10 Biggest Pokémon Controversies
Pokémon’s image isn’t as squeaky clean as you think.
Pokémon is a global phenomenon, with games, TV shows, manga, movies, trading cards, toys and more in its stable. While it has a kid-friendly image and simple charm, there’s also a tactical depth and nostalgic glow which keeps adults hooked too.
Because of this huge audience, it comes under more fire than most franchises. We know the primary audience is children, but so many adults are deeply immersed in the games, toys, cards and shows that nothing gets by unnoticed.
With big cultural differences between Japan and the USA (Pokémon and Nintendo’s two biggest markets), there’s a lot of stuff which was deemed okay for the local release, but was either preemptively changed or met with criticism in Western markets.
The world is significantly smaller with widespread internet access, so even things confined to Japan have made their way West and caused a bit of a fuss.
These things either caused a big controversy for The Pokémon Company’s image, or were changed knowing how controversial they’d be for Western audiences. Things like removing the Game Corner or the Tentacruel episode being pulled out of respect for 9/11 don’t qualify, as they’re not especially controversial on their own, but outside of that, there are plenty stories to tell.
10. Accusations Of Racism
Younger players may not be aware that Jynx’s current purple skin is actually a redesign, with her debuting with jet black skin. The big pink lips and wide eyes on a black face, looked like, well, blackface, and the design came under fire.
Jynx is believed to be based on Yama-uba (an icy ghost), and Brunhilde, the Valkyrie (an original opera lady who sings), which would explain the design, moveset and typing. However, there’s also the ganguro inspiration, a Japanese trend of using incredibly dark foundation to give women brown skin, which is certainly iffy on a global scale.
It probably didn’t help that humanoid Pokémon don’t tend to be very popular anyway. This, combined with the lingering ill will from its original design, means Jynx is many peoples' least favourite Pokémon ever.
Possibly wary of a similar reaction, Lenora was changed too. Though her in game and Japanese anime outfit shows her wearing an apron, this was shortened to become a blouse for the Western anime.
Despite the reasonable justification that Lenora was an archeologist, the apron (combined with the handkerchief and dark skin) was too reminiscent of the black mammy stereotype, and Pokémon decided to be better safe than sorry.
9. Denno Senshi Porygon
While the Tentacruel episode of the anime wasn’t considered, the Porygon episode (Denno Senshi or Cyber/Electric Soldier Porygon) definitely counts as it caused its own controversy rather than simply airing at an unfortunate time.
Porygon is a virtual Pokémon, which while seemingly similar to Digimon is actually quite different. Porygons are created by computers through a logic not really worth getting into, but this means that Porygon’s anime episode took place in a virtual world.
This led to some trippy visuals, psychedelic shapes and flashing lights, which were unfortunately too much for many Japanese children and led to multiple reported seizures.
Rather than risk this occurring again, Pokémon decided to pull the episode entirely rather than just change it. To date, it’s not been made available in syndication or in any collections, and Porygon hasn’t reappeared on TV, either.
The sequence occurred during the climax, so editing would’ve been difficult, but it’s still a shame that such an interesting character has been de facto banned.
The worst part is that the seizures were actually caused by Pikachu’s electric attack, not Porygon at all. Still, there’s zero chance The Pokémon Company were going to can their cuddly little mascot, so unfortunately the digital ‘mon got it.
8. Uri Geller Sues Kadabra
This one’s just plain weird.
Uri Geller has made a career out of being a shyster; famously claiming to be one of Michael Jackson’s closest friends when in fact they’d only had a few brief encounters and having his psychic abilities repeatedly debunked. Despite all this, his lawsuit against Kadabra may be the most bizarre.
Geller claimed the psychic Pokémon was based on his image, and sued for $60 million. This claim relied on the fact that Kadabra is holding a spoon, with spoon bending being one of Geller’s signature acts, as well as the star and zigzags.
