10 Best Silent Protagonists In Gaming History

They say it best, when they say nothing at all.

By Stacey Henley /

As games move closer and closer to being taken seriously as pieces of art, characters are becoming more developed and well rounded. Just recently, Arthur Morgan and 2018’s Kratos staked claims as some of the most complex and nuanced characters of all time. Sometimes though, characters manage to say a lot without saying anything at all.

Advertisement

These characters remain completely silent throughout their games (often across whole series), yet have still become iconic figures. There’s a few grunts and yelps along the way sure, but no words of any real note.

Mario, a long time silent protagonist, has become slightly more talkative recently. Though this often just means shouting the name of the game he’s currently in, it’s just about enough to disqualify him.

Likewise, characters we never hear speak but who talk through on screen dialogue miss the boat here too. There’s more than enough actually silent characters around without wedging in others on technicalities.

These characters don’t just exist in games without talking, their silence becomes part of the game. Either by drawing you in or strangely making the characters more relatable, this lot thrive despite a lack of dialogue.

10. Sparrow (Fable 2)

For some players, it’s hard to read the word ‘Fable’ without wincing. Right from the first game, there were empty promises which remained unfulfilled even as the trilogy closed. As for the trilogy itself, the tone and British humour was praised throughout but the gameplay style and quality varied wildly. However, it remained a solid series.

Advertisement

This was followed by a terrible Kinect focussed Fable: The Journey, a so so remake of the first game and a failed multiplayer endeavour. There are whispers that a fourth true version of the game may be on the way soon, but all in all the series has taken quite a battering over the years.

Still, it remains charmingly popular, and a lot of that is down to the game’s unabashed wit and utter silliness. Though combat styles varied throughout the series, the humour probably peaked in the second entry with the unnamed hero, nicknamed Sparrow.

A perfect foil for the jokes of the rest of the cast, Sparrow was delightfully goofy even without words. Sparrow could still laugh, dance, scream and even fart, all of which the townspeople for some reason found impressive. Even without words, Sparrow was a great entertainer.

9. Gordon Freeman (Half Life)

The second Orange Box mute in a row, and while it’s unlikely Gordon Freeman will ever get to finish his trilogy, he’s still done enough to solidify his legacy in the medium.

Advertisement

In the mould of the sorts of classic first person games Half Life went on to replace, Freeman’s complete and utter silence throughout allowed the player to push their own personality into him. Ironically, the narrative sharpness of Half Life opened the door for modern first person games at the turn of the century, and Half Life managed to be both the end of an era and the first of its kind.

Freeman is whatever you want him to be, and that’s one of the many, many things which made Half Life so iconic. Though some do see Freeman’s flatness as a weak point in a game so full of life elsewhere, it’s hard to imagine it being so successful with such a drastic change.

This counts double if they ended up giving him a personality which just didn’t mesh at all. With so much else going on in Half Life, when it comes to Freeman, less is certainly more.

8. Jack (BioShock)

Right at the start of the game, we hear someone who might be Jack or might be someone next to him on the trip to Rapture. Therefore, there’s definitely an argument to be made that he perhaps doesn’t quite fit here. However, considering his silence in Rapture forms an important part of the plot and symbolism in a game already dripping with imagery, he’s worth exploring.

Advertisement

So, would you kindly forget those opening exchanges, just for now?

Although Would You Kindly has become the ‘Bruce Willis Is A Ghost’ of the gaming world, at the time the fact you were playing as a brainwashed individual was a gripping twist.

It transpires throughout the game that player character Jack has been hypnotised with trigger phrase of ‘would you kindly’. It’s a stellar premise and even after the reveal, the game manages to have fun with it. This only serves to make Jack’s silence all the more important though.

He’s not just a faceless, wordless hero for you to project yourself onto. In fact, he’s little more than a drone, being driven around Rapture at will. Your thumbs might be on the joysticks, but there’s a much higher power actually pulling the strings.

7. Claude (GTA III)

Grand Theft Auto is one of the most popular and recognisable gaming series around now, and even six years after last release Grand Theft Auto V, the online mode is basically a license for Rockstar to print money.

Advertisement

Recent protagonists Niko Bellic and Trevor Philips have overshadowed the early entires a little, but GTA III’s Claude was the first hero (are they really heroes in GTA?) to put the game on the map.

GTA III was followed by Vice City and San Andreas, before Niko Bellic arrived in GTA IV and established the game as a modern masterpiece.

That might not have been possible without Claude and GTA III though. The 2001 release revolutionised open world, open ended gameplay, and remains the building block for several AAA games today.

Rockstar have commented on Claude’s silence previously, and were refreshingly open about the decision. Though it was in part ‘to aid people identifying with him’, it was much more a case of not adding an unnecessary job when they were already pushing so many boundaries. With cinematic cutscenes, a bigger open world than they’d ever done before and hugely detailed (for the era) NPCs, Claude’s voice just ‘wasn’t a priority’.

6. Chell (Portal)

Though Chell is technically the protagonist in that she’s the player character, one of the main reasons she works is because the villainous GLaDoS has a big enough personality for two. The silly yet incredibly dark humour of the antagonist makes the game memorable and full of life, even while Chell remains quiet.

Advertisement

If Chell did argue back though, as you might expect someone in those conditions to do, the game wouldn’t gain much and would definitely lose something. Her silence not only allows GLaDoS to dominate easier, it also puts you firmly in the driving seat. You choose how to react to her, you choose how far to believe her. Throughout the first game especially, it truly feels like you’re the one trapped in there with GLaDoS.

