10 Best Rockstar Games Protagonists - Ranked

The games are brilliant, but you LOVE them for the characters.

By Curtis Dillon /

Rockstar Games is amongst the very best developers in the entire games industry. Arguably the best.

Advertisement

There are a number of reasons for that, from incredibly interactive worlds to engrossing stories. One of the primary reasons the games are so beloved and highly anticipated though, is the fun, madcap and often controversial characters.

Rockstar video games are some of the most sprawling around, and the stories the studio weaves are twisting, captivating narratives that are unlike anything else in the medium. That's a trend that began with Grand Theft Auto III in 2001, and has carried all the way through to Red Dead Redemption II. The result is around a dozen games that have spawned some of the best and most iconic video game characters of all time.

Today we're counting down the ten best characters to come from Rockstar Games. Most series fail to create memorable characters or stories, but the wizards at Rockstar manage to hit home-runs each and every time.

Spanning multiple generations of gamers and a huge array of genres, Rockstar Games have produced protagonists that stand tall above the rest.

Still, only one individual deserves to be called the outright best.

10. Max Payne

Truth be told, Max Payne is a pretty fantastic character, but he's not a Rockstar original, and that's why he's at the bottom.

Advertisement

Rockstar Games has only made one Max Payne game (Max Payne 3), and that came way back in 2012. It jumped forward in time nine years to find a retired Max living in New Jersey with addictions to both alcohol and pain medication.

Max takes a job to be a private security contractor in South America, and finds himself trying to save his boss' kidnapped wife. It's a dark, sinister tale that twists along the way to continue the drudgery that is Max's life.

It's one of Rockstar's darkest stories and felt like an authentic continuation of Max's story. Payne is the most hard-boiled, grizzled, and downtrodden of all Rockstar protagonists, and that's what makes him so compelling. That said, the nice thing about the third game is that Max quite literally walks off into the sunset at the end.

It's the character arc that provides us, and him, with some semblance of peace after so many years of misery; a noir tale that served to say goodbye to one of gaming's most loved characters.

9. Luis Fernando Lopez

As the main character of GTA IV: The Ballad of Gay Tony, we didn't get to know Luis Fernando Lopez for very long, but he made a lasting impact - especially when you consider he was merely part of a DLC.

Advertisement

Lopez was the antithesis of many GTA characters as he's all-too-aware that he's a bad guy, and is also desperate to get out of the game. Getting out of the game is his main goal but to do so he has to dive a little further in. That leads to bank heists and cage fighting in order to earn a little more money and get a little bit closer to the light at the end of the tunnel.

He's also a loyal friend, loving son and a hard worker, resulting in a more subtle character; a far cry from the caricatures we've become accustomed to in the series. Luis works for Gay Tony and shows no semblance of caring about his boss' sexuality, which most other GTA characters would likely make fun of.

He's a far more nuanced character than his peers, and one that deserves a place on this list for not being a gun-toting maniac.

8. Carl Johnson

Carl Johnson is a sympathetic character. Unlike most Grand Theft Auto protagonists, he doesn't revel in murder and literal auto theft. He left the hood in Los Santos to seek a better life, but is forced to return home when his mother died.

Advertisement

Of course, as soon as CJ returns to Los Santos, and Grove Street specifically, he is dragged right back into the escalating gang wars. CJ's friends and family are at the heart of the story and his loyalty to them sees him do some awful things. He's quite reminiscent of Grand Theft Auto V's Franklin - in regards to his personality - but a much more charismatic version.

It helps that CJ is also the most customisable GTA character of all time, with players able to change his hair, make him fat or buff, cover him in tattoos and boost his stats. This results in a character that players feel a stronger bond with, being they're actually affecting his personal growth.

CJ is one of Grand Theft Auto's most likeable individuals; an everyday man who just can't get on the right track due to where he was born. Plus, it doesn't hurt that CJ was Rockstar's first non-white protagonist, now easily being one of the most iconic of them all.

7. Trevor Phillips

Without a shadow of a doubt, the most insane character Rockstar has ever created, Trevor Phillips is arguably the most beloved of all of GTA's protagonists.

Advertisement

Trevor kills people willy-nilly, swears more than Gordon Ramsay, and is entirely unpredictable. He's incredibly fun to watch and play as, but he's utterly unrelatable and that's why he's so far down the list.

One of the most ingenious things about GTA V is the ability to play as three characters - all representing different levels of the human psyche; Michael as the ego; Franklin the super-ego; and Trevor the id. That's perfectly showcased when you switch to playing as Trevor, only to find him naked on a beach, stomping a mudhole into a random passer-by or flying a plane.

He represents the way a lot of gamers play GTA games when they don't plan on saving. He makes you feel like it's totally fine to run a rampage because you can simply switch back to the more sane characters later. He's unabashed, unfiltered chaos, and that makes him a blast to play as, even if he doesn't feature much in the way of a character arc.

6. Niko Bellic

GTA IV is an interesting game; it was beloved when it released, received critical acclaim, and sold like gangbusters.

Advertisement

Yet nowadays it seems like something of a redheaded step-child in the series. GTA IV felt like Rockstar trying to make a more serious game following the madness that was San Andreas, only to produce something that's brilliant, but ill-fitting in the overall catalogue.

What makes the game brilliant however, is its tough-as-nails protagonist: The Serbian immigrant, Niko Bellic. An angry man who spent time in the army, Niko comes to America in search of the proverbial dream, but is dragged into a criminal underworld by his dumb cousin and underhanded associates. He's a stranger in a strange land, and that was the perfect analogy for gamers playing GTA IV.

