Why Blade Runner 2049 Flopped So Hard
"Fiery the angels fell."
There are some things that just plain ruin cinema for a lot of normally enthusiastic cinema fans and the idea that a Transformers movie could make a billion dollars while something as important and worthy as Blade Runner 2049 stumbles disastrously at the box office is right up there.
Despite glowing critical reviews and lots of buzz, the belated sequel to genre-defining cult classic Blade Runner is so far limping towards an underwhelming haul that started badly with a $30m domestic pull. Considering it reportedly cost somewhere north of $150m (with marketing on top of that), that will not make for comfortable reading.
There are now, inevitably, lots of theories on what went wrong. Limited representation, a fundamental lack of positive escapism and the ordeal of watching something so long have been widely discussed already, but essentially, it seems that the film failed to connect. Regardless of how beautiful it is and how admirably well made, it missed the magic that turns something from artistically of merit to financially successful. And though die-hard fans will insist the former is more important, the studios needed it to be both. This is a business, after all.
So why did it underwhelm at the box office?
9. It's Been 35 Years
Whether you have a major movie brand or not, letting it sit out to pasture for a long time is not the best way to ensure that anyone still cares about it. We've already seen the cost to other major franchises of belatedly releasing sequels and other than Star Wars, there isn't exactly a huge catalogue of them that were well received.
Waiting for 35 years to release a sequel is asking for trouble - even if you have one of the most compelling questions in movie conundrum history (is Deckard, or isn't he?). That's too long a period for nostalgia to work as well, and while Blade Runner was granted an A- CinemaScore, the result - and indeed the opening weekend haul - is skewed by the fervent fanbase (of predominantly older male viewers) who comprised most of that initial audience.
They might be committed, but they aren't diverse enough or numerous enough to create a proper, sustainable audience, and the sad reality is that younger audience members simply do not have the awareness to commit to something 35 years in the making.
8. Rose-Tinted Appreciation Of The Original
Appreciation of Blade Runner these days seems to come from a very vocal, surprisingly small fanbase (the same ones who made up much of the opening weekend audience), who fail to remember that the film made no money when it first came out. They also seem to ignore the fact that the infamous extended post-release tinkering process (which saw numerous cuts released in search of the perfect one) actually suggest that the film was never actually as polished as it may have seemed.
Blade Runner is a high-concept, highly-atmospheric sci-fi that made a little over $30m at the box office and which has taken on a cultural importance that seems to miss the fact that it's not all that purely entertaining. It's more of a cult thing, whose appreciation over time has inspired confidence in the brand that shouldn't be there.
Sure, it's technically impressive and it's like a living artifact of its genre (to the extent that anything that even remotely resembles it is said to be directly influenced), but its rewards aren't quite in tune with what lucrative mainstream audiences spend money on or talk about afterwards in glowing fashion. Impressive simply does not always mean entertaining.
7. It's Too Long
One hundred and sixty-three minutes. Two hours and forty-three minutes.
No film should be judged solely on how long it is: if it's good, the length doesn't matter. If it's bad, the length matters just as little. But in marketing terms, that sort of length - in 2017 - for anything that isn't a tentpole, popcorn blockbuster is difficult to get over positively.
Much like the original, 2049 may come into its own when it hits home release, because a 2.75 hour movie out at a multiplex (even with the IMAX experience) is both too costly and too much of an ordeal for the discomfort of most cinemas. That isn't a comment on film-making at all - it's a comment on audience behaviour these days.
For what it's worth, it doesn't feel like a close-to 3 hour film when you're watching it, because there's a lot to look at while you're waiting for the plot to happen, but you try marketing a film that length to the mainstream audiences that needed to see it to make it a box office success... It's just not a selling point at all.
6. It's A Self-Indulgent Tone Poem (And The Reviews Confirmed It)
Given the way Blade Runner was, you could very easily have assumed that 2049 was going to be deeply invested in its own visual mythology. Blade Runner basically invented an aesthetic, and with Denis Villeneuve and Roger Deakins in charge of the look of its sequel, it was clear the studio were looking to do something similar.
Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on how you appreciate movies as art), the result is a self-indulgent moving art exhibition that values aesthetic and style over narrative substance and coherence. It looks beautiful, but by almost every positive critique's reckoning, story is entirely inconsequential - the plot serves only to vaguely tie together all the pretty pictures.
The problem for the studio is that all of those reviews were so positive about that that they failed to whip up any hype for the movie. Already strangled by the studio's desire not to spoil any of the plot (as if it needed protecting, anyway), those critics had to talk about the visuals, and too many praised it in such a way that it sounded unappetitising to "mainstream" audiences.
You want your film marketing - both in-house and review-led - to present the most palatable distillation of your movie (whether that means lying or not), and unfortunately, though the reviews were great, if you read the actual details of them, they weren't the sales pitches they needed to be.
