10 Most Criminally Underrated Games Of The Last Generation

The diamonds in the rough you really ought to give another chance.

By Tom Regan /

There has been no shortage of great games over the course of the last seven year generation, and predictably, ever since the arrival of Sony and Microsoft€™s new consoles, €˜game of the generation€™ lists have been popping up more frequently than Pringles lids. Yet for every obvious choice like GTA V, Bioshock and Super Mario Galaxy, there are thousands more games that remain unlisted and unloved, and while they might not all be masterpieces (although some definitely are), these games still deserve recognition in their own right. Somewhat unthinkably, some of the games included on this list attracted criticisms that just weren't justified, and each remains an enriching addition to the market - far more, in fact, than some of the charlatan titles that populated the most played end of generation lists. There will be games you€™ve probably heard of and others you may not recognise, but all share one thing in common: they unjustly slipped under the radar between bigger releases, and missed out on the acclaim and the accolades they undoubtedly deserved. They are the last generation€™s diamonds in the rough that didn€™t quite get the love that they were surely due, and which now firmly deserve a second look.

10. F.E.A.R. 2

If the Ring films and F.E.A.R have proved anything, it's that little girls with long black hair are absolutely terrifying. In a generation filled with bog standard shooters, F.E.A.R 2 stood out by combining traditional FPS gameplay tropes with elements of nightmarish horror. Like all good scary movies, F.E.A.R plays with its pacing masterfully, meaning that you€™ll never know when the lights around you will suddenly go out, or when evil lurks around the next corner. Because of this (and maybe your unquenchable coffee addiction) in F.E.A.R 2 you€™re always on edge - and you should be. Here looks can be deceiving, and at the snap of a finger reality can become distorted - as the corridor in front of you suddenly opens up into the depths of Hell. Without wanting to give anything away, the story is pretty competent throughout, and allows for some great set ups for scares, but to be honest, the real draw here is the shooting. F.E.A.R 2€™s main gameplay hook is its slow motion shooting mechanic. Initially this feels cool, but somewhat unnecessary, allowing you to watch the blood splurt out of soldiers as you riddle them mercilessly with lead. While at first it just feels like a tool for unleashing gratuitous violence, slow-mo becomes essential to defeating teleporting demons and saving you from other, similarly horrific creatures later in the game. If you ever thought you€™d enjoy Slender more if you were being chased by little girls and shooting demons then this is most definitely the game for you. F.E.A.R 2 is one of the purest horror experiences of the last generation €“ and well worth picking up. Play with headphones in a dark room for the authentic experience (i.e. for added pant wetting trauma).

9. SSX

SSX Tricky was one of the best multiplayer games ever, so naturally its sequel on PS3 and 360 was destined to reclaim that crown, but sadly, EA decided to axe the game€™s local multiplayer. Yes, you read that correctly - a snowboarding game with no local multiplayer. While this may be a depressingly recurring theme for much of the last generation, SSX is a game that was built for local multiplayer and its omission here was a bizarre one. After you come to terms with this depressing fact however, you€™ll realise that SSX is still everything that you€™d hoped an HD snowboarding game would and could be. The game is absolutely stunning to look at, with entrancing lighting illuminating the rider as you traverse beautiful scenery. SSX doesn€™t just bring fancy new visuals to the table though, it also has a greatly improved trick system, and the decision to map grabs and tricks to the shoulder buttons is another welcome addition, making gnarly grabs easier to pull off than ever before. SSX also features a great ghost based online multiplayer mode that keeps you coming back to crush your friend€™s best scores long after you€™ve seen what every peak and slope has to offer. It's not the same as drunkenly elbowing them next to you on the sofa €“ but it's something. If you somehow manage to get bored of the racing and slopestyle modes, you can also try and brave the elements in the new devastatingly hard €˜Survival€™ courses, which see you racing against avalanches, using flying squirrel suits and swearing repeatedly. Whether you€™re looking to relive your PS2 glory days or simply just want to play an amazing spectacle based sports title - SSX is the game for you. Unless of course you want local multiplayer, then it€™s not, but I€™ve accepted that - and I€™m not bitter about it. At all.

