It's safe to say, as we head into the home stretch of 2014 the journey here hasn't been a smooth one. In fact, looking back the majority of the year appears more like a giant black void with the occasional spike of life through the likes of Watch Dogs or Titanfall whipping people up into a stupor, only to fade away again. The reason for the lull was apparently due to developers not being totally sure the consumer base actually wanted new consoles - only to be caught shorter than Tyrion Lannister when last year's sales figures came rolling in. They've suitably picked themselves back up even though it's taken most of the year, and now as the lead-in to Christmas kicks into overdrive, we're getting a steady stream of must-have titles. Showing that the industry itself is slowly shovelling coal back into the triple-A furnaces and giving us our yearly instalments of both Call of Duty and Assassin's Creed is all well and good, but it remains that the general sentiment shared amongst gamers across the year was that of dusty consoles and wasted potential. It doesn't help that one of our most celebrated developers who so many were relying on to deliver another landmark title in gaming history essentially dropped the ball when it came to customer satisfaction either...
10. Destiny's Budget Vs. End Product
Not to get caught in too much of a ruckus, but there are a few home truths that need to be said about Destiny, because for all the things it does very well, we need to face up to the fact that it's a 500 million dollar video game, released to a rabid and loyal fanbase, with the sole intention being to sell additional content back to the consumer over the next few years. We always get rather annoyed at any other property or developer when they do this - Bioware got it right in the neck after Mass Effect 3 - but somehow Bungie have managed to emerge rather unscathed. Take one quick glance at the promotional materials and you'll see cutscenes that weren't actually in the game, along with flat-out lies from the designers purporting to how 'every gun would have a story' alongside alluding to a gigantic world to explore that ended up as just four relatively small areas. Back to that budget though. It's the most expensive title in not just gaming but entertainment history, and aside from some incredibly proficient shooting mechanics there's a wealth of off-putting elements like the terrible voice-acting, dire story, half-baked multiplayer voiceover, lack of maps, and the reliance that blind-faith gamers will wring as much content as possible out of it regardless.
9. Microsoft's Kinect Backpedal
Remember all the Kinect games from this year's E3? Yeah, us neither. 2014 was finally the year when the industry caught up to, well, common sense, in realising the vast majority of people don't want to control their experiences with motion controls - especially by contorting their entire bodies. With even the Wii U being mentioned in passing these days, it's showing that like 3D movies this sort of gimmickry only lasts for so long before the novelty wears off. For the Kinect though it didn't even work as advertised on day one, not remotely being able to register movements to anywhere near the accuracy shown in the advertisements. It led to some hilariously awful press conferences and demos where developers couldn't get it to work, and even the initial showing of the 'new Kinect' last year was staged to make it look more responsive than it actually was. So it's no surprise that Microsoft finally had to acknowledge the tens of thousands of middle fingers standing promptly in front of them, doing away with the thing as if it never existed in the first place. A new Kinect-less console bundle was released, motion games were dropped from their lineup, and any mention of voice-controlled anything is about as relevant as the fourth Indiana Jones movie. The only casualties apart from a handful of dreamers who'd convinced themselves the kit actually worked (and Microsoft's original dev team) have been Guitar Hero/Rock Band-creators Harmonix, who were developing Disney's Fantasia: Music Evolved specifically for the device, only to release it to a world hating its core mechanic from the get-go.
8. Bioshock Creator Ditches Almost Entire Studio
It's all too easy to focus on one particular team member out of a sizeable crew when discussing some games; The Last of Us gets Neil Druckmann, Escape From Monkey Island tends to be Tim Schafer, and Bioshock is easily Ken Levine. These people definitely have a huge impact on their titles, but it's rare they have so much sway as to shake up an entire company in the process. Now you might think after producing a string of some of the most influential and talked-about games in the entire industry with a dedicated crew of people, you'd form something of a bond with them. Although this is pretty much the case with Levine and some of his team, back in February he elected to pick just 15 of them to start a new venture with - citing that "Irrational has grown larger and more successful than we could have conceived". It wasn't without a grace period, as Levine mentioned the studio would remain open for a couple more weeks for the staff to prepare their portfolios, as well as providing them with financial support. Now we don't know about you, but if we were working for a large company, only for the creative head of said company to take off, picking and choosing a select few to accompany him before leaving you behind, we'd be pretty miffed. Levine did his best to quell the general furore around the announcement, and maybe sometimes you just have to do what's best for you, regardless of anything. But still, this makes for a very dividing piece of news that left people wondering what they would do in his position.
