10 Darkest Stranger Missions In Red Dead Redemption 2

The best, darkest, and strangest Stranger Missions of Red Dead Redemption 2.

By Andy Murray /

From hunting legendary animals and bounties, robbing trains, or spending hours upon hours of fishing in the stunningly realised world, there's plenty to keep players busy in Red Dead Redemption 2 outside of its phenomenal main story missions long after the credits roll.

Advertisement

One such optional activity to occupy your time are the Stranger Missions. A handful of finely crafted side missions revolving around various colourful characters you can stumble upon in the world, it's entirely possibly to finish the game without giving those enticing question marks that appear on your map a second thought - but you'd be doing yourself a massive disservice by doing so.

Ranging from genuinely touching moments that further develop Arthur Morgan's journey for redemption in meaningful ways to the all-out insane, these missions are home to some of the best and most memorable moments in the entire game.

Moreover, in true Rockstar fashion, many of these missions venture into some bleak territory. Whether it's to provide a satirical commentary on an aspect of society or to flex the studio's creative muscles, every one of these missions offers a worthwhile experience.

But which of these Stranger Missions was the darkest?

10. A Fisher Of FIsh

One thing you'll likely spend a lot of time doing during your time with Red Dead Redemption 2 is fishing.

Advertisement

But if it's bigger fish you're after, then you'll want to start the Stranger Mission, A Fisher Of Fish, by chatting to accomplished angler, Jeremy Gill. Handing you a map and requesting you send him all 13 fish, you'll spend hours riding across the entire map to catch them all, some of which can only be accessed during the epilogue.

While catching fish sounds like the furthest thing form being the darkest part of a game contains a vampire, ghosts, and plenty of other strange happenings, sending all the fish to Gill will unlock the final part of the mission where you'll travel with Gill to catch one final fish: the Legendary Channel Catfish.

Described by your companion as the biggest and most dangerous catch yet, you'll be tasked with photographing him when he reels it in.

Unfortunately for Jeremy, though, it's the fish that gets the catch, as it pulls him into the water to his presumed death, leaving only his hat and a special fishing lure behind as your reward.

9. Oh, Brother

While this Stranger Mission is more darkly comedic than macabre, Oh, Brother is nevertheless another shining example of Rockstar's brilliant writing.

Advertisement

Putting you in the middle of a love triangle between two eccentric brothers named Proetus and Acrisus, vying for the affection of a woman named Helen, you can find this mission in Chapter Four after the mission The Gilded Cage.

After this point, all you have to do is make your way to Valentine where you'll find the group outside the General Store as the brothers debate about which one of them is the bravest in an attempt to impress their crush.

Believing you to be a good shot, they rope you into their childish contest by having you shoot bottles off their heads. With each subsequent meeting getting sillier as they raise the stakes, you'll also kick them in the groin and send them over a waterfall in barrels, which almost kills them.

Emerging from their near-death experience, however, the brothers finally understand how foolish they've been; but rather than taking responsibility for their own actions, instead they blame Helen, who was more interested in the brothers’ attention than their safety.

8. The Nobelist Of Men, And A Woman

In a saloon in the small town of Valentine, players can come across one of the first Stranger Missions in the game by talking to one Theodore Levin, a writer interviewing famed gunslinger Jim "Boy" Calloway about his glory days.

Advertisement

However, Calloway is too drunk to be of any use. Consequently, Arthur is sent on a quest to track down four other famed gunslingers to find out more about the true history of Mr Calloway.

Talking to Calloway’s former companions, it transpires that Calloway's reputation as a fearsome cowboy is a complete fabrication.

Unwilling to accept the truth, Calloway has you bring him one of his former rivals so that he can best them in a duel to prove he's still the legend he claims to be. But when the man refuses, Calloway shoots him in the back before challenging and losing to Arthur in a duel.

Rather than writing about what really happened, Levin chooses to lie so he can have a more exciting story.

In a game that romanticises western genre tropes, it just wouldn't be a Rockstar game without turning the image of a gunslinger into a cynical metaphor for celebrity culture and fame.

7. The American Inferno, Burnt Out

Even after the sun sets on Arthur's story, the epilogue still has a handful of strangers for John Marston to come across before he encounters more colourful characters during his own quest for redemption.

Advertisement

One such character is writer Evelyn Miller (someone who gang leader Dutch greatly admired) in the midst of drafting a new manuscript.

After some poignant philosophical conversations with the writer that underline the game's themes of change and industrialisation Miller will decide to lock himself in his cabin in order to complete his book, refusing to eat until the job is done.

Despite delivering food at his door, the author is true to his word. On visiting his cabin in the last part of the mission, you'll find him dead at his desk in front of his completed manuscript, his final words being to burn his body when he's gone so he "can soar with the eagles".

Granting Miller his final request, John sets the cabin alight and watches it burn.

Although it's not the most disturbing part of the game, it nevertheless makes for a bittersweet end to Miller's own story.

6. A Bright Bouncing Boy

Red Dead Redemption 2 is full of many weird and wonderful characters to meet with one of the most memorable of them being eccentric scientist Marco Dragic, who you can find sitting in the park in Saint Denis.

Advertisement

His Stranger Mission, A Bright Bouncing Boy, begins innocently enough as he has you pilot a remote controlled boat in the pond destroying other small battleships as part of a demonstration. It’s a fun distraction leagues apart from Rockstar’s other remote controlled vehicle missions, but it’s the next part where things get weird

Taking up Dragic’s invitation to visit him at his laboratory, he’ll unveil his latest project, a fully-autonomous robot, and ask you for help in bringing his creation to life by placing rods to attract lightning.