Niko is a pretty simple guy; one who feels let down by everyone around him; one who is tired of killing for the benefit of the rich; and one who just wants to live large in a new country. It makes Niko's story all the more tragic knowing how much he just wants to leave it all behind. He's not the most relatable or charismatic but Niko is one of the more realistic.

5. Jimmy Hopkins

While The Warriors is its most underrated game, Bully stands as Rockstar's cult classic.

Advertisement

The game's protagonist Jimmy Hopkins is a troubled kid that has been dealt a crappy hand in life; his mother just married a rich prick who is eager to dump Jimmy off at the preppy Bullworth Academy. He finds himself trying to navigate the choppy social waters of the school, doing favours for his peers, befriending each clique and pissing off the teachers in the process.

Bully is an incredibly fun game that those who didn't understand it were quick to judge and ridicule. While the game is called Bully and allows you to be just that, it's a story of fighting back against authority and actual bully's in order to bring people together and end corruption. And Jimmy is a fantastic protagonist because he looks and talks like an ass, but he's much more nuanced than he first appears.

He's part James Dean, part Holden Caulfield in a unique school setting. And it's up to the gamer to decide if their version of Jimmy is a nice guy with rough edges, or a true-blue bully. Regardless, the story takes Jimmy on a journey of self-discovery, one in which he shows himself to have a pretty big heart, as well as a pretty big slingshot.

4. Michael DeSanta

While Trevor is by far the more popular of these two characters, Michael is much better developed, and much more relatable.

Advertisement

As we touched upon previously, Michael represents the middle-ground between the mundane Franklin Clinton and the bat$hit Trevor Phillips. He's a guy who made money doing bad things, screwed over his friends, married someone he didn't love, and tried to get out of the criminal life.

Of course, as we've seen repeatedly, he gets dragged back in kicking and screaming, but that's what makes him the most compelling character in GTA V.

While Trevor is entirely irredeemable and Franklin is rather boring in his non-committal attitude, Michael has his foot firmly planted in both ways of life. He can seem like an ass but once you meet his ungrateful, annoying family members, you start to see why he's as bitter as he is. He isn't very loyal though, and that's perhaps a surprising spin on he and Trevor (who is more loyal). But that's what makes the story of GTA V so great, it's not predictable and the characters are grey as opposed to black and white.

Michael is a run-of-the-mill Rockstar Games protagonist, but he also shows how much the studio has developed at writing characters and giving them more layers.

3. Cole Phelps

Cole Phelps is the star of one of Rockstar's strangest games: LA Noire.

Advertisement

It was a game developed by an Australian studio, Team Bondi, over the course of six years. Interestingly, it was originally funded by Sony, but then Rockstar Games purchased the publishing rights and distributed it. The game suffered from a notoriously bad development cycle and Rockstar Games was forced to intervene and help finish it, which resulted in a severance of the partnership post-release.

All that being said, the game turned out shockingly well; LA Noire is a really great game with memorable characters and a twisting story. One major part of the game that helps it work so well, is its protagonist, Cole Phelps.

At the start of the game, Cole is portrayed as a goody-two-shoes cop with a unwavering moral code and unshakeable bravery. As the story develops, you start to see different shades of Phelps; he cheats on his wife and his touted World War II feats of bravery are unfounded.

Phelps is a coward and a bit of a rat, but by the end of the game, he makes the ultimate sacrifice in order to save the day. It's a hell of a redemption story for a character who isn't particularly likeable.

2. John Marston

John Marston was born in May 2010 when Red Dead Redemption launched. Marston came around in a time when almost every gaming protagonist was a skin-head guy with zero fear and few weaknesses. To speak with a smidge of hyperbole, it was a rather dull time in regards to characters in video games.

Advertisement

At the beginning of the game we see Marston being ushered onto a train by two government officials, who tell him he can have his family back when he finds all of his old gang members. It's a unique set-up right away, gives you a real purpose for your deeds, and a reason to care.

By the end of the game he has done some bad things and completed his journey... until he too is hunted down, and sacrifices himself to save his family.

Then we rewind to Red Dead Redemption II where the wizards at Rockstar found a way to make John an even better character. We see a younger Marston, who puts himself before his family and lacks the loyalty and badass nature we'd come to know.

By the end though, his character has developed massively, so that the blend right into the first game feels natural and earned. Marston is always a gruff, no-nonsense character, but he becomes layered and sympathetic. His rough persona is more than just bravado and his ending is perfect.

1. Arthur Morgan

For a long time John Marston was the benchmark for video game protagonists, particularly from Rockstar Games. It seemed a difficult task for Rockstar to outdo itself with Red Dead Redemption 2 and give us a new protagonist to care about. However it not only bested John Marston, it created the greatest video game character of all time.

Advertisement

Much like John, Arthur begins his journey as a no-nonsense character with seemingly no real backstory. By the end of the game however, Arthur is the most well-rounded character in the game and we know lots about his life. We know his father was not a good man, we know both his parents died when he was quite young, we know he had a woman and a child, both of whom were killed, we know he has borderline unwavering loyalty to Dutch, and he often doubts his actions.

Arthur gradually opens up and when we do learn about chunks of his past it feels like a natural progression for the character. He's a man facing his own mortality and reflecting on his life, which hasn't panned out the way he had hoped. It's a true story of redemption and self-reflection that is both heart-breaking and full of hope.

Arthur's story is unlike anything else in gaming, and no other character could be the linchpin. Roger Clark's portrayal of the character is both moving and unforgettable, particularly in the final meeting with a certain nun.

Take a bow Arthur, and especially voice actor Roger Clark.

Advertisement