The Hunger Games books were extremely popular and their film counterparts have proven to be similarly admired. With Jennifer Lawrence portraying Katniss Everdeen, she has earned the franchise a plethora of adoring fans, many of which have never read the books on which the films are based. That means they are unaware of things that have been changed or those that dont make the cut into the cinematic universe. As with most successful books that are turned into films, the cinematic versions are often designed and created as pieces of work that can stand alone as a separate entity. That has proven so with Harry Potter, and is even a method of adaptation that is often seen in TV shows, just look at Game of Thrones. However, not all viewers of the movies have read the books, something that die-hard fans often perceive as a flaw of character, and it means they are sometimes unaware of key plot points or character importance as early as the readers. Similarly, with every adaptation there is always going to be certain aspects of the book that wont make the screen version of the story for whatever reason, be it timing, structure or in some cases, the specific plot point not being necessary in the film world. Naturally directors will use their own creative license and implement it into their films, meaning that fans of the series will complain as their favourite parts are excluded or other points drawn out or changed for effect. So, with that in mind, let us take a look at the 10 biggest changes from the books to the screen and discuss whether the decisions that the filmmakers ultimately took was a good one or a bad one. As a warning, huge spoilers from the books are prevalent throughout, so read on with that caution in mind!
10. President Snows Role
In the Hunger Games books, we only get to see the villain of the piece through the eyes of Katniss, whereas in the films he features much more prominently. That means that in the book, we only get to see Snow through the eyes of Katniss and are not given the chance to build an opinion on him other than through the information we are given by our lead character. Throughout the book, she is giving us her perceptions of the man and especially how she perceives his mind to work. That of course means that as a reader we arent entirely sure of the character of President Snow, we know he is evil and whatnot, but we never get an inside view into him. In the film however, we see a lot more of President Snow as a person. Here we hear his speech to the tributes, we see him conversing with the game makers, especially Plutarch Heavensby, and he is shown in the control room carefully observing Katniss and Peetas arrival back in District 12. All of this demonstrates not only his power in Panem, but also the lengths he goes to in order to maintain control. By letting us see these ideas and machinations, it really makes the character much more evil and gives us a better insight into how things work in the Capitol, plus it gives us a proper villain to root against. This alteration is a very wise one by the filmmakers, as not only does it flesh out the movie but also gives heavy hitters Donald Sutherland and Phillip Seymour Hoffman the time on screen that they deserve. Interestingly, President Snow was only supposed to be a cameo before Sutherland sent an email to director Gary Ross detailing the character, changing the directors plans in the process and giving the character a much larger role.
9. Snow Gets A Granddaughter
This is another big change from the books that fleshes out the President Snow character and gives us an insight into his life. As we have already mentioned, because the book is told from Katniss perspective, we dont get to see how Snow reacts to events or what he does behind the scenes. Similarly, we do not know much about his life. Although in Mockingjay we are made aware that the President has a granddaughter who would be of age to compete in the Hunger Games were she a resident of the Districts rather than the Capitol, we never meet her because Katniss doesnt. In the film however, we get to meet to meet her and see what she is like through a couple of scenes in which she converses with her grandfather. This is an excellent decision by the filmmakers as it allows the viewers to see a more human side to President Snow that we dont get in the books and lets face it; a multidimensional villain is always better. At the same time, she emphasises the excessive differences between the districts and the Capitol, while also demonstrating how thoroughly Katniss is winning over the people as she is sporting the same hairstyle as Katniss because everyone at school is doing the same. That is a clear indication to Snow how much of a hero Katniss has become and likely plays into his decisions against her as well.
