X-Men: Dark Phoenix - 40 WTF Moments

The X-Men are back and they're dumber than ever!

By Simon Gallagher /

Fox

If they'd told you some years ago - when the new take on the iconic Dark Phoenix Saga was seeded in the newer X-Men timeline - that the end result of the extended, problematic production journey would have been the best X-Men movie ever, you wouldn't have believed them. There's a good reason for that, as well, because the film is actually not very good at all.

Advertisement

Mired in the fog of its controversial production, which has to include the decision to spoil a MAJOR story element in the trailers for no reason, Simon Kinberg's sequel was on a hiding to nowhere anywhere, given the Disney deal, but it could have made a better account of itself. Hell, if it had just tried to be a bit more fun, it could have scored better points.

As it is, the film is weirdly dull, oddly wrong-headed and terribly executed and it has one of the strangest scripts ever seen in an X-Men movie. And while nobody is expecting documentary realism here, there's fantastical and there's just plain... well, dumb. At least it generates a vast amount of moments that will provoke a good old WTF out of you, though.

Advertisement

It's a hell of a thing...

40. The Best Line Is Cut

Fox

All that time waiting and we didn't even get to see Charles Xavier deliver his weird "I don't know what to do!!!" line from the trailers. A thing of beauty lost forever.

Advertisement

39. "Werewolves Of London"

Asylum Records

If you're going to set a film in a certain time period, you really ought to be pretty savvy with your historical accuracy. And since Dark Phoenix chooses to be set in 1975 - partly in order to celebrate the start of Chris Claremont's revival of the comics - you'd expect any incidental details to be correct to that time period.

So that makes it extremely weird that the car crash sequence sees Jean Grey changing the car radio to a station playing "Werewolves Of London" by Warren Zevon, which was recorded in 1977 and released in 1978. Yet more time travelling in X-Men movies, then.

Advertisement

38. The Pen Analogy

Fox

When Jean meets Charles Xavier, he tries to give her a "with great power..." speech about a person's goodness relating to how they use their gifts. Nice moment, but you can't help but feel that it might have been more responsible to use an analogy that didn't involve suggesting that someone could jam a pen into someone's eye or use it to write nice letters.

Advertisement

Xavier has clearly got some issues he needs to work through.

37. 1992... Wait, How Old Are Magneto And Xavier?!

20th Century Fox

So, this time starts in 1975, where we see a young Charles Xavier with his luxurious Hugh Grant hair and weird habit of delivering every one of his lines weirdly and then we jump forward to 1992, where he's bald. Judging by the timeline established by First Class, this man - and Michael Fassbender's Magneto - is at least 60 years old.

Advertisement

And yet he looks at most about 40 because there has been absolutely no allowance given to making either of them look older than their actors are in real life.

36. Everyone Ignore The Scientist!

Fox

The opening mission to space hinges on the X-Men's ability to fly into space to rescue the stranded astronauts on the Endeavor. Right from the start, we're told it wouldn't work, because Hank McCoy keeps telling everyone that the X-Jet isn't built for space journeys. He says it several times and everyone ignores him.

Advertisement

With that warning, you'd think that the concerns might come back to haunt the team in some way, so it's a surprise that the X-Jet, which is not built to go to space, manages perfectly fine in space, despite the person who literally built it not for space warning that it won't work in space and everyone ignoring him as being over-cautious.

35. Hey, Cyclops: Shoot That Explosive Thing In Space

Fox

Having started from the position of piloting a non-space-worthy plane into space, it shouldn't be a surprise that the NASA mission isn't exactly the smartest mission of all time. But it's really something that the answer to stopping the shuttle from spinning out of control when there is literally a hugely powerful telekinetic mutant available is to simply shoot the engine.

Advertisement

Yes, it would put the engine out of order, but traditionally shooting something full of highly flammable fuel with a laser blast isn't the safest approach to anything. Particularly when you're trying to save the people inside the thing you're shooting.

