10 Deliberate Gameplay Features That Ruin Your Immersion

Just when a game was beginning to draw you in.

By Lee Clarke /

Technical issues are a constant risk in gaming. Whether rushed out for an early release or just plain poorly made, is there anything that takes you further out of an immersive game world than constant bugs, glitches and frame-rate drops?

Advertisement

Sadly, there is, and what really rubs salt in the wound is that these things are actually intentional.

It's one thing to be painfully aware you're playing a game because it doesn't work properly, but it's another entirely for your immersion to be shattered by a very deliberate and ingrained trope that's wormed its way into mainstream game development.

With each generation of video games becoming more and more focused on story and atmosphere, there's really no excuse for anything that pulls you so jarringly out of it - especially if the whole point of it was supposed to do the opposite.

There are likely way more than 10 of these infernal things out there. But were we free of these ones, at least, modern gaming would be a far more enjoyable experience indeed.

10. Mouse Cursor Menus

Immersion in gaming is affected a lot by a game's pacing. Fast or slow, it has to stick to what it's trying to achieve, otherwise you're either going to be left for dust or lulled to sleep right in the middle of your playthrough.

Advertisement

And in the case of a fast-paced action game, the last thing you need is a cumbersome menu you've got only a sluggish cursor to trawl your way through with.

This is something that works perfectly for PC games, obviously, as the mouse and keyboard setup is what free-roaming cursors are made for. But it really doesn't translate well to direction buttons and analog sticks. When you could be scrolling easily down a list of highlightable options, games like Destiny, No Man's Sky and Cyberpunk 2077 insist on making you drag your little icon from one corner of the screen to the other.

It's all time you could be spending playing the game and actually, you know, getting into it. And the more you have to navigate these achingly slow menu screens, the more detached from the game you're inevitably going to feel.

9. Selected Soundtracks

This one should be self-explanatory. These songs and the artists that perform them exist in the real world. So, if they're suddenly plonked in the middle of a video game, are we supposed to assume they exist in that game's world, too?

Advertisement

And while, fair enough, some games go for something closer to realism than others, they're still largely works of fiction, so how can you escape the fact that the developers are basically shoehorning real-life things into them for the sake of a bit more revenue?

What most people don't realise is that a lot of a game's atmosphere comes from its soundtrack. The deeper it is, the more of a unique identity that game will have. And even when there's a kind of mix between original music and catchy radio numbers, wouldn't it have been better if they'd just gone the whole hog with the former?

Bottom line: if you're trying to get into a deep fictional world, the last thing you want is for the real world to start clawing its way back into your mind - and song-based soundtracks will do that to you every time.

8. On-Disc DLC

Paid DLC is an industry staple these days. And that's fine, as expansion packs and story add-ons often feature some of the best content the game has to offer.

Advertisement

That being said, it's really NOT nice when said DLC is viewable on the game disc, but blocked by a price tag of real money or requiring an unforgivable grind that pressures players into taking the easy way out.

Surely, buying a physical copy of a game should mean you're now done paying and are free to enjoy it. But, as games like Rocket League and Mortal Kombat 11 show, there's always more stuff to invest in, be it costumes, abilities or whole new stages, and until you get your wallet out, pretty soon there's going to be more content you can't play than you can.

In general, DLC is a positive thing in gaming. But what you don't want is to feel like you've been cheated out of a portion of the base game, then have it dangled right in front of your face to tempt you into shelling out more money.

7. "Photorealistic" Human Faces

Video game graphics are getting better all the time. And surely, that can only be a good thing, right?

Advertisement

Well... the thing is, game developers can promise us "photorealistic" graphics all they like, but can they ever really deliver on that promise? When it comes to creating human faces and lifelike gestures, history has shown us what the answer to that is.

True, maybe this is an overly cynical opinion. But the Uncanny Valley is a very unpleasant place to be, and us humans have a weirdly keen eye for imperfections in things that are supposed to resemble us. Even when it's the slightest bit off, you can be sure you'll pick up on it. And when it's pre-patch Mass Effect: Andromeda? ...Yeah.

Many games come extremely close to making convincing human faces, however, and should be genuinely applauded for that. Then again, if they had opted for a less complex art style, would the developers have had more time to iron out the bugs and performance issues that plague AAA games in recent years?

6. Reskinned Enemies

Yep, corner cutting is apparently a real problem in today's video games. And, as this entry's image shows, not even the most acclaimed of game developers are above rehashing old enemies and throwing them back out there for round two against the player.

Advertisement

A lot of games that do this try to weasel their way out by contriving some story reason behind it. Of course this one enemy looks and acts only slightly differently to the others because it came from a different time period. Of course this guy's red instead of blue because he's from a distant tribe who have their showers on too high!

Truth is, nine times out of ten, it's just the developers being lazy and not wanting to make all-new character models with all-new animations. "Sure," they must have thought, "let's just slap some colour on these enemies and give them scarier eyes or something. Who's gonna notice?"

