Who Actually Killed Who In Scream?
Was it Billy? Was it Stu? Or was it really Roman Bridger?
Wes Craven's 1996 Scream is an all-time classic horror movie.
Few horrors of the past 25 years can claim to have had as much of a genuinely game-changing influence on the genre as Scream, with the film managing to both poke fun at the overtired tropes of the genre whilst somehow still managing to be a terrifying movie in its own right.
Scream stared at the formulaic rules of the horror genre, laughed in their face, and then subsequently went about breathing new life into horror and, in particular, the slasher subgenre.
Two key components to any such horror offering, of course, are the amount of bodies piled up and having a good twist at play. The twist here would be that there are two Ghostface killers - Matthew Lillard's Stu Macher and Skeet Ulrich's Billy Loomis - and the kill count of this pair is quite the impressive one.
Given how both killers were adorned from head-to-toe in the Ghostface garb, it's not revealed exactly which of Stu or Billy are responsible for each death. Added to that, there's also the revelation in Scream 3 that Roman Bridger was a sinister presence in and around that first Scream movie.
For those contemplating who was responsible for each of the deaths in Scream, here's the breakdown of who was wielding the knife for each of these murders.
7. Steve Orth
Fun fact. Actor Kevin Patrick Walls was at one point up for the role of Billy Loomis.
While Walls ultimately lost out on that role to Skeet Ulrich, he would still be a part of Scream after being tasked with playing Steve Orth. The boyfriend of Drew Barrymore's Casey Becker, Steve doesn't even get a line of dialogue in the movie, but he has a major impact on the initial viewing experience of watching Scream.
Steve is the first person that we see killed in Scream and that moment in itself is the first time that we get to see Ghostface in action. And what brutal, bloody action it is!
Gagged and taped to a chair, Steve's fate is left down to Casey's knowledge of horror films. When she incorrectly lists Jason Voorhees as the killer of the first Friday the 13th picture - the killer of that movie being Jason's mother, Pamela Voorhees - that means that Steve's days are numbered.
Stabbed, slashed, and turned into a gutted piece of patio furniture, Steve bites the bullet quicker than you can say "what's your favourite scary movie?" - and the person under the Ghostface mask for this particular kill is Stu Macher, as confirmed by the filmmakers.
With Billy's Ghostface at this point in time more focussed on what's going on inside Casey's house, it's Stu who's left to deal with matters outside Casey's house.
6. Casey Becker
For poor Casey Becker, she was the tone-setter for Scream and for the larger Scream franchise.
With Drew Barrymore the headline act on all of Scream's early promotional material, seeing the supposed star of the movie killed off after just 15 minutes was a huge shocker that let the audience know that Scream was a film where all bets were off. After all, Wes Craven's 1996 offering completely changed the horror game by openly mocking the overplayed formula and rules of the genre.
Who was the person behind the murder of Casey? Well, the simple answer to that is Matthew Lillard's Stu Macher, but there is a little more to all of this.
As Casey gets tormented by an eerie caller, it's Stu who was on the phone here. He wasn't operating alone, mind, and the Ghostface who first physically encounters Casey in her home is Billy Loomis. After those two scuffle and Casey makes her big run for freedom, it's then that Stu's Ghostface appears and stabs her in the back before leaving Casey's gutted corpse hanging from a nearby tree. In terms of an added incentive, it's later revealed that Casey was Stu's ex-girlfriend.
And with that, the table had been well and truly set to establish Scream as completely different to anything else in the horror genre at that time.
5. Principal Himbry
Upon a first watch back in 1996, it was all kinds of brilliant to see Henry Winkler turn up in Scream. For a certain generation, any appearance from the former Fonz is enough to put a massive smile on the face.
Unfortunately for Winkler's Principal Himbry, his role in Scream was destined to be a short one.
Following the lead of Casey Becker's murder, poor Himbry is likewise gutted and left hanging for all to see. Unlike Casey being hung from a tree, though, Himbry is left on display on the school's football posts.
Logic suggests that Billy Loomis was the person behind Himbry's death. With Stu at that point busy arranging his big house party, that makes Billy the prime candidate to have offed Principal Himbry and left his corpse hanging in the most public and visible of ways.
