10 Best Multiplayer Games (That Aren't Multiplayer Games)

Just because a game is single player doesn't mean it's best enjoyed alone.

By Christian Higley /

It's an obvious understatement to say that watching other people play video games has become popularized in recent years, thanks to streaming. But it's a complete misrepresentation to suggest that watching a single player game is somehow a recent development or phenomenon.

Advertisement

People have been gathering around to watch their friends play video games since video games were invented. Those of us of a certain age can fondly remember the days where an audience of strangers would gather around an arcade cabinet because someone was having a perfect game of Ms. Pac-Man, or unlocked and was about to beat Reptile in Mortal Kombat.

And that experience didn't die with arcades.

From Super Mario Bros. to Crash Bandicoot or the original Resident Evil to Five Nights At Freddies, the appeal of spectating or contributing to a single player game hasn't gone anywhere. There are always going to be challenges, puzzles, thrills and cheer-worthy spectacles best enjoyed as a group.

Here are ten games that, like many things in life, are more fun with friends. Even if only one person is in direct control of the action.

10. Uncharted Series

Naughty Dog's iconic action/adventure series, Uncharted, has set the modern standard for cinematic storytelling in video games. From the massive action set-pieces to the snappy dialogue and stunning environments, Uncharted tops the kinds of blockbuster movies that inspired it.

Advertisement

It's precisely that summer blockbuster aesthetic that makes Uncharted so immediately accessible. Even if someone can't enjoy playing the game themselves, watching it is every bit as entertaining as watching a movie, if not more so.

The platforming and gun play are fast and dynamic by design, ensuring others won't have to sit and watch you turtle behind cover while slowly taking out enemies one at a time. If anything, the actual gameplay sequences outshine the spectacle-laden cutscenes.

The pace remains consistent thanks to the balance of action sequences, puzzles and cutscenes. And the puzzles are especially fun to solve as a group - just challenging enough that the player can appreciate others chiming in, but not so tough as to grind the pacing of the story to a halt.

9. Firewatch

Campo Santo's Firewatch is one of easiest games to recommend to people who may not play a lot of games. As a fire lookout named Henry, most of the game boils down to simply walking and navigating dialog options with fellow fire lookout Delilah.

Advertisement

The first thing that makes Firewatch enjoyable with company is first and foremost its incredibly well written and performed story, even if it may not have the most cinematic presentation as a lot of the games on this list.

Second, as a so-called "walking sim," it's perfect for passing the controller around. Sure, there may not be a whole lot in terms of exploration or player agency, but someone who's never touched a video game in their life can pick this up and appreciate its relaxing nature and beautiful art style.

One thing it isn't, is a party game. Firewatch has a lonely atmosphere and emotionally heavy story, one best experienced with a loved one or small group of close friends - anyone you feel comfortable shedding a tear or two around.

You'll be grateful for the emotional support after reaching the tragic twist at the heart of the story.

8. FromSoftware Games

At first glance it might seem like playing any of FromSoftware's infamously difficult games with an audience would be boring at best and humiliating at worst. I mean, what fun is it for anyone if you're stuck fighting the Dancer Of The Boreal Valley for the 15th time? The repeated deaths, minimalist narrative and regular backtracking doesn't exactly scream "spectator sport."

Advertisement

Or does it?

Watching someone play a FromSoftware game is kind of like having a favorite sports team who suck. When you and your friends sit down in front of that game, you know what to expect - and it isn't good. But the heart is there. You love that team. None of you are ever going to quit that team, no matter how bad things get.

But, once every several years, a miracle happens. Your favorite sucky team actually wins it all and the celebration can heard throughout the many hills of the land.

That's what it's like playing a FromSoftware game with a group, except big wins come maybe once an hour instead of once a decade. Regardless, having a group cheering you on and celebrating every little victory makes these games a lot easier on the psyche.

7. Until Dawn

While any of Supermassive's later games in the Dark Pictures Anthology could be included on this list, their spiritual precursor, Until Dawn, still stands out as the best and most accessible of the bunch for group play.

Advertisement

The traditional horror movie setup makes it immediately accessible for anyone at all familiar with the horror classics of the '70s and '80s, meaning it's easy for your non-gaming friends to join the fun. And the inclusion of recognizable film and TV actors makes it even easier to embrace as the "interactive movie" it gets billed as.

But it's not just cut-scenes and dialog trees. The bulk of gameplay consists of gathering clues and exploring your environment, opening up informed discussion for how to progress. Just, maybe, shut up during the quick time events if you aren't on the controls. That'll end a friendship quicker than a blue shell in Mario Kart.

Like any good horror movie, Until Dawn is just more fun to experience with a group. The fact that your choices shape the game's story - including who lives or dies - makes the experience one where everyone can contribute and enjoy seeing the movie unfold.

6. Super Mario Maker 2

If you don't already know, Super Mario Maker is exactly what it sounds like: you make your own side-scrolling Super Mario levels in any of a number of styles spanning the history of the series. And while making levels as a group could be fun, this entry is more about playing the levels other people have made.

Advertisement

Because people are freaking lunatics.

