10 Beloved Video Games That Left A Horrible First Impression

There's a reason no one talks about Red Dead Redemption's opening hour of cow-herding...

By Josh Brown /

Terrible openings never get as much flack as botched endings, because although a poor finale can completely sink an entire game (just ask Mass Effect 3), fans are more forgiving of a shaky introduction if the rest of the game provides hours upon hours of great content.

Advertisement

Which is a shame, because the reality is that some of the most iconic games in the medium take hours and hours of relentless perseverance before you ever get to the good stuff. RPGs in particular can be particularly bad offenders, often giving players lengthy preambles that are entirely unrepresentative of the expansive game to come.

A bad opening followed by a thoroughly excellent game is a forgivable misstep, sure, yet some of the most famous games of all time have been able to hold onto iconic status, despite leaving a terrible first impression on everyone who played them.

Although all of these games eventually came around to deliver some of the best moments the medium has ever seen, I can't quite forgive them for putting me through so much lacklustre gameplay before they got to the good stuff.

10. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End

Uncharted 4 is arguably the best game released for Sony's PS4 so far, yet if you've only played through the opening few missions, you're probably wondering how the title has gained such feverish acclaim.

Advertisement

The problem stems from pacing, and the fact that this final game is structured much more thoughtfully than its predecessors - but it's not the fact that these opening hours are slow that makes them inherently terrible.

In fact, seeing Nate and Elena living retired lives is essential for the story to work going forward, but it's such a shame that these excellent moments are mired by a whole load of wheel-spinning and exposition.

Because unfortunately, A Thief's End is lumped with the difficult task of introducing a long lost brother into a series that hasn't mentioned him once in nine years. What that means for players is a wealth of chapters in the early game that serve as nothing but exercises in exposition and retconning, simply to crowbar Nate's brother Sam into the franchise.

As a result, Uncharted 4 has what feels like three different openings; an explosive boat chase that teases events to come, a flashback that establishes Sam and Nate as brothers and a final intro that reintroduces us to a newly retired Nate and Elena in the aftermath of Uncharted 3.

9. Metal Gear Solid IV: Guns Of The Patriots

Look, the cutscenes of Metal Gear Solid 4 have been a joke since before the game even released, and yet they're a real problem for new - and even returning - players who are hoping to jump into Solid Snake's final adventure.

Advertisement

Because just getting into the game can be a total nightmare. Not only do you have to go through a lengthy disc install before you can even boot it up, but once you're in the game, you're forced to watch a wealth of both live-action and pre-rendered cutscenes that spew exposition about the nanomachine-loving mind of Hideo Kojima.

Worse yet, if you for some reason skip these opening cinematics, then you might as well be playing blindfolded for the entirety of the game's introduction. Thrown straight into the middle of a war zone with no friendly allies, you're forced to navigate your way through complex and interlinking stages without any idea of why you're there, what you're doing or how you're supposed to use any of the gadgets you've been equipped with.

8. Red Dead Redemption

Although Red Dead doesn't suffer from quite the same issues as Grand Theft Auto IV (we'll get to that later), Rockstar's Western epic certainly doesn't put its best foot forward during the opening couple of hours.

Advertisement

Because instead of jumping straight into the pulpy Western action that most people expected from the game, the beginning of Red Dead Redemption casts you as a cowboy in a very literal sense, having you catch wild horses to break them in while tasking you with menial jobs like herding animals back into their pens.

Fortunately, although the pacing is a little slow, the gameplay compliments the tone of these opening missions and serves to establish John Marston as a character far-removed from your typical Clint Eastwood-esque caricature.

That said, it still could have been accomplished a little more elegantly, and the opening of RDR is indicative of a similar problem that rears its ugly head one again during the slow Mexico levels later on in the campaign.

7. Wolfenstein: The New Order

Wolfenstein: The New Order is one of the most underrated shooters of the modern generation. Paving the way for the likes of this year's DOOM, the 2014 reboot from Machine Games showed everyone that an old-school, multiplayer-less first-person shooter could still work in the modern age.

Advertisement

But most players probably wouldn't come to that conclusion if they only managed to get through the title's opening few chapters. Because not only does the latest Wolfenstein take a while to get into the action after a lengthy and awkward blimp repair sequence, but even the initial World War II assault that comes after manages to be one of the most brainless firefights the game has to offer.

Resembling more of an on-rails Call of Duty level than the wide-open player-driven skirmishes of the later campaign, this heavily-scripted introduction completely misrepresents Wolfenstein's core gameplay, and could fool many into thinking The New Order was yet another bog-standard first-person shooter.

6. Shenmue II

Since the announcement of Shenmue 3 almost fifteen years after the release of the previous instalment, the Japanese series has seen a new lease of life as new players return to the previous games to find out what they've been missing out on.

Advertisement

However, the gameplay of Shenmue isn't exactly the most immediately gripping aspect of the series, and in fact most of what you do in these games doesn't come close to the constant explosive action of modern blockbusters.