Claiming the latter elements were racist references to his Jewish faith (zigzags as a reference to the Nazi SS), the Pokémon company responded that it was a regular star, not a Star of David, that the symbols were common on mystical Zener cards, and that Geller wasn’t exactly big in Japan.
Undeterred, Geller claimed "Nintendo turned me into an evil, occult character. Nintendo stole my identity by using my name and my signature image."
Until the case is decided one way or the other, Kadabra no longer features on the cards or on TV, though it’s still in the games.
7. Creepy Trainers
A few of the trainers in Pokémon come across as a bit weird without being controversial. For one, the fact that they just stand around, staring into space, often in quite unusual formations. As the graphics have improved, this has only looked stranger.
There’s also the bonkers dialogue often wedged in there, like the Youngster who runs up to excitedly tell you ‘I like shorts!’. Again though, these aren’t all that controversial. Sometimes though, the NPC dialogue crosses the line between strange and becomes a bit off putting for what is, after all, a children’s game.
In the original Red/Blue/Yellow games, there was an old man who sat outside Celadon’s gym as a peeping Tom, staring at the pretty girls inside. In Let’s GO!, this was changed so he told you about the "strong trainers inside", with no reference to their looks or gender.
In Pokémon X & Y, there’s another, decidedly more adult moment with a creepy trainer. One of the NPC trainers is a Swimmer, who jokes that the place she keeps her Pokéballs is a ‘woman’s secret’. The trainer writing doesn’t need to be stellar, but this moment feels very out of place nonetheless.
6. Tommy Propositions Misty
This is an example of a preemptive change which was definitely for the best. The episode in question, The Kangaskhan Kid, stars Tommy, a boy raised by Kangaskhan in the style of Tarzan. He’s obviously not as polite as a child with a normal upbringing would be, but still, there are limits.
In the Western dub, he stumbles out of the bushes and eyes Misty, Ash and Brock up and down before asking brusquely ‘you people or Pokémon?’, which Misty takes offence to. After a slapstick bonk on the head, Ash tells them they’re people and the episode moves on with a light chuckle.
In the original Japanese version though, Misty had a much better reason to be annoyed. Instead of eyeing them all up and down, he stares directly at her chest and asks ‘"Can I suck breast?"
It’s obviously some kind of breastfeeding joke, but is also way too sexual for the intended audience, and his prolonged stare suggests infatuation too.
The whole thing raises another issue regarding the female characters’ body types considering their canon age, but that gets its own entry coming up shortly.
5. Ash Threatened At Gun Point
Directly after The Kangaskhan Kid, there was another anime related controversy. The Safari Zone warden threatens Ash at gunpoint, even pointing it at the camera. He later fires at Team Rocket too, and even though he misses, it was deemed too violent and was never aired outside of Asia.
It probably didn’t help that Team Rocket then capture him at gunpoint, meaning gun related imagery takes up a hefty chunk of the runtime.
Though it’s clear to see why this was considered too much, it is a little inconsistent. In the previous episode, Officer Jenny points a rifle at Ash, only lifting it when she realises the gang aren't poachers.
Earlier episodes show Team Rocket committing a robbery with firearms, with multiple townspeople pulling guns on Ash when they mistake him for Team Rocket too. Overall, it’s not a decision too many people objected to, but there’s definitely some inconsistencies in the censor’s reasoning.
One of the most frustrating parts about the episode being cut was that it featured Ash catching a herd of Tauros, which unlike a lot of his Pokémon, he keeps. This means that out of nowhere, Ash has a bunch of new Tauros which the dubbed versions never explain.
4. Nudity
Following on from the sidestepped controversy that The Kangaskhan Kid’s original dialogue would have caused, it’s important to remember that Misty’s canonical age ranges from 10-12, apart from in the Gold and Silver games which show her to be slightly older.
Therefore, it’s strange and unsettling that she’s shown in various heavily sexualised poses in the manga. While her anime persona is much more innocent, her body type is hardly correct for her age.