34. Ice In Space?!

Fox

Explosions can happen in space, even though it's a fairly accepted thing that it's not possible, but do you know what there's not in space? Water. And weather.

Advertisement

So quite how Storm manages to freeze the holes in the side of the shuttle at the start of the mission to make it safer for Quicksilver and Nightcrawler to rescue the astronauts is anyone's guess. Clearly, you're just not supposed to ask.

33. A DUCT-TAPE SPACE SUIT?!

Fox

By this point in the mission, you shouldn't be questioning anything as impossible, because of the disregard for science, but it's still remarkable that to rescue the last stranded astronaut, Quicksilver literally constructs a spacesuit for Nightcrawler out of duct tape and a helmet.

Advertisement

Talk about your botch jobs. He would be dead. But just don't think about it, because duct tape is funny, isn't it? Right? RIGHT?

32. How Exactly Was The Commander Still Working?!

Fox

So, the whole issue of Jean being infected by the Phoenix Force relies on her having to go back to the shuttle because the commander was still stranded after the rest of the crew were saved. That happened because he'd been separated to go and try and fix the malfunctioning thruster engine that has put the shuttle into a dangerous spin so bad the X-Men can't even get near them.

Advertisement

Firstly, how the HELL did the commander, hero though he is, manage to get out of his seat and to the cargo hold to "fix" the engine while spinning at several Gs? And next up, how committed to his job is he that he CONTINUED fixing the engine - as seen when he's rescued - even after Cyclops shot the engine?! That guy is the real superhero.

31. Pause For Effect

Fox

Obviously, melodrama is useful sometimes, but when it literally turns one of your characters into a dangerous idiot, you've got to question it. For instance, when Nightcrawler goes out into space to bring Jean back to the safety of the X-Jet, why does he pause when he grabs her to have a look at her? SHE'S LITERALLY OUT IN SPACE, dude, get her back to safety!!

Advertisement

Also, how come Jean can breathe in space? Does the Phoenix Force make science not work?

30. "Marry Me"

Pixabay

Because this version of the X-Men are all rockstars, when they return from space having saved the astronauts, they're met by a crowd of fans cheering, brandishing action figures and holding signs as if they're at a wrestling show. Fair play, in particular, to the literal child holding up a sign asking one of the X-Men to marry him.

Advertisement

He's about 12 at most. Aim for the stars, kid.

29. The X-Women Line

Fox

There are some severe problems with the script, which is a major shame, but it's basically proof that it doesn't matter how much you love the characters you're writing, if you can't write good dialogue, you'll mess them up.

Advertisement

The worst example comes when Mystique challenges Charles Xavier on the use of the name "X-Men" when all of the female superheroes keep saving people. "Maybe you ought to rename us X-Women" she says and everyone cheers. Or at least, everyone cheers until they realise that she's talking nonsense.

The mission they were just on did see Jean stop the Phoenix Force from killing the X-Men, but Mystique had no idea this was the case. As far as she knows, Nightcrawler and Quicksilver saved the astronauts, then Jean and Nightcrawler TRIED to save the commander, but Jean ended up being "killed" and then Nightcrawler saved her. So really, Raven should have been asking why the X-Men weren't called The Nightcrawler-Men.

Advertisement

28. Literally Nobody Seems Bothered Why Jean Is Alive

Fox

No matter how pleased everyone would have been to see Jean Grey emerge unscathed from the whole Phoenix Force attack thing or how happy and great she insisted she felt, why are literally none of the X-Men concerned about WHY she survived? Yes, Xavier orders a medical, but even when Beast uncovered actual genetic issues that put her powers off the charts, he simply remarked that he needed a better machine.

Advertisement

Why did nobody think to wonder about the huge explosion that had rushed into her body? Why did nobody ask why she hadn't died in space with no spacesuit on? Are these people that self-absorbed?!

