The Hobbit Spoilers: 13 Biggest Secrets & Changes Revealed

By Simon Gallagher /

It's been a good few years since Peter Jackson decided to bring Tolkien's other epic to the big screen, and in that time, fans of the Lord of the Rings trilogy have had a lot of time to wonder quite how the Kiwi director would approach making what amounts to a children's book for fans of his very adult fantasy trilogy. And now that the first part of the Hobbit trilogy - An Unexpected Journey - has landed in cinemas, we have our answers. But there will be some out there who want to know a little more about what Peter Jackson has created in the name of Tolkien and how he has handled the very exacting demands of fleshing out the book's main narrative with the Appendices of the Lord of the Rings books, plus other Tolkien-penned material to make a far more substantial story, worthy of three films. So, with that in mind, we're looking at twelve of the most significant plot elements of An Unexpected Journey to reveal and review exactly how Jackson has brought the first part of The Hobbit story to screen, including the changes he has made to the original text, and how successful they were in the film. Without further ado, we present, The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey's spoiler-tastic analysis. And in case you missed it: THIS ARTICLE INCLUDES SPOILERS!

1. It Starts With A Flash-Back

Unlike the beginning of the book - the infamous "In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit" - An Unexpected Journey begins with Old Bilbo (Ian Holm) relating how Smaug attacked and claimed Erebor for himself, and forced the Durin's folk dwarves into exile. In the text, the history of Smaug and Erebor are related briefly in the Durin's Folk Appendix of the Lord of the Rings, and then in far more depth in "The Quest of Erebor" section of the posthumously released Unfinished Tales. The sequence tells of how the King of Durin's Folk became obsessed with gold, and collected a vast treasure in Erebor, which stood on bountiful seams of precious gems and metals, and how the riches attracted Smaug the dragon, who coveted the treasure for himself. Smaug attacked and drove the dwarves out of the city, killing many in the process. Thorin - the king's grandson appealed to the Elves for help, but were ignored by Thranduil, the Elvenking (and father of Legolas), sparking Thorin's deep-seated hatred of Elves. The prologue format is very similar to the start of the Lord of the Rings, and it transmits a lot of information that wasn't included in The Hobbit text, but which was later embellished by further texts, adding more adult themes to the story, which Jackson has clearly decided to push to the fore-front with his adaptation.

2. The Second Prologue Focuses On Bilbo's Party Planning

Immediately after the story of Smaug's destruction of Eribor and the dwarves' forced exile, the story jumps back to Bag-End where Ian Holm's old Bilbo sits writing the account of Eribor's attack, only to be interrupted by the presence of Frodo, who brings a large pile of letters from the post-box and confirms that they are responses to Bilbo's party invitations. We quickly learn that the leaving party from the very beginning of the Lord of the Rings is set to happen later the same day, and Bilbo and Frodo briefly discuss whether Gandalf will turn up, before Frodo goes off to his Fellowship Of The Rings hiding place to surprise the wizard. At that point, Bilbo settles down to tell the story of how he first met Gandalf, and the party of Dwarves, and the film gets into its full swing. The decision to include Frodo feels somewhat superfluous, especially considering Elijah Wood is quite remarkably different in appearance from when he filmed the LOTR trilogy. He looks markedly taller and more lean, and anyone who has watched the LOTR trilogy even semi-frequently will feel the jarring effect - but you can see why Jackson chose to include it, as a sort of fan service. And it does offer a small narrative frame for Bilbo to narrate his own story.

3. It's Not A Musical

The Hobbit is essentially a children's book - or it is at least aimed at a younger readership than The Lord of The Rings trilogy - and thanks to that creative decision by Tolkien, most of the main characters spontaneously burst into song at various points throughout the novel. Somewhat thankfully, this doesn't happen in the film, though two songs do remain - both sang by the part of dwarves during their unwanted stay at Bag-End, the first mocking Bilbo for his protection of his mother's crockery, and the other telling of their forthcoming quest to Erebor. Both will feel somewhat alien to fans of the LOTR film trilogy, and those who haven't read the book - and indeed to more conventional modern cinema audiences - but they work quite well in transmitting who the dwarves are, and something of their culture. The other songs, including the Rivendell welcome song, never made the cut.

