The Hobbit Trilogy: 10 Worst CGI Moments

Just because you can, doesn't mean you should.

By Joshua Cooley /

It's been ten years since the long and eagerly awaited first Hobbit movie graced our screens. The idea of Peter Jackson taking us back to Middle-earth for a further three movies, after almost a decade, was music to our ears. That was until the first film started rolling.

Advertisement

Pretty soon it was clear something was off. The gritty tone of The Lord of the Rings had been replaced with a dream-like glow. Everything was clean and polished. It looked like a fairy tale. Now, initially that might have suited the tone of The Hobbit - the original story was far lighter than The Lord of the Rings after all - but as the movie progressed the ability to suspend disbelief soon dissipated.

The combined approach of shooting in 48 fps, with 4k cameras just made everything look too real, but not in a good way. Props looked like props, make-up looked like make-up, and the CGI looked cartoonish. Although characters like Gollum and Smaug were triumphant achievements in digitalisation, there was an over reliance on CGI throughout the trilogy. Some moments were excusable, and some would have had Tolkien rolling in his grave.

The indie director-turned-Hollywood big hitter simply dropped the ball on this one.

10. Dwarf Stepping Stones

The inclusion of Legolas in the Hobbit trilogy was shameless fan service. The filmmakers thought it necessary to reference the Lord of the Rings at every opportunity, and no one gave them more of an excuse to do so, than Legolas.

Advertisement

Admittedly his inclusion in the films wasn't necessarily a bad thing. Although Tolkien had not conceived of the character when writing The Hobbit, the information we gained from The Lord of the Rings made it plausible (and even probable) that he was around during the story.

But man did the writers really stretch plausibility into all out ludicrousness. They torpedoed the character. Put aside the whole moody teen-elf thing, every other action scene was nonsensical. No longer was he the skilled archer of the first trilogy - who did the odd impressive stunt - now he felt like a lost member of the Avengers performing ballet.

This CGI scene perfectly summed up a key issue with the entire trilogy. Peter Jackson seemed confused about the tone of his movies. On the one hand we had a dramatic chase sequence with the dwarves in a desperation situation, on the other hand he packed it full cheap laughs. One tone undercut the other and caused the entire sequence to fall flat.

Legolas skipping over dwarves heads couldn't have been more ridiculous if he was wearing a tutu.

9. Chase In The Goblin Tunnels

The first real indication that something was wrong with these movies was the big chase sequence in the Goblin Tunnels. Visually, the animated goblins weren't half bad. Jackson and his team clearly put a huge amount of effort into designing a new and unique breed of creatures. They looked like a bunch of naked sewer rats, accustomed to a life in the dank confines of the Misty Mountains.

Advertisement

The issue was, the Misty Mountains didn't look all that bleak. The tunnels were lit by a warm glow and the goblins had constructed fairly sophisticated and comfortable looking structures; it looked less like grim lair, and more like a kids play park.

But that wasn't the major issue. We were subjected to a cartoon chase sequence with all manor of ridiculous occurrence happening along the way. You had goblins swinging from ropes and dwarves bouncing off the walls. But the clincher came when the dwarves shamelessly re-enacted a scene from Looney Tunes by tumbling a giant boulder in front them as they fled.

8. Elven High Jump

Initially this scene got applause when it first hit screens. Part of the allure of the elves in the Lord of the Rings was the apparent discipline and fluid skill in battle. From that first moment in the Fellowship Prologue, when the elven swordsmen flurry their blades in a succinct motion, we were hooked.

Advertisement

As was typical for The Hobbit, Peter Jackson took everything that was great in Lord of the Rings, dialled it up to eleven and completely ruined it. The elves become too co-ordinated, too in unison and nothing about them felt natural. Having inhuman degrees of discipline and skill made them impressive, but this was a whole level above inhuman, it was simply unrealistic even for the world of Middle-earth.

It didn't help that almost all the footage of the armies was CGI. This sort of worked for the wide shots, but for the close ups, it was painfully obvious everything was digitally created. Nothing felt real, the characters looked as though they had no physical weight, pulling you completely out of the moment. The Battle of the Five Armies just looked like a cut scene from the Shadow of Mordor game franchise.

7. The Golden Chocolate Dwarf

The decision to turn The Hobbit into a trilogy wasn't taken until principle photography was completed. This meant the initially planned two movies had to be stretched into three. Peter Jackson was forced to undertaken extensive pick up shoots in order to justify an extra film, and even then he was forced to splice in extensive CGI sequences to flesh out the run time.

Advertisement

There were a number of moments when this was painfully obvious to the viewer, but non other seemed as redundant as the huge chase sequence with the dwarves and Smaug in movie two. It stretched on for an ungodly amount of time, to the point of tedium, until the egregious climax when Smaug came face to face with what looked like a giant Christmas chocolate, wrapped in golden foil.

Let's put aside how unlikely this sequence was to happen, and instead focus on the crappy CGI moment of the 'molten gold' bubbling out to douse the dragon in glitter. In contrast to Smaug - who was one of the finer CGI creations in the movie - the glowing statue just looked like a cheap bauble you'd find under the Christmas tree.

6. Bombur's Bouncing Barrel

We've already mentioned the barrel sequence in this article, but we can be forgiven for featuring it a second time; that entire scene is inundated with ludicrous clips that completely undercut the movie.

