X-Men: Dark Phoenix Trailer 2 Reactions - 4 Ups And 7 Downs

It's time to say goodbye with the last main X-Men movie under Fox...

By Simon Gallagher /

Fox

Perhaps it would have been better calling X-Men: Dark Phoenix something like X-Men: Spoiler Alert, because thanks to the second trailer that has just landed, there's absolutely no way anyone is going to be able to avoid the big story reveal in the marketing. 

Advertisement

With Fox's hold on Marvel's mutants ending this year (assuming there isn't some major twist in the tale of the Disney/Fox deal, of course), we're at the very tail-end of the First Class timeline and it's going to end with a bang. Or a solar flare and some major casualties, to be more precise.

So far, the marketing for the film has been somewhat overshadowed by the fact that Fox seemed to be lacking confidence in their own movie, but now that the second teaser is out, we're on the long, slippery slope towards its release in June and there's now no turning back.

Advertisement

So, how does the trailer work? This being Dark Phoenix, there are inevitably some major concerns reverberating around the Internet right now on the back of this, but there are actually also some positives to take away. So don't lose the will to live just yet.

Advertisement

First the negatives...

Downs

7. Straight Out The Door With A Spoiler There

Fox

So, they're just going to give away the fact that she dies then? Just like that? Wham, bam, thank you, Maam?!

Advertisement

Maybe it IS a genius marketing ploy to include the film's biggest spoiler in the second trailer for it? Maybe this is Simon Kinberg's ploy to sell how much of a threat Phoenix really is and to show this is an X-Men movie like no other? Or maybe it's a mistake on the same level as Terminator Genisys' revelation that John Connor was a Terminator in the trailer. 

Given the production so far, it's hard not to suspect this might be a last throw of the dice to make people care. After all, we don't know HOW she'll die and it might be worth the ticket price to watch. If it makes people who weren't going to see it watch it now, then it's a good move, but it still comes at some cost to the magic of storytelling.

Advertisement

6. Mystique's Look

Fox

Jennifer Lawrence might have been put through hell to prepare for shooting as Mystique - enduring hours of make-up for a role she allegedly wasn't all that keen on returning to for the sequels - but her new "improved" look is not great. 

Advertisement

She already looked a little... silly (look, she's a blue shape-shifting mutant, nobody is claiming she's going to look normal) and her design has always been the most jarring thing about these movies. Even the more cuddly Beast (who looks like a grumpy cat a lot of the time) stands head and fuzzy shoulders above her.

This trailer is just another reminder that she doesn't look good at all. Maybe it's the dime store wig-looking red hair.

Advertisement

5. Some Of The Line Delivery Is Terrible

Fox

Fundamentally, some of the lines of dialogue in this trailer aren't very good. And all writing critiques aside, it comes down to performance, rather worryingly.

Advertisement

The one line Storm gets in there isn't entirely good evidence that Alexandra Shipp's performance is going to be much better than any of Halle Berry's and Sophie Turner has some iffy delivery (particularly with "I'm scared... when I lose control, bad things happen to people I love". 

But by far the worst offender comes when Cyclops asks how to fix the jean situation and James McAvoy says "I don't know what to do!" in a manner that wouldn't be out of place coming out of Alan Partridge's mouth. 

Advertisement

Seriously, what is going on here...?!

Advertisement

4. The Repetition (Again)

Fox

Putting aside the parallels with The Last Stand for now (it's coming, don't you worry), it's rather unfortunate that we appear to be getting some narrative threads from recent X-Men movies played out again. Almost like this is a greatest hits style movie.

Advertisement

We're going to see Magneto playing the villain again and then presumably swapping his affiliation when Phoenix's threat establishes properly; we're going to see conflict between the mutants on the best way to deal with Jean; we're going to see humans putting power dampening collars on mutants and we're going to see Xavier seemingly losing control of the situation. These are all things we've already seen very recently.

If there's not enough narrative innovation in there, it's going to look like this is no more than an exercise in treading water. And for so many of the beats to be appearing in the trailers, that's a very real concern.

Advertisement

3. Professor Beast

Fox

Back around the time when Tom Hardy was making The Dark Knight Rises, he also starred in Lawless as a bootlegging tough. Even playing a hard man character, the fact that he was carrying the huge weight gain he'd achieved for Bane made him a frankly ridiculous spectacle. Particularly as he was wearing a cardigan most of the time to hide it.

Advertisement

Thanks to James McAvoy's filming schedule, he's suffered a similar aesthetic problem for Professor X. Filming for M Night Shyamalan's Glass had already kicked off before Dark Phoenix was done, and given that he had to play The Beast - a hulking fella whose size was supposed to be shocking compared to McAvoy's usual look - he had no choice but to bulk.

The result is the image of a Professor X who has been confined to a wheelchair for some time now but who is clearly an absolute gym monster. Look at his rippling pecs! It's very, very unfortunate and immediately pulls you out of the immersive factor.