27. The Aliens

20th Century Fox

In the comics, the D'Bari are part plant, part humanoid creatures that can disguise themselves as humans and one of which, Vuk - the same character Jessica Chastain plays in fact - has a Ray Gun that turns people to stone. In the film, they're a totally nondescript race of aliens that look almost identical to the aliens in Signs who turn up on Earth with the intention of using the Phoenix Force to terraform the universe's inhabitable planets, but also to take over Earth as their own planet after theirs was destroyed.

Advertisement

Slightly mixed messages there, to be honest, but then you shouldn't be surprised since at no point is it explained why the aliens were already embedded on Earth and were able to hide in top level government and intelligence agency positions. They can't have just all accidentally bodysnatched people who handily had really useful jobs.

When the writers don't care to write about their own characters properly, it's really hard to be all that invested.

Advertisement

26. Underage Drinking Is Apparently Fine

Fox

When Jean and the gang get back to Earth, we're repeatedly told that she's fine and she actually feels great to the extent that she's able to go to the kids' party in the woods where they all let loose. There's even alcoholic punch, which she uses to get extremely drunk quickly (after it's revealed that Storm's only useful job in this entire film is making ice for people's drinks).

Advertisement

But like, aside for a few of the teachers, aren't all of these mutants children? Aren't they students at the School? If so, Xavier's policy on underage drinking is remarkably lax since he could probably sense them all getting drunk. And then it turns out that they're all being closely monitored - including heat signature technology for God only knows why - by Raven and Beast anyway, who were clearly also aware of the drinking. Irresponsible.

25. The X In X-Men Doesn't Stand For That, Raven

Fox

Giving herself a two for one record on saying things that make no sense, when Mystique tries to convince Beast to leave the X-Men and run away with her, she justifies it by saying that she suspects Xavier has lost focus on what they should really be doing. She also says he should realise what the X in X-Men stands for.

Advertisement

Only, it doesn't stand for Xavier. does it? They're called the X-Men in honour of the X-Gene or X-Factor that causes their mutations, which Xavier didn't give his name to either. In the comics, he even explains it (in The X-Men #1 from 1963):

"[Mutants] possess an extra power ... one which ordinary humans do not!! That is why I call my students ... X-Men, for EX-tra power!"

24. "Ignore My Flamey Veins, I'm Fine!"

Fox

It really shouldn't matter how many times Jean Grey insists she's fine, because as soon as she gets even mildly stressed, her veins start popping out of her skin like they're filled with molten lava. Apparently, despite getting close enough to kiss her, not even Cyclops seems to be bothered or even vaguely concerned by the fact that his girlfriend's blood has been visibly replaced by fire. It's only when she passes out that he seems to worry.

Advertisement

23. Xavier Loves The Fame

20th Century Fox

The character arcs in Dark Phoenix are all mostly fine - Jean struggles with her powers, Magneto is a pacificist looking to live in isolation with other like-minded mutants who is drawn back in by tragedy, Beast gets seriously pissed at the same tragedy... But Charles Xavier's arc is more problematic.

There is literally nothing in his past that suggests he would suddenly enjoy being the media darling and celebrity mutant and while he claims it's to help mutant integration, the whole point of his retirement is him accepting that he lost his way. So we're supposed to believe that this character who devoted his life to creating a haven for young, vulnerable mutants would retire having been turned on by too much fame? No.

Advertisement

22. Why Does Cerebro Have A Nose-Bleed Setting?

Fox

Go and look at your toaster. For some reason, it has a setting that will burn any piece of bread put within it to a pitch-black, inedible piece of charcoal. Why does your toaster have this? It's ludicrous.

Advertisement

It's also ludicrous that Cerebro - which Charles Xavier built - would have a setting that practically kills him. Seriously, why would it have a nosebleed setting built into it that he could wilfully turn it up to?!

