Star Wars: Rogue One Vs Solo - Which Is Better?
Which Star Wars Story reigns supreme?
While The Force Awakens, The Last Jedi, and the currently untitled Episode IX look to deliver on the spectacle in a whole new trilogy, Star Wars' anthology films aim to give us smaller-scale, more intimate stories from the Star Wars universe.
Released in late 2016, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story decided to show us exactly how the Rebel Alliance managed to steal the Death Star plans prior to A New Hope, as well as throw its own unique flavor into the mix.
Meanwhile, the sophomore entry in the anthology series, Solo: A Star Wars Story, has just recently hit theaters worldwide. This film details one of the greatest adventures of infamous smuggler Han Solo, showing how he got his start as a criminal, picked up some of his famous trademarks, and even how he managed to make the Kessel Run in less than twelve parsecs.
With both films now available to the world and more on the way, let's compare Rogue One and Solo beat-by-beat (and with spoilers) to find out which better represents what the upcoming anthology films should aspire to be.
13. Direction
Gareth Edwards and Ron Howard both attempted to do something different with the Star Wars franchise when it came to directing Rogue One and Solo, respectively.
With Rogue One, Edwards was very much trying to make a proper war film. And he clearly knew what he was doing when it came to showing all-out combat. The action scenes are intense and intimate, the film's overall tone is very grim, and despite how much happens in Rogue One (especially in the final act), everything is presented in a way that's easy to follow.
Meanwhile, Solo is a space western through and through. And Ron Howard did the best he could to combine the high-octane action sequences Star Wars fans know and love with shots and filming techniques that wouldn't look out of place in an old Clint Eastwood movie.
Winner: Edwards and Howard both tried to do something different with the visual style of their respective Star Wars anthology films and both hit the mark. That being said, Solo's flow is occasionally hindered by awkward cuts and transitions, whereas Rogue One's is much more fluid. Rogue One takes this category.
12. Humor
Both Rogue One and Solo are fairly funny films in their own right, but it's rather clear that the latter put much greater emphasis on humor than its predecessor did.
After all, Han Solo is one of Star Wars' funniest characters, so it only stands to reason that a film based entirely around him would make for an effective comedy. Han himself had some solid quips throughout the film, not to mention Alden Ehrenreich's great comedic timing. In addition, Donald Glover and Woody Harrelson, both of whom are major players in world of comedy, get plenty of decent laughs as Lando and Beckett, respectively.
Rogue One definitely had its own moments of comedic brilliance as well, despite being more drama-centric. K-2SO was easily the driving comedic force behind the movie, with more hilarious moments that most of the other characters combined. That's not to say that the rest of the cast was completely void of comedy, mind you. Jyn Erso, Orson Krennic, and Chirrut Îmwe all had some great one-liners. Even Darth Vader got in on action, making a snarky pun as he was force choking Krennic (truly he was Obi-Wan's apprentice).
Winner: Solo takes the point here fairly easily. To be fair, Rogue One was never really trying to be a comedy in the same way that Solo was, but the fact remains that Solo is still a much funnier film to sit through.
11. Core Narrative
Both anthology films thus far have gotten a lot of flak from certain fans for their narratives being "unnecessary" additions to the Star Wars continuity. However, if anything, the stories of both Rogue One and Solo add some much-needed moral ambiguity to the Star Wars saga, seeing as how the classic "good versus evil" formula the series was originally built around has started to wear a bit thin.
In addition to being an incredibly heartfelt tale of how a ragtag group of rebels made the ultimate sacrifice to steal the Death Star plans and give the Rebel Alliance at large a fighting chance at defeating the Empire, Rogue One has a lot of unique conflicts. At its core, it is still a story of good versus evil, but the film also features plenty shades of gray. Between Cassian Andor's regrets and Saw Gerrera's extremism, Rogue One is a true-to-life war story that shows how even the "good guys" may sometimes find themselves doing things they aren't proud of.
