10 "Next Big Thing" Video Games Nobody Is Playing

Does anyone care about Fallout 76 at this point?

By Stacey Henley /

Bethesda

Plenty of video games claim the be the ‘next big thing’. Unfortunately for them, most of the time, they aren’t. Whether the developers actually believe they could be the next big thing or are just trying to ramp up sales varies from game to game, but the truth is very few actually break through.

Advertisement

This list deals with games, past and present, which just did not get the players or the traction to really go anywhere. Many games claimed to be ‘Halo killers’ for example, but it took Call Of Duty to really shift the playing field of first person shooters.

That doesn’t mean every failed Halo killer will make the cut here though. Some games have fairly solid player bases, they just don’t make a big enough splash and end up fading away. Instead, this list is reserved for games which had way fewer players pick them up than expected. In some cases, embarrassingly few.

Advertisement

As for what ‘no one’ means, that’s relative. In some cases, the playerbase is as low as double figures. Others may have what other games would have called successful, but were way below expectations and deserve zero hyperbole.

10. Battleborn

2K Games

Things could have been oh so different for Battleborn. The success of both PUBG and Fortnite proves two fresh IPs can compete in the same genre if they’re different enough, but Battleborn was simply crushed under the weight of Overwatch.

Advertisement

In fairness, Blizzard’s hero shooter still stands as one of this decade’s best games. It’s tough competition. Battleborn even had some features Overwatch lacked, like the skill tree Overwatch 2 is set to adapt. It lacked the pick up and play feel of Tracer’s gang though; Battleborn was good once it got going, but had a much steeper learning curve.

A hero shooter’s charm is its heroes. By Battleborn requiring a few rounds to get used to someone, the appeal of switching to find a character which suited was massively diminished.

Advertisement

Within two months of its release, Overwatch came out and its regular player base dropped to under 1000. This month, sales for the game officially stopped, with the online marketplace closing in February, ready for servers to be permanently shut down in January 2021.

It’s tempting to say ‘get it while you still can!’ but, just don’t.

Advertisement

9. Okami

Capcom

Okami is a truly gorgeous game, and one which holds an unfortunate world record: it has the lowest sales of any game ever to win a major Game Of The Year award.

Advertisement

These sales figures? Around 200,000 in the first year, meaning it was outside the top 100 selling games in its year of release, 2006. For reference, 2018’s major Game Of The Year winners God Of War and Red Dead Redemption sold 10 million and 17 million in the same length of time.

Admittedly, modern games sell more, but even in 2006, Oblivion won Game Of The Year at the same time as Okami, and sold 3.5 million.

Advertisement

Okami has been rereleased time and again on different consoles, and the figures finally look a bit healthier. Originally out for PS2 & Wii, it’s been ported to the PS3, PS4, Xbox One, PC and Nintendo Switch, bringing its lifetime sales up to 2.8 million.

That’s far more respectable, but Okami’s cel shaded mix of action adventure meets Zelda through the eyes of a wolf was supposed to be a game changer. Now, it’s just a curious footnote in history.

Advertisement

8. Pokémon GO

Niantic

Remember the glorious summer of love in 2016? Everyone played Pokemon Go and nothing else mattered. Age, gender, religion, skin colour, political allegiances... they were all transcended by Pikachu.

Advertisement

It’s a shame that Pokemon Go is on this list, but the numbers don’t lie. The bubble of friendship was always going to burst, but the real shame is that Niantic waited until everyone had jumped ship before they implemented the new features.

Improved nearby radars, adventure sync, raid battles, raid hours, shiny legendaries, special research, special tasks, community days, Team Rocket, trading, TMs... they’ve all improved the game massively for those who stuck around. We’re up to Gen V now too, with some Galarian forms from Gen VIII added too.

Advertisement

In truth though, it was such an ‘of the moment’ game that it was destined to have a massive drop off. What’s more surprising is that the only game to capitalise on it since is Harry Potter, made by the same developers (although less commercially successfully).

Pokemon Go currently averages about 5 million daily players, which seems to really be stretching ‘no one’. However, at its peak the official daily play figures exceeded 50 million, which done suggesting that players in countries the game hadn’t officially released (including China and all of Africa) could kick it up to 100 million.

Advertisement

If that’s true, that makes for a huge 95% drop off rate.

7. For Honor

Ubisoft

PvP online is less the ‘next big thing’ than it is a consistent staple of gaming since it moved to the internet. However, For Honor’s inventive style did pose itself as a real game changer. For a brief sliver of time, it looked like it might be too.

Advertisement

It allowed you to play as either a Knight, a Samurai or a Viking, each of which came with different fighting styles and varied approached. It forced you into close combat, but gave you a surprising amount of freedom and tactical depth.

But what’s the best way to ruin a game all about lightning quick decision making? Host it on the cheapest peer to peer servers you can find.

Advertisement

The game lagged, players dropped out unexpectedly, rage quits were abound and the connection was generally shoddy. After enjoying decent opening sales of just under 1 million, it lost a whopping 95% of its player base in just three months. Staggering mismanagement of a potentially great online game.

6. Project Spark

Microsoft

Poor Project Spark. The success of Super Mario Maker and to a greater extent, the unmascotted Dreams, proves that it really could have been the next big thing.