21. Jean Is Left Entirely Unsupervised

Fox

After Jean collapses and Charles invades her mind to reveal that he set up defences in there to stop her killing everyone - a decision Mystique seems to think was inhumane, for some reason - we see some of the X-Men exploring her mind and then trying to calm her down when she gets angry at Xavier's invasion.

Advertisement

It's then revealed that she's alone in her bedroom, despite the fact that she literally just collapsed after a serious incident in space and then an unexplained seizure. Why isn't a teacher or, you know, HER BOYFRIEND, with her, keeping some sort of close eye on her?

20. There's No Way Jean Could Stop Quicksilver

Fox

Flash forward to the point after which Jean has discovered that her father rejected her and asked Charles Xavier to take her away for his own good, we see the X-Men confront Jean in Red Hook, where her powers manifest fully and the police arrive for no reason. Seriously, what exactly are they responding to when they scream around the corner and end up being smushed by Phoenix?

Advertisement

Anyway, this leads to Quicksilver doing his thing and getting a slow motion moment, only for it to be undermined when Jean merely moves a piece of wood he was about to stand on and sending him crashing to the floor dangerously. There is a major problem here, because there's no way Jean could have moved her hand that fast. Her mind, maybe, but there is no precedent anywhere to suggest she's suddenly capable of superspeed and it's never mentioned again. Why not just have her mind do it?

19. What Was The Point In Spoiling Mystique's Death?

Fox

When the trailers revealed Mystique was going to die, it seemed like it must have been done for some crucial reason, like to show that Jean was capable of even more terrible things, but then in the film it just happens as any comic book movie death would and the lasting feeling is that they threw away the film's only truly memorable moment in the bloody teasers.

Advertisement

18. How Can You Scream With No Lungs?

Fox

After Mystique is killed, Vuk and the D'Bari head to Red Hook to interview her father to try and find out where Jean has gone. He reacts to their CIA disguises (who even knows where they got the credentials from, it's never explored), by saying he would like a lawyer present, which inevitably triggers Vuk who says "it would have been a lot easier to interrogate you if you weren't screaming."

Advertisement

Nice line that, but then she collapses his chest with her magical chest-caving powers, which probably defeats the object of interrogating him since it would clearly kill him. And yet, even with his lungs completely caved in, he's able to scream. Because f*ck anatomical science as well as physics, right?

17. Genosha Is... Well, Rubbish Really

Fox

When we meet Magneto once more, he's living in peace with his mutant buddies in his hippy commune on an island. This is clearly the film version of Genosha, where Magneto and the Acolytes lives in the comics and talked about how superior they were to humans. It was a mutant paradise.

Advertisement

In the films, they basically live on a small holding made of rusty storage containers. Paradise, this very much is not.

16. Why Would Anyone Give Magneto Land?!

Fox

And the other major problem with Genosha is that Erik mentions that the land was given to him legally by the US government and he's free to live there unmolested by the army. That's the same US government that he tried to overthrow back in the 1970s after being bust out of his maximum secutiry black-site prison, then, is it? You know, before he went into hiding and then turned up again as one of the Four Horsemen of Apocalypse's crew and tried to help him destroy the Earth.

Advertisement

Look, Xavier might believe Magneto isn't an entirely bad guy, but from the government's perspective, he's a fugitive, a dangerous criminal assassin and possibly the anti-Christ. Why would they EVER give him land to potentially build a mutant army?!

15. "When It Happens, I Can't Stop It... Until I Can"

Fox

Jean heads to see Magneto because she wants to know how to stop killing people, having killed a grand total of one people. At least her morality isn't broken.

Advertisement

She tells him that she cannot hope to stop when the Phoenix takes over her and wants advice from him on how to not let herself go to the darkness. His answer doesn't help and she just gets angry and then... stops. When the army turn up, she just turns off her Phoenix rage, which makes the whole idea that she's incapable of doing exactly that a little redundant.

