Any great film overlooked upon release is going to look overwhelmingly popular compared to how Blade Runner was initially recevied. Ridley Scott's sci-fi noir masterpiece hit in the summer of 1982, mere weeks after Steven Spielberg's E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial. Going completely against the bright and friendly view of science fiction, the film failed to capture an audience and bemused critics. The adaptation of Phillip K. Dick's novel Do Androids Dream Of Electric Sheep? didn't wallow in obscurity for long, over the course of the eighties becoming a cult hit on VHS. By the tenth anniversary it was so well regarded there was large scale rerelease and now, over thirty since it was first released, it is rightly regarded as one of the greatest films ever made. Boasting cutting edge special effects that presented a future grimier than we'd ever seen before and bringing some incredibly complex ideas to light, it has been described as the first sci-fi art film. With that, naturally, comes some audience confusion. Although the film employs many of the genre tropes of film noir, it can still prove an impenetrable beast for first time watchers, with a finale that takes time to fully unlock. Today we're going to explain what exactly is happening in the ending on a narrative and subtextual level, as well as try to give some closure to the film's most enduring mystery; is Deckard a replicant?
What's The Story Of Blade Runner?
Blade Runner is set in Los Angeles, 2019. Science has advanced so far we can now create artificial humans, known as replicants. These replicants are used for slave labour off-world and given their strength come along with some severe restraints; they have a four year lifespan and a whole police division, known as Blade Runners, exist to hunt down any escapees. When four of the latest batch of replicants, the Nexus 6, escape, Blade Runner Rick Deckard is tasked with hunting them down. Here's where the film picks up, with the first half seeing Deckard successfully take out two of the Nexus 6 and meet Rachael, a replicant who is blissfully unaware of her artificial origins. While this is going on, Roy Batty, the leader of the renegade replicants, tricks lonely genetic designer J.F. Sebastian into taking him to his creator, Eldon Tyrell. Realising his "father" can't lengthen his life, Roy gruesomely murders him. Investigating the attack, Deckard goes to Sebastian's apartment, where he and Roy engage in a gruelling fight that sees fingers snapped, hands nailed and walls head-butted. At its climax, Roy saves Deckard from certain death, delivers one of the best soliloquies in cinema history and dies. Deckard returns home and decides to run off with Rachael. The final scene of the film sees him spot an origami unicorn, the calling card of fellow Blade Runner Gaff. If you were confused by what was actually going on in the movie that should bring you up to speed. The plot is motivated by both Deckard's hunt of the rogue replicants and Roy's search for "more life", which both tie together in the ending.
Multiple Endings - An Explanation
Before delving into the complexities of Blade Runner's ending, it's worth noting that there's several versions of the films out there. While they're mostly similar, there are some key differences that do slightly alter the conclusion. They most noticably differ on whether or not the cut contains three things; a Harrison Ford noir-style voiceover, a dream scene where Deckard sees an unicorn and a happy ending with Deckard and Rachael driving in the country. Below is a list of the various versions and what they contain: Workprint Prototype Version - Narration only at Roy's death scene; no dream scene; ambiguous ending. US Theatrical Release - Narration throughout; no dream scene; happy ending. International Theatrical Release - Narration throughout; no dream scene; happy ending. The Director's Cut - No narration; dream scene included; ambiguous ending. The Final Cut - No narration; dream scene included; ambiguous ending. Odds are you saw The Final Cut, which is most widely available on DVD and, according to both Ridley Scott and ourselves, is the best version of the film. Ignoring the workprint cut, which is essentially a better version of the theatrical version, the cuts fall into two groups; Initial Relase (IR), which have narration and a happy ending, and Director's Cut (DC), which includes the dream sequence and has an ambiguous ending. Throughout this article we'll reference the two different schools of cuts as they not only alter the events and tone of film, but also its meaning (particularly in reference to Deckard's character).
Roys Speech
After saving Deckard, Roy delivers what has become the film's most iconic line:
I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion. I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhäuser Gate. All those moments will be lost in time like tears in rain. Time to die.
