X-Men: Apocalypse - 12 Perfect Actors To Complete The Cast

The key characters Singer needs to cast.

By Simon Gallagher /

X-Men: Days Of Future Past hasn't even left the cinema yet, and hype is already building for its successor in Bryan Singer's revitalised X-Men franchise. In many ways, this was to be expected: the director actively encouraged a culture of forward-looking excitement when he announced the title of the sequel before DOFP was even out, and it fits with the all-encompassing agenda in the industry now to establish unified narratives in multiple comic book movies to have suggestions for where the franchise is going next. Fox already have irons in the fire in the shape of Gambit's solo outing and X-Force, and it appears they are looking to go the same route as Marvel, DC and Sony, which means forward planning has leapt to the top of their agenda. With that in mind, news is beginning to filter through pertaining to what we can expect from Apocalypse: Singer has said the seeds of the plot were sewn in Days Of Future Past, and the casting of Channing Tatum means Gambit will appear, but beyond that, the rest is in the air. With some significant story elements to be decided on, there could well be a major injection of new characters, and naturally, the major question at this stage is who should play those potential parts...

12. Domhnall Gleeson - Nightcrawler

One of the biggest missed opportunities in Days Of Future Past was the decision - presumably wrenching - to drop Nightcrawler from the production. Bryan Singer has spoken since the film's release to confirm that the character was set to re-appear having been unceremoniously disappeared after X2, with a scene written for him, but that he was forcing in too many mutants for the sake of it. But at the same time, Singer has revealed that he is considering adding a young Nightcrawler to the Apocalypse cast, which is a shame for those who believe Alan Cumming's performance to be one of the best in comic book movie history, but which is good news for fans of the character all the same. In Domhnall Gleeson - who might be somewhat tied up with Star Wars obligations - Singer would have a striking looking actor who could fit into the hole left by Cumming well, and though he is 30, under heavy make-up, he wouldn't look as old and could add the same theatricality to the performance as Cumming did.

11. Moon Bloodgood - Psylocke

Officially we've already seen Psylocke in the X-Men franchise, but thanks to Bryan Singer's destruction of The Last Stand, there's no reason for anyone to really pay attention to the fact, considering we'll all feel better that way. The mooted introduction of a young Jean Grey (more of which later) opens up the opportunity for Singer to create a villainous mirror for her among Apocalypse's followers, and who better to fit the bill than the mutant who inexplicably acquired Grey's powers in the comics? Psylocke was of course a member of Apocalypse's Four Horsemen when her mission to assassinate the villain was unsuccessful and she was transformed by Archangel (who was set free by Apocalypse from Pyslocke's psychic controls) into one of his fellow horsemen. That would represent the best way to integrate the character as a villain. Bloodgood, who is currently starring in Falling Skies would be a strong candidate for the role: beautiful and undoubtedly skilled enough to pull off an ethereally evil villain, she already boasts geek credentials and would ensure Psylocke didn't fade into the background.

10. Deadpool - Ryan Reynolds

It has long been suggested that Fox are still willing to ignore the fact that the character assassination of Wade Wilson and Deadpool in X-Men Origins: Wolverine and give the character a rebooted solo outing, but you simply cannot ignore the fact that the star has now been in four unloved comic book movies. A solo movie might not be the best move for him, despite how well suited he appears to be to the motor-mouthed mercenary. So what better opportunity than to bring him into the X-Men universe? He's already been suggested as a cast member for the X-Force movie, and the amalgamation of those two teams would seem appropriate for the threat posed by Apocalypse, as well as as a means to set up that spin-off. Deadpool is a firm fan favourite, and there's no denying that the character still has legs, even with Reynolds under the mask. All he needs is someone like Bryan Singer to actually pay attention to the source and protect the character from cartoonish spoofing.