Advertisement

The dwarves looked weightless, the orcs looked rubbery, and the rules of physics were ignore entirely. If subconsciously something registers as unreal, then the believability of the entire movie flies out the window. We obviously know orcs, dwarves and trolls don't exist, which is why filmmakers need to use every trick to ground the characters in gritty reality. The rules of physics and logic need to apply, especially when an audiences is being asked to believe in a fantastical world.

Throughout the entire first movie, Bombur was portrayed as the fattest and heaviest of the dwarves. The filmmakers dedicated serval scenes to establish how encumbered he was by his weight. In conventional storytelling, this should have been done to set up some kind of payoff in the later narrative. But as soon as Jackson wanted a cheap laugh, all that went out the window. Bombur become a weightless, bouncy ball for a huge porrtion of the Barrel Ride, all for the sake of comic relief.

5. The Beorn Airdrop

Part of the reason the Hobbit trilogy was such a let down was due to the inexplicably bad decisions made about what to include. The Battle of the Five Armies dragged on with tedious action sequences, featuring among other things: elven acrobatics, killer mountain goats and ice skating dwarves. At times it felt as though Jackson was desperately throwing enough s**t at the wall in the hopes that something would stick.

Advertisement

But he had all the makings of a great sequence in Tolkien's original writing. One of the most memorable figures in the books is the skin-changer Beorn. He assists the dwarves before they enter Mirkwood and later turns up at the battle, saving Thorin, killing Bolg and helping win the day. There was a lot to work with.

Jackson hired the perfect actor to play the character in Mikael Persbrandt, and supposedly spent months painstakingly developing his look. So why the hell did he barely use him? The only call-back we got was right at the end of the third movie, in the tacky moment in which the Eagles airdrop the character - like some Middle-earth, Call of Duty care package. It was a throwaway moment which had no significance, other than to waste a great character.

4. Legolas' Head Chop Conveyor Belt

If you haven't already sat through the laborious experience of The Battle of the Five Armies Extended Edition, save yourself the time. All it contains is a plethora of video game cut scenes, mostly featuring Legolas doing progressively weirder stuff. The most ridiculous moment depicted the super-elf, hanging upside down from a bat, and flying through a conveniently ordered queue of orcs, so he can decapitate them.

Advertisement

It was just one of WAY too many moments like this. In the original Lord of the Rings Trilogy, we saw Legolas do some pretty impressive things. His skill with a bow aside, he managed to take down a troll, skateboard on a shield and climb a Mûmakil. Admittedly it did get progressively more silly, but at least Jackson limited these moment to one per movie. They were brief, fun scenes that were memorable because they were unique.

All that went out the window with The Hobbit, every other scene involving Legolas had him performing some kind of killer-ballet move. But it no longer felt like the skilled acrobatics of an elf, rather the inventions of a video game developer. Watching Legolas on screen was like watching the love child of Spider-Man and a character from Assassin's Creed show off their moves.

3. Every Scene With Dáin II Ironfoot

One of the few joys of the final Hobbit movie was the inclusion of Billy Connolly as Dáin Ironfoot. The Scottish actor had the perfect cadence to portray a hotheaded and feisty old dwarf, with equal parts humour and grandeur.

Advertisement

Sadly, Connolly was struggling with the early stages of Parkinson's disease during the early 2010s, as well as receiving treatment for prostate cancer. Although he'd initially visited New Zealand to have prosthetic make-up designed, it became clear the physicality of his characters would be too much of strain, given his health issues.

Rather than recast the role, however, Jackson decided to go ahead anyway. He had Connolly record all of his dialogue and made the decision to add a fully digitalised version of the character in, later. Although Dain's scene were memorable, visually he looked off. The vocal performances were great but the CGI features were immediately apparent. It was another example of Jackson thinking he could fix his movie in post-production by plastering over the holes with special effects.

2. Thranduil's Killer Elk

Peter Jackson's fear that The Hobbit would not be as epic as The Lord of the Rings spiralled into a gross overuse of CGI to generate forced dramatic moments. In short, he overcompensated for the lack of narrative with cheap thrills.

Advertisement

Every other scene in The Battle of the Five Armies was an example of this. There was almost no time to establish what was going on, or even feel a sense of drama, when you were bombarded with so many moments of visual spectacular, rather than plot substance.

Thrandiul was actually one of the more enjoyable characters in the trilogy. Lee Pace played him brilliantly. The elves of Mirkwood are described as "less wise and more dangerous" than their Rivendell counterparts. Thranduil was clearly a powerful elf lord, but his arrogance often clouded his judgment, making him an intriguing and complex character.

So it was a shame when Jackson included that ridiculous giant elk. It might have been less egregious if it weren't for that scene when the elk scoops up a half dozen orcs, in order for the elf lord to lop their heads off. One moment like this might have been excusable - enjoyable even - but by this point we were bored of it.

1. Super Mario: Middle-earth Addition

We come to it at last, the great tragedy of our time. Everything that has already been laid out in this article applies to this scene. It was a sequence that added nothing to the plot and only served to distract from more important moments. It destroyed a character and made a joke of Middle-earth.

Advertisement

By this point in the movie, suspension of disbelief was a lost cause. We'd already been subjected to one too many physics-defying sequences, and by now any hope of saving the film had been consumed by dragon fire. Continuing to watch from this moment was akin to the sick intrigue one might get while watching a forest burn or a building collapse.

But even so this took the biscuit. It was as if the filmmakers wanted to see just how far they could push things before people walked out of the cinema. This scene literally looked like an '80s side-scrolling video game had been given a 21st Century update and spliced into a movie for fun.

There isn't much more to say about this moment. Tolkien's story was already dead in the water, and this was like parading its corpse.

Advertisement