The Amazing Spider-Man 3: What Really Happened?

With a terrific Spider-Man like Andrew Garfield, how did The Amazing Spider-Man 3 go so wrong?

By Danny Meegan /

As we approach the ten-year anniversary of Andrew Garfield's web-slinging debut in The Amazing Spider-Man, it's abundantly clear that the story of his era can be summed up in two simple words: missed opportunity.

Advertisement

As Spider-Man: No Way Home just reminded us, this guy is an, umm, amazing Spider-Man, a fact that has been drowned out over the years due to the messy, controversial way that his original tenure came to an end.

So with Garfield having a bit of a moment right now - and with renewed interest in him getting another Spider-Man movie - now is the perfect time to assess the failure of the Amazing Spider-Man franchise, particularly the announced (but then swiftly cancelled) third instalment, The Amazing Spider-Man 3. What really happened there?

Well, to borrow from that classic Spidey quote, Sony wielded great movie-making power, but they failed to treat it with the responsibility it deserved.

From an overly-confident studio to a couple of bizarre story ideas, let's chronicle the entire saga of The Amazing Spider-Man 3, kicking off with the series' origins - which, funnily enough, can be found in the aftermath of another failed Spidey franchise...

8. Maguire Out, Garfield In

The road to The Amazing Spider-Man 3 begins with the cancellation of Tobey Maguire and Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 4, which Sony pulled the plug on in early 2010.

Advertisement

That in itself is a complicated story, which we previously charted here (or in video form below!). The short version is that Raimi hit a creative wall, and rather than replacing him, Sony execs decided to reboot the entire franchise.

Raimi later explained "I couldn't get the story to work on a level that I wanted it to."

That reboot was soon titled The Amazing Spider-Man, with Andrew Garfield officially signing on in July 2010, beating out the likes of Jamie Bell, Josh Hutcherson, Anton Yelchin, and even Kick-Ass himself, Aaron Taylor-Johnson.

Interestingly - and even though you'd expect the opposite these days - Sony didn't rush into the film with a big plan for a cinematic universe, and hell, at the time, they didn't even announce a single sequel. At least, that's what the public was told - behind-the-scenes, it's safe to assume the wheels were turning.

Instead, a sequel wasn't officially announced until April 2012 - three months before the first film opened. As such, Sony didn't yet know how the world would react to Garfield's first outing, but they were clearly very confident!

Luckily then, that confidence paid off when The Amazing Spider-Man opened: it scored a solid 72 percent on Rotten Tomatoes and earned $757 million at the worldwide box-office, more-or-less in line with the grosses of the Raimi films. This reception affirmed Sony's decision to move forward with The Amazing Spider-Man 2, which the first film's director, Marc Webb, agreed to helm in September 2012.

But Sony didn't just want one sequel - oh no. They wanted much, much more than that, which is where things started to go wrong for the franchise...

7. Sony Catches Avengers Fever

Let's jump ahead to June 2013: at this stage, the first film is in the rear-view mirror, and the second film is in the middle of production.

Advertisement

Here, Sony decided to stake out release dates for both The Amazing Spider-Man 3, and The Amazing Spider-Man 4. The third was pegged for June 2016 and the fourth was slated for May 2018, leaving two-year gaps between all four instalments.

Announcing two additional sequels before the second pic has landed is obviously a huge swing, but the context here is everything. Disney's Marvel Cinematic Universe was coming off back-to-back billion-dollar hits in 2012's The Avengers, and 2013's Iron Man 3. This is where the MCU became a true global phenomenon, so of course Sony was eyeing that success, wondering if they could replicate it themselves.

Disney

In October 2013, The Amazing Spider-Man 3 picked up even more steam, with Sony hiring Alex Kurtzman, Roberto Orci, and Jeff Pinkner to map out the film's story.

This trio also worked on The Amazing Spider-Man 2, essentially making them the core creative stewards of the franchise. As we'd learn when it released, the second movie was designed to set up Sony's own Marvel cinematic universe, so it made sense to keep the same writing team for the third instalment too, which would presumably continue to flesh that universe out.

Jumping back to Kurtzman, Orci, and Pinkner's hiring though, it was here where Sony's vision for the Spidey franchise really started to become clear. Or, in other words, it was here where Sony bit off way more than it could chew...