14. The Idiot Chopper Pilots... YEET!

Fox

Here's a hint for you - just in general - if you're ever in a helicopter that a supervillain with horrifying powers suddenly starts to try and destroy while you're sitting in it, maybe jump out of it? Don't just sit there watching as your would-be murderer tries to murder you while you're still a safe distance away from the ground.

Advertisement

In the end, it works out well, because Magneto saves the pilots and all of the other soldiers who stupidly climb back onto the helicopter while it's in danger because they're all idiots and then Magneto just yeets the vehicle over the horizon and all is well. Not the most subtle of films, this.

13. "Poochy Died On The Way Back To His Home Planet"

Fox

Every time Jean suddenly looks up and flies away with her arms straight by her side, it's impossible not to think of Poochy being edited out of his final Itchy & Scratchy episode. Once you see it, you'll never unsee it.

Advertisement

12. Just Leave That Helicopter There

Fox

So, Magneto has the power to do whatever he likes with metal, so you'd think he'd be able to clear up any mess made of metal that might be making his little island "paradise" dangerous. Like, say, a crashed helicopter left after the army tried to attack Jean Grey and ended up getting their asses handed to them.

Advertisement

That makes the fact that he simply leaves the crashed helicopter in the middle of his farmland until Beast appears in Genosha somewhat confusing. Sure, it could be there for continuity, but there's contuinity issues and there's common sense. He would move it with one wiggle of an eyebrow.

11. Jean Says She'll Show Magneto How To Kill, Then Doesn't

Fox

Eventually, Magneto is convinced by Beast to join the fight to take Jean down when he's told that she killed Mystique. They and what remains of the X-Men all head to New York on the trail of her and her new alien buddy, Vuk, and when they find her, sh*t seriously goes down.

Advertisement

The X-Men fight Magneto's team for a start, but then Magneto raises a subway train out of the ground to block the doorway so nobody can stop him killing Jean (he could have used literally ANYTHING other than a subway train but hey, it looked cool) and gets his chance of a one-to-one. He misjudges it badly and Jean subdues him, telling him she's going to show him how to really kill someone, crushing his head in his helmet.

But then she just stops after stabbing him with the fragments of his helmet (a set of injuries he literally forgets in the next scene) and throwing him out of the building. That's... that's not how you kill someone, Jean. You literally JUST said.

Advertisement

10. "Walk To Me"

Fox

Easily the most difficult thing to watch in this entire movie comes when Jean proves her powers to Charles Xavier by making him walk up the stairs to her, which is agonising not only for him but for us to watch.

Advertisement

It also makes no sense. If Jean is making him walk, why is he struggling and in pain? She can do basically anything with her mind and yet she's struggling to get his legs to walk in anything like a normal human way.

9. Jean Is Super Careful About Lying People Down

Fox

At several points in this movie, Jean makes people pass out. It's not clear how, but we're just supposed to accept that she has a sort of killswitch power that makes people go unconscious whenever she likes.

Advertisement

Weirdly though, every time she does it - even when it's people she sees as an imminent threat to her - she lays them down as carefully as a mother lying down their baby. It's really odd and jarring to see when we're supposed to think she's lost her mind to the Phoenix.

8. The Car That Turned Into A Train

Fox

In the problematic final sequence, which was extensively reshot to replace a space-set sequence with a major train-based action set-piece, we see the X-Men kidnapped by spooks and transported to a mutant prison. They're literally dragged by their necks unconscious using what looks like litter pickers, then slapped in power limiting collars and shackles and thrown into cars to be taken away.

Advertisement

That's right cars. Remember that when you watch it again, because the continuity editor and editing team seem to have forgotten it because the sequence transitions seamlessly from them being thrown into the cars to them being transported on a train. Without any logic at all explaining what's happening, it feels like the cars literally just transform into a train.

7. The Aliens Just Punch A Train

Fox

And speaking of that train, the sequence obviously escalates massively when Vuk sends her seemingly endless supply of alien minions in to try and retrieve Jean to steal the rest of the Phoenix Force power from her.

