Thor: Ragnarok - 8 Lessons It Can Learn From Its Predecessors

He'll have a Hulk, but is that enough?

By Geoff Cox /

At this point in the existence of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, where "hard sell" oddballs like Ant-Man, Groot, and Rocket have gone from being little-known characters to household names, it's easy to forget that many were wondering if Marvel would be able to sell the idea of a Norse god to mainstream audiences only a few years ago. In 2011, a lot was riding on Thor's arrival. We'd had two Iron Man movies and an Incredible Hulk by that point, but here was Marvel going really big for the first time, taking their first of many risks since. And succeed they did, with Thor's first outing winning over fans, opening many doors for the future expansion of the MCU, and granting the character a future that's now four appearances deep, with several more on the way. In comparison to, say, the Iron Man trilogy or the huge critical and financial upswing Captain America's own sequel got in the wake of The Avengers, however, Thor's two films haven't quite hit the same level of adoration as those of his fellow team members, enjoyable though they may be. The next time we'll be seeing the character will be in 2017's Thor: Ragnarok, which promises to be as game-changing for the MCU as the events of The Winter Soldier were in 2014. With two films under the franchise's belt already, there's a lot Thor's third solo go-round can learn from the reception and criticism - constructive and otherwise - of its predecessors to help turn it into a film truly worthy of the God of Thunder...

8. Spend Less Time On Earth

The first film got a lot of mileage out of Thor's fish out of water situation on Earth, resulting in some of the film's funniest moments, but with each appearance since, Thor's grown more and more used to our world while those types of jokes have lost impact. In The Dark World, the climactic showdown between Malekith ended up taking place primarily on Earth, with some clever portal-hopping not being used to full effect. By the end of the sequel, it was clear that the most interesting scenes had occurred away from Earth, either in Asgard or elsewhere, especially when we've got characters like Iron Man and Captain America doing enough fighting on the planet in their own adventures as it is. The new film has every opportunity to leave Earth behind and really dive deep into the realms we've constantly been told about (or briefly shown). Thor has countless words to explore and a rich comics mythology to mine; in his third outing, fans should be given the chance to explore it all with him rather than see the god grounded on Earth yet again, which would also help the film to...

7. Make Use Of The Supporting Cast

Both Thor films have featured great actors like Anthony Hopkins, Idris Elba, Natalie Portman, Ray Stevenson, and more filling out roles ranging from Thor's parents to his best friends, yet we barely get to see them flex their chops beyond moments here and there. While we all love Tom Hiddleston's Loki, he shouldn't be the only supporting actor getting so much to work with. It still feels like none of the actors have had a chance to make the roles their own, especially with interesting characters like Heimdall, Odin, and the Warriors Three practically disappearing by the halfway point of The Dark World while the joke-spewing Darcy gets scenes back on Earth all to herself. Thor's supporting cast is a wealth of talent waiting to be mined, particularly when the characters themselves have so much potential to support whatever the actors could bring to the table given more to work with. With all this talent in place, giving them more to do in the third film would go a long way in helping to...

6. Expand On Thor's Relationships

The father-son and sibling rivalry dynamics helped form the emotional core of the original film, contextualizing Thor, Odin, and Loki enough to get us through to the end and, ultimately, pave the way for Loki's motivations in The Avengers. Even though Thor's friends had to sit out in the character development department, it all at least made sense with so much ground to cover right off the bat. With those dynamics already firmly in place by the time it rolled around, the sequel had every opportunity to emphasize how everyone else around Thor felt about him on a much deeper level. Unfortunately, it squandered it, forcing Sif and the Warriors Three to sit out, Heimdall to be side-lined, and even Odin from doing more than just being salty the entire time. Despite knowing these characters his entire life, it feels like Thor is closer to some of his fellow Avengers - or even Dr. Selvig - than any of them. Everyone knows by now that the Hulk will be joining in and that, obviously, Loki will continue to pose a problem, but their inclusion, particularly the former's, shouldn't come at the expense of fleshing out characters who've been around since the beginning and deserve more. At the least, some of these characters could thoroughly benefit from Marvel dusting off their One-Shots to give them their own chance to shine.

5. Fix The Romance

While Thor's relationships with his fellow Asgardians haven't been given the chance to grow within the films, his romance with Jane Foster has played a large part in his ongoing arc, ranging from helping him learn humility to giving him something to truly want to fight to protect on Earth. Unfortunately, in comparison to, for instance, the Tony/Pepper or Steve/Peggy relationships in other films, it hasn't quite earned the level of investment it should have. Outside of helping defeat Malekith, Jane's spent much of her time fawning over Thor or serving as a damsel in distress, without really coming into her own as a fully-fledged character defined by more than just being Thor's love interest or through the obligatory lip service about what she's up to off-screen in both Avengers films. How she will play into Ragnarok is anyone's guess, especially if the film does, in fact, spend less time on Earth, but if the MCU plans on continuing to demand our investment in the Thor/Jane relationship, it needs to spend time on bringing her to the next level, where she can be a character equal to Thor without merely existing as an object to protect. By allowing more people to get invested in her, it'll go a long way in helping fans to root for them - or even just her - in the long run.

