X-Men: Dark Phoenix - 8 Mistakes It Must Avoid

Or it'll go down in flames.

By Mark Langshaw /

The Dark Phoenix Saga is one of the most celebrated X-Men storylines of all time, so why was the news that the next movie is going to be based on it met with as much fan trepidation as celebration?

Advertisement

Well, they tried to adapt it for cinema once before, and the results weren't exactly supernova.

Brett Ratner's 2006 misfire The Last Stand, which drew influence from the Jean Grey-centric event, is considered the weakest entry in the mutant series, and its worst crime was watering down the seminal arc... and casting Vinnie Jones as Juggernaut.

Dark Phoenix puts mutant telepath Jean front and centre as she becomes consumed by a twisted cosmic power, a process which kicked off in X-Men: Apocalypse.

Sophie Turner's Jean Grey struggled with her abilities throughout the movie, and all hell was unleashed during the final battle when Jean took out the titular villain by channeling a giant flaming bird.

This was a hint of what she will be capable of in Dark Phoenix, except it won't be just the bad guys on the receiving end of it.

Here's 8 mistakes the movie must avoid;

8. Shifting The Focus From Jean Grey

X-Men: The Last Stand's biggest mistake with the Dark Phoenix saga was attempting to combine the story with another comic arc, and doing justice to neither.

Advertisement

Jean Grey and her inner struggle were relegated to subplots while the film followed Magneto and his army's war against humankind, elements plucked from Joss Whedon’s Astonishing X-Men story Gifted.

The Dark Phoenix saga is epic in scope and cosmic in scale, and therefore doesn't lend itself well to dilution.

This is a major pitfall the movie must avoid by sticking to the core premise of Jean and her inner turmoil as the malevolent Phoenix Force engulfs her mind, body and soul, turning her against her loved ones.

Her plight is the essence of the story, and the one thing that must not be lost during the page-to-screen transition.

7. A Direct Adaptation

It sounds controversial but Dark Phoenix should, under no circumstances, attempt to adapt its comic book counterpart page for page.

Advertisement

The original 1980s storyline from Chris Claremont and John Byrne is now dated, and wouldn't necessarily fit in with the X-Men film universe post-First Class reboot.

Although Claremont's work is celebrated for its grasp of the team dynamic, Phoenix Saga's dialogue is bogged down by exposition, a recurring theme in '80s comics, and Byrne's artwork isn't as expressive or varied as his later X-contributions.

In any case, a direct adaptation is almost impossible given that some of the characters involved in the source material are either non-existent or dead in the movie continuity.

For instance, Colossus has a key role in the Saga, but he's off on Deadpool duties in the movie universe. Wolverine also starred in the story, while Magneto did not.

Moreover, the comics feature a gang of space pirates called the Starjammers, who would be tricky to cram into the X-Men movie universe from a tonal standpoint.

So this is where Simon Kinberg will have to get creative, swapping certain X-Men around, handing more substantial roles to others and making some tough creative choices about what needs to be cut.

But these are some aspects of the Dark Phoenix Saga which must not go up in flames during this process - the underlying themes of corruption, guilt, friendship, love and loss, just for starters.

The cosmic scope of the source material should also be retained as sending the X-Men up into the cosmos to interact with the alien Shi’ar Empire - a key part of the source material - is too big an opportunity to turn down.

As already highlighted, keeping the focus on Jean Grey is paramount, but so too is her relationship with her significant other...

6. Glossing Over Jean's Relationship With Cyclops

Sophie Turner seems to grow into an increasingly capable actress with every season of Game of Thrones, but it's fair to say she didn't exactly set the screen alight in X-Men: Apocalypse... not in that sense anyway.

Advertisement

Utilising her more effectively is vitally important to Dark Phoenix's success, but the movie must also get more out of her love interest, Tye Sheridan's Cyclops.

Their teenage romance was only just beginning in Apocalypse and most fans would be hard pressed to recall many of the scenes they shared, but it must play out with more depth and pathos in the next sequel.

Their relationship is the heart and soul of the story, and the audience needs to be rooting for them as a couple by the time Jean is lost to the Phoenix Force or the film won't pack the necessary emotional punch.

