10 Classic Video Games Only Extended By Stupid Enemy Decisions

What if the baddie just shot the good guy when he had him in his sights?

By Jack Pooley /

We've all sat through a classic Bond film and thought "Stop explaining every minute detail of your plan and just kill the guy!", and the same is often true of games as well. Often due to their own arrogance, a video game villain will toy with the weakened protagonist for far too long, giving them a ripe chance to escape, evade death and then vanquish the Big Bad once and for all. It's a trope as old as storytelling itself, and though countless fantastic games would certainly be a lot shorter without a little enemy idiocy, one can't help but imagine what a more realistic depiction of events would have looked like. What if the baddie shot the good guy when he had him in his sights? What if he just thought a little about the possible repercussions of his actions and planned accordingly? Instead, these bad guys demonstrated no foresight whatsoever, and the result was their own downfall. Are there any we missed? Or do you disagree with any entries on this list? As ever, the comments are always at your disposal!

10. Not Killing John Marston's Son - Red Dead Redemption

We were all gutted when outlaw John Marston was brutally cut down at the end of Red Dead Redemption, double-crossed by Bureau agent Edgar Ross, who had promised to let him go of his duties, but shot him down in a hail of bullets. "Fair enough", you might think, in terms of tying up loose ends, and Ross came so close to perfectly executing his villainous scheme, but there's one thing he underestimated, and that's the vengeful spirit of John's son, Jack. Three years later, the game's epilogue has the player taking control of Jack, in one final assassination mission to take down Ross, one in which Jack comes out the victor. Still, it's a move Ross should have easily been able to foresee. Would he not expect that sometime down the line, be it 3, 5, 10 or 20 years from now, a more mature Jack would want bloody revenge? Instead, Ross took no precautions to protect himself, and so was stupidly cut down for it.

9. Saddler Revealing The Plan To Leon - Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4 is arguably the best game in the series, refining the gameplay mechanics as it did so brilliantly. However, it's tainted somewhat by the drudgery of having to constantly care for, protect and hide the President's daughter, Ashley Graham, a feeble, whiny, near-useless character who only serves to make the game more challenging. She is kidnapped by a satanic cult in the middle of nowhere, and Leon S. Kennedy is sent in to retrieve her. What surprises me is how easily Leon is able to locate her in the early stages of the game, discovering her holed up in a chapel. Now, some might argue that this is merely part of the deception, as moments later, Osmund Saddler explains that the goal is actually for Ashley to be taken back to the US safe and sound, because she's secretly infected with the Plagas, and this will cause a catastrophe when she returns. It's a quite brilliant plan, really, but the stupidity is in explaining this to Leon, perhaps out of arrogance that he wouldn't possibly be able to get her cured. Still, why tell him when you can just let him escape with Ashley, and the pair of them (because Leon's infected, too) can cause a nationwide epidemic on their return to the US? The beauty of the plan is its simplicity, and yet Saddler basically ruined it all with his big mouth, because the pair then made sure to cure themselves before leaving the island.

8. Not Sending A Fleet Of Troops At Mario - Any Mario Game

This one's simple and akin to the same sort of complaints made about every single martial arts movie ever - "why don't they all attack him at once?" The Mario games see the Italian plumber protagonist darting through dozens of crazy platforming levels to reach Bowser, who litters each map with a finite number of his foes who can, for the most part, be easily taken to task a few at a time. The question is, then, why Bowser doesn't just hurl 50 of them at him at once, as that would surely be too much for even the great Mario to take on? I'm surprised this one hasn't been subverted more in the Mario franchise. Wouldn't it be cool to play through a Shenmue-esque QTE sequence in which you have to take down a horde of enemies totaling more than Mario has ever faced at once before?

7. Stripping The Earth Of Billions Of Souls, But Missing Out The World's Greatest Fighters - Mortal Kombat III

Shao Kahn is one of the few video game villains to take a step back from his failures in the previous game and actually come up with a half-decent plan to win this time. The plan involves resurrecting his darling Queen Sindel by reviving her in Earthrealm rather than Outworld, as this allows Kahn to step out from Outworld into Earthrealm, reclaim Sindel, and also steal billions of human souls at the same time. Of course, Lord Raiden manages to save a few souls, and these just happen to be the very fighters badass enough to stop Kahn. It's just difficult to buy the fact that Kahn was able to absorb billions of souls yet seemingly wasn't powerful enough to capture the precious few who stood a chance against him. Anyway, it's lamely convenient storytelling more than anything.