5. It Cost Way Too Much
Had Blade Runner 2049 cost the same as the original did, it wouldn't be a financial disaster if it pulled in less than £100m, but the minute you start making $150-180m budgeted movies (with about the same dropped on marketing budgets), you need to pull in Star Wars money to be considered a success. Or at least half-Star Wars money.
In the context of Blade Runner, that amount of money is even more insane. Blade Runner made $30m at the box office. THIRTY MILLION DOLLARS. Why the hell anyone sanctioned the same budget as Transformers: Age Of Extinction (give or take) for a belated sequel to that movie is a mystery bigger than any of the plot holes in 2049.
It was doomed from the start, because that sort of budget suggests certain things, and the marketing definitely didn't seem to suggest it was going to deliver them. As well as the studio needing to make Star Wars money because of their budget, they also needed to make a Star Wars movie to justify it. And now, because they may fail rather spectacularly to make the budget back, it's going to look like an even worse failure.
4. Jared Leto And Ryan Gosling
Both Ryan Gosling and Jared Leto are very interesting actors, and great figures to cast in movies. That's why it tends to happen with comfortable frequency for them. What neither of them is, however, is a box office certainty.
Gosling exists in the curious dead zone where he can't translate how much the Internet seems to love him into actual box office drawing power. He is not a lead that you pin a $180m movie to if you want to immediately draw in money on your first weekend. He's great, sure, but his box office track record suggests that audiences just don't flock to him regardless of how good he is.
And then there's Jared Leto, who has gone from being one of the best supporting character actors in Hollywood to being that guy who ruined The Joker in public perception. Thanks to Suicide Squad's marketing campaign - and the decision to double down on his "antics" on set - he's emerged from that movie with a grubby reputation that extends well beyond the performance. It's ridiculous, but it's still true.
Add to that the fact that 2049 didn't appear to offer many substantial roles for women or minority roles - something that massively helped Mad Max: Fury Road - and the casting definitely had some impact.
3. It Demands Too Much Of Its Audience Ahead Of Time
If you're a mainstream audience member coming in to Blade Runner 2049, it basically asks you to do homework to get up to speed on what's happening. That might just mean watching Blade Runner (though there's no indication that you'll actually learn all that much of use from it), but there's also tie-in satellite material that fills in gaps and sets the landscape.
And on top of that, you probably have to go and read around the production of the original movie, the mythology of the universe and the complex readings of the film and its philosophical ramifications. It's not an easy movie you can just dip into and know where you are and what to expect - you need to put in establishing work.
Some would say that that is brave and admirable, but it's not what the kind of audience who spends on these movies expects. And even more fundamentally, that audience doesn't really know what Blade Runner is: it's not the huge brand its fans think it is (at least not in mainstream terms), and the confidence in it is very similar to the misguided faith in the Dark Tower, King Arthur and John Carter that gave them all huge budgets.
On an executive's paper, it sounds good (and looking at social media offers a skewed picture of how popular it is), but in real terms, it simply doesn't have the same pulling power.
2. You Won't See It Again
Films can obviously be great and still be classified as definitve one-time-only deals. Dunkirk was a majestorial achievement in technical film-making, but it was so much of an ordeal that it's hard to imagine the same size audience would flock to see it again. And Blade Runner is very much the same, which kills the chance for an improved box office through repeat ticket-buys.
There could be an argument to suggest that there's so much lush detail in the film that it demands rewatching, but that would only be the case if every shot wasn't lingering and there was some sort of complex plot to distract from it. That absolutely wasn't the case, and the fact is that we spent 163 minutes wandering slowly around Denis Villeneuve's imagination (infused heavily with his Ridley Scott fetishism) with ample time to drink it in.
And there's just not a compelling enough reason to do that again when you'd get the same experience pouring over a coffee table book of the film's artwork.
In story terms, it's not satisfying, there are no stand-out performances, no really stunning revelations and no pay-off to the near endless first act-style, slow-burn building that might have made it an essential repeat viewing. And when you consider that audiences for The Force Awakens were reported to be seeing it "three or four times", that's a potentially sizeable chunk of box office gone right there.
1. It
In order to recoup some of that budget - which in itself screams a certain type of intent - Blade Runner 2049 needed to be THE event movie of the late Summer/Autumn period. It needed to be THE film audiences came out for - even those who don't necessarily go to cinemas once a week to see the big releases.
The studios needed it to be enough of a draw to overshadow everything else in cinemas, and while the immediate competition wasn't particularly difficult to best, the film - rather unfortunately - was overshadowed itself by the appeal of Warner Bros' other big release - It.
It became the event movie of the period - if not the year (Star Wars might have something to say about it) - and it's proximity to the release of Blade Runner 2049 killed some of the box office haul from less frequent cinema-goers it might otherwise have been able to count on.