10/10 Video Games Everyone Immediately Forgot About

Remember Deathloop?

By Josh Brown /

There are too many video games. There, somebody finally said it.

Advertisement

As fans, we have so much to keep up with year on year, and with the big releases today demanding up to 100 hours of our time, it makes sense that players are picky about which ones they dedicate their time to.

Consequently, while they might not hold the same cultural cache they once did, reviews are still used as valuable resources to point players towards games that they simply can't miss. Elden Ring was always going to be a big hit, but would it have sold 12 million copies in a couple of weeks and brought in a whole new audience which had never touched a Dark Souls game before without reviews lavishing it with praise, 10/10 scores, and Game of the Year accolades? Probably not.

However, sometimes a title comes out, gets an insane amount of praise from media outlets and fans alike and then immediately falls out the conversation. Let's call it the Avatar effect - a movie that immediately became the most successful of all time, but one which most people never watched or thought about again (until the recent sequel anyway).

These are the games - just or otherwise - that suffered the same fate.

10. Dark Souls 2

What makes Dark Souls 2 such an anomaly is that it's actually the highest-rated game in the franchise. I'm not making that up. It scores two points higher than both the iconic and beloved original, as well as the fan-favourite third game. Yet ask fans of this series and they'll no doubt tell you it's the worst, or that they haven't played it at all.

Advertisement

Those same fans were quick to forget this sequel, in part because of controversial changes to mechanics and systems it made to the original game's formula. An altered healing system, a drastic change in approach to the level design and enemy variety were all deemed a step back by some fans who wanted a sequel closer to the sensibilities of the first Dark Souls.

The third game would provide that more iterative continuation, forgetting developments made in the second title. Hell, even the story of that trilogy-capper was mostly unconcerned with addressing any of the narrative threads established in the second game.

Still, while many players were content to forget Dark Souls 2 ever happened, it's a shame it's not recognised as a must-play today. Sure, its elevated critical praise stinks of reviewers making good for missing the original, but it's still a worthy instalment in the series, and a daring sequel in many respects.

9. Virtua Fighter 4 & 5

When you think of the very best fighting games these days, your mind probably goes to Street Fighter, Mortal Kombat or Tekken, and while those franchises have always dominated sales, other more critically acclaimed titles have fallen by the wayside.

Advertisement

For instance, did you know that the original Soul Calibur is still one of the highest rated games of all time? Sitting at a 98 MetaCritic score it, alongside the first few games, were deemed masterpieces. But today, you'd be hard pressed to find anyone under the age of 25 who's played or even knows about it.

The same goes for Virtua Fighter. One of the longest running fighting franchises in the business, the fourth and fifth games in particular gained insanely strong reviews (94 and 85 respectively) yet were completely overshadowed by their contemporaries.

Despite being the franchise of choice for many a hardcore fighting game fanatic, to the general public, these well regarded games are nothing more than box art they remember while perusing stores decades ago.

8. Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus

Most people today remember Wolfenstein 2 as a pretty good game. It was a solid shooter that promised more than it could deliver, bolstered by a colourful story and some truly insane plot twists. It might surprise you to realise just how highly Bethesda's follow-up was rated at the time though, sitting at an incredible 88 on MetaCritic.

Advertisement

And yet, despite those aforementioned plot twists that still get talked about today, nobody really remembers it as a game. The set-pieces, the moment-to-moment shooting, interplay between stealth and action - it all kind of fell by the wayside. The score points towards this being one of the best shooters of the entire generation, but players online are more likely to sing the praises of its predecessor, or iD Software's 2016 Doom reboot.

Maybe it was too iterative or maybe Doom itself completely overshadowed it in terms of its mechanical fluidity and impact, but either way, this great game has been forgotten when discussing the best of the best of last gen's FPS library.

7. The Chronicles Of Riddick: Escape From Butcher Bay

Back in an era where most movie-licensed games were poison, The Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher Bay was a rare tonic. Rather than just a bland cash-in, the team wanted to get this adaptation right, no doubt bolstered that the star of the Riddick movies, Vin Diesel, was an avid gamer himself.

Advertisement

The Xbox exclusive scored a surprisingly high 89 on MetaCritic, with praise going to its atmospheric presentation, visceral first-person combat and stealth, and intricate level design. Sadly, that praise didn't translate to sales (the tepid reception of the movie didn't help much either), and most players ended up sleeping on the game.

Confident in its quality, a remake/sequel was produced, The Chronicles of Riddick: Assault on Dark Athena for the Xbox 360. Despite being loved by some outlets, it overall scored lower than its predecessor and once again was instantly forgotten by players, killing the franchise dead.

6. Rayman Legends

Ubisoft is no stranger to mishandling amazing franchises. The likes of Ghost Recon, Splinter Cell, Prince of Persia and more have been languishing for years now, either sitting out entire generations or being transformed into mainstream-pleasing shells of their former selves.