Advertisement

Judging by what we see of the plan, which starts with them jumping onto the train from the inside of a tunnel, the plan they're given is literally just to punch the train until something happens. If you look closely, that's exactly what the aliens are doing until the captors come to their senses and allow the X-Men out to fight.

6. The MCU?!

Fox

Let's hope this is a conscious gag, because otherwise it's just a massively weird coincidence. When the mutants are being transported to the unnamed mutant internment prison, the heavily-armed tactical team brought in to transport them have patches with MCU on their sleeves. Clearly, that's meant to be something like Mutant Containment Unit, but there's a complication that suggests this was deliberate.

Advertisement

In Deadpool 2, we meet the DMC - the same group that regulates mutants - who could very easily have just been used here as well. The X-Men cameo in Deadpool 2 establishes that this is the same universe, after all... So maybe it was a dig at the MCU being the enemy of these mutants...?

5. Nightcrawler's Rage-Out

Fox

At one point on the train, Nightcrawler is trying to save one of the MCU troops from one of the main D'Bari aliens and teleports him away to save him, only to discover that the alien got a killer blow in anyway. If you can see how this happened, your detective skills are incredible, because it doesn't look obvious (or even possible) at first.

Advertisement

More confusing is the fact that Nightcrawler reacts to this random man's death - who we've literally never met before - as if his best friend has just been killed and "hulks out" for want of a better Fox-friendly term. It's an emotional escalation that makes absolutely no sense.

4. This Film Really HATES Helicopters

Fox

Remember Suicide Squad? No, of course you don't, because nobody wants to relive that sort of pain more than a couple of times at most. Still, what you might remember about the film is that it really disliked helicopters. As soon as one was on screen for more than a few moments, David Ayer dreamed up some catastrophic way to make it crash, bringing the chopper death count up to higher than the main character death count.

Advertisement

Clearly, Simon Kinberg watched that film and agreed with the anti-helicopter agenda, because the same thing happens here. If there's a helicopter in frame, something bad is happening to it, has happened to it or is about to happen to it.

3. The Phoebe Run

Warner Bros.

The D'Bari aliens are not really much of anything, thanks to the way they've been presented in this movie. They're basically just henchmen mooks who are brought in as cannon fodder for the finale and it's a little hard to really care about them when their motivation is so basic.

Advertisement

They are pretty badass in terms of how easily they just shrug off bullets - and that John Wick-style scene where Magneto shoots Vuk with everything he's got is great - but it's all made deeply problematic by the fact that they all run like Phoebe in Friends.

2. Don't Call It Dusting, Don't Call It Dusting...

20th Century Fox

When it was revealed that Dark Phoenix had been extensively reshot in order to make it less like a recent superhero movie, it was pretty obvious that they meant Captain Marvel, because of the cosmic elements. Looking back now, knowing about the aliens disguised as humans, the super-powered badass female hero and the influence on her of a nefarious alien overlord, it's not surprising they changed it.

Advertisement

But what we didn't anticipate was that the end of the movie was going to basically just steal Thanos' "dusting" method of getting rid of enemies. How exactly did Fox look at their Captain Marvel-alike third act, decide it was a bad idea and then end up replacing it with something that absolutely everybody would say was just like Infinity War? You're either trying to avoid MCU comparisons or you're not.

1. The Cafe

Fox

At the end, we get a nice little moment where Magneto and Xavier - newly retired - meet up in France and have a nice game of chess for old times sake. You know, not the old times when Magneto was an absolute irredeemable sh*tbag, just the old times where they played chess.

Advertisement

It's a touching moment, but it would be even better if the cafe they sit outside wasn't literally called Cafe Old Friends as anyone with the slightest amount of French behind them will tell you. They even spell the French wrong. Good.

What else did you spot in Dark Phoenix? Share your finds below in the comments thread.

Advertisement