Studios often spoil major plot reveals before the credits even begin. Marketing departments and critics reviews cant help themselves when they tout the major twist within. But whats worse is a twist you see a mile off when a certain actor or actress is cast because they've played a similar role many times over. Typecasting has its pros and cons. It lands good actors more work because directors and casting directors know they can pull off the role again. And on a small scale, thats all well and good. Having seen Michael Cera act in Arrested Development, youd have no problem believing he could play the awkward teen in Juno. But when that typecasting is tied up with major plot reveals, the effect is obvious. That totally shocking and unexpected twist youve got in the third act becomes very predictable. And in the worst cases, its predictable not even from the introduction of characters in the first or second act, but from when the casting announcements are made. Spoilers obviously lie ahead, so proceed with caution. (But chances are you couldve guessed the plot reveals anyway.)
Honourable Exception: Kevin Spacey Se7en
This is how you do things right, and serious hats off to David Fincher and Kevin Spacey for the way they handled this. In the opening credits, when youve got Brad Pitt, Morgan Freeman, Gwyneth Paltrow, and everyone elses names cropping up, the one name you dont see is Kevin Spacey. His name is held back for the end credits, because if you have someone as well-known as Spacey billed in the opening titles and he doesnt show up for most of the film, youre going to assume pretty quickly that hes the mysterious John Doe that Brad Pitt and Morgan Freeman are hunting. Well played, folks.
10. Kiefer Sutherland Phone Booth
The Big Reveal The killer is wheeled out by the police and identified by Colin Farrell as the pizza delivery guy who tried to give him a free pizza earlier that day. But then while Farrell is being treated for his injuries, Kiefer Sutherland emerges as the real killer and reveals he is in fact alive and well, and will be back for more if Farrell doesnt do right by his wife. Why Its So Obvious: Its easy now to think of Kiefer Sutherland as synonymous with Jack Bauer, a good man whos willing to do whatever it takes to get results. But the actor had racked up plenty of sinister roles earlier in his career, most notably playing the gang leader / vampire in The Lost Boys and the lieutenant who gave the order in A Few Good Men. And Jack Bauer had only just hit TV when Phone Booth came calling in cinemas. So it was no surprise when the big reveal at the end of Phone Booth comes and, shock, the killer is actually still alive. It was Kiefer Sutherland who was on the other end of the phone call to Colin Farrell all along. On top of the typecasting, another problem was that Kiefer Sutherland has such a recognisable voice, which is a bit of a double-edged sword in this scenario. It works perfectly as a sinister and murderous killer on the other end of the phone call. But we know from the minute he starts talking that its Kiefer Sutherland on the other end of that line, making the reveal have a lot less impact than probably intended.
9. Sam Rockwell Matchstick Men
The Big Reveal Sam Rockwells protégé con artist has actually been pulling a long con on his teacher, Nicolas Cage. And hes been using an accomplice pretending to be Cages daughter. Why Its So Obvious Matchstick Men is a solid effort from Ridley Scott, especially outside of his sci-fi credits, but it didnt take a genius to see what was really going on here. The reason it was so obvious? Rockwell had played pretty much the exact same role three years earlier in Charlies Angels. The likeable supporting character who reveals hes been duping the main character/s from the get go.
8. Bruce Willis - Lucky Number Slevin
The Big Reveal Bruce Willis and Josh Hartnett have been working together the whole time. Hartnett is the boy supposedly killed in the opening, and Willis is the hitman who supposedly killed him, but in fact raised and trained him instead. Why Its So Obvious For the vast majority of his career, Bruce Willis has consistently played the good guy. Its what he does. So having Willis assassin kill Slevin just didnt seem like the logical conclusion for the storyline. The opening scene talking about the Kansas City Shuffle sets you up for a twist, and it wasnt all that hard to figure out what was coming with Willis in the picture. This is the man who helped save the world in Armageddon, and who single-handedly saved Los Angeles AND Christmas in Die Hard.
7. Steve Zahn & Milla Jovovich A Perfect Getaway
The Big Reveal The friendly couple who you never suspected were the killers are, in fact, murderous sociopaths. Why Its So Obvious This ones a little different than most on this list. Steve Zahn has forever been typecast as the laid-back funny guy, often a sidekick to our heroes in comedy movies. So when you see him crop up as one of the leads in a thriller, alarm bells are immediately set off. This is one of those roles that give an actor the chance to try something different. Its the exact opposite of his typical typecast roles, which is why it was so plain to see. A red herring that sticks out like a sore thumb. And it didnt help matters that he was married to Milla Jovovich, one of the strongest female presences in Hollywood, synonymous with taking names and kicking butt. By the time A Perfect Getaway came out, we were three films in to the Resident Evil franchise. What were the chances her bubbly newlywed character was innocent?
