What Does The Ending Of Logan Really Mean?
So, what about those evil corn corporation overlords?
Stop all the clocks, cut off the telephone. Prevent the dog from barking with a juicy bone. Silence the pianos and with muffled drum, bring out the coffin, let the mourners come. Wolverine is dead, and the worst thing is he died perfectly and beautifully in one of the most astounding comic book movies ever made.
Logan is the perfect end to Hugh Jackman's run as Wolverine: a brutal assault on the emotions and senses that is as devastating as it is purely entertaining. It is easily the bravest comic book movie Fox have ever made (even with Deadpool on their slate), and it closes this chapter of the convoluted mess of a book that the X-Men movie timeline has become.
But it isn't quite as succinct as you might imagine. There are still questions and shockwaves that blossom out from this movie that could actually inspire others - or at least warrant pause for thought. And there is enough in the film's storyline that suggests space for some interpretation, particularly in the context of what Fox have planned next. It's just a matter of working out what it all means...
Incidentally, don't stick around for a post-credits scene. There isn't one.
10. The Plot
It's 2029 and mutantkind has been pushed to the brink of extinction by an unknown trigger event (turns out it was Xavier, who has dangerous, killer seizures that accidentally wiped out his former students), which seems to have also aged Wolverine 30 years since the last time we saw him on this timeline. Which is definitely the same timeline as The Wolverine. And maybe also X-Men: Apocalypse. Or maybe not, who's even keeping up any more?
Logan lives in the Mexican desert with a decrepit Charles Xavier, suffering from a degenerative brain disease that has classified him a weapon of mass destruction and Caliban, an albino mutant who can smell other mutants. Which presumably isn't hard when they live in a sweaty dustbowl.
Into this dusty mess comes Gabriela, a nurse protecting a young girl called Laura, who she needs Wolverine - now a limo driver to pay for Xavier's medicine and a boat they can live on in peace - to drive her to a safe haven away from Donald Pierce's evil Reavers. Turns out she's Wolverine's clone, Pierce is working for a nefarious cloning company who created her and Wolverine, Charles and Laura are set on a road trip to escape their grasp and head to the safety of Canada.
This does not go to plan, and basically everyone dies. But that's what happens in real life, as Logan says - this is not a colourful, cheerful Marvel comic book world...
9. The Ending
Having initially escaped the Reavers, Wolverine, Laura and Charles find themselves holed up temporarily at a farm - owned by the Munsons (including Eriq La Salle from ER) - where their sanctuary is interrupted by X-24, a fully grown clone of Wolverine that Pierce's boss Dr Zander Rice (Richard E Grant) created to get around the fact that trying to teach child clones to be evil weapons doesn't work because they're all inherently good. How unShakespearean.
The younger, sleeker Wolverine #2 kills the Munsons and Charles (devastatingly), then goes to town on Logan before he can escape with Laura thanks to Caliban's heroic sacrifice and head towards their sanctuary on the Canadian border, where the escaped mutant kids were told to meet before crossing the border. There they meet the kids, all without their nurses and led by Rictor and plan to cross the border without Logan, who has a sudden attack of Han Solo pretend-not-to-care-itis.
He comes to his senses when he realises the kids have been found by the Reavers, Pierce and Rice and runs to assist them in the forest, where he ultimately finds X-24 again, after killing Rice mid-evil-monologue and the kids suddenly remember they're trained killers and take down Donald Pierce in the grimmest way possible.
Wolverine and X-24 go at it again, with the former sustaining mortal wounds as a distraction for Laura to shoot the younger model in the head with a deus ex machina adamantium bullet Logan kept around in case he wanted to commit suicide. He dies, then Logan dies after Laura calls him daddy and buries him and literally the entire audience has the rest of their week ruined.
8. So, Will Those Deaths Be Permanent?
Unfortunately, this is the end for Hugh Jackman's Wolverine, as he always stated. His death is too symbolic and too significant to retcon with a crazy time-loop and there's actually very little he could even do if he was still alive. This isn't just the death of the character, but the death of his arc. This is Obi-Wan fading away to nothing.
The same goes for Charles Xavier. Though Sir Patrick Stewart did tease that he might not be done with the character, he subsequently revealed that Logan feels like the right place to end his time as the character. And just as Jackman's exit was perfect, his death might have been tragic, but it was the right way to send him off. Bringing him back for a film set earlier in the timeline with the other X-Men cast would be a disservice to this beautiful film.
X-24 is also dead, in case anyone thought Fox might sneakily resurrect Jackman to play his own evil clone: that adamantium bullet pretty much exploded his head (even though the same thing only caused Logan's amnesia in the past). And none of the X-Men are coming back from where Xavier accidentally sent them.
So no, don't expect any Disney deaths here.
7. Where Was Mr Sinister?
The now infamous Weapon-X scene in X-Men: Apocalypse and the post-credits stinger that fed out from it both seemed to suggest that Logan would in some way involve Mr Sinister as the... sinister force behind the cloning of Wolverine that leads to X-23's being.
But in something of an unexpected twist, the film completely ignores this establishing work: the company behind the cloning is in fact Alkali Transigen, not EssexCorp, and the big bad is Dr Zander Rice - the son of one of the Weapon X scientists - rather than Sinister (whose real name is Nathaniel Essex - hence the suspicion he was appearing). So what happened? Did James Mangold just decide not to explore this narrative thread after all?
Well, Mangold was very clear that he wanted to avoid the kind of pantomime, costumed villainy that Mr Sinister would bring in Logan, so he was left out consciously. Plus, according to producer Simon Kinberg, Sinister is being set up for a future X-Men movie role, which suggests that at some point, the mainline of X-Men movies is going to explore a Wolverine clone storyline again... Otherwise what the hell was the point in the Apocalypse post-credits scene?