Jessie of Team Rocket, canonically older and therefore permitted to be more adult anyway, still had substantial breast reduction in the Western manga to avoid the novels being too obscene.
The manga tends to get away with more, seeing as it was intended for more mature audiences anyway rather than children. While that might excuse Jessie, it doesn’t make Misty’s depiction any better.
Finally, for maximum weirdness the episode Beauty & The Beach shows James of Team Rocket wearing inflatable breasts, jiggling them while mocking Misty. Ash, Brock and some creepy old guy don’t seem put off though, as the three of them openly ogle Misty in the bikini. Unsurprisingly, this episode was only shown once outside of Japan.
The nudity trend continues into the trading cards too...
3. Inappropriate Trading Cards
There were three cards in particular which have caused controversy for The Pokémon Company over the years, and all three were changed for Western release. Two follow a similar theme, while the other one appears to come out of nowhere but does seemingly have more justification.
As should maybe be expected by now, the first two cards feature nudity, again with underage girls. Staryu’s card features it being held by a naked Misty for some reason, while Grimer is just a grubby pervert.
In the West, Grimer’s card has it peeking out of a sewer like a cheeky little Oscar the Grouch. In Japan though, his eyes are clearly tilted so he’s looking up a schoolgirl’s skirt.
Now for something completely different: Golbat’s card. No nudity is involved, but the topic is if anything even more sensitive, with what appears to be a Nazi swastika in the top left corner.
In fairness, this symbol is used to signify peace or celebration in Asia, even sometimes used for various holidays in China. However, knowing the significance of the symbol in the West, it was replaced by a completely different shape. Unfortunately, that’s not the only time Nazi imagery has featured in Pokémon...
2. Nazi Salutes
While the swastika on Golbat’s card can be somewhat explained away, other examples of Nazi imagery in the Pokémon franchise are much more obvious.
Before we get onto the big controversial one, there’s another similar to Golbat’s card. Registeel’s original sprite seemed to show him giving the classic Nazi salute, which was changed to show both arms down in the Western version.
The anime though was quite clearly referencing the Nazi party, and while it was a tongue in cheek reference which clearly painted them as bad guys, it was deemed too lighthearted a take on a serious topic and the Western version of the episode was heavily edited.
In the episode All Things Bright & Beautifly!, there’s a sequence involving Team Rocket which sees Jessie, James, Meowth and an army of grunts all giving the Nazi salute. For the Western version, the grunts have their arms lowered, while James’ angle changes and Jessie raises both of hers. Meowth’s remain the same, though it’s hard to tell it’s a Nazi salute without context.
If that wasn’t enough, Meowth even dresses up as Hitler in another episode, though as this is the one with all the guns, it was already banned.
1. Protest Groups
Three major groups have had it in for Pokémon since the beginning, all for completely separate reasons. Strange, as all three groups are usually known for being so relaxed and carefree.
First up, the Christian church. The game’s characters have been compared to demons, and the inspiration from myths, supernatural beings or eastern religion has been called blasphemous. Then of course there’s evolution... but thankfully in 2000, the Pope placed on record that the church had no problem with the ‘inventive imagination’ involved in the Pokémon games.
Next up are PETA, who even made a mock up game called Pokémon Black & Blue which highlighted the "animal fighting" nature of the gameplay. The activists were roundly mocked for priorities, and promptly went back to booing Steve Irwin on his anniversary. Stay classy, PETA.
Finally, somewhat contrasting both the Christian church’s standpoint and the fact that Nazi imagery has popped up more than once, Pokémon has been accused of promoting Zionism by the Saudi Arabian government.
Zionism is a complex and sensitive issue about the protection of the state of Israel, but apparently the Pokémon games are full of secret, stone mason-esque symbols designed to brainwash kids into promoting the Jewish agenda.
Who knew?