7. Head Of Steam Gets Issued Death Threat... By Developer
Say what you like about the accessibility of Valve's Steam service in terms of how easy it is to get anything on there these days, but we'd imagine if you did to get your creative vision for a title up to potentially sell a few million copies, you'd be jumping for joy. Not the case for Paranautical Activity developer Mike Maulbeck, who in a fit of rage at seeing his game wrongly labelled as 'Early Access' on launch day, tweeted out a series of defamatory statements, ending by firing one right at the boss himself Gabe Newell, which he then retracted. It was all too late though, as once something's out on the internet there's no going back. Valve got in touch with Maulbeck and terminated his account, pulling the game from the service altogether. Not only that, but Maulbeck ended up having to resign, giving up his share in the company as well as being a figurehead or having any creative input. He fully apologised in a lengthy blog post where he admitted his misconduct, and it's been reported he's tried to at least get the game back on the Steam page for the sake of his colleagues that must have spent endless hours coding the whole thing - but as of yet, no sale.
6. Watch Dogs' Graphics Scandal
Well we say 'scandal', but depending on how much you read into this at the time it'll colour how annoyed you were, still many pointed a very accusatory finger at Ubisoft after the reveal that a markedly better - and advertised - graphics option was actually contained on the disc. So it was though, that even if you could see past the Frankenstein'ing of various other popular franchises together to create the completely hollow main game, there was no denying that the game we had in our hands was nowhere near the version that was advertised - or even unveiled as the initial build two years prior. The reason? Ubisoft stated they had reduced the graphics rendering options for the sake of "performance", something that was royally flipped on its head when PC owners discovered the original settings in the code and switched them back on. Performance was unhindered, shadows burst back into life and the whole thing looked definitively 'next gen'. Ubisoft's response was fairly moot, sticking with the a line of "Well if you want to do that, that's cool, we dunno!" while console owners were stuck with something that looked like a toned down Sleeping Dogs. Throw in a six month delay to get to this reduced state in the first place and the fact that certain art assets around the city - such as train tracks - seemed to have literally been stitched together to make this deadline (making for trains that took 90 degree-angle turns) and the entirety of Watch Dogs felt like a game designed by a bunch of box-ticking businessmen with zero idea of artistry or what makes a game genuinely fun.
5. Hatred's Trailer Reception
The surge of popularity and general sporadic condemnation of video games kind of came and went with the announcement of this, but we wouldn't be surprised if there's a storm on the horizon if and when it finally gets a full release. Hatred is a title inspired by the likes of Postal, where you play a guy who literally just wants to butcher as many civilians as possible. The trailer opens with what sounds like some Columbine-inspired manifesto-speech, before close-ups of knife-stabbings and in-mouth gunshots play out, all in black and white with your protagonist mentioning that he's acting out a "genocide crusade". Tasteful stuff then, yeah? Check it out and see how much you can stomach:Developer Destructive Creations' head Jaroslaw Zielinski has gone on record saying that he just wants to make a game that reverts to how things "used to be" and how he's sick of all the "political correctness" in games - which would be great if GTA V wasn't literally the best selling entertainment property of all time. In response to the completely tasteless and "Hey mom, look at this!" attention-grab of a trailer, game engine-owners Epic Games asked the Polish studio to remove their Unreal Engine logo from it, but since then it still makes you wonder how much we're willing to indulge in when it comes to video game violence. Film has its Human Centipedes, Hostels and Saws, and along with older titles like Night Trap or Custer's Revenge, 2014 is adding Hatred to that fly-circling pile.
4. DriveClub's Launch Day Server Problems
Another major release, another launch day server crash. When EA and Rockstar can't align the coding planets for Battlefield 4 or GTA V respectively, there's little hope for us. Still, even Sony proved that despite rigorous pre-release testing on simulated servers, Driveclub's momentous launch had a list of necessary online features totally broken. The 'free' Playstation Plus version is still delayed a month later too, and being it was set to be the first PS Plus release that wasn't a side-scroller more at home on your phone, that could've been a very big deal. The vast majority of racing games tend to be used by the bigger companies to show off their newest tech by rendering the shiniest car possible for whatever year they debut in. After leading the initial PS4 press materials with this new flagship franchise, Sony are still pushing the full retail edition, despite it not working to spec. It's pretty shocking stuff really, considering the always-wavering faith people have in their new machines. The idea of finally ponying up the cash for something you've been looking forward to for over a year, only for it to sit on loading and crash screens for the majority is more reason the retail edition should join the PS Plus one in the pits for now.
