10 Best Video Game Sequels That NEVER Happened

Divulging the secret of the real Fallout 3.

By Zoë Miskelly /

It's strange to think how many famous games franchises have has cancelled games that many of us will never know about our entire lives. Due to a mix of time, non-disclosure agreements, and cruel fate, many otherwise promising games have been lost in the annals of history, unlikely to ever be finished.

Advertisement

And - though most of these games we cannot play any of for obvious reasons - it's still fascinating to learn of these games, as through research you can learn both about what could have been and also a little about the world of video game creation.

Though doing so may make you slightly sad about cancelled titles like Fallout: Van Buren - and a little sadder about some sketchy business practices that appear to have gone on - it's still worth learning about all these cancelled gems, if only so you appreciate the games you have all the more.

More than one person has likely drank a couple cold ones mourning the loss of the Final Fantasy games that never were, and we can only support these souls by learning about all the best games that never made it to the shelves.

10. The Thing II

It goes almost without saying that having another game about the horror film classic The Thing would have been awesome.

Advertisement

And, indeed, the work that had gone into planning the game before it was cancelled in 2003 does suggest it would have been a fun experience. For example, developers had designed a "burst-out" system, allowing various creepy new Things to bust out of random NPCs, bringing you some genuine and delightful horror.

These were also supposed to grow and mutate, turning more horrific as time goes on.

Tragically, these plans for gross, ever-changing beasts were cut short, as the studio creating the game - Computer Artworks - closed down, prematurely ending both The Thing II and also an Alone In The Dark sequel.

While the games hadn't been very developed, it's still a shame that they were canned, as those involved in creating The Thing II did seem to be approaching its development from a smart perspective. After all, there's no point creating a game based on a really cool monster without first making your monsters as nuanced and scary as you can.

9. Castlevania: Resurrection

Given the Castlevania series altogether has almost forty separate games comprising it, it's fair that you might not notice individual games slipping through the gaps.

Advertisement

And Castlevania: Resurrection - the initially planned sixteenth instalment of the series - very much appears to be a case of this. It's an especially unusual case of cancellation, as work ceasing on it definitely wasn't down to internal issues or the studio working on the game closing, as the game was being developed by Konami.

Fans have speculated that the ceased development of Resurrection was down to Konami's skepticism about the Sega Dreamcast, which is supported by the fact that the game was cancelled the same day that the Playstation 2 was announced.

While it might sound wild to quit creating a game because of another impending console, the Dreamcast's sales did dwindle in comparison to the Playstation 2, so - from an entirely financial perspective - if this was the reason Konami quit making the game, it was a successful choice.

However, from a creative perspective, it does feel like a tragic waste, as we'll always wonder what a fully finished version of this game looked like.

8. Chrono Trigger: Crimson Echoes

Creating a fan game is, strangely, even more fraught with danger than creating a licensed sequel. Even if you don't intend to sell the game, you can still be considered to be infringing the copyrights of the franchise you are utilising - like, for example, Pokémon Prism being handed a cease and desist by Nintendo.

Advertisement

A similar scenario occurred with the ambitious Chrono Trigger sequel Crimson Echoes. Fans intended to create it as a mid-point between Chrono Trigger and the legitimate sequel, Chrono Cross.

Volunteers worked tirelessly on the game, and - an astounding five years later - were almost finished totally developing it. Then, in a cruel twist of fate, Square Enix issued these creators with a cease and desist of their own, mere weeks before the completed project was to be released into the wild.

Paradoxically, versions of the game can still be found on the internet - although it's unclear exactly how, since an almost fully finished version of Crimson Echoes can still be found on some strange corners if you look for it.

7. Legacy Of Kain: Dead Sun

Legacy of Kain: Dead Sun is an especially tragic case of a cancelled video game sequel, as it was cancelled a whopping three years into its production.

Advertisement

This led to some understandable ire amongst fans and developers alike, as both were upset that all one thousand and ninety-five days work on the project were going to be totally thrown to the wayside. While the rest did go to waste, the multiplayer mode created for Dead Sun was repurposed into another game named Nosgoth.

However, in a jazzy twist, Nosgoth would be the reason Dead Sun itself became revealed to the general public, as details about the original game would be leaked onto internet forums, with concept art and gameplay footage eventually following suit.

Naturally, this made the situation slightly more uniquely painful, as while Legacy of Kain: Dead Sun was cancelled in 2012, its existence and cancellation was unveiled a year later.

While Dead Sun would have been the sixth entry in the series, there was clearly a desire to see it come out, which is what leaves it especially confusing that Square Enix officially stated that it "just wasn't the right game, at the right time".

6. Saints Row: Money Shot

The one absolute shame of learning that this game was cancelled is that the franchise could have had the phrase "money shot" in its holster, and now we can only dream of such a thing.

Advertisement

Intended to be placed between Saints Row 2 and Saints Row: the Third, Money Shot revolved around a character named Cypher.

The levels would focus around Cypher pulling off various, increasingly elaborate trick shots, with the player controlling the bullet after it is fired. This might sound overly simple, but it's a premise that can quickly become incredibly complex, and knowing what Saints Row is usually like, would have definitely gotten hilariously ridiculous real fast.

