Nowadays your face is everything. An actor like Lon Chaney, The Man Of A Thousand Faces, was indispensable in the early days of Hollywood, making his way as a consistently credible actor who could nonetheless utterly transform himself using prosthetics, make-up and performance so as to render himself totally unrecognisable, being absorbed completely into any role he was cast in. Thats not so much of a worry in the modern entertainment industry. In fact the opposite is true, with face rather than name recognition being the driving force behind getting people to go see films, to buy albums, to tune into TV shows, to shell out for perfume, cars, clothes, you name it. Selfies are the primary form of communication for a reason. Its all about the face. At a time when likenesses are at such a premium, the entertainment industry is naturally inclined to make as much use of famous faces to make as much money as possible. At the same time, celebrities have to be constantly on their guard so that their brand isnt being diluted by lookalikes appearing on every billboard, screen or stage in the world. And yet, on more than one occasion, theyve slipped up. Theyve not guarded their looks quite as well as they should, or somebodys gotten cocky enough to think they can get away with pinching it. Video game dopplegangers, movie magic, and a con man pretending to be Stanley Kubrick all figure into the ten celebrities who had their likenesses stolen.
10. George S Patton
Perhaps the strangest (at least the most recent) celebrity lawsuit against a company that unlawfully used their likeness is somebody who is dead. Yep, a ghost filed a lawsuit. Actually it was CMG Worldwide - which acts as a kind of copyright-holder for dead celebrities - who actually kicked up a legal fuss on behalf of General George S Patton, but still. He didnt pull many punches in life and apparently death is no barrier to his combatative nature, with GMC suing the makers of a real time strategy game that came out four years ago. Not very quick off the mark, but more than making up for it by claiming that History: Legends Of War: Patton wrongfully misappropriates the persona of a historical figure. Theyd probably have more of a case for crimes against semi-colons but no matter. Its actually all about money, since they may not necessarily have a leg to stand on with the game depicting a historical figure. Fair use or something. No, GMC wanna protect their right to sell Pattons likeness in any future video game, like maybe a FPS based on Dr Strangelove.
9. Manuel Noriega
At least Patton has a likeness (and a reputation) worth protecting. More perplexing is the former military dictator of Panama from 1983 to 1989 deciding that the way he was characterised in a Call Of Duty game was a step too far, electing to take Activision to court over his appearance in Black Ops II. Noriega had sought damages from a Californian court which, when you know his human rights record, is pretty rich. "This was an absurd lawsuit from the very beginning and we're gratified that in the end, a notorious criminal didn't win," said Rudy Giuliani, the former mayor of New York, who for some reason defended Activision in the case. The court eventually ruled that, again, the character based on Noriega was protected under free speech laws. Its probably worth pointing out that during all this said Panama dictator was (and currently still is) serving a jail sentence in for crimes committed during his time in power, including money laundering and murdering anybody who didnt agree with him. Couldnt happen to a nicer guy.
8. Lindsay Lohan (But Not Really)
Right now video games appear to be the hotbed of famous people having their likenesses nabbed, because apparently after youve come up with Mario, Sonic and Bubsy designers are all out of ideas. Much easier to just go on Wikipedia and grab the first despot/hero (depending on your point of view) who looks like theyd be a good player character or villain in your hyper-violent war simulator. Then theres Lindsay Lohan, who reckons that blonde in the bikini that was emblazoned on all the marketing materials for Grand Theft Auto V was a spitting image for her. Which, yknow, she really wasnt, with many internet commenters initially thinking it was actually model-turned-actress Kate Upton whod been digitally painted over for the illustration. That didnt stop Lohan from filing a lawsuit against Rockstar and Take Two Interactive claiming the characters an "unequivocal" reference to her. Thats despite Rockstar coming out and disclosing the fact that they hired another model to essentially trace for the Lacey Jones character, and why would Lohan want to be associated with a character whos meant to be a narcissistic, anorexic and idiotic struggling actress?
7. Karen Gravano
Rockstar are no strangers to controversy, routinely courting it in the Grand Theft Auto games to various degrees of success. Then there are the times they appear to ruffle feathers without even intending to, as seems to be the case with both the Lindsay Lohan thing (which has long since been thrown out of court) and a similar lawsuit filed by Karen Gravano. Who is Karen Gravano, you may well be asking yourself. Who indeed? A similar question may have been asked by the courts. Shes one of the stars of the reality television programme Mob Wives which, to be fair, does sound like a pretty good TV show. Like, more exciting than the Real Housewives of wherever, if not quite at the level of Rupaul's Drag Race. Gravano was seeking $40 million in damages because of the character of Antonia Bottino, one of those random-encounter NPC missions who complains about having spent time in witness protection thanks her father, mob boss Sammy 'Sonny' Bottino. Gravano went through a similar thing thanks to her dad but, really, there the similarities end.
6. Frank Sivero
Apparently in between shaking down bookies, getting laundromats to pay protection and stealing cannoli from people theyve just shot the mafia still find time to go to court a bunch. Youd think thats the last place people connected to organised crime but wanna spend their time, but there is overwhelming evidence to the contrary, with Frank Sivero being another prime example. Okay, so to save him from spending more time in a courtroom with defamation charges, he isnt actually a mobster himself. Instead hes an actor who played a mobster, by the name of Frankie Carbone, in Martin Scorseses peerless Goodfellas. Which hes fine with because hey, who wouldnt be? The real problem is The Simpsons. Louie, a member of the Springfield chapter of the mafia under Fat Tony, is quite clearly based on Siveros character from the film. Which would be fine for a one-off Goodfellas spoof, but Louie quickly became a recurring character who turned up any time Fat Tony did. So maybe he was justified in filing a lawsuit asking for $250 million from Fox for misappropriation of likeness, infringement of the right of publicity, misappropriation of ideas, and interference with prospective economic advantage.