There's actually more to Himbry's death than simply another dead body for the sake of another dead body, for it's his death and the subsequent displaying of his lifeless body that later leads to all of Stu's house guests leaving the party - which then leaves our two Ghostfaces alone with Sidney and a select few others.
4. Tatum Riley
When it comes to imaginative kills, death by cat flap is certainly right up there.
There was, of course, a little more to it than just that, but the demise of Rose McGowan's Tatum Riley is one of the more memorable ones of the entire Scream franchise.
After being confronted in Stu's garage by Ghostface, Tatum's only route of escape is to somehow try and get through the garage door's cat flap. Managing to get halfway through the cat flap, Tatum then has the electric garage door lifted on her - in turn crushing her neck and killing her.
It's not made abundantly clear who killed Tatum, but Billy Loomis seems to be the most logical answer to that conundrum. Stu is a pretty permanent presence at his house party, and disappearing to kill his own girlfriend would be a bit heavy even for a deranged killer.
As such, it seems as if Billy was the person responsible for Tatum's creative death - with Loomis then turning up at Stu's party and seemingly giving a knowing nod to Stu about what he's just done.
3. Kenny Jones
Played by W. Earl Brown, Kenny Jones was Gale Weathers' cameraman in the original Scream movie.
Like everybody else featured on this list, however, Kenny was another who would end up as part of Scream's body count by the time all was said and done with that 1996 picture. In terms of who killed Kenny, that's one of the more clean-cut deaths of the Scream franchise.
With Billy Loomis out of the equation due to being 'dead' - as in, Billy had been faux killed by Ghostface as part of his and Stu's grand plan - the person responsible for killing Kenny is Stu.
While Gale would later play up how Kenny was gutted by Ghostface, the reality was that Kenny had his throat sliced by the killer. His final words of "the door" would help Sidney get to temporary safety, but Kenny's corpse was soon placed on top of his news van - with that dead body conveniently falling onto the van's windshield when Gale tries to make her escape.
Kenny may have been a minor character in the greater picture of Scream, yet his role is one that's been referenced in subsequent Scream movies. That being in how Gale Weathers' new cameramen always have a sense of trepidation at taking the gig, for fear of their fate ending up the same as Kenny's.
2. Maureen Prescott
Maureen Prescott was a fleeting presence in the first Scream movie, although she's obviously a vital piece of the franchise's overall puzzle.
The very first victim of Ghostface, Maureen was killed a year prior to the events of Scream. It was only in Scream 3, though, that we got to find out the exact details behind Maureen's death.
As revealed by Maureen's abandoned son Roman, it was he who had orchestrated that death after he was rejected by Maureen upon turning up at her doorstep to start up a mother-son relationship. Angry at Maureen and at Sidney for the life that she had, Roman instigates a plan of revenge.
That plan would see Sidney's long, lost brother get in the ear of Billy Loomis to make him aware that Maureen was having an affair with his father - an affair that led to Billy's mother walking out on the family.
Not just did Roman give Billy this information, he also gave him the tip of getting someone else involved to be his fall guy. That's where Stu Macher came into the fold, with Billy convincing him to join him in killing Maureen Prescott - and that's exactly what the pair did.
Framing Cotton Weary for Maureen's murder, Billy and Stu both partook in the rape and murder of Sidney's mother.
1. Stu Macher And Billy Loomis
With the cat well and truly out of the bag as Scream's final act concludes, there's zero guesswork needed where it pertains to who was responsible for killing Stu Macher and Billy Loomis.
After Billy's initial 'death' was revealed to have all been a façade, Billy would finally get to meet his maker for real by the time Scream came to an end. But before Billy made his big exit, his best pal Stu was the first of these two deranged killers to die.
Stu went out in style, having a TV dropped directly onto his head. That was courtesy of Sidney, and it was Sid who would also incapacitate Billy. A tussle with Sidney left Billy seemingly dead as a dodo - only for uber-geek Randy to warn how killers aren't always as dead as they may seem.
With that, Billy jumps up for one last scare... but is greeted by a bullet in the forehead from Gale Weathers.
Having caused so much bloodshed and torment throughout Scream, Stu and Billy fell afoul of Sidney and Gale, respectively, when it came to crunch time.
Then again, who knows if we somehow see one of these Ghostface killers back in action in Scream 5. After all, Matthew Lillard has admitted that his Stu Macher was originally meant to return in Scream 3 before last-minute plans changed that.