10 Dumbest Plot Reveals In Gaming History
Resident Evil 5, where Jill Valentine's character died.
When a shocking twist is done well, it has the power to really stick with you.
Finding out you've been killing colossi for the villain's benefit, or that GLaDOS was human are just a couple of twists that are both original and done very well.
That can't be said for every reveal in gaming, though. Whilst the absolute daftest is "your dead wife is your bionic arm", there are some that aren't far off of that. Plot-convenient devices like sleep and memory loss are just two of the laziest and dumbest, but it doesn't stop there.
Retconning stories to fit a twist that had no build up, ruining both sequel and original game, is pretty near the top. As is pulling a crafty yet failed attempt at the game you're playing actually being very meta, and sullying the lineage of the series thus far.
For every good there must be a bad, for every twist about a soldier's real mindset, there must be something completely naff to balance it out. A karmic balance for shocking and dumb twists to coexist.
With that in mind, and obviously there will be spoilers for the games listed, here are ten of some the dumbest and most downright disrespectful plot twists in gaming.
10. Detroit: Become Human - Alice Is An Android Too
Throughout the years, many a piece of science fiction has tackled "Can artificial intelligence replicate human emotion?". Works like Blade Runner, I, Robot and Ex Machina, to name a few. It's a scary prospect, but a relevant topic.
So, trust good ol' David Cage to completely miss the point in one of Detroit: Become Human's story arcs. Connor and Markus' stories are, whilst a bit hammy, somewhat relatable with established interpretations.
Kara's... not so much, and here's why:
She's a robot nanny, programmed for housework and other tasks. Seeing her break her programming and care for Alice is admirable, and has us thinking that she may have learnt human compassion. At least it would have, if not for something to derail it later on.
Something like Alice is also a bloody android.
First off, can't androids sense other androids? You'd think that'd be, like, an inherent software mechanic. But more importantly, it undoes any sentiment for Kara showing human-learnt compassion and protective instinct, because she was never looking after a vulnerable human.
For all we know, it's one android protecting another, borne of in-built command.
9. Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood - Desmond Stabs Lucy
Assassin's Creed current-world story, that ran alongside the Animus parts, was divisive but did its best to keep events on track. Desmond's capture, Abstergo using him to find pieces of Eden, and the inevitable escape, all played accompaniment to the leapy-stabby main gameplay.
But, with a twist like this, it's not hard to see why players weren't keen on it.
It's established early on that Lucy, an Abstergo employee, is actually a double-agent for the assassins. Hence why she aides Desmond's escape. But then, right at the final moment, Desmond (under the influence of Juno) stabs her.
And why? Because Lucy is a triple agent.
However, there's a massive, glaring omission here: Assassins (in this universe) are meant to be immune to influence from the Old Ones/pieces of Eden - it's why ancient assassins were able to break free of the Old Ones' facilities in the first place. Juno shouldn't be able to possess Desmond, let alone steer his blade Vainto Lucy's stomach.
It was certainly shocking to watch, but as soon as that magic wears off, it leaves more plot holes than it does cliffhangers for the next game.
8. Resident Evil 5 - It Was Jill Valentine All Along
Resident Evil doesn't do massively dramatic plot twists with sincerity. If players didn't see Albert "I Wear Sunglasses Indoors" Wesker's betrayal at the end of the first game, then they weren't paying attention.
Resident Evil does cheesy dialogue, grand and gruesome boss battles, all with a heap of self-aware stylings that we've come to love over the years. By the time of Resident Evil 5, after the spectacle of 4, gamers were very aware of what this series brought.
As such, the masked lady that looks a bit shifty had fans immediately thinking, "Why hasn't Chris mentioned Jill much?" and wondering why her absence was a mystery. Then there's the flashback in which Jill and Wesker do a fancy bit of defenestration. Bare in mind, Wesker's all enhanced at this point, and we don't see Jill's body for an autopsy.
Cue later-game boss fight with Wesker and the hooded lass, and lo and behold... oh, it's only Jill. Like we didn't see that coming a million miles off. Also, why didn't Wesker have a more contingent brainwashing device than a simple, detachable chest piece?
7. Death Stranding - Higgs Is The Pizza Fan
We'll start off with a twist that isn't grandiose, nor does it ruin the entire experience that players have invested it, but is just downright daft. Just one of those ones that really, really feels like a waste of time.
Which is fitting for Death Stranding, as it is a time sink. Delivering packages as Sam Porter-Bridges is either entertaining or tenuous, depending on your point of view. But it is the main gameplay tenet.
And a lot of it does make sense, given the whole "rebuild America" thing. But that one chap that really likes pizza? Seems like a waste of time and resources, surely.
Players never see the guy, and his requests are verbose and over-the-top for basically dough and toppings. But after a few deliveries, it just feels really pointless to keep doing.
But the shocking reveal? It was Higgs all along!
That's right, the main antagonist, who wants to cause another Death Stranding, also likes winding Sam up by making him deliver pizza. Bare in mind, this is the same Higgs who has you deliver a nuke if you're not careful.
So, so dumb.
6. Dishonored 2 - Delilah Is The Queen's Sister
Retcons, the act of retroactively altering past events to fit a new narrative, barely work. More often than not, they actually create new plot holes. The biggest of which being:
"Oh right, and nobody thought to mention this before...?"
Case in point, the familial bond between late Empress Kaldwin and Delilah, the erstwhile leader of the Brigmore witches. The witches coven who, up until this point, had been more of a foil to the assassin Daud than the empire.