In fact, unless you deliberately manipulate the portals to work like pseudo mirrors, you can barely see what Chell looks like in the first game.

The second game does attempt to flesh her out a little, but again GLaDoS (now a potato) is the star attraction. Chell often gets overlooked because of this but her introverted style is a big part of the game’s success.

5. Protagonist (Gris)

Gris is a game driven by sound, and while the wordless singing of our nameless protagonist does feature throughout, that’s not too different from the various grunts some other so called silent protagonists here.

Advertisement

Gris is one of the most beautiful games ever, with the artistic backgrounds slowly filling with colour as you return more light to the world. The soundtrack is wonderful too, subtle throughout then crescendoing just as it needs to. Our protagonist is beautifully drawn, with her spindly limbs, flowing coat and evocative facial expressions.

Gris is a less a game than it is a piece of art with puzzles attached, and the quietly contemplative protagonist is the perfect fit for that.

Throughout the game, there’s various challenges which tie into the five stages of grief our protagonist seems to be going through. Her silence played against the soft soundtrack and gorgeous art work draw you in much more than any long monologues might have. The protagonist’s silence and an almost complete lack of hints or direction leave you with a similar feeling of isolation.

Though several indie games have silent protagonists for convenience, Gris is one of the few that actually uses it to its advantage.

4. Doomguy (Doom)

Doomguy, sometimes referred to as the Doom Slayer instead, is pretty much the epitome of this trope. Though he has to settle for a spot just outside the medals (it’s a tough competition, after all), Doom Guy probably personifies what we expect from a silent protagonist more than anyone.

Advertisement

Once an everyday space marine, Doomguy gets involved in a beef with demons on Mars after his crew is killed. He ends up almost single handedly defending humanity from Hell, with the Doom games being some of the coolest and most visceral around.

Doomguy certainly isn’t the blank slate of Chell or Gordon Freeman; nor is his silence some artistic comment on grief as it is in Gris. Instead, we see a man who keeps his mouth shut, grits his teeth and does what has to be done.

The rugged marine is hardly a unique archetype in gaming, but several ropey heroes over the years have shown the dangers of leaning on one liners. Dukem Nukem was decent in his heyday, but the revival was painfully dated. Doom’s silence and focus on gunplay makes it a timeless, wordless classic.

3. Crash (Crash Bandicoot)

Crash Bandicoot is in the midst of a stellar revival right now, after the success of the N Sane Trilogy and Crash Team Racing: Nitro Fueled. A ‘90s star whose stock had faded almost into obscurity, the last few years have been very kind to him.

Advertisement

With both of those being remakes (the former of the glorious original trilogy and the latter a mash up of the two more successful kart racers), Crash will need a great truly new game before he’s officially back, but right now the future looks very bright indeed.

A rival to the witty and talkative Spyro, Crash never said anything more than ‘WHOA!’ through his halcyon days, and so it’s remained in his renaissance. Though the game itself does have an (often nonsensical) story, the main narrative weight has been carried by his sister Coco or his protective mask Aku Aku. The villains are far more chatty, with Cortex, Uka Uka, N Gin and the rest also prone to monologuing.

Crash does excel however when it comes to facial expressions and dance moves, as well as having some of the most entertaining death animations in gaming. He doesn’t need dialogue to be massively over the top.

2. Link (The Legend Of Zelda)

The Zelda games are some of the most iconic and enduring gaming franchises ever, led by silent hero Link. He’s gone through several redesigns in his time, but through them all he’s hardly said more than a grunt.

Advertisement

The hero of Hyrule is one of the most recognisable characters around, with even the most casual of casual gamers aware of his impact on the genre. Most recently, Breath Of The Wild pushed all sorts of boundaries, but even as it brought in more characters and a bigger role for Zelda than ever before, Link remained tight lipped.

Still, as a launch title for the Nintendo Switch it helped get a firm foothold for Nintendo’s new flagship console before the likes of Super Mario Odyssey, Let’s Go Pikachu/Eevee and Super Smash Bros Ultimate joined the party.

Link’s been a major hitter for Nintendo for a long, long time though, first launching in 1986. Although many point to Breath Of The Wild as his best ever, others have a place in their heart for the likes of Ocarina Of Time or Majora’s Mask.

One thing’s for sure though: whichever one your favourite is, it won’t be for Link’s sparkling conversation.

1. Red (Pokemon Red & Blue)

...

Advertisement

That’s all that needs to be said for Red, really.

The protagonist of Pokémon Red & Blue never says a word, not even when he crops up as one of the best bosses in gaming in Gold & Silver, nor as one of the most challenging NPCs in Let’s Go. However, as the lead of one of the most famous gaming franchises ever, he does more than enough without dialogue to secure his place here.

It’s become a tradition for Pokémon protagonists to be silent, though in Sun & Moon and the trailers for Sword & Shield, their expressionless gaze is a little disconcerting. Back in the classic pixel days of Red & Blue though, Red’s reserved style was perfect.

With so many vibrant and exciting Pokémon to focus on, the player character took a backseat to give them the spotlight. Professor Oak, your Rival and the Gym Leaders all had enough personality, so it was nice for Red to simply sit back and let his actions speak louder.

Pokémon Red & Blue remains one of the definitive experiences in gaming, and despite his silence, Red is the perfect guide.

Advertisement