Why The Exorcist: Believer Failed
David Gordon-Green's Exorcist reboot has bombed critically and commercially, and it's no shock why.
The latest Exorcist film, The Exorcist: Believer, hasn't done too well at the box office or with critics, but that shouldn't come as a huge surprise. The film, which takes a similar sort of requel approach to the franchise in the same way 2018's Halloween did, brings back original Exorcist cast member Ellen Burstyn as Chris MacNeil to tell a new story of two children who seemingly become possessed after going missing for several weeks.
Intended to be part one of a trilogy, Believer landed a paltry 22% on Rotten Tomatoes and has so far grossed only $109 million at the global box office (as per Box Office Mojo). The latter sum may seem respectable given its reported $30 million budget, but it's a middling return that will ensure it just about limps into the breaking even category - a just reward for a film that probably shouldn't exist in the first place.
When it was announced in 2020 that Blumhouse would be resurrecting the Exorcist franchise with Halloween trilogy director David Gordon Green at the helm, alarm bells went off pretty quickly. Not because Gordon Green's Halloween movies were bad, necessarily (the 2018 entry was largely well-received, only to be followed by two polarising sequels), but rather that making an Exorcist film without its creator, the late William Peter Blatty - who passed away in 2017 at the age of 89 - should've been a non-starter.
Blatty authored The Exorcist in 1971 and adapted it for the screen to be directed by the late William Friedkin two years later, telling a uniquely personal story that reckoned with his own Catholic faith and arrived at an equally personal conclusion: that, if the devil exists, then God must too. The story was inspired by a reported account of demonic possession that took place in 1949, an account Blatty felt was an affirmation of divinity rather than something that should dispirit the idea of faith itself.
[Article continues on next page...]
This reconciliation is the driving force behind The Exorcist, which sees conflicted priest Damien Karras already struggling with his own crisis of faith when confronted with the possession of Regan MacNeil. It's only in the demise of Father Lankester Merrin, and the looming death of Regan, that Karras finds the strength to reembrace his faith and make a noble sacrifice, tumbling to his death but in essence ascending to Heaven. That element of theological strife and eventual conciliation becomes even more pronounced in "The Version You've Never Seen", which restores a sequence Blatty was desperate for Friedkin to include in the original theatrical release, where Merrin and Karras discuss the purpose of evil. As summarised by Exorcist authority Mark Kermode, "It isn't about the girl - it's about everyone else in the house, it's about the priest."
Blatty would revisit these same themes years later with Legion, a sequel to The Exorcist that he also directed for the screen in 1990. While it has taken some time for The Exorcist III to be reappraised as a truly great horror film, when taken together with Friedkin's seminal original, everything that has needed to be said about this story has been said.
Not that that has stopped others from trying. Two Exorcist prequels were released in 2004 and 2005 respectively - The Exorcist: The Beginning and Dominion: The Prequel to The Exorcist, which were adapted from the same script by William Wisher and Caleb Carr and expanded the origins of Merrin's character many years before the events of the 1973 movie. Neither fared well with critics and were commercial bombs, continuing a trend set by John Boorman's misjudged 1977 effort Exorcist II: The Heretic, which is widely regarded as the worst sequel ever made.
[Article continues on next page...]
The Exorcist: Believer Misses The Point Entirely
This poor franchise history does not excuse The Exorcist: Believer's failings, however. Directed by Green, who co-developed the story alongside Halloween scribes Danny McBride and Scott Teems, alongside new collaborator Peter Sattler, Believer is, by all accounts, a typification of every boring conversation that has ever been had about The Exorcist. Said conversations have historically tended to relitigate whether Friedkin's film is worthy of its "scariest movie of all time" tagline. The Exorcist is scary, of course, but the issue is that the mythology that has been built around the film is largely focused on that scare and shock element, and that seems to be where Believer has sourced its entire understanding of Blatty's story from.
This failure to grasp the soul of the text is exacerbated by Believer's mostly reiterative approach. It lifts the same structure from Friedkin's film, concluding with a grand exorcism sequence but without any of the heart that was there in its progenitor. Equally as bad is how Green fumbles at the "requel" tropes he established with 2018's Halloween, pointlessly bringing back Burstyn's Chris like she's a Laurie Strode figure before removing her from the film unceremoniously towards the end. Such a move may have played better five years ago, but since Halloween, we've had Scream (2022), Texas Chainsaw Massacre, and Candyman (2021), all of which brought back characters or cast members from previous installments to maintain franchise legacies. With Believer, this approach now feels more formulaic than ever - right on down to Green and Co. planning a trilogy the same way they did with Halloween.
[Article continues on next page...]
William Peter Blatty Was Right About The Exorcist's Title
The other issue here, though, is that while The Exorcist maintains a legacy as being the greatest horror movie of all time, both the series and the exorcism genre as a whole have seen diminishing returns in the 50 years since the first film's release. Of the now six installments in The Exorcist franchise, only two are legitimately great, and one of those two - the Blatty-directed Exorcist III - was initially met with a tepid response from audiences and critics.
At the time, Blatty lobbied hard for the film not to carry the Exorcist title and to instead use the name Legion like his novel, mainly due to the fact there wasn't to be an exorcism in the film, but also because of concerns over Exorcist II going down as one of the worst films ever made and thus toxifying "The Exorcist" as a title. Blatty was conscious of this in 1990 - 33 years ago - and claimed that studio executives admitted to him after The Exorcist III's release that "The Exorcist" titling was having a negative effect on its audience lure.
Not that it mattered though, as the same mistake was repeated twice again in the 2000s and now once more with The Exorcist: Believer. While there have been successful possession and Exorcist-style films since Friedkin's original, they have proven few and far between. The Exorcist has a legendary reputation, but it seemingly hasn't been enough to overcome the glut of bad genre entries and for a sequel to thusly cash in that credit.
But all of this comes back to the biggest issue with The Exorcist: Believer - it should never have been made. It may have been the scares that made The Exorcist a phenomenon, but it has endured because of the theology that was inexorably tied to Blatty's own relationship with his faith. This is something that fails to register with Believer on the most profound level, ensuring its status as another insipid example of the requel era, as well as one that, quite simply, never stood a chance in the first place.