5. Axl Rose
After that brief sojourn into the legal wranglings of Springfield (nothing actually came of that since the voice of Louie claimed he was more based on Joe Pesci from Goodfellas, and anyway Frankie Carbone was based off a different real person), its back to the crazy world of video games and stolen celebrity likeness. Except this one is a little trickier. Remember Axl Rose? He used to be in a popular rock band in the early nineties called Guns N Roses, and then he was in an unpopular rock band in the noughties called Guns N Roses and he had braided hair and had long since replaced the original line-up of the band in favour of one who would put up with him being late for concerts cos he was busy eating a full turkey backstage. It was that disagreement with his former bandmates that had him suing Activision for $20 million a few years ago. Apparently the developers had agreed not to feature the likeness of his former friend, now hated rival Slash in Guitar Hero 3 for them licensing the song Welcome To The Jungle, which wound up being boohockey and the court threw it out, obviously.
4. Kim Kardashian
Theres this weird trend with commercials these days where if the company in question dont get what they want, they simply produce a cheap copy instead. Theres tons of examples of adverts that have tried to license certain songs, the band have turned them down, and instead theyve just hired a soundalike thats basically the same tune, only with different lyrics. Pretty cheeky. The stranger development is when adverts hire what are essentially lookalikes to endorse products when they cant get the real thing, as was the case with American clothing store Old Navys "Super C-U-T-E" campaign, starring actress Melissa Molinaro as a woman being hounded by the paparazzi wherever she goes. Whilst dressed in Old Navy, obviously.The problem was that Molinaro bore a striking resemblance to Kim Kardashian, somebody who isnt averse to the odd endorsement and is also used to being followed by tabloid photographers. The similarities were pretty obvious to anybody paying attention, with Kardashian filing a $20 million lawsuit for violating her "right to publicity".
3. Kurt Cobain, Joe Strummer, Joey Ramone, And Sid Vicious
Surely the mother of all such stolen celebrity likenesses in adverts was the spectacularly wrongheaded campaign by Doc Martens who decided to harness their reputation as the footwear of choice for true punks with a series of TV spots where musical heroes Joey Ramone, Joe Strummer, Sid Vicious and Kurt Cobain all hung out in heaven together. Wearing Doc Martens. With hokey little angel wings strapped to their backs. Using dead musicians (many of whom died under particularly tragic circumstances) to hawk footwear seemed to be in pretty bad taste to begin with before you even get to the fact that the company apparently didnt ask anybody involved if it was okay to use their likenesses. Supposedly the logic was that dead men tell no tales, and they dont demand to be consulted before making endorsements? We wanted to communicate that Dr Martens boots are 'made to last,' and we discovered that these idolised musicians wore them. Showing them still wearing their Docs in heaven dramatised the boots' durability perfectly. And, as images, they feel very iconic, was their reasoning. Courtney Love rightly kicked up a fuss, and the whole campaign was pulled.
2. Stanley Kubrick
And now for something completely different. Popular culture is riddled with examples of big companies using the identities of famous people in order to squeeze more money out of them (even when theyre dead, most chillingly), but how about when individuals give it a go? Such is the case with Alan Conway, who spent the better part of a decade pretending to be Stanley Kubrick. The genius director of - amongst other things - 2001: A Space Odyssey, The Shining and Eyes Wide Shut had moved to England early on in his career, but was a recluse who had been absent from the public eye for a good 15 years before Conway started his long con. His thinking was that nobody would remember what he looked like, opting for a clean shaven look as a misdirect since Kubrick had worn a beard during the sixties. Conway actually managed to pull the scam off for a while, convincing members of the entertainment industry that he was Kubrick to get free meals, drinks and the like. Dream big, eh? Kubrick's lawyer was notified of the scam and Conway swiftly reprimanded, with his story later being turned into the film Colour Me Kubrick starring John Malkovich.
1. Crispin Glover
Perhaps the most famous of all celebrity likeness swipes was also one of the most groundbreaking, setting the standard for all ensuing lawsuits pertaining to Hollywood trying to nab off with peoples faces. Not literally, of course. Face/Off remains but a beautiful dream of what could be, rather than a reality. Crispin Glover starred as George McFly, ineffectual father of Michael J Foxs Marty, in the original Back To The Future film. Unfortunately the infamously eccentric Glover and the producers did not agree on terms for him to appear in the sequels, so the role of the character was greatly reduced and recast. Deciding to keep more continuity than they bothered with Martys girlfriend - who was played by Claudia Wells in the first film, and Elisabeth Shue in the second - director Robert Zemeckis used footage of Glover filmed for the first movie combined with new footage of Jeffrey Weissman wearing a false chin, nose and cheekbones to look more like him. Glover was billed as "George McFly in footage from Back to the Future" in the closing credits, a cheeky little nod to Zemeckiss admittedly ingenious solution which wasnt enough to put the actor off of suing the studio on the grounds that they did not own his likeness. Subsequently, there are now clauses in the Screen Actors Guild collective bargaining agreements to the effect that this is no longer permitted. The worrying thing being that it took until Back To The Future Part IIs release in 1989 for Hollywood studios to be stopped from owning actors likenesses...