6. You Get A Spin-Off! And You Get A Spin-Off!

One month after that writing trio was brought onboard for The Amazing Spider-Man 3, it was confirmed that Sony's plans consisted of more than just Spidey flicks.

Advertisement

In November 2013, Michael Lynton - who, at the time, was in charge of Sony Pictures Entertainment - told investors that a cinematic universe was coming, which would utilise the wide array of Spidey-centric characters the studio held the rights to:

"We do very much have the ambition about creating a bigger universe around Spider-Man. There are a number of scripts in the works."

In December 2013, these plans were detailed even further. A Venom spin-off was announced (which the aforementioned Kurtzman would write and direct), alongside a Sinister Six movie, which was set to be helmed by Cabin In The Woods director Drew Goddard. Reportedly, Goddard would also pen the script.

In addition, Sony unveiled a "franchise brain trust", consisting of Kurtzman, Orci, Pinkner, Goddard, and Marc Webb, on top of Men In Black writer Ed Solomon, and Spidey producers Avi Arad and Matt Tolmach.

This group would "collaborate on overseeing the developing story over several films", making them the architects of Sony's budding cinematic universe.

Remember though, this was still several months away from The Amazing Spider-Man 2's May 2014 release. Sony was banking on the film being a hit - not just for the continuation of Garfield's Spider-Man, but for the rapidly-expanding web of spin-offs the studio had planned.

Unfortunately however, the film didn't fare so well...

5. The Not-So Amazing Spider-Man 2

Though The Amazing Spider-Man 2 wasn't a total disaster - it comfortably turned a profit at the box-office, and scored an okay 52 percent on Rotten Tomatoes - it underperformed when compared to the first film.

Advertisement

And not only that, but it massively underperformed when measured against Sony's lofty expectations. Again, this was a time when the MCU was starting to churn out billion-dollar hit after billion-dollar hit, so when The Amazing Spider-Man 2 made just $708 million, it was almost viewed as a failure.

And that's not to mention the fact that this was supposed to be a cinematic universe-starter, which was a bit of a problem considering that one of the film's biggest flaws was its clunky world-building and forced sequel-teasing.

Overall, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 was widely regarded as a step down for the franchise, and its lukewarm reception prompted Sony to change course. Although, as it would turn out, one bad movie was the least of the studio's problems...

4. Hack To The Drawing Board

In the aftermath of The Amazing Spider-Man 2, Sony, rather wisely, decided to rethink its plans for the entire franchise.

Advertisement

In July 2014, The Amazing Spider-Man 3 was delayed by two years (moving from 2016 into 2018), with Goddard's still-in-development Sinister Six stepping in to fill the void, with an 11 November 2016 date.

By giving these movies release windows and not removing them from the schedule entirely, it seemed like Sony still had some faith in the direction of the franchise - but that faith appeared to wane rather quickly over the coming months.

Around the same time as those release date shifts, Orci told IGN that he was "not officially involved" in writing The Amazing Spider-Man 3, a clear sign that the project was in trouble. Then, in August 2014, Deadline reported that Sony was doing a "top-to-bottom revamp" of the Spidey franchise, with behind-the-scenes executive shake-ups also taking place - which, apparently, was a "last-ditch effort of management to save themselves and turn the studio around."

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 was certainly a misfire, and we can certainly level a huge chunk of the blame at the studio's feet. But, to be completely fair to everyone involved, absolutely nobody could've predicted what would happen next.

Chris Pizzello/AP

In November 2014, Sony Pictures was hacked, resulting in an enormous amount of confidential information being made public.

Alongside details about the Bond film Spectre - including story spoilers and budget concerns - the most interesting tidbits for movie fans revolved around the Spidey franchise. Emails between executives (including former Sony Pictures co-chairperson Amy Pascal, pictured above) revealed that there was talk of actually replacing Andrew Garfield as Peter Parker, and that Sony was even considering throwing in the towel and rebooting the series all over again.

While this wasn't outright confirmation that Spidey's big-screen future had been decided, the overall negative tone of these internal communications did seem to indicate that the Amazing Spider-Man franchise had run its course.

