10 Developers Who Have Never Made A Bad Video Game

Take a bow, Rockstar.

By Scott Tailford /

Rocksteady/CDPR/Rockstar/Nintendo/Blizzard

There are some monumentally talented people working in the video game industry. Symptomatic of just how little the average consumer knows about the sheer level of stress, hours invested and broad range of talents required to create a game in the first place, the medium tends to not be celebrated as much as film, where behind the scenes "making of" documentaries are commonplace.

Advertisement

Recommended are Double Fine's phenomenal "Double Fine Adventure" series showcasing how their own Broken Age went from idea to playable across many, many months, Danny O' Dwyer's NoClip channel that provides crowdfunded looks at gaming's most interesting stories, and Indie Game: The Movie, where you'll find the histories of Super Meat Boy, Braid and Fez.

So far so good, and they're certainly helping turn the tide, highlighting some of the industry's most ambitious and talented teams hard at work - but which are the studios that have never released a bad game? Be it because of a smaller pool of titles or just meticulous quality control over time, are your favourites completely spotless?

Advertisement

From triple-As to indies and everything in between, the following examples aren't meant to denigrate the collective efforts of all developers, and instead, let's celebrate the medium's finest.

10. Klei Entertainment

Klei Entertainment

From Eets to Mark of the Ninja, Shank to Don't Starve and especially Invisible Inc., Klei have been one of the shiniest examples of how experimental and worthwhile the indie scene can be for years.

Advertisement

Just run down some of their choice cuts: Eets was a charming platformer, Shank instantly became a standout Xbox Live Arcade gem thanks to its Saturday morning cartoon look, then Mark of the Ninja proved the impossible and did one of the most feature-complete stealth games ever... in 2D.

Never content to rest on their laurels, Klei released Don't Starve - possibly the best, most pure survival game of all time - only to pivot again into Invisible, Inc., a turn-based strategy with endless tactical experimentation and another killer art style.

Advertisement

From risks that paid off to solid sequels and buckets of charm from lead artist Jeff Agala, Klei are still firing on all cylinders, 13 years later.

9. CD Projekt RED

CD Projekt RED

Okay, sure, CDPR have only released four games, but MAN - just chart the arc of quality from the first to last Witcher. And that's not even saying the first Witcher was anything close to "bad" - quite the opposite.

Advertisement

The first entry in the franchise is literally the one that put CDPR on the map, showing gamers what the world of Andrzej Sapkowski's books looked like in 3D. Primitive though it may look now, you'll still find legions of diehard fans who first came on board through this release.

Witcher 2 then amped everything up, fleshing out the production values from some substantial initial sales - actually seeing CDPR create two separate campaigns that trigger depending on which faction you side with. Assassins of Kings reigned in more lovers of their heartfelt design ethos, allowing the studio to put all their money and expertise into developing the mighty Witcher III: Wild Hunt - a landmark open-world adventure that remains the best fantasy title on current-gen hardware, if not the best game of the generation so far.

Advertisement

Oh, and almost as a "Sure, why not?", in their spare time, they released a Gwent card game, which honestly rivals Hearthstone and Magic: The Gathering when it comes to building a deck and tactically dissecting your opponent.

8. Harmonix

Harmonix

Sometimes you come across a game developer that is absolutely ensconced in their passion of choice. With Harmonix, it's music, and they've spent their life's work creating some of not only the best rhythm games of all time, but software that actually encourages people to pick up and learn real instruments.

Advertisement

Rock Band 3 was the nearest the team got to essentially making a plastic guitar replete with strings, but even their debut efforts Frequency and Amplitude provided an insight into music composition, alongside how to get an feel for timing.

And of course, there's Guitar Hero, quite possibly the biggest peripheral craze of the 2000s - something that returned a few years ago for another go-round, but still represents one of the most important steps towards video games being accepted as a mainstream, living room-based form of entertainment.

Advertisement

Game studios aren't often thought of as teams of musicians with orchestral, compositional brains, but Harmonix really are that dedicated, that cherished and that reliable.

7. Blizzard

Blizzard

You can claim that some of Blizzard's older games don't hold up today - but to do so would be missing the point. This is a studio that always had balanced artistic creativity with dogged, business-minded determination to make the biggest franchises possible.

Advertisement

Overwatch is the most recent example of that, but look wider and you'll see the behemoth that is World of Warcraft, Starcraft, the loot-grinder's dream, Diablo and the hour-stealing addiction of Hearthstone.

Blizzard have everything from their own fan convention to a back catalogue worth millions: A mentality that affords them the time to polish every last release to a mirror sheen. This mentality of quality over quantity existed way back when they were making side-scrolling Superman beat 'em ups and Justice League fighting games (yes, really), and though they're unfathomably big now, hasn't changed one bit.

Advertisement

6. Rocksteady

Rocksteady

Talk about making an entrance, only a select few knew of the fantastically overlooked Urban Chaos: Riot Response before 2009 - but with Arkham Asylum, that all changed.

Advertisement

Singlehandedly ending the, "Can good video games come from movies?" discussion (the answer was always yes - it's the other way around that doesn't work), Rocksteady's innovative combat system would go on to influence pretty much every third-person action game since. To this day we're still playing games that have these "rhythm-based" mechanics, but putting Batman behind those punches make them extra special.

Come Arkham City, Rocksteady challenged themselves to expand the Arkham formula and make it open-world, scattering mission objectives and environments across a sizeable chunk of Gotham. It split the fanbase down the middle as to which style of game they preferred - a fractionating decision that, if you're in Camp Open-World, was made even better in Batman: Arkham Knight.

