Suicide Squad: 10 Actors Who Could Replace Tom Hardy

Now is not the time for fear, Warner Bros...that comes later.

By Tom Baker /

The Suicide Squad lost their first member in the wee hours of this morning (or €œdaytime€ as those sick perverts in Hollywood call it). According to reports, Tom Hardy has dropped out of DC's next big comic book adaptation after Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice, a somewhat left-of-centre choice of the supervillain covert ops team whose name is to be taken literally €“ as in, they're almost always sent on suicide missions. A high turnover of characters is par for the course in the comics; losing such a big name, from a cast full of big names €“ Hardy would have starred alongside Will Smith, Margot Robbie and Jared Leto €“ is more unprecedented. Now Warner Bros have the unenviable task of finding a suitable star to replace him. Apparently it's all down to scheduling and the like, meaning Hardy literally couldn't be around for shooting, but he's at the point in his career where he can carry a film all on his own (as is the case with the upcoming Mad Max sequel-reboot thing). So the new star has to be around Hardy's level, but not quite a breakout who will hog the limelight. So who exactly is the right fit for Rick Flag, the slightly unstable all-American hero who despises being teamed with a bunch of supervillains? Here are a handful of thespians who might just be able to fill Hardy's shoes (if not manage quite as many colourful accents). Here are ten actors who could replace Tom Hardy in Suicide Squad.

10. Frank Grillo

This one is dependant on how flexible Grillo's contract with Marvel is €“ and it's possibly about as malleable as The Thing €“ but thanks to his appearance as sorta-villain Crossbones in Captain America: The Winter Soldier and a starring role in surprise hit sequel The Purge: Anarchy, he's a rising star whose got the right look and track record for a Rick Flag type. Previously making his name on television as hard-bitten characters in the likes of Prison Break and The Shield, Grillo is a little older than Hardy €“ 49 to the younger actor's 37 €“ but depending on how Flag is being characterised, that could be work. He's the cranky leader keeping everyone on the straight and narrow! A cranky elder who can nonetheless handle himself in a fight. Besides the obvious action scenes in The Purge and The Winter Soldier, Grillo also appeared alongside Hardy in superior MMA drama Warrior, and he was no shrinking violet there either.

9. Jack O'Connell

Of course, if the producers did want to skew a little younger even than Hardy, they could just plump for the next big thing. Jack O'Connell is so far on a very similar track to Hardy (although hopefully without all the substance abuse issues that blighted his early career), starting with some acclaimed performances on TV and in smaller films. In fact now's the perfect time to get O'Connell, since he's right on the cusp of becoming a major star. He's currently winning plaudits aplenty for his role as real-life Olympian-turned-WWII POW in Angelina Jolie's Unbroken. Much like Hardy, O'Connell has proven his ability to adapt to any number of characters, genres and €“ yes €“ accents. It feels like he's just waiting for his one huge role that will make him a household name outside of the UK, and Rick Flag (his second army role after IRA drama '71) could be just the role he's looking for.

8. Chris Pine

Grillo and O'Connell are fine possibilities to consider from a performance point of view, but it's possible €“ on the basis of the rest of the cast €“ that Warner Bros are going to be going after more of a €œname€ actor to star in Suicide Squad. Somebody who's not only got the acting chops of Hardy, but also the brand recognition. Hey, here's somebody who might be on the look out for a new franchise! It's possible that, after the third Star Trek film, the main cast will go off in search of new things (their contracts will be up, at least), and Pine has confirmed that his iteration of Tom Clancy's spy hero Jack Ryan won't be returning after last year's fine but underperforming Shadow Recruit. Pine also has the right look for Rick Flag. He's supposed to be an all-American hero in the truest, slightly troubling sense. Grillo is a fellow American, but he's a little older, a little rough around the edges; O'Connell has the same quality, is younger, and a bloody Limey. Pine, meanwhile, oozes matinee idol cool €“ and he's a damn good actor to boot.

7. Aaron Eckhart

To some, Tom Hardy dropping out of Suicide Squad isn't the surprising thing. The surprise is that he was cast in the first place, since he'd already played a pretty iconic character in a DC film recently with Bane in The Dark Knight Rise. So why was he so eager to be in another? Apparently he wasn't, but it probably would've worked. He spent most of the Batman film behind a mask, after all. So what's to stop Aaron Eckhart from pulling the same trick? He played Harvey Dent in The Dark Knight, but half of his screen time (no pun intended) was in full Two-Face make up. And again, he's a great actor with the all-American Rick Flag look. He's also, like Pine, somebody in search of a franchise. It's just that his latest attempt was an entirely more embarrassing failure, as I, Frankenstein earned about as much from the box office as critics €“ ie very little. He's basically in the same position as Pine, just older.

