10 Challenges That Ruined Video Games

When extra grind becomes a mood killer.

By Greg Hicks /

There's a simple pleasure in finishing a good game, yet sometimes we strive for more. That little extra challenge or maybe a second playthrough on a higher difficulty, it's alluring at times. Even more so if there are achievements or trophies tied to it.

Advertisement

What isn't fun, however, is when a game or series adds a challenge that's just too much. Whether it be an insane amount of grinding to achieve completion, or something far worse like a tacked on progression system that breaks flow.

Whilst finishing a game or level, it can be fun to push yourself to not die. But when it ruins the immersion of the game itself, that's when it becomes tiresome. Or a counterpart that needs a literal game exploit to get the upper hand on, lest players just give up trying.

It's not that the following examples are impossible, or game breaking. They are achievable, should players want to persevere. Instead it's more a case of "Can I be bothered to do this for such little reward?".

Most of the time, the answer is a firm, "Nah". What you are about to read are ten examples of added challenge and/or achievements that just suck the fun out of the game they're in.

You may even feel compelled to try them yourself. Good luck, and don't say we didn't warn you.

10. Trials Rising - Incessant Level Grind

Trials games, in all of their iterations, have had one simple mechanic: do well, unlock more levels. As players progress, the requirements for higher medals becomes steeper, so the need to revisit old tracks and do better arises.

Advertisement

Which is fine, it's how you get better for the increased challenge in tracks.

Fast forward to current times and Ubisoft has, unsurprisingly, slipped some insidious mechanics in there. Like a leveling system.

Whereas before, when players unlocked new tracks based on skill, instead they're now behind level caps. So players could have gold or platinum medals up to this point, yet still need to repeat tracks for paltry experience gain.

It goes completely against the established progression pattern that made Trials great and as such, ruins the "one more go" attitude. Sitting on a bank of medals, but still not being able to progress with them, just ruins the later half of the game.

If there's ever a case example that Ubisoft's "sandbox formula" additions can be a bad thing, it's Trials Rising.

9. Limbo - Die Less Than Five Times

Limbo, Playdead's 2010 Xbox 360 debut, could easily be described as "an experience". It's dark, it's harrowing, and it's got the best/worst giant spider implementation since Resident Evil.

Advertisement

That's not an exaggeration, it still gives me nightmares.

Part of the joy(?) of experiencing this bleak adventure is going in blind, experiencing the twists and turns it brings. Traversing different landscapes, each one rife with puzzle and pitfall in equal measure.

For the hardcore, there's an attached achievement for making it through the game dying no more than five times. If you know the game like the back of your hand, maybe you should attempt it.

But as a first playthrough, it just sucks the fun out of the game. It's impossible for players to take it the nihilistic ambience if they're getting frustrated and quick-restarting before a death counts.

It ruins what Playdead set out to do if players treat death like an inconvenient counter, rather than what makes the hazards of this macabre tale part of the adventure.

8. Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time - Dark Link

It is said that mankind's greatest foe is himself, and in this instance it's very, very literal.

Advertisement

The Water Temple in Ocarina of Time is already regarded as an absolute pain to navigate. Backtracking, raising and lowering water levels, it gets frustrating.

But the zenith is a mid-point sub-boss in the form of Link's dark doppelganger. An exact copy, it even copies every single move players throw at it. It can absolutely frustrating, clanging sword against sword and not getting an attack in edgeways.

Want to try and catch it out with some strafing and backflips? Well, you may as well be doing those in front of a mirror for all the effect it has on the evil shadowy thing before you.

Unless you had a friend of a friend that knew the hammer exploit (being pre-internet for a lot of people), players could be here for a long time.

Attrition and patience can only go so far, with many citing this as a reason for getting stuck at this particular embuggerance in gaming history.

Curse you... other me.

7. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns Of The Patriots - The Legendary Hero

Before the release of the MGS HD collection and its trophies/achievements, fans were crying out for trophy support in Metal Gear Solid 4. Never mind that players had to start a new save to earn them, that wasn't the biggest hurdle.

Advertisement

Having to complete the game a minimum of eight times is.

Whilst there are some fun trophies to unlock, that I won't spoil, it makes it all for naught when you realise the biggest requirement: unlocking forty badges.

Some of which require beating the game on its highest difficulty, not killing anyone, that kind of insanity. In a Metal Gear game, no less.

Oh, and to really butter the crumpet, they don't stack. Hence the need to complete the main game eight times. Have you played MGS4? Some of those cutscenes are massive, let alone the loading times when you try and skip them.

"Not for the faint hearted" is an understatement. This one is for the flat-out masochists. Even I, a self-confessed Metal Gear fan, haven't even bothered with some of these.

It just doesn't look like fun.

6. Mega Man 9 - The Whole Game On One Life

If you thought the Limbo one earlier sounded tough, a little series from Capcom would like to nudge its way in. Mega Man 9, technically the tenth game, was a return to the series' roots laid out in its NES days decades prior.

Advertisement

And by roots, I mean, "Still harder than a stale baguette left in the freezer for a few years".

Completing an 'old school' Mega Man game is hard enough, but the real cherry on the cake with this game is the Invincible challenge. That's right, the entire game from start to finish without dying.

