10 Divisive Video Game Endings Nobody Agrees On
"But him damning mankind to save her was the right thing to do!"
For whatever reason, video games have a history of providing less than stellar endings. Whether its because of expectations or the all too common 'end game twist', genuinely good video game finales are a dime a dozen.
And yet, perhaps even less common are the endings that arent so cut and dry, leading to people never agreeing on whether they're truly good or bad, for a variety of different reasons. While one person may see the brilliance of something that takes you by surprise and undermines expectations, another may simply feel betrayed or unsatisfied.
Perhaps something is near universally praised, while its contents inspire passionate debate regardless. Either way, some of the biggest talking points fans will engage in come from whatever they were feeling when the credits rolled.
It serves that as video games evolve and content creators take more creative risks, we get more and more things to pick apart and analyse.
However, the following endings - for a variety of reasons - have proven controversial and divided gamers since day one...
10. Resistance 2
Resistance 2 continues the story of Nathan Hale and his battle against the invading Chimera. Much of the game deals with the fact that Hale is infected with the Chimeran virus and his efforts to resist it, but contrary to what you expect, the game ends with him completely succumbing to the infection.
With no hope of recovery, he is shot in the head by his comrade Joseph Capelli. That... was... worth it?
Its always risky to dispose of your protagonist midway through your overall story, but the developers of Resistance 2 felt it was the right decision. And while one can see the merits of taking such a risk, the opinion of many is that the execution is lacking and thus dramatically unsatisfying. It doesnt help that a gunshot followed by cut to black has become such a cliché that it borders on absurdity, either.
Still, you cant argue that it goes against expectations, and it ups the stakes quite dramatically going into the next game. It was a bold move, and there is no doubt that a good number of people were responsive to what is essentially a resetting of the table just as things get intense, which, according to who you talk to, is either a brilliant move or a colossal misfire.
9. Deus Ex: Human Revolution
Deus Ex: Human Revolution deals with heavy ideas regarding mankinds relation to technology, specifically the ways in which we rely on it and use it to empower ourselves. The final moments of the game sees these issues brought to a head, forcing you to choose from four distinct directions humanity may take going forward.
Through the implication of being multiple choice, these endings may be intellectually divisive, but conceptually, they are very thoughtful and compelling. They force you reflect upon various philosophical subject matters and then take a moral stance based on your conclusion, which can be tough because moralistic value can be found in each of the four choices. Its impossible to just choose one without giving it considerable thought, and each comes at a cost.
There is no doubt that there have been many discussions about every one of these, and which one is the most right, which will vary depending on your own values. But that is whats so great about this whole setup; they divide people in a stimulating way, inspiring debates that otherwise might not have happened.
No one can agree on which ending is the unequivocal 'best', because there is no right answer, and that makes for a powerful conclusion to one of the more cerebral action games to come out in the last decade.
8. Borderlands
Borderlands has you searching for the Vault, a legendary structure rumored to contain powerful alien technology. After a long and arduous journey, you finally make it, but its contents are not what you expected.
Turns out the Vault isnt a technology cache, but is instead a prison containing The Destroyer, an ancient creature with the ability to destroy everything. You were deceived and led to kill this monster, and the game ends with you gaining nothing.
Its easy to see why so many were disappointed by this ending. Borderlands is an RPG that puts a lot of emphasis on loot to the point where finding the ultimate score is the main narrative thrust of the game. To have all your efforts undermined for a twist can feel extremely underwhelming and make it feel like a waste of time.
Conversely it could be argued that this undermining of expectations is what makes it great. The realization that the Vault isnt what it seems, and that things are much bigger than your selfish ambitions, opens the world up and makes the story more interesting. Its a nice twist that, if perhaps it were in another medium, might be more universally well received.
7. Bioshock Infinite
Much has been made about the mind-bending nature of the ending of Bioshock Infinite. Booker Dewitts mission to rescue Elizabeth from Columbia ends with the revelation that not only is the villainous Comstock actually Booker from an alternate timeline, but that Elizabeth is also his daughter. The game concludes with Booker being drowned at his baptism by multiple Elizabeths from different timelines, eliminating any chance of him being reborn as Comstock.
Bioshock Infinites ending sent shockwaves through the video game industry for its complexity and layered twists. It was meticulously unpacked and analyzed by gamers, critics, and pundits, and was subsequently praised for its thematic resonance. Anyone who has completed the game will tell you that the ending stays with you long after you put down the controller.
On the other hand, the ending has been criticized for leaning far too much on twists and plot at the expense of character. Unlike the original Bioshocks elegantly simple and genuinely shocking reveal, Infinites is big, clunky, and lacks a solid moral message. It relies far too much on your knowledge of the technicalities of its plot, much of which can be easily missed. Also, many feel that the brief visit to Rapture at the end feels shoehorned in and serves as nothing but pure fan service.
So depending on who you are, Bioshock Infinites ending is either brilliantly intricate and multifaceted, or needlessly convoluted and illogically absurd. Take your pick.
6. The Last Of Us
To be clear: its nearly impossible to find anyone who hates the ending of The Last of Us. It is subtle and nuanced in the way that few video games are, and the response to it was overwhelmingly positive. However, the ending is divisive not because of how it concluded the story of Joel and Ellie, but more so because of the motivations of the characters and the moral questions it brings ups.
The Last of Us ends with Joel killing the Fireflies and saving Ellie at the expense of a potential cure. In essence, Joel dooms mankind because he cant let go of Ellie, who has become a surrogate daughter to him. The ending forces you to kill good and innocent people to save a character youve grown to care about.