6. Guy Pearce

Again, if you're going to go for an older actor to play Rick Flag, you may as well do it right. Pearce is currently also flying high off of a villainous turn in a superhero film, having played central antagonist Aldrich Killian in Iron Man 3. Thankfully he definitely isn't locked into a multi-film deal with Marvel, which means he's all freed up to appear in Suicide Squad. Hooray! Pearce's career trajectory is a little unpredictable. It looked like he was being tipped for big things off the back of acclaimed performances in LA Confidential and Memento, but he never quite capitalised on the hype. Instead he stepped back, returning to Australia and doing neat stuff like The Proposition and Animal Kingdom. Now he appears to be back on the map in a big way, with not only his turn in Iron Man 3 but briefs appearance in Prometheus, The King's Speech and The Road proving he's a diverse, talented actor whose face audiences know. Plus Jack Irish is pretty much Rick Flag with a different accent.

5. Joel Edgerton

Speaking of Animal Kingdom, Joel Edgerton's been working in Hollywood for a good long while, but came to prominence thanks to his involvement in that superior Australian crime film. Since then he starred alongside Hardy in Warrior as his fellow MMA fighter, ably holding his own, acting and physique-wise. Despite also having a couple of years on Hardy as well, his career seems to be in much the same place. He had celebrated roles in Zero Dark Thirty and The Great Gatsby, and recently got upgraded to near-leading man status in Ridley Scott's Exodus: Gods And Kings. Edgerton just seems right for the role of Rick Flag. He's a phenomenally talented actor, again awaiting that big part that will tip him over into being a truly big name, who would do a sterling job as the conflicted, somewhat bitter Suicide Squad leader who could easily go off the deep end at any minute.

4. Luke Hemsworth

You have to feel for the elder Hemsworth. Where Chris (two years younger) has the part of Thor keeping him in mansions and blockbuster hits for the better part of a decade, and Liam (eight years younger) managed to escape a life sentence on Neighbours to star as Gale in The Hunger Games film series, Luke has yet to find his big breakthrough hit. What's a guy got to do to get his own trilogy? He must be feeling left out. Unlike his Aussie brethren, Luke has yet to break out of the Neighbours ghetto. That isn't any sort of reflection on his talents, he just hasn't quite seized the opportunities like his brothers, his latest big shot €“ Noel Clark's sci-fi thriller The Anomaly €“ being characterised as a noble failure. Not that he should get the role of Rick Flag solely out of sympathy. For one thing, that's not how Hollywood works. For another, he is a genuinely good actor, has the right look (if, again, not nationality) for Flag, and the Hemsworth name is worth a few bob, whichever it is.

3. Channing Tatum

At this point it seems kinda strange that Channing Tatum hasn't appeared in a superhero movie. Okay, so technically he voiced Superman in The LEGO Movie. Despite being thought of as a bit of a joke, probably thanks to his comic turns and Magic Mike, Tatum has recently been getting a lot of recognition for his part in Foxcatcher. Tatum probably fancies something different after that earnest and serious based-on-true drama. Which is probably why he starred in the Wachowskis' forthcoming Jupiter Rising, where he plays a space elf. That's probably not going to be a hit, gloriously unhinged though it looks. Suicide Squad, meanwhile, is pretty much guaranteed to be a box office smash €“ so long as they get a big name front and centre. Tatum fits the bill to a tee, and again, has both the right look and the talent to bring Rick Flag to life.

2. Jake Gyllenhaal

Right now, though, the number one rumour of whom DC and Warner Bros are looking at to replace Hardy is Donnie Darko. He's practically already played a superhero! And there was that close call where he almost replaced Toby Maguire in Spider-Man 2. Is Gyllenhaal right for the character of Rick Flag, though? Maybe a couple of years ago that would be more unbelievable. Since his early successes, though, Gyllenhaal has made some daring choices, and they've more or less paid off. He's been great as the troubled cop in End Of Watch, and managed to single-handedly hold together Source Code's ludicrous premise. Even better, he's been making waves with even more interesting, strange roles this past year by starring in first Enemy and then Nightcrawler, a couple of dark psychological thrillers. Take that mindset, put it in Suicide Squad, you have your Rick Flag.

1. Idris Elba

Who says Rick Flag has to be white, though? Is there necessarily a prerequisite that all-American precludes people of colour? Well, probably in some people's eyes, but best to ignore them. They are awful. And Idris Elba is one of the best actors working today, whether he's playing it straight in The Wire, or a little more broad in the likes of Luther. He's a blockbuster name, too, thanks to his stealing the show in Pacific Rim. Right now he's locked into the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but he doesn't sound all that happy with how much time he spends fannying about on green screens for his rather small role as Heimdall in the Thor films. More than anyone on this list, Elba's long been deserving of a starring role in a major Hollywood production. And he's perfect for Suicide Squad, perfect for Rick Flag. He can do the leader thing, as shown in Pacific Rim. He can do the gruff military man, too, based on that and 28 Weeks Later. He's good in whatever context you place him. That's if he's not busy playing a two-fisted, drunk superhero version of Edgar Allen Poe, anyway...