4. Help Us Get To Know Thor

We still haven't learned a whole lot about who Thor is under the surface. We know he's mighty, brave, often instinctive, and a host of other adjectives, but we haven't truly had the chance to see what makes him tick or how he's adjusting to a life where he's sharing drinks with mortal friends. For example, take Tony Stark. Over the course of his films, we've seen his quirks - i.e. he doesn't like to be handed things - followed his evolving viewpoints on issues like security and warfare, and even saw him suffering through PTSD after the events of The Avengers. We've even seen Steve Rogers, uprooted from the only life he knew, dealing with a drastically changed world, where those friends who haven't since passed are on the way out and where the very idea of patriotism he adhered to has been radically upended. Outside of his quick turn from brash to humble over the course of his first film, Thor hasn't really undergone a huge evolution as a character over the years since. With the Hulk and Loki in the mix, more focus on the other people in his life, and even the inevitable revelation awaiting him at the end of his quest over the mystery of the Infinity Stones, the sequel can add it all up to color Thor in through the eyes of other characters and how he responds to all that's going to be happening to them (and him) over the course of the film.

3. Value The Musical Score

One thing the Marvel Cinematic Universe struggled with early on was maintaining musical consistency, with Captain America being the only Avenger who had a memorable theme all to himself, which has been carried on throughout every film he's appeared in. The Avengers, too, had a singular theme introduced by Alan Silvestri, which has also continued on in subsequent films. With 2013's one-two punch of Iron Man 3 and Thor: The Dark World, composer Brian Tyler sought to finally deliver both characters their own true - and presumably permanent - themes, with both making minor reprisals in Age of Ultron's score. However, in Thor's case, it meant ditching Patrick Doyle's excellent work on the first film, dropping every single theme the composer developed that could've and should've formed the basis for future Thor films. The original film's score is elegant and often understated; though its themes may not be as instantly hummable or recognizable as Cap's or the Avengers' singular themes, it's a great piece of work and, arguably, the best overall score to come out of the MCU yet. In comparison, Tyler's work on The Dark World, particularly the thumping primary theme, is more bombastic and rousing, if ultimately lacking in depth. Ideally, Ragnarok could bring both works together, weaving back in some of Doyle's work - like the recurring Sons of Odin theme - with Tyler's, uniting the two disparate scores for Thor's (likely) final outing for the sake of musical closure.

2. Mix The Tone Up

If the success of some of the MCU's projects over the last two years has proved anything, it's that audiences are willing to go along with anything. The Winter Soldier moved the Captain America films from a serial adventure tone to one akin to a political thriller; Guardians of the Galaxy was a wacky space action-comedy with a whole lot of heart; Daredevil and Jessica Jones explored the darkest corners of the MCU; and Ant-Man succeeded as a light-hearted, amiable heist movie. Whereas the first Thor benefited from the clash between its Shakespearean Asgard realm and the lighter world of Earth, The Dark World struggled with somewhat of an identity crisis, unable to raise the bar for his films like The Winter Soldier did for The First Avenger. Instead, it came off rather paint-by-numbers and risk-averse; an enjoyable adventure but one rendered generic in comparison to many of the projects the MCU has put out before and since. As has been noted earlier, Ragnarok is going to be a huge event - for Thor, for Asgard, and for the MCU as a whole - so it's not like it can be treated like a joke, but the film itself should take the types of creative and tonal risks that have helped the other projects stand out. Aside from merely going bigger, it shouldn't be afraid to go weird and explore its own boundaries. After all, we've seen sentient trees and been to the Microverse already - and we'll have seen Doctor Strange and his world by the time Ragnarok arrives - so it shouldn't shy away from giving Thor the truly epic, moving, and dynamic outing he deserves.

1. Give The Villain Depth

Perhaps the most disappointing thing about The Dark World was how much it wasted Christopher Eccleston in the role of the villainous Malekith. Over the years, many people have complained how the MCU has underutilized most of its villains and the actors behind them - on the big screen, at least - and Malekith is, perhaps, the best example of that issue. Following in the footsteps of Loki was going to be no big feat, but the casting of Eccleston had many fans excited ahead of the film's release. Unfortunately, Malekith didn't even come close to living up to his predecessor, with his lack of screentime - which, ironically, served to give Loki more screentime - preventing anyone from being able to connect with him as a character, see his personality, or even sympathize with (or be disgusted by) his motivations. Unlike Loki in the first film, by the time the final showdown between Malekith and Thor rolled around, we had no reason to root for or against the villain, or even feel satisfied or conflicted about his defeat, and he's since been relegated to the bottom of the barrel in term's of the MCU's antagonists as a result. Fans love Loki because they can relate to or, at the least, understand his character, and because the films have capitalized on Tom Hiddleston being in the role; in comparison, fans don't care about Malekith because he only existed to be a generic "final boss" for Thor to beat up. Whether it's the Enchantress or Surtur or any of the other villains people have been asking to see Thor go up against for years that we get when Ragnarok arrives, the film needs to give them something to chew on. There's going to be a lot going on within the film, but a fantastic villain can help turn a good film into a great film, and Thor's series and the MCU as a whole would benefit greatly from the rise of another big screen antagonist that can leave fans talking for years to come. What do you want to see from Thor: Ragnarok? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.