Next Saturday night, and into Sunday morning, millions of children will go to sleep with the whisper of magical sleigh-bells just beyond hearing, and the hope of multi-coloured, ribboned surprises to greet them when they wake, and the biggest part of that spell, and indeed the mystique of Christmas in its entirety is the red-robed, roly-poly gift-giver at the centre. Santa Claus is Christmas - it goes without saying - and as such he's appeared in a load of films dedicated to the festive period. But who has played the best, and indeed definitive Santa Claus from the movie world? If I could stretch the rules a little, I'd suggest it was that clearly CGIed geriatric who stars in the Coca Cola adverts. He's like a great big walking ball of Christmas joy. And those rosey cheeks could warm even the coldest of Scroogey Grinch hearts. Here are my top Santas: some qualify for slightly unconventional reasons, but it's Christmas, and I can do whatever the hell I want...
10. Tim Allen - The Santa Clause Trilogy
It's difficult to resist including him, considering Santa Claus (along with Buzz Lightyear) is arguably the defining role of Tim Allen's entire Hollywood career, but he definitely wasn't one of the top five. Still, it would feel somewhat wrong not to throw the Home Improvement star a bone at this time of year, and you do have to concede that he looks the part.
Advertisement
9. Tom Hanks - The Polar Express
The technology might not yet have been perfected, and as a result all of the characters had that slightly creepy dead-eyed glaze about them, but The Polar Express is a charming Christmas film with an endearing storyline and some well-pitched characters. Hanks of course plays multiple parts, and he brings a nice removed majesty to his Santa Claus which is perfect for the children's vision of the magical figure. Nice character design as well.
8. Paul Giamatti - Fred Claus
Terrible film, but Giamatti was a surprisingly good casting choice as Santa Claus. He has a delightfully idiosyncratic little soulful face, which crucially features some fine, round cheeks that form the perfect accessory for the obligatory big white beard. He also brings authenticity to the pudding shape he's packing especially for the film.
7. Edward Asner - Elf
Asner just looks right as Santa Claus. He's a fairly minor part of the Will Ferrell comedy but he brings a lot as Santa, and though it sounds vaguely ridiculous, he is believable in the role. Believable as an imaginary Saint/magician who gives all kids presents for free. Impressive acting achievement that.
6. Edward Ivory - The Nightmare Before Christmas
He had to feature in some way, because Burton's festive brain-child is my favourite modern Christmas film by some distance. But his inclusion is much more than obligatory: Ivory's voice-work is exceptional, especially in his exchanges with Oogie during "Oogie Boogie's Song" and it is nice to see that Burton's idea of Santa Claus is as traditional as his storyline is odd-ball.
5. Billy Bob Thornton - Bad Santa
A work of utter genius - remarkably removed from the traditional image of the loving, altruistic old man in the red suit, Thornton's take on Santa is a chauvinistic, womanising drunk with a serious attitude problem and very little in the way of Christmas spirit. Still hugely watchable, and charming for entirely the wrong reasons.
4. Jack Skellington - The Nightmare Before Christmas
Second entry on this list from Burton's colourful imagination, and the least traditional of all ten choices since he's like a skeleton but Jack's journey to discovering what Christmas is all about, through self-discovery and fascinated exploration is a fine basis for the film's overall festive themes. Ironically, it is only when Jack takes off the misappropriated "Sandy Claws" suit that he realises exactly what Christmas is about, and decides to rescue the real Santa from Oogie's evil clutches. But for a minute there, it's impossible not to be sucked in by Jack's naive joy at being given the chance to do Christmas his own way, and his pride in wearing the famous red suit.
3. David Huddleston - Santa Claus: The Movie
Aside from the Coca Cola Santa Claus, Huddleston was THE Santa Claus of my childhood - Santa Claus: The Movie played a massive part of my early Christmas movie watching life, and the kindly, soft face of Huddleston would then prefigure how I imagined Santa Claus from then on for a long time.
2. Richard Attenborough - Miracle on 34th Street
A narrow miss on the top spot for Richard Attenborough, who replaced Edmund Gwenn in the remake of the beautiful Miracle on 34th Street. Attenborough brings a grand, wise old man touch to Kris Kringle, and he has that universal appeal that makes him feel like everyone's grandfather. He also very much looks the part, with that ageless twinkle in his eyes and an overall jovial demeanour that adds pathos to the more melancholy elements of the story.
1. Edmund Gwenn - Miracle on 34th Street
A genuine Oscar winner, and the most charming Santa Claus of all. Really, how could it have been anyone else? Gwenn brought the perfect magical touch to the character, with the same endearing appeal that Attenborough did, but with slightly more finesse and poise. He is the definitive Santa Claus, without the Coca-Cola influenced look (the big bushy, curly beard), and he sets the standard. Merry Christmas to all, and to all a good night.