Advertisement

The latter is easily the culmination of six years' worth of talent and time investment, producing the ultimate Dark Knight experience: One where cleaning up Gotham's dark underbelly, busting out an array of gadgets and facing off against iconic villains is all in a day's work.

5. Kojima Productions

Kojima Productions

Parsing out where Konami ends and Kojima Productions starts can be pinpointed to 2005, when Hideo Kojima's own team of developers was allowed their own independent label, but as a creative team existing within a larger developmental framework, they were still responsible for every main Metal Gear Solid, Zone of the Enders, Policenauts, Snatcher and even the ace card game, Metal Gear Ac!d.

Advertisement

The hugely risky Castlevania: Lords of Shadow also went down a storm thanks to having its heart in the right place, and experimental one-off demo P.T. (Silent Hills) became many peoples' 2014 Game of the Year. The "worst" the studio ever got was the Wild Guns-esque Metal Gear Touch on phones, but even that was playable and fun enough for a quick five minutes.

Back to P.T., as even though it was a demo; literally one L-shaped corridor filled with secrets and things to find through sheer repetition, it was so well made; so scary and so shareable, it outdid the majority of full releases. Now THAT really is talent.

Advertisement

With Metal Gear, it goes without saying that not only did the first entry invent stealth mechanics, but Metal Gear Solid introduced a level of cinematic quality and framing to cutscenes, that meant the industry would never be the same again.

Here's to Death Stranding. If any part of you is wondering if it'll be any good - just look at KojiPro's immaculate back catalogue.

Advertisement

4. Supergiant Games

Supergiant Games

Another studio that take their time and emerge from years of development with the finest experiences around, Supergiant are three for three, releasing the phenomenal Bastion, the aesthetically stunning Transistor and their magnum opus, Pyre, all this decade.

Advertisement

The best thing about following their work comes from seeing the connective tissue and lessons learned between games. Bastion started as an isometric hack n' slash/twin-stick shooter with a killer progression, only for Transistor to take that combat and apply a more contemplative, "stop and plan, then watch everything execute" mechanic. Visuals are distinct and stellar for both, but Pyre rolls these gameplay lessons into a competitive sport, establishing a story built around teams of excommunicated convicts attempting to win their freedom by facing off in a future version of basketball.

Across the board we've got such a strong, confident series of games. All stick to the most artistic tenets of game design and creative expression, resulting in titles that all feel distinct, loveable and propulsive as to Supergiant's upward curve career.

Advertisement

Oh, and composer Darren Korb should be a permanent fixture on any game music-lover's playlist.

3. Naughty Dog

Naughty Dog

To this day, Naughty Dog are one of the most reliable developers in gaming. We know their story, their characters, their work ethic and ethos in general. They really care about what they put out, and though you can look to things like Uncharted 4 and Uncharted: Lost Legacy as "needless sequels/spin-offs", the quality of those games far outweighs any criticism.

Advertisement

Go all the way back to the start and you'll find the Mortal Kombat rip-off Way of the Warrior alongside innovative RPGs Keef the Thief and Rings of Power - all before Crash Bandicoot blew a hole of pure charm into the side of the industry. Seriously, check out Naughty Dog's 30th Anniversary art book - even they had no idea Sony were going to make Crash the "face of PlayStation" back when he was being created.

Thankfully it all came together flawlessly, and we've enjoyed 30 years of hit after hit, franchise after franchise, with Naughty Dog moving onto new pastures at the turn of each generation. Crash Bandicoot, Jak & Daxter, Uncharted and now The Last of Us - you can chart the studio's maturity alongside their games, and it's a journey I'm still adoring every minute of.

Advertisement

2. Rockstar

Rockstar Games

Rockstar's output has been nothing short of monolithic, to say the least. Essentially going through their teenage punk rock phase with the earlier Grand Theft Autos, we saw a phenomenal step up into releasing new IPs and passion-filled experiments in the 2000s.

Advertisement

GTA III, Vice City and San Andreas led into Manhunt, The Warriors - the generation-defining Bully. Even smaller franchises Smuggler's Run and Midnight Club were used to perfect tight driving mechanics and open-world traversal respectively, before feeding that data back into GTA, making GTA IV and especially V, something truly special.

Now, GTA Online rakes in around $5 million a day from DLC and microtransactions, yet they come alongside a free base game - one stuffed with multiplayer modes, customisable homesteads and high-octane cop chases.

Advertisement

What was once a hungry, ambitious studio has blossomed and flexed into a genuine entertainment powerhouse. The world waits with baited breath to see how Red Dead Redemption 2 will turn out, but chances are... it'll be fantastic.

1. Nintendo

Nintendo

If we're talking about the sheer amount of products made vs. median quality, Nintendo have the best ratio in the history of entertainment.

Advertisement

Go on, try and think of an abjectly bad, first party Nintendo game. Wii Music perhaps? For whatever hardware-based failings it had, there were TONS of youngsters for which this was essentially their Guitar Hero; the pure enjoyment of composing some original music far outweighing the bad.

Go older and you'll find the NES' Urban Champion, a one-on-one fighter that sure, has aged like a cheese sandwich in a landfill, but was damn fun with a friend, and mechanically tactile enough to just go with in 1984.

Advertisement

Flip to the positives, and... well, Nintendo's first-party high points speak for themselves. The Legend of Zelda, Super Mario, Metroid, Animal Crossing, Pokémon, Smash Bros., Kirby, Yoshi, Star Fox, F-Zero, Splatoon - no other company has shaped the gameplay side of things anywhere near as much as Nintendo, and that "Seal of Quality" maintains to this day, even if they don't advertise it.