6. What Was With The Corn Syrup Sub-Plot?
As the narrative progresses, it turns out there's a nefarious farming corporation who harvest corn and produce corn syrup in vast quantities because apparently nobody in this universe drinks anything but energy drinks (which might explain why everyone is so eager to rip each other to shreds).
The farmers come into contact with Logan when he stays at the Munsons and the farming patriarch reveals that the company has ben turning off his water to try and force him to leave his farm in the middle of their intended expansion path. It's a sub-plot straight out of Shane, the single biggest narrative influence on the film, and while it's distracting, it does serve a purpose (though it's absolutely contrived).
Though it isn't explained nearly as well as it could have been, it turns out that the corn company are a false front for Alkali Transigen, who have been using the mutated corn (ironically) to infect the population with an anti-mutant "vaccine" that has cured the world of its mutant problem.
So it wasn't just an excuse for Logan and X-24 to chop up some rednecks.
5. What About Alkali Transigen?
Though the end of the movie sees Logan kill Dr Zander Rice and the mutant kids kill off Donald Pierce and the Reavers (who are no more than glorified cannon fodder), there's no suggestion that the company they all work for is no more. The mutant children still have to flee to Canada, and the company presumably still lives to clone another day (or they'd have nothing to run from).
The real question here is whether Alkali Transigen were a legitimate, government-backed organisation, and the only answer can be that they were. In the face of Professor Xavier's seizure that killed the X-Men and injured hundreds of "norms", the population must have gone through another phase of anti-mutant hysteria (despite the fact that they made comics celebrating the X-Men and sold their likenesses as action figures).
It's not overtly spoken, but it appears that Alkali Transigen do have the backing of the government, which suggests the war between man and mutant rages on. But not in Canada, which is a much more level headed place.
But, could they have cloned other X-24s? Why would it be the case that they'd breed a whole batch of child clones as an army but would stick to only doing one of the superior models? It makes no sense that there aren't other young Wolverines out there waiting to be used by whoever fills the power vacuum created by Rice.
4. Could There Be A X-23 Spin-Off Or Sequel?
For all of those reasons outlined above, there absolutely could be a spin-off movie focusing on X-23. Her enemy still exists as a corporation, there is room to bring in a Mr Sinister type as the real head of the organisation, and it's not like she's going to be a well-adjusted member of society.
It's somewhat unfortunate that the character has to exist in this universe where mutants have all but been eradicated in America, as it closes a lot of story-line opportunities. She's never going to be an X-Men team member for instance, unless Fox cleverly write in another time-travel conceit and she ends up in the other timeline thanks to Bishop or Cable. Don't rule it out, but maybe don't hold your breath.
What's more likely is that X-23's movie would focus on what remains of Alkali Transigen and the American government's potential involvement. We could easily see a Colonel Stryker type brought in to clean-up, and there is a rather compelling argument for him using a team of mutant clones to hunt X-23 down. She's basically both a weapon of mass destruction and a major national embarrassment rolled into one, after all.
3. What About The Other Young Mutants?
The mutants who all escape into Canada - where it seems there is either a mutant sanctuary or a government more willing to harbour fugitive mutants than America's - are all cloned from other mutants from the comics and come with some pretty interesting powers, including Rictor's ability to force throw massive objects.
The question now is whether this group will become another new X-Men team, in the vein of the New Mutants (who will be an entirely different team in the older timeline as directed by Josh Boone). Even in the more realistic world written by James Mangold there could be supervillains worthy of their teaming up, and it would almost feel like them not using their powers for good would be a betrayal of Wolverine's sacrifice to save them.
Equally, it might not be the worst thing if they were seen to go on and live "normal" adjusted lives where their powers don't define them (a rather poetic outcome given their stories), but as all comic book movies ever have always said - almost in capital letters - "the world needs heroes."
If Logan does as well as it looks like it's going to, Fox have an opportunity to give them a sequel/spin-off that wouldn't betray their arcs at all.
2. How Do Fox Sell Another X-Men Movie?
Possibly the biggest connotation for Fox coming out of Logan is that they're going to struggle to be able to hype another X-Men movie after such a perfect full-stop on the original Bryan Singer arc. And that's a serious issue, given that they're already apparently moving ahead with X-Men: Supernova (a fake title for the Dark Phoenix saga apparently).
The only way they can do it - barring a deal with Marvel that sees another reboot and the X-Men meeting the Avengers (OH PLEASE KEVIN, PLEASE) - is to recast Wolverine pretty sharpish and make the new Dark Phoenix event also the new Wolverine event.
Sure, that might distract from Jean Grey's story, but there's very much a feeling that the new mutants introduced in Apocalypse weren't as strong as they really needed to be. And going with a full reboot at this stage would look like an admission of fault, so it's unlikely with other spin-offs planned. Without that Wolverine unveiling, it all looks like a bit of a mess.
1. Who Plays Wolverine Next?
It goes without saying that Fox are going to recast Wolverine. Right now, even with his death enjoying special accolades amongst fans, he's the strongest, most bankable brand Fox have going for them.
They're currently talking about making movies that don't focus as much on Professor X and Magneto (lunatics), and without Wolverine as well, they're fighting a losing battle. So it's only a matter of time before they bring the character back.
So how do they do it? Do they go for a straight recast that drops into the post-Apocalypse timeline? Do they bring him back for a solo series that avoids his origin but sees him team up with other mutants not involved in the main X-Men team? Gambit maybe? Jubilee perhaps? Or do Fox just pull the trigger on an X-Force team with Deadpool, Cable, Psylocke and Wolverine at the core?
Whatever the case, they need to strongly consider writing a blank cheque for Tom Hardy to replace Jackman. Because he's definitely the pick of the possible bunch.
What did you think of Logan? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.