The games are also known for having some of, if not the, most intense and difficult 2D platforming in the history of gaming. That's what happens when you release a construction kit to a community who've been playing, breaking, speed running, and mastering your games in every conceivable way since 1985.

It turns out there are a lot of Super Mario experts out there and they are absolute sadists. Find the most ridiculous levels you can and then have a go. Place bets on who can make it to the end. Whatever you do, everyone will be laugh-crying into their hands when they first see the kinds of things people have come up with.

5. Silent Hill 2

Any of the Silent Hill games are best enjoyed with others, if only to ease the ever creeping sense of dread that builds between save points. But nothing beats Silent Hill 2, considered by many the best in the franchise, and one of the best games of all time.

Advertisement

The story provides an easy hook for player and bystander alike. Unlike the first Silent Hill, where your goal from the start is to find and rescue your daughter, Silent Hill 2 begins with a mystery, as main character James Sunderland is summoned to the cursed little town by a letter from his dead wife.

From that point, your primary motivation is to find answers, both to the question of who sent James this letter (if not his supposedly dead wife) as well as the many more questions you'll encounter as you make your way through the town.

Add to that the fact that one of the first characters you meet is a Bizarro-style doppelgänger of James's wife and, like any good horror story, it's impossible not to want to know more.

And you'll all be happy to have friends nearby when Pyramid Head shows up.

4. Telltale Games

There are a lot of Telltale games. The studio put out so much content so fast, their own market saturation is arguably what killed them.

Advertisement

But in their relatively brief time they were able to appeal to a wide array of people by using the same basic gameplay principals in all of their games. With the likes of The Walking Dead, Game Of Thrones, Batman, and so much more, there's a Telltale game for just about anyone.

While repeated playthroughs of their games have demonstrated that their content really doesn't change a whole lot based on player choice, it feels like it does. And that's really all that matters if you've gathered some friends around for a casual yarn adjacent to one of their favorite pop culture IPs.

And it certainly helps that, regardless of their shortcomings, most of their games are genuinely well written. It's not easy to add new canon to a story and world as thoroughly fleshed out as Game Of Thrones but they did; their take on Batman is original and complex; and Tales From The Borderlands is one of the funniest games ever written.

They may not hold up to repeat plays but that's OK. Some games are best enjoyed once.

3. Portal & Portal 2

Depending on how much (or little) patience you have when it comes to video games, puzzle games can often be best enjoyed with an audience.

Advertisement

This is especially true of the Portal games, two stories so well written and performed that halting progress because you're stuck can easily cast a shadow over the entire experience. It isn't fun to turn grumpy in the middle of something so enjoyable.

Conversely, playing with friends makes those moments you get stumped even more enjoyable. You'll all be scratching your heads, trying to progress via trial and error, when, inevitably, someone will chime in, "Guys, I've got a crazy idea." And usually that crazy idea is the right idea.

Valve of course realized this themselves when they added an entirely separate co-op campaign to Portal 2. Fortunately, the group fun of the single player wasn't compromised and it proved to be even better than the original.

Not to mention that they're comedies, and like most comedies, are best enjoyed with an audience. You'll laugh harder, form inside jokes, cooperate to solves puzzles, and get high off those sweet, sweet hits of oxytocin.

2. Detroit: Become Human

Like Telltale, developer Quantic Dream has been experimenting with same basic formula for years, making narrative-heavy games with butterfly effect-like branching paths. Unlike Telltale, they've done so much more sparingly and with a lot more iteration and experimentation.

Advertisement

Infamously, most of their games come close to greatness until torpedoing themselves with one or two unbelievably bad choices. Does anyone else remember the Matrix-style, aerial kung-fu fight against the Internet at the end of Fahrenheit? If that sentence makes no sense to you then it's worth a Google, because it's far too much to explain here.

Throw in the "JAY-SON" memes that dogged Heavy Rain, and 2018's Detroit: Become Human was arguably their first true success.

The game is visually stunning, has a cohesive world that firmly grounds you in its overtly political narrative, and a truly fantastic cast brings its complex and sympathetic characters to life. On top of that, your choices are significant. The game even includes a map so you can reference where the story branches.

Detroit is full of difficult choices with unpredictable consequences. Making those choices by committee eases the stress and makes the twists and turns even more compelling. Additionally, its themes might give you something to talk about afterwards.

1. Resident Evil VII: Biohazard

There's a reason why there are three horror games on this list. It's easy to just say, "horror is more fun with friends." Because it is. But Until Dawn, Silent Hill 2, and Resident Evil: Biohazard give us a full trifecta of scaries.

Advertisement

Until Dawn is enjoyed like a classic horror, more fun-gruesome than scary-gruesome. And Silent Hill 2 provides a gripping mystery and a lot of spooky imagery, but definitely does not put up the frights like it did two entire... oh boy... DECADES ago. (I threw my back out just saying that.)

Resident Evil: Biohazard gives us a bit of everything while still being one of the most genuinely scary games in recent memory.

For added fun, play this one on VR and pass the controller around. Seeing your friends, especially your non-gamer friends, try to run and hide from evil family patriarch Jack Baker while fully immersed in a VR headset and headphones is were the real fun is.

Advertisement