3. Violence In Video Games (Shockingly) Not Cause Of Aggression
You wouldn't know it from looking at the likes of Hatred or to a lesser extent the head-popping - and hugely enjoyable - Shadow of Mordor, but with the increased fidelity in graphical quality along with some more tactile-feeling control methods, games are still not little indoctrination machines, systematically breaking down any who play them and rebuilding them into desensitised narcissists with a penchant for saying the worst thing possible. At least not all of us anyway, we're going to get to #GamerGate in a moment. Anyway, in another shocker of a revelation where scientific research caught up to what gamers have known for years, Oxford researcher Dr. Andrew Przybylski pointed out in his April study that it's not the depictions of violence on screen that lead us so spread vitriol on the internet, break a controller or have other aggressive tendencies - it's the idea of not being able to control what's happening on screen. It's true too, how many times have you raged at the screen for swearing blind that you hit a command like a dodge button, only to get skewered in half anyway? To throw in our own two cents here, it's easy to say we're fairly desensitised to depictions of violence in the media these days anyway - just look at your average nightly news report - and instead 'gamer rage' or violent mindsets stem from, as Przybylski mentions "This need to master the game far more significant than whether game contained violent material." It's in the idea of becoming proficient at a game and having it stolen from you by a 'cheap' boss or enemy, or feeling like the game isn't fair that riles us up, not the very sight of some claret or a severed torso. Comforting, perhaps? You might be screaming "Duh!" at the screen at this point, but this is a worthwhile distinction to be made, so we recommend checking out link in the above text, alongside bringing this up whenever anyone attempts to pull the whole "Violence in video games is the antichrist" shtick again.
2. Censorship In South Park: The Stick Of Truth
It's an age-old mindset that exemplifies how much you can make somebody want something - just simply tell them they can't in the first place. Whilst that's not always applicable to every instance, when it comes to Obsidian's long-awaited South Park RPG The Stick of Truth, players throughout Europe and Australia were very annoyed by the fact that their copies of the game were censored in certain areas, whereas the American version shipped as intended. Sure the scenes people were 'fighting for' were nothing more than gory depictions of anal probing and abortion, but it's more about the principality of another party deciding what a mass group of people should be 'allowed' to see or interact with. We had the same problem back in 2005 with The Punisher, as its interactive torture scenes were deemed far worse than something like Manhunt - who let you suffocate a dude with a plastic bag sure, but it was an animation, not something you controlled with the analogue sticks, which was far worse apparently. These are the big differentiations the industry has had to go through over the years - it makes you realise just how farcical a lot of this stuff is. In South Park's case writers Matt Stone and Trey Parker ended up writing some pretty hilarious blurbs that would surmise the events you weren't allowed to see, popping up on the Australian version to the accompanying picture of a crying koala at the exact moment where the game would go 'too far'. Included in these 'censored' versions of the game was still a boss fight against a giant Nazi, "Heil Hitler"-spouting foetus too... prompting the question as to what discussion was had on its inclusion in comparison to what was censored. That's definitely a conversation we'd love to hear.
1. #GamerGate
Sadly apart from the lack of games for the majority of it, 2014 is most likely going to be remembered for the year when feminist Anita Sarkeesian was threatened with being responsible for a mass school shooting if she opened her mouth, along with female game industry workers having their personal details shared online, and the systematic breakdown of one Zoe Quinn's private life. Now we've done quite a bit of GamerGate coverage since everything kicked off, and there's definitely a thin veil of right-meaning individuals amongst all the disgusting stuff that floats to the surface. But like the Occupy Wall Street movement, many can get behind a nebulous call for 'change' - it's when it comes to actually developing a strategy with clear goals that the entire thing falls apart. The real problem 'GamerGaters' face in all this is your average person on the street doesn't understand what the cause is for, not to mention scratching at the surface reveals two entirely separate arguments - one about ethics in journalism needing to be clearer, and the other about the portrayal of women in games themselves. The two are only tangentially related in regards to industry females being targeted by vile abuse-throwing keyboard lunatics, but the comparisons stop there. It's a confusing debate to wrap your head around from the outside, but with everyone from Giant Bomb to Polygon weighing in (the latter changing their review structure to show more transparency in their business practice) both sides of the GG blade continue to be pulled apart. Which of these rattled your cage the most, or are there any total ground-shakers we missed? Let us know in the comments!