And sure enough, the final nail in the coffin arrived just a few months later...

3. Spider-Man Joins The Marvel Cinematic Universe

9 February 2015 was a landmark moment in modern pop-culture. That was the day Sony Pictures put out a press release announcing that Spider-Man was joining the MCU, in an as-yet undisclosed upcoming movie.

Advertisement

Fans had been clamouring for this to happen, but few people actually thought that it would - so it was a genuinely pleasant surprise when the news first broke!

Of particular note in the press release were the words "New Spider-Man", a signal that Garfield's time in the spandex was well and truly up. There had been speculation - and much hope - that it would be his Spider-Man joining the MCU, but if the press release didn't make it clear, then Tom Holland's June 2015 casting certainly did.

Holland made his debut in 2016's Captain America: Civil War, and went on to appear in Avengers: Infinity War, Avengers: Endgame, and a trio of hugely successful Spider-Man movies, all set within the MCU.

Garfield later stated that he was "heartbroken" about losing the role.

But what if things had panned out differently? What if The Amazing Spider-Man 3 - and movies beyond - had actually been made? What would they have looked like?

Well, in a single word... weird.

2. The Amazing Spider-Man 3: Revenge Of The Popsicle Head

Over the years, various details have emerged about The Amazing Spider-Man 3, its sequel, and a few of those cancelled spin-offs. You might want to buckle up for this bit, because things are about to get nuts.

Advertisement

As evidenced by Sony's desire to make a Sinister Six movie, that villainous group would've been at the heart of the story going forward, with Marc Webb telling Den Of Geek that Norman Osborn - aka the Green Goblin - was planned to be its leader.

You might recall that Osborn actually appeared in The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (played by Chris Cooper), where a disturbing genetic illness killed him off. So how could he lead the Sinister Six if he was dead? Well, according to Webb, Osborn's head was going to be frozen, allowing him to be brought back to life.

Again... weird.

As well as getting their own spin-off, Webb also indicated that the Sinister Six would've been the main threat in The Amazing Spider-Man 3, adding that the filmmakers also discussed bringing in the Vulture.

Paul Giamatti has also confirmed that he was set to appear in the film as Rhino, which makes sense considering the final scene of The Amazing Spider-Man 2.

Sony Pictures Releasing

Another interesting tidbit (and another character returning from beyond the grave) is that Gwen's father, Captain Stacy, could've been brought back.

In 2015, actor Denis Leary revealed that there was talk of The Amazing Spider-Man 3 featuring a "formula" that allowed Peter Parker to bring people back from the dead, which could've also opened the door to Gwen Stacy's return, as well as her dad's:

"There was this idea, at one point, that Spider-Man would be able to take this formula and regenerate the people in his life that died. So there was this discussion that Captain Stacy would come back even bigger in episode three."

Yeah, maybe it was for the best that Spidey joined the MCU.

1. #MakeTASM3: A Possible Future?

Spider-Man: No Way Home was a redemption story for Garfield's Peter Parker.

Advertisement

As we mentioned in our introduction, this movie has reminded us how great he is in the role, and that it was studio politics and messy storytelling that dragged the Amazing Spider-Man series down, not his performances.

The actor would've easily been at the bottom of "favourite Spider-Man" polls a couple of months ago, but now, he's closed that gap significantly - to the extent that a #ReleaseTheSnyderCut-esque movement has dominated social media in recent weeks, with fans lobbying for Garfield to finally get The Amazing Spider-Man 3.

The actor has stated that he's open to whipping out the suit once again, but the more important question is... could this actually happen?

Well, sure it could. Why not?

Sony Pictures Releasing

Sony would have very little to lose. Not only would The Amazing Spider-Man 3 be a guaranteed box-office hit, but it would also allow the studio to have two cinematic Spider-Men on the go at once: Tom Holland as the Disney/MCU Spider-Man, and Garfield as the main hero of the Venom-verse. It's a win/win scenario.

And hey, in an era where we have multiple big-screen Bat-men, two different Jokers (possibly even three), Charlie Cox back as Daredevil, Jamie Foxx back as Electro, and an actual, completed Snyder Cut, literally anything is possible.

So go on Sony. #MakeTASM3. And this time, please do Garfield justice.

Advertisement