Meanwhile, Solo's main narrative is one based almost entirely around moral relativism. It's a story of a street criminal from Corellia teaming up with a group of professional thieves to rob people even worse than them. Yes, Han's true colors as a hero do shine through every so often, but at the end of the day, Solo is very much a story of someone who is simply doing what he can to survive.
Winner: Rogue One and Solo feel like Star Wars stories that were truly worth telling and both help blur the lines between good and evil. But the high, all-or-nothing stakes of Rogue One's story do make it more enthralling that Solo's heist-centric plot. Rogue One takes this point.
10. Subplots
Rogue One's major subplot revolved around who would receive credit for the Death Star. While this is essentially the intergalactic version of a company's executives fighting over who was actually hatched the idea for a big project, it tied into the main narrative just fine and the banter between Orson Krennic and Grand Moff Tarkin made it entertaining enough. The subplot revolving around Saw Gerrera's extremist group was also decent, even if not a whole lot of time was dedicated to it.
Solo is also a film that featured subplots that were fairly interesting, just not all that well developed. The romantic subplot between Han and Qi'ra was well written and added a new layer of depth to Han's history, but never really got the chance to hit any sort of stride. In addition, Han's time as a street criminal on Corellia, as well as his time as an Imperial trooper were mostly glossed over. Finally, the Enfys Nest subplot as well as L3-37's rebellion are fun and do play to the themes of the Star Wars universe at large, but aren't especially great outside the bubble of Solo's runtime.
Winner: Neither anthology film particularly excels as far as subplots are concerned. That said, Rogue One's subplots carry little relevance outside the film, whereas Solo's help add layers to both Han Solo's character, as well as the early days of the rebellion. In turn, Solo takes the point.
9. New Characters
Given how its entire purpose was to tell an entirely new and different story than any of the other main Star Wars films, it comes as no surprise that Rogue One had no shortage of great, brand-new characters on display. Jyn Erso is a fun lead, her father Galen is a complex foil for the Empire, Cassian Andor is a great deuteragonist, and Bodhi Rook is a charming everyman. In addition, Chirrut Îmwe is an incredibly entertaining character who is more than capable of bringing the action alongside Baze Malbus. Finally, there's sassy droid K-2SO, who steals the show at every available opportunity.
Solo also introduces some solid new characters, but they clearly take a backseat to the returning characters of Lando, Chewbacca, and, of course, Han Solo himself. That said, Beckett is still an entertaining character, Dryden Vos is a terrific villain, and say what you will about Emilia Clarke's performance, but Qi'ra was very well-written. However, while Val and Rio were fun, they were killed off very early on. L3-37 could also be hilarious, but she is sure to split fans down the middle.
Winner: Rogue One wins this round handily. It was focused around fresh new faces who were given more than enough time to make a significant impression. The newcomers in Solo were solid and had their time to shine, but the classic characters were very much the stars of the show.
8. Set Pieces
Rogue One has a few solid set pieces throughout its first two thirds. For instance, the huge fight sequence on Jedha is spectacular, as is the destruction of the moon's capital by the Death Star.
However, it's the final act that Rogue One really pulled out all the stops. The battle on the surface of Scarif, as well as the space battle above were full of incredible, emotional set pieces that just came one after the other. Between each main character's death, the ramming of one Star Destroyer into another, the Death Star firing upon Scarif, and, of course, the iconic Darth Vader hallway scene, Rogue One's third act is an eventful one, to say the very least.
Solo has some truly great set pieces on display as well. The opening chase scene was good fun, the train heist was a great way to get the ball rolling as far as the main plot was concerned, and the fight sequence on Savareen capped things off in a satisfying way. Finally, there's Solo's crown jewel: the Kessel Run, which is beyond exciting to watch.
Winner: Solo had some fantastic set pieces that helped make the film such a ride, the Kessel Run especially, but they don't pack quite as big a punch as the unadulterated chaos and emotion of Rogue One's final act. Hence, why Rogue One deserves this point.