It's even more beautiful in the film, with Rutger Hauer (who, according to various sources, rewrote the original, more typically sci-fi speech) dragging everything he can from each word, taking a minute to just say the whole thing. Apart from being an awe-inspiring moment that creates more wonder than CGI representations of these locations ever could, it's the moment when it's made clear that Roy has actually been at the end of his four year lifespan throughout the film. We've chalked up his near-insanity as a central part of his character, but so much of it (sticking a nail through his hand to keep him alert, crushing Tyrell's skull out of anger) stem from his knowledge of his impending doom. So Roy isn't an all-out psycho, rather someone simply trying to survive. But why, after manipulating humans with little remorse does he suddenly save the man mere moments ago he was trying to kill? Roy states to Deckard "quite an experience to live in fear, isn't it? That's what it is to be a slave" but as his life is almost at an end why should someone else get safety from fear? The clue is the message of his speech - when he dies all his incredible memories will be lost. Memories form a central theme to film and here Roy passing on his brief account to Deckard is a way to conserve his legacy. Giving them to Deckard, who, despite their differences, is now viewed by Roy as an equal brings us to what has become a dominating part of the film's legacy.
The Significance Of Rachael
As we said in the introduction, Blade Runner is the dual-story of Deckard and Roy. Integral to Deckard's journey is Rachael. A replicant working for the Tyrell Corporation (the major company behind the artificials), she is initially oblivious of her true nature, believing herself to be human. As well as potentially drawing parallels to Deckard (more on that later), it shows how belief plays a strong part in identity. The Voight-Kampff test, which by measuring eye-dilation (eyes are a key image throughout the film, serving as a window into the soul) through a series of questions determines whether someone is human or not, normally takes thirty or so questions to tell if someone is a replicant or not, but with the deceived Rachael is takes almost a hundred; in believing she is human, she somehow becomes more human. Part of the deception comes from having memories (from Tyrell's niece) artificially inserted into her mind. She fully believes them, but we (and subsequently her) know they're entirely fabricated. This will prove incredibly important in later arguments, but also brings up the film's question of what it means to be human. With Roy his memories were what made him unique, but for Rachael they're central to what makes her so fake. What's this got to do with the ending? Well, it stems from that Blade Runner is, at least in part, indebted to film noir; the story of a detective coming out of retirement, the trenchcoat and the voice-over are all very noir tropes. By that logic, Rachael should fill the femme fatale role; a woman who ensnares the protagonist with her seductive manner, ultimately to negative effects for the male. While she does lead to Deckard turning his back on the police, it isn't with any malicious intent. Her being so different is what allows not only this subverting of genre conventions, but also the very possibility of a happy ending. And ending which we'll explore next.
What Happens After The Final Shot?
So Roy expires and Deckard runs to the north with Rachael. What next? Do they escape to live happily ever after or do other Blade Runner's catch them? This is where the multiple cut issue really becomes prevalent, but we'll strive to keep things simple. The theatrical version and its ilk end on a scene of Rachael and Deckard driving north though the countryside, with some narration tying up all the issues nicely.
Gaff had been there, and let her live. Four years, he figured. He was wrong. Tyrell had told me Rachael was special. No termination date. I didn't know how long we had together. Who does?
So essentially that's the ideal situation with nothing actively working against their future. However, as this isn't viewed as the definitive version of the film it only exists as one possibility. And the other possibilities are more interesting. Narration-less versions (the workprint for those keeping track) of the scene are less overt and maintain an ambiguity to the character's future, while the later edits don't contain this scene at all, with the credits starting the moment the elevator doors close on Deckard. Obviously the latter leaves whether they'll even make it to the countryside up in the air, but both of these endings are open to interpretation; are they really free? These hinge heavily on how you read Gaff's line to Deckard just after his fight, "it's too bad she won't live. But then again, who does?" The theatrical version gave its own take on it, but without the voice-over there's multiple ways to read it, which require us to look at one specific moment.
The Unicorn
All versions of Blade Runner feature the scene at the end where Deckard finds the origami unicorn, but there is a major difference in meaning from the Initial Release (IR) and Director's Cut (DC). The scene itself plays out rather plainly. As Rachael heads to the elevator she knocks something on the floor, which Deckard picks up and sees is a unicorn made by Gaff. He shows recognition of the origami model, crushes it and runs to the elevator. In the IR this can either be read as Gaff letting the duo escape (as the narrative version shows) or pushing it a little further, as Gaff telling Deckard that the Blade Runners are aware of what he's doing. We know that the police chief is expecting Deckard to hunt Rachael down, so to have others do it when he fails is to be expected. Either way it's a rather simple ending. In the DC, however, things get a lot more interesting. You can read it the same as in the IR, although the ambiguous ending could suggest that Gaff is actually telling Deckard that if he runs he will hunt him, making the final shot an act of defiance. However, an added scene earlier in the film makes all that a secondary concern; earlier on Deckard had a dream where he saw a unicorn. We know it's possible to insert memories into a replicant, as seen with Deckard learning some of Rachael's most cherished 'memories', which provides central evidence to the most captivating of theories; Deckard is a replicant. Head to the next page and we'll run through the mystery in full.
