), and while it was something prevalent in the theatrical version, it's only been exacerbated by George Lucas' additions to the 2001 DVD. There was a lot cut from Lucas' ode to Ben-Hur, and while elements still remain on the cutting room floor (don't forget, The Phantom Menace was shot on real, actual film), he managed to mush most of it back in for home video, with call-backs to characters from the opening and expanded cases of Sebulba's dickery (we get to see him use his flaming vents on an unsuspecting racer). It's all unnecessary, not really adding anything to the plot at hand (which should be focused on Anakin), and really only stretches out an already pretty long sequence - it's a lot of action involving characters we only partially care about (and no, a five-second shot of them pre-race doesn't count as development).
4. Anakin Goes Spinning
You know what's worse than simply chucking in a bunch of extraneous moments into the pod race? Even when Lucas does put the focus on Anakin we still lose a sense of purpose, with an over-reliance on proving just how great a pilot is getting in the way of an engaging, tight sequence. In the original film, the first lap has Anakin at the back of the back, the second him catching up and third sparring with Sebulba. The DVD throws a spanner into the works with a second lap bit where Anakin's pod somehow detaches from one of his engines, sending him spinning (with unconvincing green screen) and setting him further back. It's a messy sequence, but also totally unnecessary when you consider all the other mechanical problems Ani comes up against in the race (if anything this makes his win even more unlikely). What purpose does it add Sebulba's tampering didn't? Is the "spinning" meant to be foreshadowing of how he enters the Trade Federation ship? Because that makes no sense.
3. Jar Jar And Ani Ride An Air Taxi
The air taxi sequence is one of the most perfunctory in all of Star Wars; Anakin and Jar Jar ride through the skies of Coruscant and... that's pretty much it. Jar Jar makes some quip about the Queen being nice (which I will concede is fair seeding of the identity twist), but then it's just a stream of location shots with the oddly designed vehicle sweeping through them. No wonder it originally wound up on the cutting room floor. The scene was only added into the film for the 2001 DVD release, and has no effect other than further bloating the odd end-of-second-act Coruscant interlude. So why was it added back in? Well, looking at its release before being part of the movie proper might reveal that. Like the pod race it was a late removal, so no real CGI work was required to get it ready for the film. This ease point keeps popping up, and is certainly damning of the whole exercise of changing the film, but that this scene worked its way in is particularly astounding; these are two of the most despised characters in the film, and by the time he was prepping the home video release Lucas will have known that. It's almost like he's trolling the haters.
2. Orn Free Taa's Aides
Nothing shows the ridiculousness of producer Rick McCallum's "it's so dense" quote, so regularly used as an example of how the creative targets of the prequels were off, than the story of Orn Free Taa's aides. That's right - there's an entire behind-the-scenes tale about the extras who accompany a background character who wouldn't get a line until Revenge Of The Sith (telling Jar Jar to "watch it"). Orn Free Taa is a fat twi'lek senator throughout the prequels, in The Phantom Menace seen briefly in the Senate chamber. On set he had a pair of fellow twi'lek helpers (played by costume designer Trisha Biggar and concept artist Iain McCaig), but when the movie rolled around they had been replaced by two humans, cameos for Chrissie England (Visual Effects Executive Producer) and Jim Morris (then President of Lucas Digital). Clearly not happy with his in-joke, the DVD reverted back to the aliens. Except he replaced McCaig with a green twi'lek, preempting her minor appearance in Attack Of The Clones. Neither of these options is really better than the others - a senator having representatives of his own species may make sense, but it's not like human's wouldn't - and that's exactly the problem. In the massive, oft-criticised Senate sequence George changed only the most minor of things, almost teasing his detractors (although, again, it appears to come once more from it already being shot).
1. Yoda
Probably the most well known change to The Phantom Menace is the replacement of the on-set puppet Yoda with a CGI model more in-keeping with the one seen in Episodes II-III. Now this may, on the face of it, appear to be a solid alteration; that original Yoda puppet looked a bit off - overworked and a tad plastic-y - and this creates a greater overall coherence across the prequels. And I will allow both those points (even if "coherence" led to Temura Morrison voicing Boba Fett in The Empire Strikes Back), but they don't do enough to justify the alteration. The Yoda in The Phantom Menace wasn't out-and-out bad, and we still have the issue of prequel and original Yoda looking like two different creatures (and the first Phantom Menace one actually looked more like The Empire Strikes Back's). It's like fixing a naked exhaust port with plasterboard. And, once again, when you boil it down it's not a product of necessity or even a desire to better link The Phantom Menace to the later Episodes; it's only included in the Blu-Ray because the work had already been done. As prep for Revenge Of The Sith, where the CGI Yoda played a much larger role and had more complex scenes than previously, ILM went back to The Phantom Menace for a test, pasting their model in. When it came to doing up the Blu-Ray, that well-worn question of "if it's done, why not use it?" reared its head again. Just be thankful they didn't also go and paint over the original trilogy Yoda too. Like this article? What's your least favourite change made to the prequels? Let us know what you think down in the comments.