4. Golf Makes Its Bow

It might seem like a fairly simple element that Hobbit fans had wanted included in the film in some way, but the inclusion of Gandalf's story about Old Took great-grand-uncle Bullroarer (grandfather of Bilbo, who is half Baggins, half Took) who was so huge (for a hobbit) that he could ride a full-sized horse, and who unintentionally invented the game of golf in battle feels like a conscious nod towards the fans. Here's the story as it appears in the novel, which is almost word-for-word as it appears in the film:
He charged the ranks of the goblins of Mount Gram in the Battle of The Green Fields, and knocked their king Golfimbul's head clean off with a wooden club. It sailed a hundred yards through the air and went down a rabbit hole, and in this way the battle was won and the game of Golf invented at the same moment.
By no means an important narrative inclusion, the decision to reference the story nevertheless proves once more Jackson's conviction to adapt the book as a fan for fans.

5. Dain Ironfoot Doesn't Kill Azog (The Pale Orc)

As he promised ahead of the film's release, Peter Jackson took to the Lord of the Rings Appendices to flesh out the story of The Hobbit, and one element he explored and embellished is the story of Azog the Defiler, the Orc warrior who killed Thorin Oakenfield's grandfather Thror at the battle of Azanulbizar. In the original texts, Azog kills Thror, as well as his cousin Nain Ironfoot, but was then killed by Dain's son Nain Ironfoot, who will be played by Billy Connolly in the Hobbit film sequels. But in the film, Jackson has chosen to keep extend Azog's story, keeping him alive after the battle for Moria, where instead of being killed by Dain, he has his arm chopped off by Thorin, who takes up a branch of oak as a shield (thus earning the name Oakenshield) when attacked - all of which we see in a flashback explaining why Thorin is the leader of the party of dwarves. Azog is dragged away by some of his fellow Orcs and Thorin assumed he died, only to find later that the pale Orc survived and is out for revenge. This additional chase element of having the Orc pack and their terribly CGIed Wargs (wolf-like creatures) adds a dramatic element that simply wasn't in the original text, and allows for more moments of tension, to manufacture more of a climax for the end of the first chapter. It also allows Bilbo to prove himself to Thorin, as he saves the wounded dwarf's life, and because Azog once more escapes with his life, despite his pack being decimated by a Great Eagles attack summoned by Gandalf, it suggests further drama will come in the sequels.

6. Radagast The Brown Sets Up LOTR Events

Despite only being mentioned once in The Hobbit text, Radagast the Brown - a fellow wizard of Gandalf's (who is actually mentioned as his cousin in The Hobbit) - plays an important, expanded part in the film adaptation. He is shown as a resident of Greenwood the Great (later to be known as Mirkwood), who looks after animals and can control them thanks to his powers: somewhat foolish, he is nevertheless powerful and he stumbles upon the presence of the Necromancer in the castle ruins of Dol Guldur, who has power over the dead, and who accidentally allows Radagast to take an ancient relic of Mordor as proof of his existence to Gandalf. That sets in motion the wheels that will eventually lead to the discovery of the Necromancer as Sauron, and the White Council's intervention to drive him from Mirkwood, which was originally set about by Gandalf's own exploration of Dol Guldur in Tolkien's texts and his reporting to the White Council. The details are changed slightly to include Radagast in order that the Necromancer's story, which is told in the LOTR Appendices can run concurrently with the main events taken from The Hobbit, and so Gandalf didn't have to be in two places at once. It's a good expansion, all told, and Sylvester McCoy's take on the character is very good, if a little odd, and the presence of the Necromancer adds further darkness and drama to The Hobbit's main adventure.