8. Haymitchs Backstory
Interestingly, the last person to have competed in the Quarter Quell and won it was Haymitch, District 12s own champion. In the books, Peeta and Katniss make it a point to watch and see how their mentor fared in his victory. It gives them an interesting insight in to how he was able to overcome obstacles and win the whole tournament despite losing his partner in the arena. Through this learning process they of course discover how he used the arenas force field to his advantage, a clever trick that allowed him to survive. In the film however, this is never discussed, meaning Haymitch is left as just an amusing and clever, albeit drunken mentor for the pair. This is an interesting decision by the filmmakers because the force field in Haymitchs video foreshadows the force field that will appear in Katniss and Peetas Quarter Quell. That means that the characters learn how to use it against their opponents much earlier in the book, whereas in the film it takes them longer to work out. At the same time, the film has taken away an extra dimension to Haymitch that ultimately makes him a more interesting and rounded character. Considering they also decided to remove a scene where he falls off the stage drunkenly during the ceremony, it means the movie was keen to promote him as more than just comic relief, which makes this exclusion all the more strange. Perhaps it will be an area that will be covered in the last two films instead.
7. How Katniss Gets The Pin
In both the books and the films, the Mockingjay pin plays a very important role in how Katniss becomes an icon for the people of Panem. However, her procurement of the pin changes drastically between both mediums. In the book Katniss is given the pin by the Mayors daughter, Madge. The book explains how the pin represents a subtle dig at The Capitol, as the real life Mockingjays were the result of bio-genetic spying programme that the public became aware of and used against the government. In the film however, Katniss finds the Mockingjay pin at a market, but there is no explanation of the importance of the pin nor why it is a clear show of defiance to the Capitol. Leaving all of this out of the film is actually a poor choice from the filmmakers. By making it just a pin without a backstory, it means that Katniss transforms the Mockingjay into a symbol of rebellion, rather than simply being the wearer of a symbol, which already has significant meaning. Also, by removing that significance from the pin, it takes away the idea that there was already some opposition to the Capitol before the events of Katniss Hunger Games, meaning the momentum from the next two films is somewhat held back and it makes the revolution more hasty rather than the culmination of a long build up.
6. Gales Whipping
One of the biggest changes from the books to the film is the role Gale Hawthorne plays and more importantly, how he gets whipped in District 12. In the book, Gale is brutally whipped by the new Head Peacekeeper Romulus Thread after he is caught with a poached wild turkey. The fact that Gale is willing to outside the walls and risk such punishment is used as an indicator of how scarce food is in District 12, and how bad the overall situation is outside of the Capitol. In the film however, Gales whipping is much more dramatic. As soon as Thread arrives in District 12, he sets his cronies the task of terrorising the citizens by burning down the Hob, the districts black market. When Gale sees Thread attacking a citizen, he attacks the head peacekeeper who subsequently drags him to the square and has him publicly whipped. This is one of the better changes by the filmmakers for two reasons. Firstly, it makes Gale more of a hero in the film and helps to develop the wider overall role that he is given in the film. Secondly, it makes the whole scene much more visually dramatic and helps to emphasise the evil of the Capitol much stronger than the books does, although it does detract the focus away from the seriousness of the scarcity of supplies that is present in the districts.
5. No Avox Girl
This is one of the most important differences between the book and the film and it all revolves around a very minor character. In the book, as Katniss is preparing for the games, she meets several individuals from the Capitol who serve her meals and drinks. These people are mutilated servants, known by the general term of Avox. Katniss actually remembers one particular girl who serves her from earlier, informing the reader that she was a girl who tried to escape the Capitol but was caught, labelled a traitor and punished by having her tongue removed. Most importantly, we learn the back-story of this particular girl and how Katniss regrets not saving her. In the film however, none of this is given to the viewer, the relationship is never fully realised and Katniss connection to this girl is never revealed. That means that one of the more interesting side characters from the book is completely overlooked, most likely to save a couple of minutes of screen time. Although the decision to leave her out is understandable given the need for time, it does mean we arent shown that people are trying to leave the Capitol, which would hint at the problems there, nor are we given the extra dimension of Katniss being haunted by her not helping when she was younger. Although its understandable, this was arguably a bad decision.
