10 Deceptively Innocent Games With Incredibly Dark Lore
This is some of the most twisted stuff in gaming history.
Adding lore to a game can do a lot for your overall experience. Extra bits and pieces of story add more context to whatever you're doing, and help emphasize parts of the narrative that most people wouldn't pay attention to otherwise.
Most games try to make their lore synergize with the main storyline in some way, but there are also some exceptions to this rule.
...Very disturbing exceptions.
Some games that, at first glance, may appear to be quite innocent are actually full of references to a dark and gut-wrenching kind of expanded lore. Though they rarely mention it explicitly, their cutesy design and gameplay geared towards younger or wider audiences are merely a facade, concealing some kind of post-apocalyptic nightmare or Eldritch horror lurking in the shadows.
Let's take a deep dive into the strange and eerie lore of some of the most inconspicuous-looking games out there. You'll never be able to look at them the same way again.
10. War With The Gotoro Empire - Stardew Valley
Although Stardew Valley is often described as a cozy, comfort game, there are a number of eerie things that exist in its lore. The game is filled with monsters, ghosts, and magical beasts, but truth be told, all of these mystical creatures are not nearly as disturbing as the full-scale global war taking place away from your friendly small town.
That's right, while you're having fun petting chickens and growing parsnips, the nation of which Stardew Valley is a part of is engulfed in a bloody conflict with the tyrannical government of the Gotoro Empire. You can find numerous references to the war throughout the game, but in the second year of your time in Stardew Valley, you actually get to meet a soldier who experienced the horrors of it firsthand.
Kent, Sam's father, returns to the town with a clear case of PTSD. The man struggles to fit back into Stardew Valley, and everything around him keeps reminding him of the war. Some of the items you can gift him can even cause him to have flashbacks to the time when he was tortured in one of Gotoro's prison camps.
And you thought working for Joja was bad.
9. Post-Apocalyptic Squid Civilization Has Replaced Humans - Splatoon
There are quite a few dark themes explored in Splatoon's colorful world. You have the wars over shrinking dry lands with the Octolings, the blatant discrimination within the Inklings society, and a bunch of weird stuff like mind-controlled super soldiers and mutated salmon people.
The most disturbing part, however, has to be the one that hits pretty close to home in the current day and age: The reason why the Earth in Splatoon is completely devoid of humans
According to the official timeline of the game, Splatoon's world used to be populated by humans, but due to rising sea levels, all land-based creatures drowned and went extinct. The game points out that the great deluge was caused by global warming, which humanity first ignored and then accelerated when the desperate nations of Earth started waging nuclear wars on each other in a vein attempt to secure whatever meagre amount of resources were left.
This doomsday scenario sounds like something straight out of Fallout, and yet it's part of a game about squid-kid hybrids shooting each other with squirt guns.
Perhaps Splatoon's writers should consider a different line of work.
8. Nuclear Extinction - Pikmin
The setting of Pikmin might look bright and colorful, but in reality, it's all just a clever front concealing a very dark concept of humanity's future. More specifically, that humanity has been completely wiped out in a nuclear disaster.
Though it's never been outright confirmed, the games leave a lot of hints, which have caused much debate amongst the fans of the franchise. The first and most obvious hint regarding humanity's existence are the small objects like soda cans, bottle caps, and batteries the player can find throughout the levels. The planet that Pikmin takes place on also resembles Earth, or rather a hypothetical version of it from 250 million years in the future, called "Pangea Proxima."
But what about the nuclear stuff?
Well, in the original Pikmin game, one of the very first objects the player has to find is a Geiger counter, a device used to measure radiation. The counter in the game is constantly clicking, meaning that the entire surface of the planet is highly radioactive.
Of course, a lot of this is speculation, but you can't deny there's something eerily creepy about the empty world of Pikmin once you remove the pretty flowers and aliens.
7. Adorable, Life-Consuming Parasites - Bugsnax
Back in 2020, the internet created a trend of getting hyped for Bugsnax, jokingly referring to it as the game that would push the graphical boundaries of the PlayStation 5, despite it clearly being a smaller title aimed at young children.
... at least on the surface.
However, when the game finally came out, it actually did end up pushing some boundaries. The only catch was that they were of a more graphic than graphical kind.
It would be no exaggeration to compare the twist ending of Bugsnax to the plot of John Carpenter's The Thing.
In the final act of the game, the player finds the lost explorer, Lizbert, who reveals to them that the cute and tasty Bugsnax they'd been collecting the entire time are actually incredibly dangerous parasites - ones that transform the person's body and take control of their brain.
Keep in mind that this revelation was given to you after you had spent hours feeding Bugsnax to your friends on the island and laughing at their food-shaped bodies. The game did not only turn the Bugsnax into a terrifying hivemind, but it made you the real monster.
6. The Origin Of The Grox - Spore
The cartoony life simulation game Spore is all about making light of the history of evolution. However, once the player reaches the end of the game, things take a pretty dark turn.
Easily the most recognizable species in Spore, the Grox are a super-advanced civilization of cyborgs that serve as both the main antagonists of the game as well as its greatest mystery. They are inherently hostile to all lifeforms in the galaxy, and every single faction you encounter is afraid of them.
Very little is known about the Grox, but the ancient records the player can find mention that their species was created as some kind of experiment that turned rogue and started exterminating entire civilizations.