7. Music
As great a film as Rogue One is, one of its shortcomings is the film's score, which was composed by Michael Giacchino. In fairness to Giacchino, he is an incredibly talented composer (with several Grammys to his name) who simply had a lot working against him. Alexandre Desplat was the Rogue One's original composer, but had to drop out as a result of the film's reshoots. So, Giacchino had very little time to put his score together. And while the final product was serviceable, much of it was a rehash of John Williams' work from previous Star Wars films and the original pieces didn't really stand out.
On the other hand, Solo's score absolutely soars. The film's composer, John Powell, had a lot more time to put his Star Wars anthology score together and it shows. His original pieces are energetic and fast-paced, which perfectly match the film's tone, in addition to being incredibly memorable. Powell did carry over several fan-favorite motifs from John Williams' scores (including a very nice, subtle nod to Duel of the Fates during the Darth Maul reveal), but at no point did they take priority over the original pieces.
Winner: As far as music goes, Solo blows Rogue One out of the water. Thanks to some production issues, Rogue One's music feels like an homage to the original films first and an original score second. Meanwhile, Solo is the exact opposite, prioritizing the fantastic new songs while classic motifs take a backseat.
6. Plot Twists
Rogue One's ending of every single one of the main characters dying in their final bid to get the Death Star plans off of Scarif makes for an incredibly emotional and shocking moment, especially when you see the film for the first time. That being said, it doesn't quite count as a plot twist, per se, as the film never did much to make it seem like things would play out any other way. In fact, in hindsight, the writing on the wall in regards to the characters' fates was apparent fairly early on.
Solo, on the other hand, has a number of minor plot twists, some of which work better than others. Beckett's betrayal of Han and company was well-done and necessary plot moment, but was also telegraphed pretty hard and most viewers likely saw it coming a mile off. However, the twist of Enfys Nest actually being a rebel cell, as opposed to marauders, was genuinely unexpected and really helped piece together Solo's final act. And, of course, there was the final reveal of (Darth) Maul being the leader of Crimson Dawn, which marked the character's first theatrical appearance in nineteen years.
Winner: As genuinely emotional as Rogue One's final act is, the film made it fairly obvious that none of its new characters were going to make it out alive. Meanwhile, Solo has three genuine plot twists, at least two of which really land. Another point for Solo.
5. Villains
In addition to the returning Darth Vader and Grand Moff Tarkin (both of whom have terrific moments), Rogue One added a new villain to the Star Wars lore: Orson Krennic. Admittedly, Krennic didn't really live up to his potential as the film's main antagonist, but he was still a fairly solid baddie. The way Krennic carried himself and commanded his forces made him look like a convincing Imperial leader and Ben Mendelsohn's performance as Krennic was absolutely stellar.
Meanwhile, Solo introduced Dryden Vos (the quasi-leader of Crimson Dawn) as its main villain, who was an absolute joy. Vos has a unique look, is a cold-blooded killer who can more than hold his own in a fight, and Paul Bettany wonderfully portrayed a crime boss with unsettling mannerisms who tries to appear calm, but always seems as though he could snap at any moment. He's by no means a game-changer, but he's great for what he is.
Although, thanks to the aforementioned plot twists, Vos is really Solo's only villain. Enfys Nest ended up not being bad guys at all and while the Darth Maul reveal was very cool, it was more of a wink and a nod to those who follow the Star Wars TV shows than anything else.
Winner: Orson Krennic was a serviceable villain, but is easily topped by Dryden Vos. However, as fun as Vos is, he can't quite stand up to the iconic Darth Vader going on an absolute rampage in Rogue One's final moments, nor the ever-sinister Tarkin (especially not by himself.) In the end, Rogue One just nabs this one.
4. Pacing
Comparing the pacing in Rogue One to that of Solo is a fairly simple task for two reasons. First of all, the films' runtimes are virtually identical (with Rogue One clocking in at 133 minutes and Solo at 135 minutes.)
Secondly, to decide which one is better, you simply have to look at the first act. Both films are (mostly) paced terrifically and their second and third acts absolutely fly, but both have also been criticized for their respective first acts feeling a bit too slow and clunky.