4. Further Absence Of Characters
As well as the missing Avox girl from the previous point, there are also several other characters missing in the film that played minor but important roles in the books. The first of these missing characters is Darius, a kind-hearted peacekeeper who steps in when Gale is being whipped in the book. As reward for speaking out, he is himself beaten and has his tongue cut out, being turned into an Avox in the process. The second of these missing characters is actually a duo, namely Twill and Bonnie. Early on in Catching Fire, Katniss meets Twill and Bonnie during a hunting trip to the woods. She learns that they have ran away from their district and are seeking refuge in District 13, which most people believe no longer exists. Both of these absences are important for separate reasons. By leaving out Darius, the viewers are not really aware that not all of the peacekeepers are evil, nor are they aware that there is mild resistance to the way the Capitol goes about things. As we have mentioned already, the filmmakers seem to have wiped away any ideas of existing resistance to the Capitol. By leaving out Twill and Bonnie, the movie loses the foreshadowing of events to come and Katniss herself loses the hope that District 13s potential existence gives her. Ultimately, neither change is too drastic nor a bad decision as the overall story is more cohesive without their existence and its likely we may see the duo in the Mockingjay films at some point.
3. The Mockingjay Watch
The Mockingjay watch plays an important role in the books and is another foreshadowing device that is left out of the film. In the books Katniss and Head Gamemaker Plutarch Heavensbee share a dance at the Capitol, where the Gamemaker shows her a watch that features a subtle image of a mockingjay, which is of course the symbol of the rebellion. That leads to Katniss first beginning to question Plutarchs loyalties and her later realisation that he has given her a clue about the design of that years games, namely it will be in the design of a clock. In the film however, the pair only share the dance and chat, there is no watch in the scene to be used as a method of foreshadowing although what the gamemaker says kind of plays a similar role. This is actually a good decision by the filmmakers as it means that when the viewer eventually gets to see the arena it makes its design all the more clever. Also, by leaving out the watch but letting us see how supportive Heavensbee is of the rebellion behind the scenes, especially in his manipulation of President Snow, we gain a greater appreciation of the character and how he seemingly only joins the games to free Katniss. That means the story in the film is richer because of the background information we are given while the character is better developed as a result.
2. Threshs Death
Of all the characters Katniss comes up against inside the games, Cato is easily the worst of the lot. The cocky and muscular tribute is quickly set up as the games villain in the first film, introduced as an unrelenting killer willing to snap the neck of an ally if that helps him towards victory. As Katniss is hunted during the first games it is clear how evil Cato is and how he dominates the rest, especially when he orders the girl to murder the tribute who has foolishly built and lit a fire, leading the group to her. As the others die, the stage is of course set for Katniss to come up against Cato at some point. During all this, the other District 11 tribute Thresh saves Katniss life as repayment for how she protected and cared for Rue during the games. After he saves Katniss, he is murdered, and in the book it is suggested that Cato is his killer. In the film however, the dogs that the game creators have designed to hunt the remaining contestants murder Thresh instead of Cato. This is a bad choice by the filmmakers because this minor difference means that Catos murder of Thresh does not set up the stage for the intense final showdown, meaning it actually loses some of its poignancy while Katniss motivations are also decreased somewhat.
1. Peetas Realisation
This change in the film is fundamental to how the versions of Katniss and Peeta in the books differ from those in the films. In the book, Peeta realises that Katniss thinks they were faking their love the entire time, which ultimately leaves him heartbroken, mostly likely because he seems to think that Katniss had genuinely fallen for him. In the film however, Peeta merely says that he doesnt want to forget the time that they spent together in the arena, and the affection, fake or not, that they shared. Although he is upset, the revelation does not seem to leave him completely dispirited, making him somewhat stronger than his book counterpart. Ultimately, this change is neither a bad one nor a good one from the filmmakers. In the film, Katniss is torn between two men, while in the book that is less clear despite her often questioning her feelings. In terms of story, Peetas realisation helps to keep the flow of the story on track, while also giving Katniss a more hero narrative style. Similarly, it also makes Peeta a much stronger character than his book counterpart, which will be an interesting element considering hes now in the hands of the Capitol. Are there any changes that we left out? Perhaps you think we should have focused on the rebellion, or perhaps the bread code, or even Haymitch and his relationships with food and drink and all of the symbolism involved in that? Let us know your opinions in the comments below.