As it turns out, all of us. And that was also the moment we remembered we were just playing a game.

5. Invisible Walls

Now this is a gameplay limitation that has REALLY stood the test of time. Is there a single gamer alive who hasn't run right out towards the beautiful outskirts of a game's landscapes, only to smack their poor player's head on thin air and run on the spot like a ninny?

Advertisement

It's no mystery as to why invisible walls are a thing. After all, the playable terrain can't go on forever, and the developers need some way to keep their inquisitive players hemmed into where they're supposed to be. These walls can be anywhere at all; way out to sea, high up in the sky, or, most egregiously, right in plain sight.

Wouldn't a simple way around this be putting a wall up to block off inaccessible areas? Or even a huge mountain range that's too big and unclimbable to see over? In some cases, that's exactly what happens, and well done them!

But it definitely doesn't happen enough for my liking. And as amusing as it is, trying to dress invisible walls up as quirky little forcefield generators doesn't solve the problem either. Sorry, Spyro.

4. The Same Voice Actor Voicing Everyone

Many of gaming's most prolific voice actors have quite the impressive range, letting them step into the shoes of video game characters of all shapes and sizes. Even they can only do so much, however, especially when they have to voice dozens of different characters in a single game alone.

Advertisement

This is really the fault of the casting directors rather than the voice actors themselves. A company as huge and successful as Bethesda should really know better than to hire so few actors to voice so many characters. In the case of The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, it's even too much for the legendary Jim Cummings to handle - shouting "Fus Ro Dah" in the same room as Festus Krex and Olfrid Battle-Born would be total sensory overload.

And the problem with this is that background characters in video games almost never know when to shut up! Picture it: you're talking to an NPC when someone else comes up to you and starts to talk over them - in a voice that's almost identical.

It's enough to drive even the most sane gamer mental, and you can certainly kiss goodbye to any sense of immersion you may have had.

3. Characters Describing Button Prompts

Okay, admittedly this one doesn't happen all too often anymore. Not that it's completely dead and buried.

Advertisement

How are you expected to absorb yourself in a game's story if the characters make reference to the fact you're playing a video game? Sometimes, they're intentional fourth wall breaks, so you can afford to throw those ones a bone for obvious reasons. Other times, characters just spurt out the most jarring of phrases and then act as if everything's totally normal. Oh yeah, sure it is - apart from the fact you've just ruined all my investment in this story!

"Press X to do this." "Press the Action Button to do that." "Press the power button to turn off the console and find something better to do." These are things you should never hear the actual characters in a video game saying to you. They shouldn't know they're in a game, and if the story is a particularly serious one, it's even sillier when they start telling people to press buttons to jump instead of actually, you know, jumping.

Call me old-fashioned, but when I don't know the controls, I don't assume the NPCs around me know either.

2. Repeated Character Models

I'm sure creating detailed character models is a long and strenuous job, but when the alternative is every other person going around with the exact same face and clothes, doesn't logic tell you that it's the lesser of two evils here?

Advertisement

Open world games are especially guilty of this unfortunate habit. The more characters there are, the better the chance they're going to be wearing the face of someone you've already seen before. Literally, for all you know. At least that would be a more satisfying explanation than the developers pressing Copy and Paste a few hundred times.

This doesn't just apply to human characters, either. Isn't it a marvellous coincidence that all those enemies coming towards you have sores and wounds in the exact same places? Why, it's almost as if they're all the same model!

If the scope of a game calls for lots of unique characters, then that's what has to be done, otherwise there's your immersion straight out the window. Let's never again have to say to ourselves, "Say, good sir, haven't I met you before? Oh wait, no, you just look and act identical to them in every way. My mistake."

1. Celebrity Likenesses

"Hey, have you seen the new Keanu Reeves movie yet?" is a question you've very likely asked or been asked yourself. One question that should NEVER pass from a human being's lips, however, is, "Hey, have you played the new Keanu Reeves game yet?"

Advertisement

There's no better money-spinner than a glorious 4K rendering of your favourite A-list actors. Willem Dafoe, Jon Bernthal, Kevin Spacey, Norman Reedus... regardless of who gets the big-budget motion capture treatment, their starring role serves only one purpose: relentless, unending marketing, and big, big bucks for them and the companies.

Gaming seems to suffer from this far more than movies do. Do you see the lead character in Beyond: Two Souls and think "Jodie Holmes" or "Elliot Page" first? Exactly. And you know Page is primarily a film star, so how is this supposed to encourage immersion?

Not only that, but isn't recreating real-life people with computer animation a huge waste? The animators could design anything they wanted, but because they have to squander their efforts on making a high-def Keanu Reeves, both the story and its ability to suck you in are seriously compromised.

There's a reason video games and films are different mediums. Designers could do well to remember that before they ram an out-of-place celebrity into their next games and leave us with that feeling of, "Well, that was fun while it lasted."

Advertisement