Both first acts are mostly filled with set-up and exposition that help set the course for the rest of the story, but both also have bombastic conclusions that really kick the film into overdrive (the destruction of Jedha's capital in Rogue One and the train heist in Solo).
That being said, while Rogue One's first act has a better payoff, Solo's is much faster-paced and arguably does a decent job at getting the audience warmed up for the rest of the movie.
Winner: It's a close call, but Solo takes this one. Both first acts are very methodical, but while Rogue One has the better overall story, Solo (quite literally) cuts to the chase much quicker.
3. Visuals
If absolutely nothing else, Rogue One is an utterly beautiful film in terms of visual effects (practical or otherwise), set design, and cinematography. Jedha was lovingly-crafted, its destruction looked utterly stellar, the space battles were some of the franchise's best, and every single thing about Scarif was absolutely gorgeous.
Let's also address the elephant in the room: the CGI recreations of Peter Cushing (Grand Moff Tarkin) and young Carrie Fisher (Princess Leia), which, quite frankly, are nowhere near as bad as some people make them out to be. Sure, they weren't perfect (given the experimental nature of the effect), but they still looked pretty great, all things considered. And the fact that they were able to pull this off at all while also making the rest of the film look as beautiful as they did is pretty remarkable.
Solo had its moments of visual brilliance as well. The costume and set design were on point, the explosion that toppled a mountain at the end of the train heist sequence was something to behold, and the monster that attacked the Millennium Falcon near the maw was absolutely breathtaking (as was the Kessel Run as a whole.)
Winner: Solo had some undeniably great visuals, but they pale in comparison to the crisp, unparalleled beauty that was on display throughout Rogue One's entire runtime. Your feelings on the CGI resurrections aside, Rogue One deserves this point.
2. Mythology
As stated before, both Rogue One and Solo do a fantastic job at adding moral ambiguity to the Star Wars films. And while some old-school fans of the series are hesitant to accept it, the fact of the matter is that if Star Wars is to carry forward, it needs to have shades of gray. Through Rogue One and Solo (as well as The Last Jedi), Lucasfilm have proven that they understand this.
In addition to their fresh take on "good versus evil", Rogue One and Solo also had their fair share of new lore and ideas to add to the Star Wars mythos.
Rogue One, much like the TV series Rebels, makes it a point to show viewers what it was like for the common people of the galaxy to live under the rule of the Empire. It also does a great job at showing the fallout of the Jedi Order's downfall through Chirrut's fighting techniques and apparent Force-sensitivity, as well as the state of the Jedi temple on Jedha. Finally, there's the touching, overarching story of all those who made the ultimate sacrifice to make sure the iconic Rebellion could live to fight another day.
Meanwhile, Solo has gotten some serious flak for its mere existence, as some believes that giving Han a backstory detracts from his character's mystique. In reality, though, it was clear from day one that Han had some serious stories to tell, so finally getting to see one first-hand feels pretty special. What's more is that Solo added a lot of depth to Han's character that retroactively carries over into the Original Trilogy.
Winner: Both films succeed in helping to fill in the gap between Episodes III and IV, but whereas Solo helped flesh out Han himself, Rogue One is so much bigger than itself in terms of the Star Wars mythology it built upon. So, Rogue One takes the final point.
1. Overall
As far as quality goes, Lucasfilm is two for two with their Star Wars anthology series. Both Rogue One and Solo are worthy additions to the iconic space opera saga that add new layers to the established timeline (while the sequel trilogy paves the way for the future).
However, in the end, one must stand victorious over the other. So, it's time to tally up the score.
Winner: Solo put up a valiant effort, to be sure. But at the end of the day, Rogue One prevails with seven out of a possible twelve points to Solo's five out of twelve. Due in large part to its enthralling story, characters, and emotional resonance, the first Star Wars anthology film remains the gold standard for the series.
With that said, the Star Wars anthology films are far from over and rumors about which characters or stories the next one will be centered around are constantly circulating. In turn, it will certainly be interesting to see if any up the upcoming films manage to unseat Rogue One (as well as how they fare against Solo), because it seems that things are just getting started.
Which movie did you like better? Let us know down in the comments.