Fans felt like they had been stabbed in the heart when Wolverine met his maker in the excellent Logan, and Dark Phoenix has to stir up the same emotions for Jean.

5. Overstuffing The Roster

There's always the temptation to pack these movies with characters to ensure they're suitably epic, but Dark Phoenix needs to strike a delicate balance.

Advertisement

Sophie Turner and Tye Sheridan will be joined by series mainstays James McAvoy (Professor X), Jennifer Lawrence (Mystique) Michael Fassbender (Magneto) and Nicholas Hoult (Beast), and then there are the other returning Apocalypse actors.

There's also the fan-favourite Evan Peters as Quicksilver, while Olivia Munn is reportedly reprising her role as Psylocke.

Add newcomers to the equation - such as Jessica Chastain's Queen Lilandra (rumoured) and Scott Shepherd as Jean's father, Dr. John Grey - and the Dark Phoenix roster is beginning to rival Marvel's Infinity War.

The cast is growing by the day, and Simon Kinberg has to stop it spiraling out of control, because Jean and Cyclops's story will need all the screen time he can give it.

4. Overhaul The Team Again

There's been a lot of chopping and changing among the X-Men's ranks since First Class, so it's time for some consistency.

Advertisement

For all of its flaws, Apocalypse ended with a great shot of the latest lineup about to undergo a spot of training in the Danger Room.

It was a solid unit comprising Cyclops, Jean Grey, Nightcrawler, Storm and Quicksilver, under the tutelage of Beast and Mystique as well as Professor X.

Aside from the odd newcomer - the pop star mutant Dazzler will be featured, for one - this lineup should be remain united, right up to the point when Jean succumbs to the malevolent Phoenix Force.

What we had at the end of Apocalypse felt like a well-balanced team of iconic X-Men, so the movie should cling onto that consistency.

3. Fail To Tell The Phoenix Force's Origin Story

This was another of The Last Stand's cardinal sins.

Advertisement

The Phoenix Force is one of the most awesome powers in the Marvel Universe, with enough ka-pow to shatter worlds and reduce civilisations to dust.

It has an entire mythology behind it which is ripe for fleshing out on screen, but The Last Stand took the reductionist approach and repackaged it as the repressed part of Jean Grey's psyche, bursting to the surface.

Dark Phoenix cannot afford to make this mistake. It must delve into the origin of the Phoenix to set the stakes, establishing it as the most dangerous entity in the universe.

Sticking closer to the comic book source material will help Simon Kinberg swerve this particualr pitfall.

2. Bringing Back Emma Frost

The Hellfire Club, introduced to the X-Men movie universe in First Class, plays a major role in the Saga as the Earth-based catalyst for Jean Grey's transformation.

Advertisement

Emma Frost, in particular, has a hand in breaking Jean's mind, but bringing back January Jones's scantily-clad version of the mutant would be a huge misstep.

Although she was killed off screen during the events of Days of Future Past, the soft reboot this film ushered in means Simon Kinberg could recall her if he chooses.

Except he should avoid doing that because Jones was horrible for the part, looking dead-eyed and disinterested throughout First Class' duration.

This is where the director will have to get creative with the characters he does have at his disposal. Case in point, Psylocke is blessed with similar powers and could deputise for Frost if the Hell Fire Club is deemed essential to the adaptation.

1. Pull Punches With The Ending

If you're keen to avoid spoilers from a comic book series that's more than three decades old, shield your eyes now.

Advertisement

The Dark Phoenix Saga reaches its gun-wrenching conclusion with Jean Grey sacrificing herself, choosing to die as a human rather than live as a dark, planet-devouring goddess. A sound choice.

It was an emotional gut-punch from Marvel and writer Chris Claremont, although they later cheapened it by retconning the whole thing.

One twist and a whole other story arc later and Jean was alive in suspended animation - the Phoenix, apparently, mimicked her likeness and took her place.

So what can the movie learn from this? For one, don't pull any punches when it comes to the ending - teasing that Jean is still alive in a post-credits sequence would only undermine her sacrifice.

Her demise needs to deliver an emotional sting and leave the audience feeling like they've witnessed a tragedy of Greek proportions, but it won't do either if her survival is revealed to set up a future sequel.

Advertisement