Advertisement

Project Spark was a design game exclusive to the Xbox One, which released in 2014 and was killed off two years later. The funeral was sparsely attended and poorly catered.

It was supposed to dig deeper than LittleBigPlanet or Minecraft, letting creation truly run wild. The Kinect could be used for it too, and the general idea was to either build a world from scratch or customise a pre-designed one.

Advertisement

The problem was it was far too fiddly and the actual gameplay of created levels felt like a rush job. There were simply too many barriers to it, and the lasting creation is Linkin Park’s Guilty All The Same video, which was made through the engine.

What remains the worst thing about it though was how it bastardised and sanitised Conker into a squeaky clean mascot to help promote it. Not only did it completely fail, it added even more insult to the once great Conker.

Advertisement

5. The Order 1886

Ready At Dawn

The Order: 1886, or as it’s better known, Quicktime: The Game.

Advertisement

It’s easy to point to 2018 as proof of PlayStation’s utter dominance of exclusives this generation, especially when backed up by Horizon: Zero Dawn and Uncharted 4 in the two years previously. Back at the start of this gen though, PlayStation’s exclusives were appalling.

Xbox’s Ryse wasn’t much better, and they had Forza doing all the heavy lifting until Cuphead came along, but this list isn’t about them. No need to start a console war; both of the big hitters got off to a bad start.

Advertisement

Of those though, The Order: 1886 was arguably the one with the biggest bluster behind it. Its claims of reinventing the Soulsborne style genre turned out to mean adding long loading times and lots of quicktime events. It would take until Nioh and Sekiro for The Order’s promise to be fulfilled... just not by them.

A solid outing, but not one which lived long in the memory. A popcorn flick of a game.

Advertisement

4. Fallout 76

Bethesda

Is it cheating, putting Fallout 76 here? Just an excuse to kick it while it’s down? Honestly... maybe. The uncomfortable truth for Fallout fans though is that Fallout 4 could easily have made the list instead.

Advertisement

Starting with Fallout 76 though, the scandals are too many to list here. In fact, they once had a list entirely of their own, one which predates arguably the biggest scandal of the premium passes. It tried to bill itself as the next big thing, a more focussed RPG in the MMO mould, one set to unite two of the biggest genres in gaming.

Right from the start though, very few expected it to do so. Sales were so poor some stores were giving away physical copies with console bundles that already contained the digital copy. Even those who did pick it up abandoned it almost immediately.

Advertisement

Fallout 4 meanwhile enjoyed Bethesda’s most successful launch ever, and peaked at almost half a million concurrent players on Steam in November 2015. A year later, that figure dropped to 60,000. Not bad, but not great. After such a huge launch, Bethesda will surely be annoyed that they couldn’t kick on.

3. Evolve

Turtle Rock Studios

While not an entirely new idea as an asymmetrical PvP, Evolve did have some new ideas. In a five player match, four would play as the hunters, and one as the monster. It was an idea designed to offer a different gameplay experience, not too dissimilar from the cancelled Fable: Legends game.

Advertisement

The gameplay itself however was clunky and uninspired. A launch DLC which cost an eye watering $136 would have been pricey in any game, but to shove it in Evolve just felt insulting.

Within a month, players struggled to even find matches, so Evolve (a full release title with a triple A price point) went free to play after just over a year. That naturally saw a massive boost of 3600% to the online player base, but they didn’t stick around.

Advertisement

The game was put down shortly after, delivering a bark much worse than its incredibly tame bite.

2. Watch Dogs

Ubisoft

Like Pokemon Go, Watch_Dogs can point to its respectable sales figures as proof positive that ‘no one plays’ is incredibly harsh. The game sold well enough to warrant two sequels, the second of which will be out next year: Watch_Dogs Legion.

Advertisement

However, Watch_Dogs painted itself as a ‘GTA Killer’ one set to revolutionise the open world genre. It was to give you complete control of the universe around you at your fingertips. You were god, creating the world in whatever image you saw fit.

In the end, you could change the traffic lights and set off some steam pipes. Watch_Dogs isn’t here because of monumentally low sales or player activity, but because it fell almost laughably short of being the next big thing.

Advertisement

10 million in sales for a new IP is huge. It makes Watch_Dogs look like an imposter on this list. But it’s less than a third of GTA V’s daily player base of 33 million; a figure they sustained for over a year.

1. Artifact

Valve

The big one has been saved for last, or rather the small one. Some of the games here have had disappointing sales figures or player drop off, but that’s nothing compared to Artifact.

Advertisement

It began with a fairly modest playerbase of 60,000 in November 2018, a figure which dropped to 1,500 in just two months. By July this year, the number had fallen so low it was in double figures. Yep, you read that right. From 60,000 to less than 100 in seven months.

Why such a sudden drop though? Well, take your pick.

Advertisement

Artifact is a collectible card game in the vein of Magic: The Gathering, and was even designed by MTG’s creator Richard Garfield. It was made by Valve and set in the DOTA universe, and immediately felt like a game no one had particularly asked for.

Aside from the comments complaining that Valve should be focussed on Half Life 3 though, that Artifact had to be bought while competitors were free to play was unpopular. This was made worse by it still containing microtransactions, and was hit with a barrage of ‘pay to win’ complaints.

Advertisement

It was reviewed bombed almost immediately, unfavourably compared to Hearthstone and MTG and just generally felt like a huge waste of everybody’s time and money.