9. John Malkovich - Warren Worthington II

He might not be a mutant, but Worthington could play a significant part in Apocalypse, considering the potential to see Angel (or Archangel, more specifically) under the villain's control. His relationship with his father - the inventor of the mutant cure - could represent a significant step in telling that story, as well as playing a fundamental part in Apocalypse's agenda to assert mutant control once more. The issue of the cure will no doubt re-appear in the X-Men movies, because it is an inherent part of the wider narrative arc, just as the shadow of civil rights allegory will continue as long as the franchise exists. And Worthington is a key element to that story, as well as being a key figure for Angel's arc, considering he's Warren Worthington III's father. It would be intriguing to see someone like John Malkovich brought in to rechannel his famous on-screen malevolence, and allow him the opportunity to star in a comic book movie that was taken away when Sam Raimi was unable to follow through on casting him as Vulture in Spider-Man 4. Given the opportunity to actually act, and not play a caricature, Malkovich would add the same classical edge that Kelsey Grammer wonderfully did in The Last Stand, and he has proven himself capable of creating genuinely unlikeable, complex characters in the past.

8. The "Old Cast" Members Who Should Be Included

The word from within the production is that some of the original X-Men cast will unquestionably be included in Apocalypse, which inevitably is an intriguing prospect, given the questions it opens up. It seems likely that Blink (Fan Bingbing) will return, since she's signed up to a five picture deal (unless Fox are setting her up as a member of X-Force or something alternative), and you would have to suspect that Bishop would be the most likely of her new team-mated to jump back in time, given his association with time travel. But what of the original cast? James Marsden has expressed a desire to return, but Singer has to be careful not to simply retread the same ground as Days Of Future Past, so it's more likely a core representation of the original team would be present. And that's only if they can come up with a means to satisfactorily facilitate the time travel aspect. Presumably, they'll rely on the fact that Apocalypse is basically a God, and can do pretty much what he wants. So maybe we'll see another book-ended format that focuses on the old cast and then has the villain travel back to the '80s to a point where mutantkind was at its perceived weakest. And that would mean a return for everyone initially.

7. Ben Foster - Archangel

He might have already played the character once, and rather unspectacularly thanks to the film's lack of focus on him as anything more than a plot device, but Ben Foster has come a long way since the days of The Last Stand. His CV is peppered with the kind of roles that suggest that he is more than capable of playing memorably unhinged characters with a darker edge, and there is very much a feeling that he deserves another go at an intriguing character who was unfairly crushed in a poor script. Some might suggest it more likely that Singer will recast Angel if he's going to use the character, but it would be far more interesting to see Worthington Jnr brought back in time by Apocalypse as a slightly older character, having had to endure his father's insistent quest for a cure and the fundamental belief that he is a sub-human from those he loves. And Foster is the perfect actor to play both the good and evil sides of the character, so comfortable is he with crossing that divide.

6. Joe Manganiello - Cable

Inevitably, the Apocalypse storyline, and the hints that we will once again see multiple timelines both lead to the possibly wishful suggestion that Cable will appear. We already know that X-Force is at least tentatively slated to become part of Fox's wider X-Men movie universe, and Cable obviously plays a major part in that team, so at some point he's going to be introduced to the XCU. And the Apocalypse storyline would offer a classic approach to that question, as well as allowing for a slow-reveal that he is the child of Jean Grey and Cyclops. Cable could simply come back in time from the future to attempt to take Apocalypse out at a key juncture (in the '80s timeline), bringing some of the X-Force with him, including Blink, Warpath and Bishop perhaps. Manganiello has already been close to a key casting in comic book movies twice, and he's also an enduring suggestion to replace Hugh Jackman as Wolverine when he gives up the claws, but there's something even more intriguing in the image of him as a John Connor type, grizzled by future combat, playing alongside Jackman's Wolverine in a clash for alpha-male supremacy.

