The Martian: 10 Reasons Why It's Better Than Interstellar

Scott's sci-fi epic squashes Nolan's nonsense.

By Chris Haydon /

Sir Ridley Scott finally makes a welcome return-to-form with The Martian; the brilliant, expansive and immersive sci-fi blockbuster aided by a remarkable ensemble cast. After underwhelming consistently with his recent outputs (Exodus: Gods And Kings, The Counselor, Prometheus), the Matt Damon vehicle sees the legendary auteur's most robust and coherent release since Gladiator. Hollywood has now mastered the art of space imagery and is truly able to transport their audiences to planets and galaxies far, far away, but despite exceptional visuals and dramatic advances in filmmaking technologies, the principals of great cinema will forever rely upon storytelling and realised characters. Last year, fanboys across the globe were left stunned and speechless by Christopher Nolan's operatic and sprawling Interstellar, and clearly enraptured in a haze of Hans Zimmer-Hoyte van Hoytema wonder, forgot that it's actually an incredibly mediocre movie. The Martian on the other hand, serves a beautiful remedy to the bombastic and incoherent space epic. Whilst some may follow the way of the McConaughey, the truth is that it's Damon who's here to stay. Here are ten reasons why Scott's latest is a far better film than Nolan's.

10. Space Is The Principal Villain

During the second act of Interstellar, Cooper (Matthew McConaughey) and the team arrive on Mann (ice planet), in which they locate a hypersleep pod. Inside lies a very special guest; Mr. Matt Damon. Starring as the deemed deceased Dr. Mann, Damon and the group instantaneously bond, and the now-awakened astronaut details the perils of such an environment. Fast forward twenty meandering minutes and it turns out everything Mann has been spitting is fictitious. His only agenda is to get himself home and away from isolation, and he'll do this at any cost: even attempting and succeeding at murder. He and Cooper break out into a sprawling fist fight against the swirling winds and teeth-chattering ice, and honestly, it is one of the dumbest moments in the entire picture. It feels so random, so empty and could have screened with significantly more menace through intricate dialogue deliveries rather than gravity-enhanced Street Fighter choreography. The Martian knows much better. The film is perfectly aware that Mars and indeed botanist Mark Watney's (Damon) scenario is villainous and perilous enough. A singular man stranded on a distant planet, 140 million miles away from civilisation with limited resources, no natural outlets for food and water, and the high risk of anything and everything placing your already fated life in severe jeopardy. Now that is a proper antagonist.

9. It Lacks Endless Exposition

So much of Jonathan and Christopher Nolan's screenplay for their 2014 odyssey is controlled by pointless exposition dialogue. In fact, it has scenes that can run in excess of ten minutes without a character actually offering prose of any coherence or particular relevance. Sure, the research behind the film is towering in its detail (although a number of scientists at NASA and various universities have claimed much of the 'facts' are actually false), but it sacrifices essential emotional development for the sake of buzzwords. It is ironic that Interstellar is at its smartest and sincerest when stationed back on Earth prior to the wormhole exploration. The connectivity between Cooper and young Murph (Mackenzie Foy) feels like the most authentic and densely nurtured aspect of the entire project. Meanwhile Scott's latest has its cake and eats it too; The Martian understands the importance of character-building, and delivers such in spades, but it beautifully balances the factoids and formalities, which in turns leads the spectator into a sense of security. Being both a sprawling and riotously entertaining blockbuster and indeed a technical, intellectual affair is a rare achievement.

8. The Visual Effects Never Taint

There is simply no questioning the progressive skill of Nolan's lens and set designs; heck, Inception is one of the most impressive and important films of the last decade. A number of core sequences in his sci-fi epic are dazzling too - namely when the ship first blasts through the wormhole on the fringes of Saturn littering the screen with hypnotic, enigmatic beauty. With the additional support of IMAX, there are very few who can say it didn't take their breath away. Despite some astonishing set pieces, Interstellar also has a handful of visual effects which absolutely rip the audience from any sense of drama or danger; the worst offender being upon the central Miller (water planet). As the tension cranks and the tidal waves rise, Dr. Amelia Brand (Anne Hathaway) is busy searching with a data recorder and becomes pinned by debris. All of a sudden, on-board computing robot CASE folds into a gigantic metallic Kit-Kat and dashes to her rescue like Usain Bolt. Scooping her in his 'arms', CASE sprints back to Ranger 1 looking like a steroid-induced stick-man. In a scene so intent on purposefully amounting atmosphere, the addition of such idiocy belittles it all. One recalls the entire screening audibly laughing at the stupidity; not the reaction the filmmakers would have wanted. The Martian's immaculate visual effects never once taint the film-going experience - and more importantly, the emotional - by brilliantly working side-by-side. Scott's film screens with expressive excitement consistently and ensures the machine is perfectly fine-tuned and well-oiled.