The experiment, however, is a failure as the robot breaks after taking a few steps.

Returning to the laboratory to catch-up with Dragic a few days later will reveal the scientist has been murdered and his robotic boy, now nowhere to be seen.

This tragic Frankenstein story isn’t over, though. If you travel deep into the mountains, you can find the robot now sitting alone, mourning the loss of his "father".

5. American Dreams

Within the expansive open world of Red Dead Redemption 2, there are a lot of hidden secrets and strange things to stumble upon.

Advertisement

One such thing you can find during your travels are some grizzly murders where the dismembered bodies are gruesomely displayed next to messages asking you "behold" and "look upon" the perpetrator's efforts. And luckily for you, the murderer has also left a piece of a map next to the body.

Finding one of these three crime scenes after completing Chapter One will start the mission American Dreams. If you're able to find all of crime scenes and recover each map fragment, you'll be able to travel to the serial killer's lair - if you feel brave enough, that is.

Located in the basement of a rundown old shack, the creepy hideout is exactly what you'd expect a deranged serial killer's workshop to look like. Telling notes and skulls line the shelves, with their latest work in progress being displayed in all its gory glory.

Of course, the killer is waiting for you. And if it weren’t for throwing a severed head at him, Arthur could have been the next victim.

This killer is seriously deranged, even for Rockstar's standards.

4. The Mercies Of Knowledge

Rockstar have never been afraid to shine a critical light on various aspects of American society. And in Red Dead Redemption 2 the studio turned their satirical light to the subject of capital punishment.

Advertisement

Venturing to the northeast of Saint Denis, players will be beckoned by one Andrew Bell III who’ll ask them to locate 100 gallons of moonshine for him to complete his invention. Upon delivering his large drink order, he’ll explain that he’s working on an electric chair, a revolutionary invention that will kill criminals in a far more humane way than hanging them.

Having then acquired a permit from the police chief and wrangling a wanted criminal of animal husbandry to be the professor’s guinea pig, you can then make your way to witness the demonstration of this contraption.

Despite the professor’s hyperbolically poetic speech, the demonstration goes horribly wrong, resulting in the criminal dying a long and excruciatingly painful comparable to Delacroix’s execution in The Green Mile.

The biggest irony of this whole ordeal is that Bell, attempting to speed up the process, is electrocuted himself and dies a much quicker and humane death than the unfortunate test subject.

3. A Fine Night For It

From the hordes of hungry alligators, the dense fog that covers the area in a palpably creepy atmosphere, or the ghostly figure that calls this place home, the swamps just north of Saint Denis are a terrifying place, especially at night.

Advertisement

However, none of these things are as nightmarish as the group of killers known as the Nigh Folk who roam the area after sunset, robbing and killing anyone unfortunate enough to cross their path. Hanging their dismembered victims on trees or seen performing violent rituals, encountering the Night Folk is always an unpleasant experience.

After you have the displeasure of being acquainted with them, you'll have the opportunity to get even closer to these terrors in the Stranger Mission A Fine Night For It when you help an elderly man reclaim his home back from the Night Folk.

Walking through the dark swamps as your companion informs you about what the Night Folk get up to is like something out of a horror movie. And despite there only being a handful of them at the house, their animalistic behaviour, speed, and ability to kill you in one hit makes them a serious threat.

You'll never explore those swamps at night again.

2. The Iniquities Of History

Arriving in the dusty town of Rhodes, players can meet a dishevelled and homeless old man named Jeremiah Compson. Approaching him, he'll spin you a tragic story about how he was once a respected gentleman who lost everything before tasking you with travelling to his former home to retrieve some of his treasured belongings.

Advertisement

At first, it's easy to sympathise with Compson's situation; and being a kind-hearted cowboy, you oblige his simple request.

While exploring his dilapidated house, however, it becomes apparent that Mr Compson isn't the nice man you thought he was.

Examining letters and pictures scattered around the house along with his old ledger, it's revealed that the esteemed livelihood that was supposedly "stolen" from him was that of a slaver, and an especially cruel one at that. You'll even uncover a hidden basement with chains attached to the walls where he held these people.

A brutal reminder of America's history, you won't feel as sorry for the old man when Arthur burns his so-called legacy in front of him. Whether or not you leave him in his misery or put him out of it is up to you.

1. The Wisdom Of The Elders

There are many strange places in the world of Rockstar’s masterpiece, but arguably none more so than the secluded town of Butcher’s Creek. And when you find a distressed man just west of Van Horn who can only say the settlement’s name, you'll see just how weird things have become there.

Advertisement

After returning the, players will fend off “demons” in the form of rabid dogs before meeting a mysterious shaman who informs you the town has been cursed.

Believing something suspect is going on, you’ll then set out to destroy charms throughout the area said to be holding the curse, and when the shaman claims your actions have only made things worse, your investigation takes you to an abandoned mine where you’ll discover arsenic is poisoning the water.

Confronting the shaman once more, who’s attempting to get the town to sign papers that he claims will lift the curse, it’s revealed he works for the mining company and wants to trick the townsfolk to leave.

Despite knowing the truth, though, the poisoned population still believe they’ve been cursed.

Although this curse was a lie, it still doesn’t explain the mysterious pentagram that appears in the town at night...

Advertisement