The Dark Knight Rises: 20 Blunders in Chris Nolan’s Trilogy

By Stuart W. Bedford /

12. A Reactive Batman

Proactivity is what makes Bruce Wayne Batman. He doesn€™t wait for things to go down, he doesn€™t hang up the cape and cowl simply because the denizens of Gotham aren€™t his biggest fans. Batman doesn€™t care; all he knows is that Gotham needs a Batman. He views everything else as secondary. Fair play, Nolan has seemingly lifted the 8-year sabbatical that Batman has been on at the beginning of TDKR directly from Frank Miller€™s €˜Dark Knight Returns€™, but like so much else it€™s been rather clumsily forced up the backside of the franchise without lube or even a courtesy spit. Miller€™s book was a €˜What If€™ response to the overwhelming outcry caused by the main canon death of Robin at the hands of the Joker. It was a response to the death of a child in his care. In TDKR he left Gotham to its own devices simply because it asked him to. That€™s just not copacetic. Then, he abandons Gotham for a second time after he somehow escapes the blast from Bane€™s nuclear bomb because€well, you give me the reason. Whatever it is, it surely isn€™t good enough to justify why Batman leaves the GCPD to round up every escapee from Blackgate (addressed by a couple of quick shots of them arresting a few guys €“ that explains 5 or 6 of them I suppose) and leaves a complete rookie in charge of the Bat legacy. Some theories even dictate that the vision of a living Bruce Wayne in the closing scene is merely Alfred€™s grief-stricken hallucination €“ a dream within a dream if you like €“ that he actually died in the blast. And if you can stomach that, you can stomach anything.