5. Emma Watson - Jean Grey

It is inevitable that Jean Grey will return to the new X-Men timeline at some point, given how important she is to the formative years of the X-Men, and Bryan Singer has already dropped hints that he will recast the key X-Men characters who haven't yet been redone by the new timeline started by First Class. If we're going to see a version of the Apocalypse story arc where Cable does appear and take on the Godlike mutant, inevitably we're going to have to see the lead up to why Cable is such a key to his demise. He is of course the genetically superior offspring of Grey and Cyclops, and as such both of his parents are going to need to appear - perhaps as the key to why Apocalypse chooses to go after the mutants in the 1980s. Perhaps we could see Apocalypse appear under the guise of raising mutantkind as the dominant species, only for the X-Men to discover that his real agenda is to wipe out the chances of Cyclops and Jean Grey conceiving Cable, and ensuring his future demise never happens. Watson might have taken a while to cut her teeth in the Harry Potter franchise, but her subsequent work has been a lot more impressive, and she has similar poise on screen to Famke Janssen, and importantly she is more than capable of showing the slightest hint of darker waters beneath the surface that would make Grey the complex character she needs to be.

4. Johnny Depp - Mr Sinister

Depp has long been attached by rumour as the fore-runner for the lead in Marvel's Doctor Strange for good reason. He has an ethereal air to him that translates well to supernaturally slanted characters, or at least exotic ones (hence Edward Scissorhands, Icabod Crane, Raoul Duke, Sweeney Todd and Jack Sparrow), and it remains a missed opportunity that he hasn't played more villainous roles. Fox should steal a march on Marvel by casting Depp for the key role of Mr Sinister - one of Apocalypse's four horsemen, who created Cable in the comics - and play the mad scientist element of the character in Apocalypse. He should be presented as a renegade, having left the Horsemen in order to destroy Apocalypse, and as the key to the creation of Cable using Cyclops and Jean Grey's genes, and thus top of Apocalypse's hit-list along with the young mutant pair. The resolution of that plot would then allow for a switch-turn that revealed Mr Sinister to be a villain to take him into the Gambit stand-alone movie, as well as being a presence in the X-Force universe, and having an actor of Depp's ability and profile would be a major bonus.

3. Lupita Nyong'o - Storm

Forget an Americanised version of the weather-wielding demi-Goddess, Bryan Singer needs to reimagine the character with a closer portrayal to the source, and frankly it couldn't hurt the X-Men team to have a little more global diversity in their ranks. Having just been added to the Star Wars cast, Nyong'o is hot stuff, and though she hasn't got a considerable number of films under her belt so far, her impact in 12 Years A Slave came thanks to a wonderful performance, and her ability is not under scrutiny. After Halle Berry's near-ruinous performance as Storm in the series so far, we need something different, and this casting would be a smart move that draws a line under that era of the franchise. And hopefully Singer will resist the urge to have Berry re-appear as one of the continued original cast members.

2. Logan Lerman - Cyclops

The X-Men under James McAvoy's Professor X are now missing a tactically minded leader on the ground. Yes, Nicholas Hoult's Beast is basically Xavier's right-hand man, but he is no leader, and the introduction of new members of the mutant team, including Gambit presumably in some way, will require a captain-like figure to emerge. We've already seen a Wolverine-lead X-Men arc, and perhaps it's time to cast a strong enough, likeable enough lead to make Cyclops as important in the films as he was in the comics. Lerman might not be X-Men fans' first choice, considering some of his past form, but he has proved himself a bankable enough lead in the Percy Jackson movies, and his more recent work has suggested he's capable of transcending genres. And if he is as good in Fury as we can only hope, he's likely to see an uplift in his profile that would cement the reasoning behind the casting.

1. Hafthor Julius Bjornsson - Apocalypse

We already know from the news of Josh Brolin's casting as Thanos that the actor will only lend his voice to the character, and that should perhaps be the approach that Fox take with casting the villain of the piece. It's unlikely we will see the same actor play the character as was presented in the post-credits scene in Days Of Future Past, and we really need a casting that reflects the villain's almighty power and the threat he poses to the X-Men, and to humanity. That means a physically powerful figure, and they don't come much larger or much more impressive than Hafthor Julius Bjornsson, the hulking actor who brought the latest version of The Mountain to life in Game Of Thrones. While he may not be the correct choice for the vocals - perhaps that should go to someone like the excellent Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje - Bjornsson would be a fantastic physical presence for the role, and Apocalypse would be a genuinely dominant force. Who do you think should be cast in X-Men: Apocalypse? Share your picks below in the comments thread.