But, by the time the sequel came around, and Delilah rocks up to Empress Emily's digs and demands the throne it's... because she's Emily's aunt. There's no mention of this in the first game, nor the DLC that specifically focus on the witch.
Why couldn't the villain just be a new, hostile threat to spur the events of the game on? History is literally paved with events like this that the game could have interpreted.
Alas no, and players were fed some shoehorned in retcon about how we all conveniently forgot that Emily and Delilah were sisters, living out a Prince and the Pauper-style lifestyle to motivate the throne-grab.
5. Star Ocean: Till The End Of Time - It's All A Game
The Star Ocean games, prior to TtEoT, have been well written if a little formulaic when it came to their stories. They are, in short, massively sprawling space adventures, often added multiple endings to encourage different choices. Hell, The Second Story has eighty odd endings.
So, when it came to the leap to the PlayStation 2, Till The End of Time had a fair bit riding on it to continue that storytelling style.
And boy, did it drop the ball on that one.
Familiar players are going to expect/want some big, massive reveal about a world destroying evil, or something JRPG-like. And what did those who persevered get for their troubles?
The big reveal that all of the events in the game are a simulation.
That's right, the big twist is that we're playing a game within a game. That's what players got, after the [inter]stellar efforts the first two games laid out.
From time-travel, planetary destruction and councils of wisemen to... "it's all a game". No wonder the next game was called The Last Hope, as this game sank a lot of enthusiasm and faith in the series.
4. Super Mario Bros. 2 - It Was All A Dream
Fans of the now-vintage TV show Dallas were in uproar when a large part of a season was subject to an "It was all a dream" rug-pull at the start of the next season. And as such, it's been parodied over the years over how absurd it was.
But when a video game does it? That's just... well, it feels like the whole endeavour was pointless. Was dodging those horrible floating masks for nothing? Were all those deaths at the hands of Wart pointless?
Yes, it seems, as it was all the figment of a sleeping Mario's dream, who clearly doesn't get enough excitement in his day job. Which apparently, is plumbing.
Now, part of this could be down to the strange history behind Super Mario Bros. 2, in that it is essentially a reskin of another game; Doki Doki Panic. Which in terms of divergent gameplay, explains why it's not really considered story canon in the Mario universe.
But it's not necessarily an easy game either, with players wanting a little more in their resolution than, "Oh yeah, it's just Mario having a snooze".
3. Metroid: Other M - Madeline Is A Mother Brain Clone
Metroid games, throughout the annals of gaming, have always been pretty simple: bounty hunter kills evil forces. That's it, that's all we needed to keep the formula going. Samus is a badass, Ridley keeps coming back and the Metroids need stopping.
But when Team Ninja got their hands on the license, that's when it all got really stupid. One of Metroid's key selling points is the minimalism in the story, letting players go explore and bookend the plot instead.
Whereas Team Ninja thought that cribbing Aliens and making Samus a broody, suddenly parental would pass muster. It did not, but that's not the dumbest thing here.
No, the dumbest plot reveal in the game is that Madeline Bergmann, the missing scientist who led the Mother Brain research, is an artificial intelligence/clone of Mother Brain. And how sly is this reveal? Well, the project name is "MB", to show how subtle it is.
It's been long established that Mother Brain is the big evil in the series, controlling Ridley and Space Pirates. But making clones, that look and act human?
Too obvious, too predictable, and too daft for a Metroid game.
2. Final Fantasy VIII - All Amnesiacs
Amnesia, as a plot device, has been massively overused in media over the decades. When a big reveal is, "It was X character all along, but they'd forgotten" for the umpteenth time, the dramatic effect wears thin.
But leave it to Squaresoft to not just double down but... well, Square it. That's right, it's not just one member of the edgy teenage world-savers with plot-convenient memory loss, it's pretty much all of them.
Turns out, they all went to the same orphanage together. That, in itself, is one massively lame reveal. The next doubling down part? Irvine dropping some late-game knowledge that he knew this already, and that it's the use of the game's summons that cause the amnesia.
And what? We had to go through several discs' worth of wondering when some reveal would happen, and the bullseye-shooting berk didn't think to bring it up sooner?
It just smacks of a writing team that ran out of time/money/inclination that went, "...and they all grew up together, go team, saves the day". Probably the same laziness they brought over to Final Fantasy IX's story too...
1. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain - You're Not Big Boss
Fool us once, Kojima, shame on you. Fool us to play as someone that isn't the series stalwarts that gamers had come to love, them doubly shame on you.
You'd think, after the ire and bile aimed at the Snake/Raiden switch in MGS2, Kojima wouldn't pull this on the fans again. But he did, and then some, for Metal Gear Solid V.
Did it ever seem strange that some characters don't seem too keen to see Big Boss? Or weirder still, have to double-take and confirm it is him? Perhaps Boss' lack of chat seemed odd, considering MGS is known for word vomiting.
Turns out, there's a bigger reason for that, and not just the Sutherland-for-Hayter voice actor switch.
No, it's because Boss isn't the Boss, he's a medic hypnotised to pretend to be a Boss. That's right, this massive, sprawling conclusion to the Big Boss saga is that players don't actually play as the Boss at all.
Even worse, it retcons as far back as the original Metal Gear games. It just raises more questions, the biggest being, "Why did we spend 60 hours being duped?".