The Galactic Adventures DLC even has a mission that lets you experience a Grox invasion firsthand. Their motherships, equipped with life-destroying toxins and ravenous hordes of cyborgs, look so different from the typically cartoonish style of Spore that you would almost think they belonged in Mass Effect.
The most disturbing part of Grox's lore, however, is that you never learn who created them. Their makers' existence was completely eradicated from the galaxy, making you wonder what the Grox are truly capable of.
5. Brutal Murderers - Puyo Puyo
Puyo Puyo is a weird mix of Tetris and Doctor Mario that was created as a spin-off of a Japanese franchise called Mado Monogatari.
The spin-off ended up being more successful than the original and was eventually turned into a standalone franchise, however, it did retain some of the storyline and the lore of its source material. Including some pretty disturbing stuff.
The characters in Puyo Puyo are all mages-in-training that attend a magic school and have small misadventures together. This all sounds pretty innocent, but in the Mado Monogatari series, those "little misadventures" were actually really graphic. The characters would straight up kill enemies in the school dungeons by decapitating them, all fully displayed in gory detail. Oh, and by the way, this is all happening while they're only four years old...
It may not seem like a big deal since Puyo Puyo is not a dungeon crawler, but here's the thing: The writer for Puyo Puyo, Utako Yoshino, is a huge fan of the Mado Monogatari series, and has stated that she wanted to integrate the games' lore into Puyo Puyo, meaning that those murders the character committed at the age of 4 are likely canon.
4. The Great War - Pokémon
Pokemon lore is riddled with all sorts of morbid concepts, both intentional and accidental. You have Pokemon that are known for kidnapping children, dead people appearing out of thin air, and, of course, a wide selection of criminal organizations bent on destroying the world.
However, there is one piece of Pokemon lore that is so grim and out of place within the happy world of Pikachus and Jigglypuffs that it has boggled the minds of the fans for years: the Great Pokemon War.
The first reference to the conflict came from Pokemon Red and Blue. Lt. Surge, one of Kanto's gym leaders, mentions that he served in the war alongside his Pokemon. The creatures apparently saved his life.
In itself, the line is pretty vague, but Game Freak decided to elaborate on it more in Pokemon Black and White. The games mention that the war was a large-scale conflict between Kanto and the Unova region. They also acknowledge that Lt. Surge, despite living in Kanto, is a born and raised Unovan.
Was this information really necessary, Game Freak? Did we really need to know Lt. Surge and his little Raichu killed Kanto soldiers before opening a gym in their territory??
That's just messed up.
3. Olive's Murders - The Sims 2
If there's one thing that can be said about the Sims series, it's that the Sims are really, really weird. Between woohoo'ing ghosts and playing rock-paper-scissors with the Grim Reaper himself, the games enjoy mixing the dark with the silly.
However, in The Sims 2, there is a pre-made family called the Specters. The matron of the Specters, Olive, is hinted to be a serial killer responsible for the deaths of over twenty Sims buried in her backyard.
According to her memories, Olive fell in love with the Grim Reaper at a young age and began to kill people so she could summon her forbidden lover and spend a brief moment together. Her preferred method of luring her victims was to seduce and marry them, which is why she had inherited a great fortune.
For a cartoony simulation game, this is some pretty heavy stuff. The only thing that could make Olive's crimes any more messed up is if she killed some of her victims by removing the ladder from their pool.
2. Mario The Poacher - Donkey Kong
When you think of the original Donkey Kong for the arcade, you picture Donkey Kong as the angry evil ape and Mario as the hero who saves the day. However, according to interviews with Miyamoto, the truth behind their in-game feud is actually not so black and white.
The legendary Nintendo producer admitted that the reason Donkey Kong kidnapped Mario's girlfriend was actually because Mario was keeping him locked up in a cage. The poor ape was simply seeking revenge after the seemingly heroic plumber took him from his natural habitat and stuffed him into a tiny metal box.
But whatever, right? Maybe Donkey Kong deserved to be imprisoned... somehow.
Except in Donkey Kong Jr., the sequel in which the titular son needs to rescue his dad from Mario's evil clutches, it's revealed that Mario is actually running a circus, and he uses the animals he imprisons to do his bidding.
Mario's appearance in Donkey Kong Jr. is the only instance of the character being portrayed as a villain. However, given how the game exposes him as a poacher and an animal abuser, it leaves quite an impression.
1. Humanity's New Home - Kirby And The Forgotten Land
Kirby games are possibly the best example of how looks can be deceiving. Their characters are cute, their villains are loveably cartoonish, and yet the world they inhabit is filled with references to the fall of human civilization and the catalysm that caused it.
Though subtle references to humanity's fate existed since Kirby 64, the most recent game in the franchise, Kirby and the Forgotten Land, is actually fully based around this concept. It throws the player right into the middle of a ruined human city and lets them discover the fate of its creators.
According to the story, humanity was at some point visited by a malevolent lifeform from outer space called Fecto Elfilis. The creature arrived on Earth by creating a dimensional rift and immediately began to eradicate all life in sight.
Humanity eventually managed to capture the lifeform, but not before it had done irreversible damage to the planet.
After this, the humans decided to use Fecto's dimensional rifts to migrate to a new world - more specifically, Kirby's Dream Land. And if everything so far didn't sound messed up to you already, fans have speculated that the adorable Waddle Dees in the game are actually humans malformed by interdimensional travel.
Yup, Kirby's been eating humans this whole time.