8. Bayonetta

If you€™re looking for the evolution of fast paced third person hack and slash games then this is it: forget Devil May Cry 4, forget DMC, forget Ninja Gaiden 3 (you probably already have) €“ this is the game that you want. You play as a witch named Bayonetta, who is a descendant of the ancient Umbra clan but has managed to lose her memory after years of solvent abuse (maybe), and throughout the game you strive to uncover the mysteries of her past, and kick a lot of angel tail along the way. The story doesn€™t really make a lot of sense and there may be too many anime clichés here for some to stomach, but gameplay wise, Bayonetta is the absolute pinnacle of the action genre. The controls have been absolutely nailed in this game, with each attack and combo feeling almost effortlessly responsive and fluid, allowing you to pull off screen filling mayhem with the upmost ease and on screen elegance. Platinum Games seem to have a knack for precision when it comes to action games, and while easy to pick up, this game is hard as nails to master, so good luck completing it on its hardest difficulty. From the incredibly memorable, screen filling boss battles to one of the least offensive use of QTE€™s in gaming, Bayonetta is a near flawless example of how to out DMC, DMC. Action game fans do yourself a favour and buy this sadly under performing classic immediately.

7. Bulletstorm

It€™s not often that games manage to be genuinely funny €“ especially intentionally - but Bulletstorm is one of those delightful rarities. After years of po-faced military shooters, Bulletstorm injects the genre with a much needed dose of over the top humour, and luckily for us the quality of the gameplay actually matches the humour here, which doesn€™t often happen in gaming (Deadpool, anyone?) Being a shooter, the gunplay is obviously pretty key, and as you would expect the guns feel great; heavy and satisfying in a Killzone-esque way. But they€™re not the only tool at the player€™s disposal: you are also armed with a laser whip, and slinging enemies all over the place will never fail to put a grin on your face. Bulletstorm has a unique score based kill system, which encourages you to slaughter enemies in completely over the top ways; using the whip, you can fling enemies into lasers, spikes, off ledges and against walls, transforming the environment around you into one big playground that€™s there to boost your score. Rather than the cliché marine core pep talks of other shooters, Bulletstorm has your squad constantly insulting each other in hilarious ways; when attacked by a huge ugly brute your character yells to your female squad mate €˜Hey Trishka, one of your old boyfriends is at the door€™. The whole game is big, loud and refreshingly silly, and you can operate a remote control, laser shooting, giant Dinosaur. If that doesn€™t sell Bulletstorm to you then nothing will.

6. Tales Of Vesperia

After the JRPG glory days of the PS1 and PS2 , the PSWii60 era has been as disappointing for JRPG fans as Indiana Jones IV was to the movie going public. Luckily for us, Microsoft decided to splash their cash on some JRPG exclusives in a (failed) bid to drive 360 sales in Japan €“ and Vesperia was one of them. Featuring probably the least offensively generic characters of any JRPG, Vesperia offers a great cast of likeable characters and a pretty entertaining story. Harking back to the PS1 glory days and the gamecube classic Tales Of Symphonia, Vesperia continued the tradition of bringing back gripping real time combat to a JRPG, and the battle system is a joy to use throughout. After the crushing disappointment that was FF XIII, Vesperia and Lost Odyssey were the genre's Knights in shining armour, and Vesperia was one of the few last gen games to rival the PS2€™s spectacular JRPG output. Its cell shaded visuals are some of the best of the last generation, and the game is still a feast for the eyes on the ageing 360. If you€™re yearning to step into the boots of some Japanese teenagers and slay hoards of monsters for sixty hours, you can€™t do much better than Tales Of Vesperia.

5. Metroid Prime 3: Corruption

Let€™s face it, while the Wii had some great games, many of them were buried under piles of mini game collections, shovelware and Wii Fit knock offs, and Metroid Prime 3 was one of those sadly neglected games. Continuing the Prime series€™ staple of eerie isolation, Metroid Prime 3: Corruption has a sense of atmosphere that still makes it feel like an entirely unique take on the first person shooter. The game€™s haunting locales and great use of minimal story set it apart from its contemporaries and make it a highly enjoyable and refreshing experience from start to finish. The tight gameplay combined with some great pointer controls, gave us a glimpse into what could have been a glorious Wiimote FPS future. Sadly that was a future that never materialised. This game was not only the best shooter on the Wii, but one of the best FPS€™s of the generation, and if you have a Wii U or an old Wii lying around, you owe it to yourself to play through this forgotten classic.