There are some ways around it, relying on the use of save manipulation and the like. It's a knife's edge though, as there's no way of telling if it has been done correctly or not.

However, the last area, Dr. Wily's castle, cannot be manipulated as such. So, save scum away, but it could all be completely wasted by the time players get to the last level.

There are so many hours in the day, and the thought of wasting them at the eleventh hour to see Mega Man pop his robo-clogs seems like an infuriating waste.

5. Fable 3 - Paying Off The Evil

Fable has always been a bit of a quirky series. A light-hearted take on the fantasy genre, it's still managed to mess around with moral choices and consequence throughout.

Advertisement

Which is why it was somewhat funny when the third game gave you the option to "pay off the final boss", as it were. Long story short; big evil roaming land, ultimatum is let it destroy half of your kingdom or pay it a massively large some of money.

It sounds pretty straightforward and binary, yet the catch is that the player is on a time limit. If, and it's a big if, you knew it was coming and had the foresight to save ahead, then it's slightly more enjoyable.

To the unsuspecting, though, it is a ridiculous amount to cough up to keep the evil at bay in such a short time. Worse still, the game will catch you out if you try and accrue money without letting the time pass, making it completely pointless in the end.

On the bright side... at least the kingdom will be slightly quieter with less noisy people around.

4. Red Dead Redemption 2 - Going For Gold(s)

Rockstar, for all their faults, can write a good story. Red Dead Redemption 2, 2018's prequel Western hit, is one of rich and detailed world and narrative.

Advertisement

As such, it should be played naturally, and not rushed. Living out Arthur Morgan's journey is something to take in stride, however missions play out.

So when players think they've done well in a shootout, or a robbery, it's discouraging to see a bronze medal reward at the end. It's even more disheartening to see what the requirements for gold are at times.

A lot of it boils down to speedrunning, effectively. But to rinse through missions is a massive waste of the world that Rockstar have built, but that's not all.

It's also finickity to control in a rush, nor is Arthur built like a tank. Which makes it a rigmarole to die, restart, load a cutscene, then hope for the best.

The game also doesn't tell you the requirement(s) the first time you play it. So, the fact that players will have to do every mission at least twice to gain gold just taints the whole thing.

3. Monster Hunter World - Tempered Tantrum

Monster Hunter, as the title suggests, is all about the hunt. Within each title, they start off small, but by the end players are chasing the most illustrious and magnificent of beasts.

Advertisement

As such, the bigger they are, the easier they fall when you've got a likeminded team of hunters on your side. A problem shared, that kind of thing.

Tempered monsters, introduced in World, are the peak of hunts. The holy grail, the bragging rights. Killing or capturing these is the highest of accomplishments.

Unless, sadly, players got no one to help them with it.

It seems obvious to say, "Don't take on the big nasties solo", but then that implies players have to play online/with others. Conversely, it's not an impossible feat to fell them on one's own.

It is, quite rightly, a highly straining task that will net high reward if you're lucky, but more often than not comes with the hefty fine of reduced loot via way of knockout.

I'm sure the hardcore have done it, but for the everyman hunter, it just isn't worth the hassle.

2. Alan Wake - Too Much Coffee For One Man

Finding hidden collectibles in gaming is usually quite a fun activity. Going off the beaten track to grab something shiny breaks up the main game monotony.

Advertisement

But as games got bigger in scope and size, so did the amount of trinkets to find. Pigeons, drug packets, and in tortured writer Alan Wake's case: coffee thermoses.

One hundred of the beverage counters, dotted about Bright Falls landscape. There must be some really careless hikers around there.

At first, it's fun to see them shining on the horizon, a little light in the dark. But soon after, as set pieces get bigger and enemies tougher, it just becomes more of a grind.

For those intending to do it, there is a tracker in the main menu. However, that's just a total. There's no chapter/act breakdown to tell players which ones they've missed.

So you could be, like me, stuck on 97/100 since its release way back in 2010. What with the remaster now available, that means starting that kleptomaniac habit from flask one again. No thank you, no one needs that much coffee.

1. OlliOlli World - God-Tier Grind

Hot off the press, OlliOlli World is Roll7's latest skateboarding arcade offering. It's adorable, it's colourful... and it's also really difficult to master.

Advertisement

Much like their previous skateboarding titles, OlliOlli World gets progressively harder as tracks go on. Standard, as far as arcade games go. The road to skate wizard mastery is long and thumb-twiddly, but is possible to get through the story relatively cramp-free.

But it's when the main quest is done that Radysus, the skate god, adds some additional challenge to proceedings. Insanely difficult criteria per level, like not using ramps or any grinds.

Or pulling off incredible combos and not wallriding, grinding, or some evil combination to mess with players' heads.

That's a small example. Later tracks, hard already before the added challenge, just become absolutely insane. Bordering impossible, without years of practice.

As it currently stands, the unlock rate for the Platinum trophy stands at 0.0%. That says to me that not even the developers have managed to do it.

So if you are looking for that sweet, sweet 100% completion rate... expect to do a lot of grinding. And kickflipping, etc.

Advertisement