As a result, Shenmue 2 can initially feel quite boring, especially as you slog across opening levels that barely have you touching the controller at all. Throw in some awkward dialogue and the seeds of a narrative that doesn't really begin to satisfy or make sense until much later and what you're left with is a confusing and jarring introduction to the series.

But while playing Shenmue is weird, slow, and oftentimes accidentally hilarious, it's exactly because of these same features why the game - and the series at large - is considered to be so special all these years later.

Sadly, this slow-burn didn't help the game at the time, as the acquired-taste nature of the title meant it was unable to recoup its then unprecedented $70 million budget.

5. Dark Souls

Part of Dark Souls' charm is that it throws you straight into the deep end without virtually any warning. Right from the beginning of the game you're left to fend for yourself, given a measly sword and told to fight your way out of an undead prison.

Advertisement

But unlike others in the genre the game expects you to learn through trial-and-error, demanding that you get to grips with its systems and mechanics all on your own if you don't want to keep seeing the same "You Died" screen over and over.

However, while this system is certainly one that fans adore, it's one that you have to learn to love over hours and hours of gameplay.

Because initially, jumping into Dark Souls without any knowledge of what to do or where to go is a nightmare. Hell, even creating your character can be confusing, as there's no explanation for any of the abilities you're pumping stats into.

And while the tutorial teaches you the basics of fighting enemies and tackling bosses, the subsequent open-ended area at the Firelink Shrine can be daunting for first time players.

Walk down a wrong path into a zone with high level enemies and you could spend hours throwing yourself against a brick wall without realising that there are other possible avenues you could explore.

4. Mass Effect

Establishing one of the most iconic gaming universes isn't easy, and unfortunately, the introduction to the first Mass Effect suffers from the developers trying to cram too much content into the title's opening hours.

Advertisement

Within these first hours or so, as Commander Shepard you've already been given a prophetic vision of the future, blasted your way through an awkward opening skirmish and been forced to abide by the politics of the alien council while exploring the Citadel.

While it's important to open your blockbuster game in an explosive way, perhaps throwing you straight into the action wasn't Mass Effect's smartest decision.

By doing this it meant that the only real breather came once you left the tutorial planet for the Citadel, and even that location, with its wealth of side-missions and sub-plots to attend to, made for an awfully dull box-ticking experience before you were eventually allowed to set off and explore the galaxy.

3. Grand Theft Auto IV

Although we've already covered Red Dead Redemption's tedious opening few hours, Rockstar had even more trouble when it came to the introduction of their previous game, Grand Theft Auto IV.

Advertisement

Moving away from the pulpy camp of previous GTA games, the fourth entry in the series attempted to reinvent the franchise with a more serious and character-driven tone by dropping the over-the-top shenanigans GTA was previously known for.

So, instead of throwing you straight into the action, Rockstar opted to open this fourth game in a more contemplative way, focusing on the the relationship between the characters and giving Niko a foothold in American culture.

But while the developers pulled off this new tone expertly, it was let down by repetitive gameplay that only had you partaking in menial tasks during these opening hours.

Games don't have to feature shootings and explosions all the time, but GTA IV had nothing interesting to replace these classic gameplay staples with, and as a result you spent the first few hours of the blockbuster living a life closer to that of a glorified taxi driver than an up-and-coming gangster.

2. Grim Fandango

Although the gorgeous charm of Grim Fandango can't be overstated, the opening puzzles of this classic point-and-click adventure don't quite live up to the quality of the title's writing and presentation.

Advertisement

And while these opening levels are perfectly fine from a storytelling perspective, it takes hours to get used to Grim Fandango's obtuse and convoluted puzzle system.

Because it came from an era where puzzle games were as nonsensical as possible (seriously, just opening a door can take an hour and require you to find five seemingly random items that for some reason work together), the frustration of Grim Fandango's opening hours can often offset the amount of sheer fun that comes from the game's brilliant cutscenes.

It's not necessarily fair to asses Grim Fandango's dated gameplay in a modern context, but because the title has only recently been made widely available thanks to a brand new remastered edition, these opening puzzles would only have new players wondering why Grim Fandango is seen as such a revered cult classic in the first place.

1. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

Like most RPGs, The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion had difficulty introducing its expansive narrative and gameplay to new players in just a few measly hours.

Advertisement

In fact the first level of Oblivion has infamously gone down as one of the biggest examples of how you shouldn't open an RPG. Although witnessing the murder of the king and fleeing your prison cell is cool from a narrative standpoint, the way the game funnels you down drab sewers and makes you fight annoying rodents completely sucks the fun out of what should be a daring prison break.

And it doesn't help that your new-found freedom once you do escape the overly-long sewer segment completely contrasts with every skill you've just learned. At this point you're used to following tight objectives down linear paths, so the choose-your-own adventure gameplay that comes after this first level takes much longer than it should to get used to.

As a result, entering the world of Cyrodiil feels nowhere near as refreshing and freeing as it should, and in reality only ends up being oppressively daunting and overbearing as you figure out where to go next.

--

Which iconic games totally ruined their opening stretches? Let us know in the comments !

Advertisement