Advertisement

2. Sophie Turner's Performance

Fox

For a lot of fans - Game of Thrones ones, in particular - Dark Phoenix represents an opportunity to see whether Sophie Turned has it in her to graduate from that show to leading roles in movies. On the evidence so far here, it's unclear.

Advertisement

As was brought up with X-Men: Apocalypse, the new cast members brought in as the next generation of X-Men lack the presence and chemistry of the so-called old guard. Even in this trailer, the likes of Nicholas Hoult, Michael Fassbender and James McAvoy already seem to be on a slightly higher level. 

It's a real shame, because it looks like Turner might be struggling to carry a role this important and a movie this big. Some of her lines in the trailer are stunted and aside from that opening sequence of her crying in the rain, she's a little clipped on her emotions too. It's not a strong case.

Advertisement

1. It Looks WAY Too Much Like The Last Stand

20th Century Fox

If you're going to try and remake the worst movie in your franchise, it's best you make it very clear how different your new version is going to be. Any suggestion that you're just doing the same thing again is an invitation to be accused of insanity (what with that Einstein quote and everything). 

Advertisement

So it's rather unfortunate that this looks like a little bit too much like a beat-for-beat remake, albeit with the added element of Jessica Chastain's mysterious alien (who now looks like Jean Grey's imaginary friend, in all honesty). Both Professor X and Magneto seem to have the same storylines and they've replaced Wolverine with Cyclops, which is something of a trade-down.

But hey, if they keep the Vinnie Jones cameos down to a minimum, we can probably all agree it won't be recapturing the worst of that movie.

Advertisement

Now the positives...

Ups

4. It's Better Than The First Trailer

Fox

The big issue with the first trailer for Dark Phoenix was that it was boring. Even with such an important storyline behind it, it failed to capture anything like the right levels of excitement, drama, or emotion. It was dull, it was flat and it was undoubtedly a misstep.

Advertisement

It seems that the lukewarm (and worse) reaction to that trailer may have been taken into account, at least, though, because this is a major improvement. It starts with emotion (okay, it might be too big a spoiler to get there, but it's right to aim to capture something the first teaser missed), there's a lot more action and there's at least some attempt to let the performances shine.

if we're taking this as pass/fail based solely on what came before, then it's definitely an upturn.

Advertisement

3. There's Another Quicksilver Sequence

Fox

The benefit of Dark Phoenix being a bit of a greatest hits set-up is that we're actually going to get some welcome returns. Fassbender being a villain is a great thing, for instance, but even better, we're going to get another of the impressive slow motion Quicksilver sequences that have been the most inventive parts of the previous X-Men movies.

Advertisement

Obviously, it's going to be important to make sure that this isn't just another repeat of what's come before, even though those past sequences were incredible. Every time you do something the same, you get diminished returns, so Fox have hopefully made sure that something is different or even more impressive.

There's actually a hint that this sequence might not actually go as the others have, with Jean interrupting Quicksilver's attack on her to show how infinitely powerful she is. That alone should mark this set-piece out as different enough.

Advertisement

2. The Action And Effects Do Look Great

Fox

When Dark Phoenix was delayed, it presented Fox with an opportunity. Despite all of the hand-wringing and cycnicism that it meant that the flm simply wasn't good enough, Simon Kinberg told EW that it was actually to allow for an improvement in the effects. And even if the writing and characterisation isn't up to much, Dark Phoenix could claw some ground back with some properly good action sequences.

Advertisement

So far, it looks like they might have achieved that. The effects look atypically good for a comic book movie teaser (even the MCU movies struggle in that respect a lot of the time) and there are some hints at some pretty impressive set-pieces too, including the train sequence that closes out the trailer.

Putting aside the very obvious trainwreck jokes, watching Jean really spread her wings and show the full spectrum of her powers in displays like that is going to be a riot. And mercifully that might prove to be a bit of a saving grace for the movie.

Advertisement

1. The Civil War Vibe

Fox

As Kinberg told EW in the interview that is designed as a companion to this trailer release (thank him for the Mystique confirmation, because he says it in there), Dark Phoenix is going to pit the X-Men against each other.

Advertisement

Essentially, we're going to get a replay of Civil War, only with the warring factions deciding on how best to deal with Jean as this story's stand-in for The Winter Soldier. In both cases, characters will be drawn to their sides of the argument based on emotion - Cyclops to Jean out of love, Beast against her in mourning for what she does to Mystique. 

it might be a little cynical of them to be trying to remind us of a film that came out so recently, but Civil War was absolutely brilliant and there's nothing like the thrill of watching heroes fighting each other is something that has endured through both comics AND comic book movies. We love it for a reason and it at least adds a new element to this story.

Advertisement

What did you think of this trailer? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.