7. Bilbo Tricks The Stone Trolls, Not Gandalf

In The Hobbit, it is Gandalf who tricks a trio of Stone Trolls into staying out in the open until the sun comes up and turns them into stone, when they have captured Bilbo and the dwarves. He impersonates one of the trolls and confuses them by offering tips on seasoning for their upcoming dwarf meal, and they lose track of the sun coming up. In the film however, Jackson chooses to make Bilbo the trickster, having him berating the trolls for their choice of seasoning and offering cooking instructions to the dismay of the dwarves who believe he is a traitor. He says the dwarves are riddled with parasites and shouldn't be eaten at any cost, and he stalls the trolls just long enough for Gandalf to reappear from his solitary sojourn (he gets sick of the dwarves) to move some landscape and reveal the rising sun, that turns the trolls to stone. This has obviously been changed in order to reinforce the idea of Bilbo as the hero, and to give him a chance to endear himself to the dwarves and Thorin in particular who doubts him from the outset of the adventure, but in hindsight, given the finale of the film and Bilbo's saving of Thorin from Azog, it seems like overkill that Bilbo would have to prove himself twice. The trolls themselves are well-designed and well voice-acted, and the combat sequence between the part of dwarves and the trolls is arresting - though the scene in which one of the trolls blows his nose on Bilbo accidentally feels a lot like a hangover from Peter Jackson's more gorey career history.

8. Saruman Appears During A Brief Rivendell Stop

When chased by the pack of Wargs led by Azog, the dwarves are unwittingly directed by Gandalf to the hidden valley that leads to Rivendell, home of the Elves ruled by Lord Elrond (Hugo Weaving), much to the disgust of Thorin, who memorably hates Elves. There they are wined and dined, while Gandalf attends a meeting with Elrond, Lady Galadriel and Saruman the White - three members of the White Council - to discuss the growing darkness around the area that would become Mirkwood and Dol Guldur, and Gandalf's suspicions. In The Hobbit text, this council meeting is given as the reason for Gandalf's absence for part of the journey, though it is not shown in the book. It is this council that leads to the White Council's intervention to drive the Necromancer out of Dol Guldur after a further council where Gandalf had announced his own discovery of the Necromancer - only to be shot down by Saruman, who had begun to covet the One Ring for himself, so Jackson has obviously changed Tolkien's time-line to shift events into the future slightly. Over the course of the meeting in the film Saruman expresses his doubts about Gandalf's theories, including the evidence provided by Radagast, and he convinces the council that nothing need be done, before saying he cannot endorse the dwarves' quest to Erebor. The council then learn that the dwarves have left Rivendell prematurely, and Galadriel realises that Gandalf knew all along that Saruman would forbid the quest. This all occurs over what seems to be only a few days, when in the text, the company stay at Rivendell for a number of weeks. The sequence is clearly included to more explicitly set up the events of the Lord of the Rings, though it seems odd that Gandalf is clearly presented as already doubting Saruman's loyalties when he apparently goes to the white wizard during Fellowship blissfully unaware of his treachery. And again there's an element of fan service as it gives Jackson an opportunity to reintroduce LOTR characters - though it's a shame that Christopher Lee appears to have aged 100 years since filming the LOTR trilogy.

9. The Stone Giants Play A Much Bigger Part

Despite having a blink and you'll miss it part in The Hobbit book - they amount to around three sentences - the Stone Giants play a signficant part in a sequence of The Hobbit movie. When the party are on the mountain pass, they encounter a storm, only to discover that they are in fact caught in the middle of a Stone Giant conflict, and the terrain they were traversing is in fact alive. This leads to a dramatic sequence in which the party attempt to stay alive as the Stone Giants battle to the death, jumping from cliff to cliff and avoiding falling avalanches of rock. The effects are good here, and the Stone Giants themselves look lifted out of a Guilhermo Del Toro production, but the sequence feels a little close to the Mountain pass sequence in the Lord of the Rings, despite its impressive effects. All-in-all it feels like WETA flexing their muscles to bring to life a tiny piece of Hobbit lore for the sake of showing off.

