10 'Emotional' Video Game Endings That Fell Completely FLAT

Despite their best efforts, these endings ensured there wasn't a single wet eye in the house.

By Iain Taylor /

Video game endings have come a long way since the days of a single screen offering a heartfelt "Conglaturation" to the player. From Persona 3's fateful rooftop finale to Big Boss' graveside salute in Metal Gear Solid 3, many a game has concluded with scenes that make the player weep like a Tesla shareholder after Elon Musk opens his mouth in public.

Advertisement

As video games have matured, so has their ability to deliver tear-jerking finales that resonate with the player long after the credits roll (we can only assume Nintendo never ported Mother 3 out of Japan because they felt enough guilt over emotionally devastating one country, let alone the entire planet). Unfortunately, as with any art form there have been times when creators' reaches have overextended their grasp, resulting in game endings more worthy of the loo than the Louvre.

As you have no doubt surmised, it is these toilet bound finales that will be the focus of this list. And to start us off, we have a relatively recent example of how not to kill off a protagonist...

10. Resident Evil: Village

The above scene is when Resident Evil' Village's conclusion begins a nosedive it never manages to pull up from.

Advertisement

Let's start with the "nothing but mold" bit. In Village's conclusion, we find out that protagonist Ethan Winters actually died in the introduction to Resident Evil 7 and that the player has been piloting a sentient pile of mold over the past two games. Then, before your mind even has time to boggle over the ridiculousness of this twist, Ethan has his heart ripped out by the game's big bad.  A shocking, tragic conclusion. Except Ethan is still alive! And he's rescued by the mysterious Duke! Except he's really dying! Finally, one (disappointing) final boss battle later, Ethan dies for good. 

Good flipping grief. Resident Evil: Village's conclusion feels less like an emotional roller-coaster and more like Capcom giving you repeated swirlies. "He's mold!" *flush* "He's dead!" *flush* "He's alive!" *flush* "Dead again!" *flush*. 

Each development is barely given any time to breathe, resulting in a finale that was clearly meant to be tear-jerking but just ends up bewildering the player with its breakneck pace and nonsensical plot twists.  

9. Marvel's Spider-Man

It's strange how storytelling work. Sometimes the people involved can do an impeccable job, yet the resulting tale falls flat on its face. Case in point - the death of Aunt May.

Advertisement

First off, full respect must be paid to the actors and technical artists behind this scene. Peter Parker's deathbed goodbye to Aunt May is beautifully shot and acted, with Yuri Lowenthal and Nancy Linari putting award-worthy effort into voicing their respective characters. Unfortunately, their good work is undone by the fact that, for the player, May's death feels more like saying goodbye to a passing acquaintance than a loved one.

Put simply, Aunt May does not get enough screen-time for her death to make an impact. Across the game's 20-hour run-time, May only gets a handful of minutes as an on-screen presence. This, unfortunately, means we've barely got to know her before she departs. It's as if the writers thought the affection people have for Aunt May the comic book character would transfer over to her video game counterpart, but it doesn't. As a result, when May dies in the game it comes across as a pale shadow of her iconic death in the comics.

(Although the video game May at least stays dead, whereas the one in comics turned out to be an actress hired by the Green Goblin to mess with Peter. As good an indicator as any as to why Marvel nearly went bankrupt in the nineties...)

8. Yakuza: Like A Dragon

The above pic shows Ryo Aoki, one of the most eminently punchable scumbags in a series famed for its scumbag-punching.

Advertisement

Like A Dragon is no stranger to loathsome villains, and Ryo is one of the series' most reprehensible reprobates. A charismatic politician who campaigns on a platform of cleaning up Japan, Ryo is a ruthless monster who delights in tormenting the downtrodden. He deports illegal citizens after they sign up for a scheme promising them legal employment; he dismantles government programs designed to help the poor because of a grudge against the politician who founded them; and he taunts the aforesaid politician on the latter's deathbed.

Ryo is an amoral, sociopathic scumbag who thoroughly deserves the ass-kicking he receives at the end of the game. Which makes it all the weirder than Like A Dragon tries to generate sympathy for him at the end.

As it turns out, Ryo is actually protagonist Ichiban Kasuga's long-lost half-brother (because the Yakuza series is essentially a long-running soap opera, except every story arc ends with shirtless men beating seven bells out of each other). As Ryo lies dying in Ichiban's arms - having been stabbed by one of the many people he betrayed in his rise to power - Ichiban's tears feel wasted on the man he's grieving for.