Advertisement

Why this treatment particularly stings when it comes to Rayman, though, is that the series was on a roll when it was unceremoniously dropped. Rayman Origins and Rayman Legends are some of the highest-rated Ubisoft games ever produced, and completely revolutionised a flagging franchise with creative ideas, tight platforming mechanics and a renewed sense of passion.

Because it wasn't an open world, box-ticking bloatfest though, the publisher was all too content to sweep the titles under the carpet and try to shift players' focus elsewhere. Consequently, in 2023, it's tough to remember that Ubisoft ever made games like this, let alone allowed one of their most beloved franchises to do something so different to their usual formula.

5. Splinter Cell: Double Agent

Generally, Splinter: Cell Double Agent didn't have much of a shelf-life. The follow up to the classic Chaos Theory attempted to provide a slight reinvention for the franchise, bolstered by the move to the then futuristic hardware of the Xbox 360. It reviewed extremely well, but the higher rated Xbox and PS2 versions were instantly forgotten.

Advertisement

Why? Well, because they were radically different to the fancier next-gen version that received most of the attention, and the biggest marketing push from Ubisoft. We take it for granted now that big games are going to receive cross-gen releases at the start of a new generation, but back in the era of Double Agent, you often just got two different versions of a game, made by two completely different studios.

And despite the fact that the original Xbox version of Double Agent provided a more polished and robust stealth experience that resonated with fans and critics, it was seen as the inferior product when compared to its next-gen counterpart, and overlooked by fans as a result. Hell, it wasn't even canon, meaning Ubisoft themselves were eager to forget it as they moved to the next game in the series.

4. Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker

Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker is one of the most important games in the entire franchise. The key narrative and gameplay bridge between Metal Gear Solid 3 and the final game in the series, The Phantom Pain, it's an absolutely essential instalment, directed by Hideo Kojima.

Advertisement

And yet there's a reason why this critically beloved game was forgotten about until fans had to play catch up in order to understand what the hell was going on in MGS V: it released exclusively for the PSP.

While it later did get a HD remaster for consoles, it initially was unclear just how important a game this was. Well, most of the mechanics you loved from MGS V are present here (albeit in a more rudimentary form), while it moved the story of Big Boss on leaps and bounds from the climax of MGS 3.

But again... it was on the PSP. While every other main instalment was talked about for years after its release, even today Peace Walker isn't appreciated or fully respected when it comes to ranking the entire franchise.

3. Max Payne 3

Rockstar is one of those companies that causes a cultural shift every time it releases a game. The GTA titles, Red Dead, Bully - we talk about them to death, picking apart their differences and recalling fond memories of being absorbed by each one.

Advertisement

And yet, one of Rockstar's best games, Max Payne 3, failed to receive this kind of longevity. A departure from the studio's open-world fare, this release instead offered fans a dark, narrative-driven, linear third-person shooter experience that stayed true to the company's attention to detail and polish. Despite being more straightforward, it seemed like another sure-fire hit; strong critical reviews helped, as did Rockstar's own reputation following the release of LA Noire and Red Dead Redemption.

Max Payne 3 was a rare commercial disappointment for company though, and stands as one of the few titles they've developed that isn't discussed as an all-time great.

It should be, but the mammoth success of GTA V just over a year after Max's third outing hit shelves meant that nobody was pining for a return to this series, and tragically we've not received a follow up since.

2. Tomb Raider

Tomb Raider deserved better.

Advertisement

The reboot trilogy - which kicked off with 2013's incredible inaugural release - received solid reviews across the board, with the first two instalments in particular being marked as some of the best action-adventure games of their time.

So what ensured that, despite their warm reception, they'd be left behind by players and ultimately leave the iconic franchise in a state of unpopularity? Well, a couple of things.

The doomed exclusivity deal with Microsoft for the second game, Rise of the Tomb Raider, certainly didn't help, minimising the potential audience and stalling momentum. The huge success of Uncharted also has to be a factor, serving as a more popular franchise which many viewed as being capable of doing everything Tomb Raider could do, only better.

The Tomb Raider trilogy should have been a smash-hit - the biggest names of the last generation. Instead, all three games are doomed to forever be overlooked.

1. Deathloop

Everyone thought they knew exactly what Deathloop was going to be before it came out. Arkane's prior releases were cult favourites, getting solid reviews but not setting the world on fire. So, players assumed this title, with its strange time-loop formula and asymmetrical multiplayer, would follow suit.

Advertisement

That wasn't the case, and Deathloop instantly became one of the strongest releases of the year, nabbing multiple 10/10 scores which intrigued casual fans who previously wouldn't have looked twice.

Unfortunately, players didn't have the same response as the critics. While it was still broadly well received and loved by some, the general consensus was that Arkane's other games - including Dishonored and Prey - were just as good, if not better.

Despite being such a critical hit, Deathloop went on to become a commercial disappointment. It fell out of the conversation rather quickly, and over a year later is not discussed anywhere near as much as other 10/10 darlings.

Advertisement