Is Deckard A Replicant?
It's been a question that's plagued Blade Runner for an exceedingly long time, with everyone - from fans to the likes of Harrison Ford and Ridley Scott - putting forward their own opinion. Although different versions lean more heavily on one side of the argument than others, it's still exceedingly vague, hence how we can still discuss it with a sense of ambiguity over thirty years later. So, is Deckard a replicant? In Do Androids Dream Of Electric Sleep, he certainly isn't. In fact, it's one of book-Deckard's major character arcs is about the reality of his existence. Of course, that has little bearing on a film adaptation that has already changed an awful lot. We're going to present a case both for and against Deckard being a replicant, giving you everything you need to draw your own conclusion (as well as presenting what we think).
Arguments For
We've already covered the unicorn, which in the Director's and Final Cut at least, almost serves as proof that Deckard isn't human; it's too much of a coincidence otherwise. Ridley Scott has stated it is his belief he is a replicant and his subsequent cuts of the film are likely to push the argument more towards this side. There are plenty of other elements of the film that add fuel to the idea, some more resolute than others. The biggest is that in one shot, back in his apartment after Rachael has shot Leon, Deckard's eyes flash red, one of the telltale signs of a replicant. This has been emphasised in the DC, but is present in the IR versions as well. This same scene sees Rachael ask Deckard if he has passed the Voight-Kampff test, but as he's fallen asleep we get no response (in the book he takes and passes the test). Gaff's congratulations following his fight with Roy is equally suggestive - "you've done a man's job, sir" - and opens up an ambiguity of Deckard's world; he has lots of mementos and photos, which initially seems pretty normal, but contrasting with Leon, who appeared obsessed with getting his amateur photographs back, it could be a common tic of replicants.
Arguments Against
It certainly seems that initially Deckard wasn't intended to be a replicant. He isn't in the book and many people involved in the production have claimed it was never meant to be a prevalent element of the film (including Harrison Ford, who states the previous red eye trick was a mistake). This side of the theory relies more on semantics - the fight between him and Roy loses much of its significance when it's not man vs. machine - but you can easily argue the onus is on those who think Deckard is a replicant to prove their argument. Much of the argument in favour is based on little more than conjecture, making it a very involved fan theory and not a definitive reading of the film. One little-noted piece of evidence against is that throughout the film the humans are called by their surnames (Sebastian, Tyrell), while replicants use their first names (Roy, Leon, Rachael). As Deckard is never called just Rick, it's a stylistic suggestion he's in the human camp.
The Verdict
Like many ambiguous movie endings much of the power is in not knowing what the truth is. The question of whether he's a replicant plagues Deckard in the short story and him never knowing in the film ties strongly into Roy's talk of fear; is it better to fear knowing your mortality or fearing death? Of course, you came here for some sort of answer and we'll provide you with one, should you want it. In the initial release versions Deckard is probably human (there's nothing concrete to suggest otherwise), but in the Director's and Final Cuts he's got to be a replicant (that dream is too potent to ignore). So even though there's slight differences in the edits, they lead to totally different plot twists. But on top of the leap of saying Deckard is a replicant, there's a nothing, very interesting reading of the character we'd like to highlight...
One Final Thought - Is Deckard Gaff's Replicant Replacement?
Gaff is another police officer who works in the Blade Runner department. He's the one sent to bring Deckard out of retirement and appears again at the end to congratulate him and leave that foil unicorn. Walking with a cane it's clear he's past his prime, which prompts an interesting idea; if Deckard is a replicant, is he a replacement for Gaff. Essentially the theory is that Deckard is a new replicant created to track down the rogue Nexus 6, implanted with Gaff's memories of being a Blade Runner. Importantly it answers the question of why there'd be a replicant Blade Runner out there anyway - the best Blade Runner is not only retired, but injured - but it also explains some of the two characters' interactions. Gaff knows about the unicorn dream because it is one of his, he is rude to Deckard because he dislikes the idea of being replaced and "you've done a man's job" is a sign of his acceptance. When we first meet Deckard (minutes before Gaff's first appearance) he slumped by a window reading a newspaper while an overhead blimp talks about "a chance to begin again". This is in reference to off-world colonies, but in the setting of Chinatown could it be invoking the concept of reincarnation? Ray's journey is all about gaining more life, some semblance of immortality, so another form life-beyond-death would fit right in the film. What do you make of our evaluation of Blade Runner? What film would you like to see us dissect the ending of next? Let us know down in the comments.