Sorry for your loss, Ichiban, but after watching your brother be an irredeemable monster for 60 hours it's damn near impossible to join you in your tears. 

7. Sonic Frontiers

You know an ending's bad when the developers create an entire DLC to retcon it out of existence.

Advertisement

As revealed in a translated interview on Sonic City, Sonic Team were not happy with the final hours of Sonic Frontiers (that's a lot of Sonic for one sentence). Frontiers' finale was essentially a rough draft that made its way to market, as the game's troubled production meant the developers didn't have time to create a satisfying finale. This was especially clear in the ending, in which Dr. Eggman's AI daughter Sage sacrifices herself for humanity.

Despite stellar acting from Eggman VA Mike Pollock, the moment fails to land. Much like the rest of the final act, Sage's sacrifice feels like it was hastily put together - so hastily, it gets undone in the post credits scene in which we see Eggman recreating Sage's software in his secret lab. 

And even that scene - along with the final act in its entirety - was rewritten with the launch of the Final Horzion DLC. This free add-on delivered the intended conclusion to the game by introducing three new playable characters, a boss fight that wasn't an Ikaruga reskin, and an ending that didn't go for cheap waterworks by killing off a character with all the emotion of ticking an item off a shopping list. 

While SEGA are to be lauded for making Final Horzion a free download, hopefully the next Sonic game won't make us wait over a year for a conclusion that doesn't feel like it was written on a developer's napkin.

6. Ghostwire: Tokyo

Attention, developers: simply saying "that character is related to the protagonist" is not a shortcut for making us care about them. You still need to give them a personality, so we actually feel something when they die. 

Advertisement

Case in point - Mari from Ghostwire: Tokyo.

In Tango Gameworks' supernatural adventure, protagonist Akito is driven by his goal of saving his comatose sister from the clutches of the madman who kidnapped her. Unfortunately, that previous sentence sums up the entirety of Mari's character: Sister, Comatose, Kidnapped.

Three bullet points do not a compelling character make, and the end result is that the final scene creates a marked disconnect between player and protagonist. Akito thwarts the bad guy but fails to save his sister, resulting in him bawling his eyes out over her lifeless body. While undoubtedly sad for Akito, Mari's total lack of characterization means that for the player, he might as well be crying over the loss of his favourite Pokemon card.

Ghostwire never once treats Mari as a person, only as an object that needs saving, and as a result it's impossible to care about the poor girl's demise. 

5. The Witcher 3 (Bad Ending)

Many thanks to the talented WhatCulture staffer who whipped up the above picture to explain why Witcher 3's worst ending was more rage-inducing than tear-jerking.

Advertisement

In CD Proket's seminal trilogy concluder, the ending you get depends on how you interact with Ciri across several key scenes. Should you make too many wrong choices in these moments, the ending sees Ciri getting killed in the final battle. This results in the final scene of the game - and indeed, the entire trilogy - being Geralt (Ciri's father-figure and the player character) clutching her pendant while being swarmed by monsters.

It's a tragic ending, yes, but not a satisfying one. Firstly, Ciri's death completely undermines all the foreshadowing in the game about her following in Geralt's footsteps and becoming a Witcher herself. As a result, Ciri's demise is more baffling than upsetting - a poorly executed plot twist that annoys more than it surprises.

Secondly, the criteria to get Ciri's 'good' ending is utterly maddening. Told Ciri to stand up for herself in an important meeting? She dies. Shared a beer with her instead of having a snowball fight? She dies. Told her to restrain her violent impulses instead of indulging in them? Guess what, she lives! No, only joking, of course she dies.

Granted, the game does allow for a couple of 'wrong' choices. But when the wrong choice is so unclear, it's easy to accidentally kill Geralt's adopted daughter through nothing but good intentions. 

4. Mass Effect 3

Despite the premise of this article, it's not difficult to make this writer cry (hell, re-reading Aunt May's comic book death for the nth time was enough to set off the waterworks). Given that, Commander Shephard's self-sacrifice at the conclusion of Mass Effect 3 should have resulted in enough salty tears to short-circuit the laptop it was played on. Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending how you look at it), the laptop remained dry as a bone as the credits rolled

Advertisement

More than a decade on, Mass Effect 3's ending has become a byword in the gaming industry for how not to close out a story. After three games and five years of fist-pumpingly great galactic space opera, Mass Effect stumbled at the finish line with an ending so abrupt it evoked memories of Monty Python and the Holy Grail's "everyone gets arrested" anti-climax. 