It's an interesting rogue for a spin-off in the series, but it does make some sense as to why the game may have been cancelled - since it's a very different from the way the other games play out, and has significantly less opportunity for dick jokes, despite the game's title.

While we never got our glorious Money Shot, this at least didn't spell the end for the entire series, even if it was without trick-shotting assassins.

5. Fallout 3: Van Buren

It may come as a surprise to learn that, technically, the Fallout 3 we got to experience is in actual fact technically Fallout 4, if you count the cancelled Van Buren title.

Advertisement

Intended to be the third instalment of the Fallout series, Van Buren was developed by Black Isle Studios, who intended to allow players to decide their game experience; either a turn-based game like Fallout 1 and 2, or real time like the series would go on to be.

The game would start with your character waking up in a prison - either from a legitimate crime or an unfair incarceration, depending on your choice - only to manage to escape. The plot would go on to cover you finding out why exactly you were imprisoned in a place you can't remember, and why the prison was then the subject of an attack that allowed you to escape.

However, due to unforeseen financial issues, the project would be canned, and when Fallout 3 was put into development, it would be under Bethesda, not Black Isle.

4. Silent Hills

What's a list without a cancelled Hideo Kojima project, really?

Advertisement

While P.T is the crowning jewel of fan disappointment - as the trailer we got, suggesting a horrifying and fantastic game, promptly became all we got - some likely don't know what it was the demo for.

This was supposed to be the sneak preview for a game called Silent Hills, which would be a collaboration between two directors; Hideo Kojima, and Guillermo Del Toro, a famous filmmaker responsible for gothic works such as Pan's Labyrinth.

It was also revealed that iconic horror manga artist Junji Ito would have been involved in this project, which is especially painful to learn, as much of his works involves making the everyday frightening - which would have made him a perfect fit to make the franchise even more terrifying.

As it is, professional conflicts appear to have birthed this cancellation, as it was reported that Kojima and a section of his staff intended to leave the company after Metal Gear V was completed.

While we'll never see what glorious prospect this game appeared to be, Del Toro and Kojima would produce Death Stranding together, under new company Kojima Productions.

3. Final Fantasy: Fortress

Final Fantasy: Fortress was an undeniably ambitious game. It was intended to be set years after the events of Final Fantasy XII: Revenant Wings, bringing the cast back to see them face off against a Viking-like invading force.

Advertisement

While Fortress initially was set out to be an independent IP, Square Enix were impressed with developer Grin's prior work on Bionic Commander, leading them to request that this pending title be made into a Final Fantasy instalment.

Square Enix were supposed to pay Grin studios a sum of 16.5 million dollars for the entire creation of Fortress. However, despite working on the game for several months, Square Enix did not pay up. Indeed, Grin co-founder Bo Andersson believed that the company had turned on the idea of Fortress after Bionic Commander received negative press on release.

If the story about Grin sending pictures of Final Fantasy XII when Square Enix asked to see the game - only for them to be told that these pictures "didn't look like a Final Fantasy game" - this line of thought goes very much appear to be true.

Grin would go bankrupt because of this debacle, and were summarily never paid by the company that had commissioned them.

2. Fez II

Generally, when a game is cancelled, it's not something that's down to those working on creating it. Many a time those working on a cancelled project are those hit hardest, because not only do they have to stop doing their jobs, but they also lose the ability to use this game to showcase their work when looking for further work.

Advertisement

However, in rare cases, a game's creation can stop because of the creator. Anyone who is aware of Fez's creator, Phil Fish, is likely pretty unsurprised that he is one of such creators.

Regardless of your personal opinions on Fish - who's rants on the internet and gaming can still be found to today - it's fair to say he's a temperamental individual. This quick-to-anger nature would collide with the podcast GameTrailers' host Marcus Beer, and the two would get to a spot of good old fashioned Twitter arguing.

This would prove to be the final straw for Phil and his catalogue of internet beefing, who would then announce the cancellation of the recently announced Fez II - much to the surprise of his company, who didn't appear to know beforehand. Given Phil Fish has announced he wishes to sell rights to the game and his company, it seems like it is currently cancelled for good.

1. Conker's Other Bad Fur Day

With Conker's Bad Fur Day having become such a memorable game - to the extent that it's still being sought out and played today - it makes logical sense to try and continue the series. While many applauded the first game for ending on a low note, it was also undeniably sad to leave Conker after all your adventures with him to seemingly live out a life of regret and misery.

Advertisement

All this in mind, when Rare revealed that they intended to continue the crude red squirrel's adventures, many fans were understandably delighted.

From what has been shown to us, the plot would have revolved around Conker battling it out with the now undead Panther King, who was brought back by Death himself. Throughout these struggles, Conker battles Death, sees the universe's equivalent of the underworld, and at the end is attacked by what appears to be a carefully changed version of a Star Destroyer.

While these plans sounds genuinely interesting - and appear to set up the franchise as a trilogy - it was not to be. This would happen once more in 2015, when another potential sequel called "Conker's Big Reunion" was also left to the wayside.

Advertisement