4. Vanquish

Sadly this is the second Platinum Games developed title on the list: while this game has probably been even more overlooked than Bayonetta, Vanquish is a fast paced joyride of a game. You know when you play a game and the cutscenes end up being infinitely more exciting and action packed than any of the actual gameplay? With Vanquish all the gameplay is as over the top as the cutscenes, as the frantic action throws you into the deep end on the first level and never really lets up from there. The futuristic sheen from the razor ship visuals and extremely fast paced gameplay provide the player with an adrenaline-filled cover based shooter experience that you won€™t soon forget. It€™s not every day that a third person shooter manages to somehow combine the speed of Wipeout with the ferocity of Max Payne... or even more surprising that it works so well. The incredibly fast dash mechanic contrasts with your character€™s slow-mo mechanic perfectly, creating a unique gameplay experience where you always feel completely in control of the carnage you are inflicting on screen. Disengage your brain, ignore the ridiculous story and strap yourself in for 10 hours of pure action-packed fun.

3. Rayman Origins

As you may have garnered from SSX, it€™s rare to find a truly great local multiplayer game in this day and age. Sure, there are the reliable stalwarts of COD and FIFA, but nothing will put a grin on your face after a few beers like four player Rayman. With its gorgeous 2D visual style, hilarious sound effects and tightly honed platforming there are few platformers this generation that rival Origins, aside from its better performing sequel, of course. From the sheer breadth of levels to the creative boss fights, the experience stays varied and compelling right until the final level. Whether you€™re exploring dimly lit underwater caverns, jumping through lush greeneries, or dying repeatedly as you fail to complete the absurdly difficult treasure chest levels -you will always find something new that brings a smile to your face. The replay value is phenomenal here too, with the game challenging you to go back and collect hidden lum lums, beat each level€™s time attack mode or even just making you yearn to replay your favourite levels for the sheer fun of it. If you€™re looking for a pure single player platforming experience or a laugh with three of your mates, you really can€™t go wrong with Rayman Origins. Grab some friends, a case of beer, and put on your Rayman gloves and prepare to be charmed silly.

2. Heavy Rain

There aren€™t many games that make you spend the first half an hour showering, washing the dishes and playing with your kids, and there are even fewer that would capture its gamers while doing so. Yet there€™s something strangely endearing about the tutorial come plot set up, and its subsequent turn into a multi character, Saw inspired murder mystery. Heavy Rain feels unlike anything else in gaming, and while some will detest its QTE reliant, point and click nature, the immersion found in Heavy Rain is unlike any other game you€™ll play. The unique choice based system, the great characters, and the interesting controls create a unique experience that you won't soon forget, and its many different endings will bring you back for repeated play throughs. While footage of the game doesn€™t exactly look exciting, the story is really what carries the experience, and this and its star studded sequel are probably the closest you€™ll get to playing an interactive film. If you want a break from dull grey and brown shooters and a narrative to really sink your teeth into, then this is exactly the palette cleanser you need.

1. Catherine

A Japanese puzzle game about the complexities of adult relationships was never going to set the charts on fire, and predictably €“ this one didn€™t. Catherine is one of those rare games that pulls off being both utterly bizarre and yet completely compelling, somehow managing to combine a surreal nightmare world with one of the most relatable and gripping gaming narratives in recent memory. Putting you in the shoes of Peter Pan-syndromed 30 year old Vincent, you have to choose whether to keep flirting with the sexy and mysterious Catherine, or to settle down with nagging long term girlfriend Katherine. The whole game is about dealing with the inevitability of growing up - and grown men in their underwear racing against dream sheep€ did I mention this was Japanese? The game€™s fiendishly difficult and addictive puzzle sections see you frantically climbing towers , as you constantly pull out blocks to create a path towards the exit €“ all while trying to avoid plummeting to your death. The combination of these demented Jenga-from-Hell sections with the gripping choice based rpg mechanic of the day sections, is unlike anything else in gaming, and ensures that the overall experience stays with you long after you see the credits roll. If you€™re looking for something a bit different do yourself a favour and pick up this criminally overlooked gem. Which other brilliant games that didn't get the love they deserved belong on this list? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.