The Batman: Every Rumoured Affleck Replacement Ranked
The men who would be the Dark Knight...
The tale of Ben Affleck's tenure as Batman has been one of the greatest and most annoying will-they-won't-they romances in the history of Hollywood. Now, after three performances as the Caped Crusader, rumour has it he's not returning for Matt Reeves' The Batman, which has naturally kicked up a hornet's nest of rumours surrounding his replacement.
Despite the baggage that comes with playing Batman (it's hurt some careers while helping others), it's still one of the true crown jewels of characters left to play with decades of lore behind him and a guaranteed major box office haul. Anyone with aspirations to really hit the top of the A-List would be mad to turn it down.
So who are the contenders so far, according to rumours and which of them would be best?
8. Kit Harington
Rumour Source: Revenge Of The Fans
There's no denying that Kit Harington has done incredibly well for himself as Jon Snow on Game Of Thrones: he has managed to completely own the role despite never really needing to show too much range The character is more about presence and likeability, though, and as long as he lives up to the mythology of Snow, he'll always be a winner.
Of course, the same could be said of Batman, but there are more subtle nuances required in the role of Bruce Wayne that might well test him too far. The point, though, is that he hasn't really proven that he could take on the duel role and casting a Brit wouldn't be a smart move at this stage.
He'll get big roles off the back of Thrones, but this shouldn't be one of them.
7. Ben Affleck
Rumour Source: Various
Despite the merry dance that's gone on for months, there's still no concrete confirmation that Ben Affleck won't be the guy under the cowl for Matt Reeves' film. That would obviously mean a defiance of several of the more popular rumours that have come out of early production, including Reeves' apparent desire for a younger lead, but stranger things have happened. It's not like most rumours even end up being close to the truth these days.
If we were to get Batman v Superman's Batfleck rather than the diluted version we got in Justice League, it wouldn't be a bad thing, but Warner Bros keeping him in the role isn't the best look generally anyway. The story of production so far has been defined by the perception that he doesn't want to be there (rightly or wrongly) and to address that with him still in the role would take more marketing than should be necessary.
It's time to move on, in other words.
6. Christian Bale
Rumour Source: OK! Magazine (via IBTimes)
Let's be honest here, the claim that Christian Bale had been offered an almighty $100m to return as Batman (supposedly according to UK tabloid magazine OK!) is hardly the most dependable of claims, but it raised a few eyebrows all the same.
You can even see why Warner Bros would be willing to pay that sort of money to bring him back: you manage that and you're effectively making the fourth Christopher Nolan movie, with all of the marketing power that would inherently carry. And Matt Reeves would absolutely be the right candidate to do just that.
But again, this film needs to really run with the idea of a new dawn and as great as it would be for a fourth Bale film, that's not the best way to kick off another new franchise. Which you really get the sense Reeves is looking for.
5. Jack Huston
Rumour Source: Revenge Of The Fans
Jack Huston is one of the less famous names who's been linked to playing Batman for Matt Reeves, but rumour has it that he has actually met Reeves and Warner Bros to discuss the part. His rising star has thrust him into that vaunted position, but the rumours almost immediately turned on the idea, suggesting Reeves wants a younger actor.
Apparently, Reeves' latest draft has Batman between 25 and 30 (hence the speculation that he's making a Year One adaptation of sorts), so Huston would be out of the picture. Reeves was still impressed enough to hire him though, according to the same rumours, as he's in line to play Harvey Dent.
Huston is certainly a more left-field choice, but he's far better than Ben-Hur suggested he was and it might not be the worst thing for Warner Bros to go with a less established name.
4. Oscar Isaac
Rumour Source: Omega Underground
Oscar Isaac is one of those names that you'd consider part of Hollywood's hottest talents. He consistently chooses interesting projects (even when he goes with a big franchise), intriguing characters and roles that give him scope to show off his range and he's being rewarded with a growing reputation.
It's only a matter of time before he follows his Star Wars role with something in a comic book movie that doesn't actually suck (like Sucker Punch and X-Men: Apocalypse did - the latter at least according to most critics) and rumour has it he's under consideration for The Batman. Right now, quite who he's linked to remains to be seen, but it would be interesting to see the Guatemala-born star under the cowl.
It's certainly been discussed in captivated tones among certain fans and there's no denying he's one of the more interesting options.
3. Jake Gyllenhaal
Rumour Source: Revenge Of The Fans (yep, again!)
Pretty quickly after Matt Reeves was hired to replace Ben Affleck, a rumour emerged that the director wanted to remove Affleck from The Batman entirely and that he already had a replacement lined up. That replacement turned out to be Jake Gyllenhaal who was previously in the running to play the Dark Knight in Batman Begins.
All legitimacy aside, Gyllenhaal would be a great choice. He's no longer the Donnie Darko guy and has grown his profile with roles of major depth, physicality and emotional range that would all help him play Batman and Bruce Wayne. He's also shown a particular ability with fractured characters and that's everything we'd need for a new Dark Knight.
Unfortunately for fans, Gyllenhaal has already kicked this rumour to the curb and his appearance in the MCU's Spider-Man: Far From Home seemingly kills it dead.
2. Jon Hamm
Rumour Source: Graham Bensinger's In Depth
Jon Hamm's name has been linked to Batman films ever since fans started to realise that he basically has the perfect face for Bruce Wayne and how fitting his Don Draper charisma would be for that "disguise."
The latest on that front is that Hamm would be interested in the role if it came to him, which was naturally spun out to an actual rumour that he might be under consideration. But then he has been linked to the role in the past - some rumours said he was actively "pursuing" the part - and you know what they say about no smoke without Batman. Or something.
He's linked constantly because he's great and if Matt Reeves was looking for something like a Batman Beyond adaptation, he'd be absolutely perfect. But all signs are pointing towards a younger Dark Knight, so it's probably unlikely. Unfortunately.
1. Ryan Gosling
Rumour Source: Variety
If you're a young(ish) actor these days who hasn't been in a comic book movie (or even just not in a good one), you're bound to face the question of whether you will and who you'd like to play. Given Batman's apparent availability and Ryan Gosling not having played a comic book movie character, it's inevitable that he'd face that particular question.
Gosling responded to Variety's question by saying he'd only do it if Damien Chazelle made a Batman movie (which would be GREAT) and naturally that made him a rumoured Affleck replacement too.
And the Chazelle link is part of the reason it's such a good idea: Gosling has played two characters driven by singular desires that threaten to destroy them because it's their calling (in La La Land and First Man) and that would work with Bruce Wayne too. On top of that, he's already been given the superhero treatment by Nicolas Winding Refn in Drive and Only God Forgives (which both went heavy on mythology building and less on pure performance) and that too works for the Dark Knight.
If you're not excited by the idea of him playing Batman, you're not paying enough attention.
Which actor would you like to see play Batman in Matt Reeves' The Batman? Share your reactions below in the comments.