10. Bilbo Wins The Riddle Game

I mean, OBVIOUSLY, given that the trailers ahead of release featured Gollum's wager for the game - and the assertion that should Bilbo lose, Gollum will eat him whole. There's very much the sense that this scene was designed as Jackson's crowning glory The riddles themselves are taken from the Hobbit text, though there are only some of Tolkien's original riddles included - Bilbo's teeth and egg riddles make it in, and as does his victorious "what do I have in my pockets?" query, while Gollum's wind, and time riddles are included. That means there is no space for the remaining four riddles from the original text - whose answers are the sun on a daisy, the dark, a fish and finally "Fish on a little table, man at table sitting on a stool, the cat has the bones." Obviously the were cut for timing issues - though the sun on the daisy and the final riddle are a little too poetic to fit the increasing darkness of Jackson's take on the scene - and the embellished interactions between the two characters more than make up for the missing parts.

11. No-One Dies

What were you expecting? It's The Hobbit after all, not Lord Of The Rings. There are a few fatalities in flash-back, and a lot of villainous characters bite the dust, including the excellent Great Goblin (voiced to perfection by Barry Humphries), but none of the main party of dwarves die, despite the traditional cinematic connotations of having a large party at the start of any kind of dangerous adventure (especially when some of them are shown to be idiotic). Thorin himself almost dies towards the end when Azog's warg savages him after he attacks the mounted Orc in an attack of pride, but his severe injuries clear up quite remarkably after Bilbo saves him from having his head chopped off and he is rescued in the grip of a Great Eagle.

12. Where Does It End?

One of the important issues that Peter Jackson faced when he said he was splitting the film into three was the issue of breaking the narrative - the same issue, on lesser scale that has faced Harry Potter and Twilight directors before him. How do you solve a problem of breaking something already designed as three parts into three more parts, to effectively reshape the narrative into nine different phases? Well, for Jackson, the answer was manufacturing more drama to make the dwarves' escape from the Goblin underground city more of a big deal. He created an "out of the frying pan, into the fire" situation where the escaped party, plus Bilbo who triumphs in the riddle game with Gollum and emerges with the One Ring, run out of Goblin danger and straight into Orc danger in the shape of Azog and his pack of mounted Orcs. Once the party, who are driven up trees by their attackers, have forced the Wargs back using incendiary pine cones lit by Gandalf's staff, they celebrate their victory, only for the one tree holding them all to topple and hang precariously over a cliff edge. It is at this stage that Thorin decides to try and take on Azog, while the other dwarves hang on for dear life, and Gandalf calls for help from the Great Eagles, who turn up and rescue them, including the injured Thorin. They are then flown to safety by the Eagles who disappear, rather than simply flying the entire party closer to Erebor, which is still miles away on the horizon. Helpful.

13. We Don't Get To See Smaug

Or at least not properly. In the flashback sequence that forms the film's prologue, we see the dragon attacking Erebor, but the creature's form is never revealed on screen - Jackson instead goes for the smoke and mirrors approach of showing the destruction the creature wreaks and implying his presence through shadow and forms cloaked in smoke and fire. It's a clever sequence, and one that builds the mythos around the creature, and the final scene of the film, where we see Smaug awaken from slumber in the great treasure hall of Erebor serves the purpose well. A single bird can be seen flying towards Erebor by the party of dwarves who take it as a positive omen, with Bilbo remarking that he believes the worst of it is behind them. We then follow the bird as it lands on the wall of Erebor and pecks at a nut, the noise reverberating through the halls within, and waking Smaug. The only glimpse we get though is of a single smokey nostril and one of his eyes opening under a pile of gold - borrowing a little from the LOTR iconography to draw a comparison between Smaug and Sauron for the purposes of dramatic tension. And it works well: as a final shot the opening eye of Smaug is a good tease for the second film, despite some of this film's shortcomings. What did you think of the changes Peter Jackson made to the original Hobbit text? Were his creative decisions the right ones to make? Share your thoughts below.