After stumbling into the final room, Shephard is essentially given a list of bullet points and asked to tick which noble death they'd prefer. It's a staggeringly blunt conclusion to the series, knocking all the wind out of the occasion like a lead pipe to the gut and ensuring Mass Effect ended on the flattest note imaginable. It's as if Bioware, having heard the old adage about it being the journey and not the destination, took that as a cue to spend years crafting the ultimate road trip only to ensure it ended by deliberately crashing into a tree. 

3. Wanted: Dead

Ah, Wanted: Dead. One of the best-worst games of all time, it's only fitting that it's conclusion is as bizarre and tonally off-beat as the rest of the experience.

Advertisement

The conclusion to 2023's roughest diamond sees heroine Agent Stone making a tearful call to an adoption agency regarding a child whose parents died in a murder-suicide case earlier in the game. Stone's conversation with the boy at the scene of the crime is genuinely touching, but that doesn't excuse how farcical her decision to adopt him is.

Like most of Wanted: Dead's storytelling, there's no build-up to Stone's decision to adopt this child - the first we know of it is during her tearful call to the agency. The player is clearly meant to cry along with Stone when her request is denied, but instead we're left scratching our heads at why she made the effort in the first place. As far as we know, she only ever had the one conversation with the child, and her lifestyle isn't exactly conducive to healthy child-care - hell, the scene ends with her apartment being swarmed by a special forces team out for her blood!

Like most of Wanted: Dead's plot, Stone's thwarted adoption is dumped into the narrative with absolutely no regard for narrative cohesion, plot relevance, or basic common sense. Just one more reason Wanted: Dead is the video game equivalent of The Room...

2. Final Fantasy XVI

Final Fantasy XVI's ending is what happens when someone tells a writer "less is more", only for the cloth-eared scribe to hear it as "death is more". As a result, the latest entry in the Final Fantasy series concludes with not one but three major characters kicking the bucket in a contrived attempt at wringing emotion out of the player. 

Advertisement

Which makes it all the more embarrassing that none of these deaths land. At all.

Let's start with the first fatality. FF XVI ends with a triumvirate of heroes engaging big baddie Ultima in a climactic clash, and the first to fall is Dion. Sadly, by this point in the story Dion is so extraneous to narrative requirements that he may as well have gone to battle wearing a red shirt. Sure enough, he's the first to fall, having fulfilled his remaining duty of "guy who dies to show off how strong the big bad is".

Next up is Joshua, the brother of protagonist Clive Rosfield. Despite excellent acting from Ben Starr (Clive's VA), Joshua's death fails to live up to its potential. The death itself happens too quickly, and there's barely any time to dwell on the emotional fallout before the rousing final battle music kicks in and you begin the process of knocking Ultima's block off.

And then there's Clive. The older Rosfield brother's death comes out of nowhere, as Clive suffers from ye olde anime trope of having his body slowly disintegrate after using too much power. It's so abrupt that the only emotion it evokes is ironic laughter, leaving the player shaking their head in disbelief that such a ham-fisted conclusion made its way past the first draft.

Three deaths, zero tears. A pitiful conclusion to a polarizing game.

1. Astro Bot

2024's Astro Bot has many gifts, but storytelling is not one of them. Indeed, the Astro Plot (sorry) is mostly AWOL from the game, right until the conclusion tries to force emotion into the story with all the grace of an angry toddler trying to jam a star-shaped puzzle piece into a square hole.

Advertisement

Astro Bot's conclusion sees the eponymous android being dragged into a black hole by his nemesis, only for the robots he's spent the game rescuing to collectively grab his hand and try to pull him back from the brink. Astro, however, decides to let go and sacrifice himself to the void to ensure the other robots' safety (don't worry, he still survives).

Astro's sacrifice is clearly meant to be a sombre moment, but it's more eye-rolling than tear-jerking as it makes the other robots look absolutely useless. Astro has spent the entire game rescuing them, and this was the game's chance to show that good deeds come back round - just as Astro saved them, they can now save him. But no, Astro has to play the hero one last time, like a diva superstar insisting the spotlight shines on them at all times. Yes, the robots do contribute parts to his repair job, but by then the moment has passed - they had their chance to save the hero, they blew it, and was only dumb luck that he survived.

Given that the other robots are all based on characters spread across thirty years of PlayStation's history, Astro Bot's ascension to Astro Messiah is even more self-aggrandizing. Essentially, the developers are stating their character is superior to all those who came before him, inadvertently turning the adorable android into an arrogant Mary Sue.

Frankly, the the ending would have been more satisfying if it simply consisted of the titular bot turning to the player and saying "I am Astro Bot, and that's your Astro lot".

Advertisement