7. The Score & Music

Perhaps the most unexpected pleasure of The Martian is its soundtrack. The diegetic sound a cavalcade of hilariously cheesy 80s pop hits which provides a delightful running gag focused around Jessica Chastain's Captain Melissa Lewis. Littered throughout includes the likes of Donna Summer's "Hot Stuff", the Happy Days theme tune and perhaps the most poetic usage of David Bowie's seminal "Starman" ever put to screen. Further supporting the nostalgic tunes is a dense and fulfilling score from Harry Gregson-Williams which elegantly and equally intensely renders the scenes; forming a prominent, emotional edge to everything unfolding. Like the very best audio work, it counteracts and balances what is visually unfolding, together forming a beautifully symphonic marriage. The same cannot be said for Interstellar. Usually a total master of his craft, long-time Nolan collaborator Hans Zimmer truly dropped the ball here, providing a score so intensely over-powering it often dulls the senses like empty white noise and consistently feels intrusive. Even worse is that Nolan supported the idea of the score blocking particular dialogue, suggesting the sounds of space wouldn't exactly accommodate to chit-chat. Artistically and factually true no doubt, but the primary task of film is to entertain. If your spectators are already baffled by endless jargon anyway, they'll need to listen up; something Zimmer's warbling, earthy noise frequently stops.

6. The Earth-Bound Supporting Cast

Once Nolan's picture blasts off, it shattered the most profound character tie (Cooper and young daughter Murph as stated earlier). What we have left upon the dying planet is a wildly underused John Lithgow, a wildly underused Michael Caine, a wildly underused Casey Affleck, a wildly underused Topher Grace and an underdeveloped elder Murph (Jessica Chastain). Perhaps the biggest cardinal sin the film makes is actually placing Affleck on earth and putting Wes Bentley in space. Bearing in mind the characters have aged dramatically, not a single person would question their looks. We could have enjoyed the always excellent Affleck as Doyle and the often average Bentley as brother Tom. Meanwhile The Martian enjoys the best of both worlds (quite literally). Some of the film's finest, sharpest moments come from our home planet as the NASA headquarters houses some brilliant characters and performances. We get Jeff Daniels' excellent NASA Chief Teddy Sanders, the delightful Mindy Park (Mackenzie Davis), a rib-tickler from Donald Glover as astrodynamicist Rich Purnell, the best work in years from Sean Bean as NASA official Mitch Henderson, joyous PR cover-up artist Annie Montrose (Kristen Wiig) and most importantly, a sublime turn from Chiwetel Ejiofor as NASA engineer Vincent Kapoor. The sequences upon the homeland never detract from the thrills and terrors of Watney's endeavour upon The Red Planet, rather support it; further it. The introductory act of Interstellar leads audiences into a false sense of security by implying the same, but little after Ranger 1 leaves the stratosphere, it becomes a distant memory.

5. It Has A Wicked Sense Of Humour

When a person is isolated and tangled in a particularly defeatist position, there are usually two emotional responses which come into play: comedy and tragedy. We opt to break out in laughter at the preposterous nature of our predicament, or break down into tears as we reflect on our sudden hopelessness. Either way, this is what defines us as cognitive, free-thinking beings; it's the whole 'glass half-empty, glass half-full' optimism test. For a film so thematically tense, The Martian is beautifully poker-faced and reveals its pair of aces thanks to such brilliant injections of humour. In fact, it is one of 2015's funniest movies. A number of sequences provide entirely laugh-out-loud joy and these are even outside of the aforementioned disco tracks which populate. Rather than endlessly wallowing in self-pity and accepting fate, Watney is a deeply intelligent, forward-thinking individual; his smarts further his flurries of funny. Even when he is reaching out to NASA with the hope of detection, he does so with smart aleck sarcasm, proving that his harrowing scenario upon Mars does not render his personality. We believe this is an established character, a developed man; being stranded within the fringes of the galaxy is merely a technicality... Now do you remember laughing once during Interstellar, better yet, do you even remember cracking a single smile? Whilst some may have been left slack-jawed by the engrossing visuals early on, that is merely a reflection of impress, not entertainment.

4. It Has Massive Rewatch Value

Many have likely watched Nolan's space saga a number of times as a means to decode, or you know, attempt to fully understand it's purpose and point, but it is unlikely that many rewatch purely for the fun of it. Interstellar is a major time commitment and large portions of its duration feel sluggish and expendable. The Martian is just as intelligent, just as expansive and just as immediate, but it is also a whale of a time in the process. Even at 141mins, Scott's latest has a breezy-cool aura surrounding it; making it feel both relatable and informative. Much of this is due to the high-wired balance of the detailing; included is physics, botany, math and chemistry - heavy subject matter which requires explanation. The winning formula is that not only do you buy everything you€™re being sold, but it€™s all treated with sunny glee. Watching Watney attempt to grow food sources upon a planet where nothing grows is equally thrilling as it is beguiling. These integral elements to The Martian's thematic design is what sets apart and furthers from a film like Interstellar. There is simply no doubt that across the next few weeks, Scott's film will be a box-office sensation; likely topping the core markets worldwide, and a number of those ticket sales will be audiences returning for rounds two and three. The same process will ultimately occur when it reaches home entertainment platforms in the coming months.