6. Charlize Theron Hancock
The Big Reveal Charlize Theron is actually a super powerful, essentially immortal being, just like Will Smith. Why Its So Obvious Some actresses get typecast as the loving wife. Others the sultry mistress. Theron has had the uncommon fortune of being typecast as a strong-willed and powerful woman. The trailers did a good job of keeping her character out of the action and saving that for the movie (Im not sure Sonys marketing department would be so willing these days). But it was still easy to see coming a mile off. Charlize Theron doesnt really do the uncomplicated domestic life. Shed been a prostitute-turned-killer in Monster. She was a safecracker in the remake of The Italian Job. And shed starred as a skilled warrior/assassin in Aeon Flux only a few years prior to Hancock. So when she was revealed as a second god-like being in Hancock, it wasnt a huge surprise. (But that doesnt mean it wasnt still cool when the big reveal came.)
5. Ben Affleck Gone Girl
The Big Reveal The big big reveal is of course showing Rosamund Pike staged her death and framed her husband. But bound up with that is the smaller big reveal - Ben Affleck is innocent. Why Its So Obvious Ben Affleck is the perennial good guy. With the exception of his douchbaggery in Kevin Smiths Mallrats, very early on in his career, hes pretty much always been a through-and-through American hero. He played a blind lawyer by day and superhero by night in Daredevil. He helped rescue Americans from Tehran in Argo. And he helped John McClane (a.k.a. Bruce Willis) save the world in Armageddon. This is not a man you cast as a wife-killing murderer. This is a man you cast as someone whos been framed for the death of his wife. The trailers did a good job of pinning the blame on him, and those unfamiliar with the source material might not have been any the wiser. Except for the fact that its Ben Affleck. Of course he's not guilty. Unless youve read the book, you might not have seen the fact that his wife is the one doing the framing, with a terrifyingly elaborate scheme. But thats besides the point. Affleck did a great job in the lead. But it might have been more interesting for Fincher to cast someone you could believe as being guilty of murdering their wife, as tall an order as that sounds. Steve Buscemi, maybe?
4. Sean Bean The Lord Of The Rings: The Fellowship Of The Ring
The Big Reveal Sean Bean betrays the Fellowship and tries to take the Ring from Elijah Wood. Didnt see that coming! Why Its So Obvious Like Sam Rockwell in Matchstick Men, it was obvious because wed basically seen the same thing happen in GoldenEye. Those whod read Tolkiens original novel obviously knew what was going to happen. But even those who hadnt could plainly see that Sean Bean / Boromir was going to betray the Company. This is Janus were talking about. Hes renowned for being two-faced. Gandalf should have known better.
3. Marion Cotillard The Dark Knight Rises
The Big Reveal Marion Cotillard's Miranda Tate is actually Talia al Ghul, daughter of Ras al Ghul, and shes the one behind the plan to level Gotham and complete her fathers work. Why Its So Obvious Similar to Charlize Theron, Marion Cotillard is well known for taking on interesting roles. She won an Oscar for her role as Edith Piaf in La Vie en Rose. She played twin sisters with completely opposite personalities in Pretty Things. And anyone whod seen her in Christopher Nolans previous film, Inception, could guess there would be more than meets the eye to Miranda Tate. Lo and behold, after being the fairly passive love interest with whom Christian Bales Bruce Wayne has sex, she finally reveals herself to be the villainous mastermind we all expected her to be in the first place. If Cotillard hadnt worked with Nolan on Inception, it might have been harder to see it coming. But her role as Mal tipped everyone off to the subterfuge in Nolans final Batman film to the point where Cotillard was forced to continually deny it during the run up to release. And, if you remember, no one was convinced by her responses.
2. Andrew Scott SPECTRE
The Big Reveal Andrew Scott has been working with Christoph Waltz the entire time. Much to the shock of absolutely no one. Why Its So Obvious They cast Moriarty as one of the main villains. It couldnt have been more obvious if theyd tried. So much so that it didnt even feel like a reveal, which is the worst kind of big reveal. Its one of the many problems that Spectre has. Theres nothing satisfactory or surprising about the reveal that Scott is in league with Waltz, and it was immediately obvious that was exactly what would happen when the casting announcement was made and the actors and actresses were all brought out on stage one by one. As soon as Andrew Scott appeared, you knew he was going to play a baddie. Hopefully theyll do things a little differently next time.
1. Ian McDiarmid Star Wars: The Phantom Menace
The Big Reveal Ian McDiarmid's Senator Palpatine is the Emperor/Darth Sidious, the Big Bad of the original trilogy. Why Its So Obvious George Lucas took typecasting to a whole new level when he cast the same guy to play the same role hed played sixteen years earlier, and expected us not to guess who Palpatine would become. Good job. Was it a nice touch to have McDiarmid come back and play a younger version of the character hed played in Return of the Jedi? Sure. But it came at a high price. When the 'big reveal' finally comes in the prequel trilogy that Palpatine would go on to become the Emperor, its not remotely surprising because Lucas has the same actor playing them both. It would have felt like much more of a twist if theyd brought in someone else to play the younger version of the character. If the make-up from Return Of The Jedi made it a little less obvious, McDiarmid's voice should have tipped you off. Its basically the same, only with a little more Parseltongue in Episode VI.