6. Failing To Kill Max When He Is Unconscious - Max Payne 2: The Fall Of Max Payne

Max Payne 2 begins with Max waking up, scarcely conscious, in a hospital, and is a pivotal moment later on in the game's story. Most of MP2 sees Max chasing down The Cleaners, a gang of contract killers, and complicating matters is the interference of Detective Winterson, who impedes Max's investigation by trying to bring down his uneasy partner and love interest, Mona Sax. After Max and Mona take out some of the Cleaners, Winterson arrives and tries to bring Mona in, so Max shoots Winterson to allow Mona to escape. However, in her final moments, she lets a shot out at Max, who is put in hospital as a result. He wakes up and has to shoot his way out of the hospital, but isn't it awfully convenient that nobody was able to get to Max for what is presumably a considerable amount of time while he's taken to hospital? The Cleaners are otherwise so efficient at chasing Max around New York, yet when he's at his weakest, they can't quite make it there in time, despite how many of these guys there are to do the job.

5. Ganon Failing To Kill Link - The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina Of Time

During The Ocarina of Time, Link reaches the Sacred Realm inside the Temple of Time and finds the Master Sword, which is capable of destroying all the evil in the world. The problem is that Ganondorf, the game's prime villain, was smart enough to follow Link into the Temple and get the Triforce. However, what he wasn't smart enough to do was kill Link and be done with it. Instead, Link wakes up 7 years later, having learned that his spirit had been sealed until such a time that he was strong enough to use the Master Sword to kill Ganondorf. Of course, Link eventually faces off against Ganondorf and defeats him, when had Ganon not so gravely underestimated a young punk and actually made sure he murdered him on the spot, this all could have been avoided. It might be easy for an egomaniacal fiend like Ganon not to think much of some child, but running him through would have been the safest option. Why leave it to chance or risk?

4. Wesker Doesn't Know When To Cut & Run - Resident Evil

The main twist in the first Resident Evil game is that Albert Wesker is the douchebag double agent working for Umbrella, and he has been recording battle data during Chris, Jill and everyone else's fights with the various monsters littered throughout the mansion. The problem is that he just doesn't know when to quit, because when it became clear that his colleagues were cottoning onto his plans, he should have just shot them on sight. Instead, they fought their way to the foot of the conspiracy, and managed to escape, blowing the mansion sky-high. This is also not to forget that Wesker ends up being impaled by the very Tyrant he unleashes, essentially becoming the test subject he was meant to be setting his co-workers up as. You'd think the guy might have thought about what he was doing a little bit more, but such is madness and greed (as we later find out that Wesker was going to sell the Tyrant to Umbrella's rival).

3. The Didact Believing He's Tougher Than He Is - Halo 4

Halo 4 was mostly a great game, but it did feature the worst villain of the series so far, The Didact, a badass-looking Forerunner Promethean who turns out to be not very badass at all. The final boss fight against the Didact is pitifully short and easy, after which Cortana manages to bind him to the bridge, while Master Chief plants a grenade on him, blowing him off the bridge and sending him hurtling to his demise. It's not so much that the Didact was stupid for being such a bad fighter, but that he clearly believed he was a better fighter than he was. Egotism had gotten the better of him, yet even in the interest of caution, it might have made sense to surround himself (and his prized weapon, The Composer) with as many guards as possible. Instead, he gets his ass kicked and thoroughly outsmarted in an embarrassing, crushing defeat.

2. Not Shooting Gordon When They Captured Him - Half-Life

One of the all time dumbest moments in video game history has to be the Marines' capturing of scientist-turned-badass Gordon Freeman halfway through the brilliant Half-Life. So, when they have him, what do they do? They throw him into a trash compactor of course, because there's no possible means of escape, right? Well, Gordon escapes and subsequently manages to complete his quest, of travelling to Xen and defeating the Nihilanth, and living to fight another day, something which could so easily have been avoided had the HECU soldiers just popped a bullet in his head. It's gross incompetence on a massive scale. Given that the HECU officers had orders to kill any civilians they found in order to cover up the Black Mesa incident, dumping him with the trash is a Bond villain-esque folly of epic proportions. It could have been over so easily.

1. Not Shooting Solid Snake - Metal Gear Solid

The Metal Gear Solid games feature a complex, weaving narrative meaning that often it's difficult to know what characters are truly intending until they reveal it later on in a 15-minute monologue. The premise of Metal Gear Solid is pretty loopy, in that Liquid Snake, under the guise of Solid Snake's old buddy Master Miller, allows Solid to make it all the way to their operation, in the hope that he will inadvertently use the PAL card to arm nuclear robot Metal Gear REX, which is exactly what happens. However, Snake manages to defeat REX, at which point any normal villain might think, "Hmmm, maybe I better just shoot this guy?", but instead, Liquid challenges Snake to a fistfight atop Metal Gear REX, which Liquid loses, and even when he finally decides to shoot Solid after a catastrophic car crash, he's claimed by FoxDie before he can pull the trigger. Basically, Liquid was too arrogant, too egotistical and too flat-out stupid to execute his enormously convoluted plan properly. Are there any other absurd enemy decisions I missed? Let me know in the comments!