3. Astronauts Actually Enjoy Space

There is not a single sense throughout Interstellar where any of the NASA occupants upon Ranger 1 look like they are engaged and satisfied by their intergalactic excursion. The film even goes the distance to shatter the live and love of a young girl for the sake of the voyage, so there is already a bad taste before the thrusters are ignited. Whilst the purpose of the mission in Nolan's film bears a much broader impact upon humanity - they are searching for a new habitable environment for our species after all... - never does the endless possibilities and unfathomable potential of space seem truly apparent to the crew. This cannot be said for those on the Ares III expedition. The group who make up the team include Chastain, Michael Peña, Kate Mara, Sebastian Stan and Askel Hennie; all of which appear to be bewildered, confused, bewitched and dumbfounded by the glorious other-worlds in our solar system. Scott expertly aids this thanks to reverent direction and set photography, like the moment teased in the trailer as Mara's Beth Johanssen waves poignantly from the satellite ship as it spins 360 degrees, leaving her standing upside-down defying gravity. Throughout The Martian, we as the audience, and they as the crew experience some of the most radiant and compelling space imagery in recent years. It bathes in the ethereal, potent glory and in the process, often betters the Academy Award-winning effects work from Interstellar.

2. Matt Damon

It is true that across the past several years we have entered the 'McConaissance'. The formally slurring Texan has gone from roles in mind-numbing 'chick-flicks' like Fool's Gold and Ghosts Of Girlfriend's Past to show-stopping, Oscar-clinching work in Dallas Buyers Club, and stunning everyone with the likes of Killer Joe, True Detective and more. Matthew McConaughey is a fantastic performer and his offerings in Interstellar are by far the film's strongest asset, but Matt Damon has been consistently excellent since the mid 1990s, and his role as Watney here simply crushes Cooper. Damon is similar to Tom Cruise in the sense that he is a proper 'movie star'; a charming, charismatic and approachable performer who can sell a film merely on his involvement, rather than the product itself, yet he is also a definitive and exceptional actor - a transporting and captivating screen presence who can burrow into a role and change colours like a chameleon. Just look at his work in films such as The Informant!, We Bought A Zoo and Behind The Candelabra as mere examples. His central performance here is so attention-grabbing and urgently charged, yet also distinctly human and sumptuously weighted. It blends the two art forms and celebrity identities with remarkable efficiency and consequently serves up one of the year's very best leading male screen turns. An Academy Award nomination would be wholly warranted.

1. Jessica Chastain

There are many mysteries through the Academy voters heritage which will forever remain unearthed, but certainly one of the largest, most gleaming misjudgments in recent years was Jessica Chastain losing out on a Best Leading Actress award for her emphatic work in Kathyrn Bigelow's Zero Dark Thirty. That being said, the wounds have been licked and we move on. Since exploding onto the scene a number of years ago, the fiery redhead has proven herself to be one of the greatest actresses in our modern sphere of filmmaking; supportive and progressive across all genres and platforms, she'll excel in a tiny independent feature equally as in a commanding $200 million blockbuster. The Nolan brothers' bogged screenplay truly affected the quality Chastain brought to Interstellar. She is still good in the movie, but feels endlessly redundant and static despite being one of the film's foundations. The beauty and brilliance of her craft is speaking volumes with subtleties; something Interstellar very much isn't. Whilst The Martian is too a flamboyant, silver screen-swallowing adventure, it is jigsawed together with finite character detailing, and Chastain rightly gets the very best pieces. Following the dreadful storm which leaves Watney stranded (all in the trailer), we get a quick close-up of Captain Lewis as she leans over to the shuttle chair beside her - now sadly vacant. Scott quietly lingers on her eyes and captures a poignant exhale as she engages the departure. That few seconds of celluloid pack more tenderness and heart that the wealth of her performance in Nolan's film; a tale in which she has been neglected and potentially left for dead on a starving planet, forced to fend for herself and age without her father. Sorry, that is quite frankly ridiculous. Drew Goddard's sublime screenplay for The Martian builds Lewis as a complex creation; she is badass, but also distinctly vulnerable and unsure of her command over the crew. She is also complicated and compelling - all the theme elements Chastain absolutely excels with. She'll be back on our screens later this month in Guillermo del Toro's eagerly-awaited Crimson Peak. Did you love The Martian? Share your appreciation below in the comments thread.