Theres a fascinating moral quandary at the centre of all that, and its one that the game has no easy answer to. Many people would argue that what Joel did was damning and selfish. Others see him as being in the right. After all, is mankind worth saving if it means taking the life of a child?
On top of that, the game also ends on the question of whether Ellie knows Joel is lying to her. Again, it leaves it open to interpretation. Some people are convinced she knows; others believe she accepts Joels lie. The strength of this ending lies on its ambiguity, and its one that gamers continue to discuss.
5. God Of War III
For the most part, God of War III is a hugely satisfying conclusion to Kratoss apocalyptic quest for revenge against the Olympian Gods - save for one last twist at the end. Upon finally reaching Pandoras Box, which will give him the power to kill Zeus, Kratos discovers that it is empty.
It turns out that Hope, which was thought to be the only power left in the box, has been within him the whole time, giving him the strength to kill the gods. After killing Zeus, Athena demands Kratos give her the power, but he kills himself instead, releasing Hope to the rest of mankind.
If that all sounds a bit hokey to you, well, youre certainly not alone in that feeling. While God of War III was universally praised when it was released, its ending was certainly more divisive. A lot of people feel like it is too corny and contrived, especially for the God of War series, which is known for its distinct lack of sentimentality.
On the other hand, a legitimate argument could be made that the ending is very appropriate, not only for its sense of closure, but because it explores the tormented psyche of Kratos, a character who, until that point, was rather one-note. The trilogy ends with his redemption through sacrifice, which is actually quite fitting when you think about it.
4. Bioshock
Nearly a decade on and Bioshock is still considered one of the all time great video games; a creative triumph that shows off the power of the art form like few others. That being said, even many of those that profess their adoration for the game admit that the ending, specifically everything after the jaw-dropping twist, isnt quite up to the same standards at everything that came before it.
A lot of people specifically have a problem with the fact that Bioshock ends with a traditional boss fight against an ADAM-fueled Frank Fontaine, claiming that it feels out of place and silly after the more thoughtful events that preceded it. Many also have an issue with the all or nothing endings, making Jack either an angelic savior or an immoral monster.
Others have no problem with this, feeling the final boss fight contradicts nothing and adheres to the same design philosophy that makes Bioshock such a great game. After all, Fontaine isnt the only boss you face in the game, so the final conflict with him is a natural way to end it. And while their may only be two different endings, they are both interesting and different enough to make playing through it twice a must.
3. Mass Effect 3
Considering the sheer amount of unified vitriol aimed at Bioware after the release of Mass Effect 3, youd think the response to this infamous ending would be near unanimous. However, time has allowed gamers to move on and accept the ending for what it is, and while it is the opinion of many that it is still a colossal misfire, there are plenty of those who embrace it for its refusal to coddle towards expectations.
Those that hate the ending have plenty of legitimate reasons for doing so. They claim it feels rushed and shallow, that it exposes major plot holes and contradicts previously established lore, and worst of all, lacks the heart and soul that made so many connect with the Mass Effect universe in the first place.
Others genuinely admire it for its bitter sweet ambitions. Instead of giving fans everything they wanted, it forced them to make a hard choice that fundamentally changes the galaxy they fell in love with, followed by an open-ended conclusion with no answers. It is a cold and bleak ending with only a glimmer of hope, and after investing hours into the journey of Commander Shepard, many fans felt more than depressed.
Legitimate arguments can be made for both sides, and a great portion of the internet has been dedicated towards debating this very subject. Whether you love or hate it, theres no denying the impact the ending of Mass Effect 3 had on so many people.
2. Metal Gear Solid 2
To say that the plot of Metal Gear Solid 2 - or any of them for that matter - is 'complicated', is an understatement. Series creator Hideo Kojima is notorious for filling the games with his own personal brand of insanity, and the most extreme example of this is probably the second games ending.
In a nutshell, it is incredibly convoluted to the point where a significant percentage of gamers were destined to be left confused and unsure of what is going on. For those that love creator Hideo Kojimas style and can decipher the method in his madness, it can all be extremely enthralling, but for anyone on the opposing side, everything comes across as polarising, to say the least. Youll find just as many people claiming this ending to be pure nonsense, as you will those proclaiming its brilliance.
In a way, Metal Gear Solid 2s ending is a microcosm of the overall series. It appeals to enough people to create a long-running franchise, but many just do not understand it and likely never will.
1. Final Fantasy X
While the plot of Final Fantasy X is, like most games in the series, long and complicated, what motivates a lot of players to push forward more than anything is the romance between Tidus and Yuna. It is the emotional heart of the story, and you want to see the two of them make it out together in the end.
Given the tragic nature of their relationship though, they are destined to be forever separated, and this is how the game ends. After defeating Sin, Tidus begins to fade from reality, and before disappearing completely, they proclaim their love for one another as Tidus wraps his arms around Yuna one last time.
The conclusion to Final Fantasy X just might be the definition of a divisive ending. Feelings towards this ending are nearly split down the middle, with some seeing the ending as poetic and emotionally devastating, while others were left feeling confused and underwhelmed.
So divisive was it that many believe that Final Fantasy X-2, the first connected sequel in the series, was made in part because of this diverse response. Whether this was actually the case is mere speculation, but it only goes to show how mixed people felt about this ending.
What other video games contain divisive endings? Let us know in the comments!