10 Saddest Video Game Endings Of All Time
Sometimes a downer ending can be the stuff of legend.
Eliciting sympathy and remorse in an audience is one of the most challenging tasks of any writer, filmmaker or game designer. Excitement, laughter and fear can all be manufactured in a moment with the right combination of factors – but tragedy requires in-depth characters, motivations and a world indifferent to the desires of the hero.
As the video game industry continues to grow, so to does the quality of the writing behind our favourite games.
Whether they are big hit blockbusters or heavily budgeted indie titles, believable characters and emotionally driven motivations are often enough to help us suspend disbelief for the most unlikely of world events or outdated graphics.
As we invest hours of time into bonding with our on-screen companions, it is natural that their motivations become our own, and whether we sometimes have the omniscience to know more than they do, or we're faced with an impossible choice, often a tragic ending will resonate most heavily.
10. Nier
The game sees its titular hero and his companions, Kainé and Emil, battle monsters known as Shades as he seeks to be reunited with his daughter, curing her of her mysterious illness. While Emil is sacrifices himself to aid Nier on his quest, the ending is ultimately cheerful as father and daughter reunite.
Play the game a second time, and Emil will even survive this sacrifice.
Even better, right?
Well, play the game a third time and the player will find Kainé dying in agony. The hero is presented with a choice to either kill Kainé, or sacrifice himself.
The catch? Sacrificing your hero truly means sacrificing the character you have grown attached to over three iterations of the game. All memory of them is wiped from the game characters, and to make this more real, Square Enix throw in a fourth wall break by erasing all save data from the console, and starting a new game prevents the player from naming the character the same name as used previously.
9. Brothers: A Tale Of Two Sons
With their mother already drowned at sea, Naia and younger brother Naiee set out to find the Tree of Life to save their sick father. The bond between the cooperating brothers is made all the stronger by the unique control mechanic where the player controls each brother with a designated analogue stick on the controller. Each brother literally cannot progress without the other, solidifying their dependence on one another.
So it is all the sadder when the girl they rescue turns out to be an enormous, grotesque spider and, despite the brothers defeating her, Naia is mortally wounded, proving once again that spiders are the route of all evil!
The two venture on to the Tree of Life and Naiee climbs the tree to find the water, but is too late, his brother succumbing to his wounds before he can drink. Although Naiee makes it home, overcoming his fear of water and healing his father, the time we spend bonding with the two brothers, witnessing how they were two halves of a whole, makes Naia's death all the harder to bear.
8. Red Dead Redemption
After John Marston's first encounter with his old gang leader doesn't go so well, John finds shelter with the MacFarlanes. His titular redemption begins with some farm work before continuing on, traversing southern USA and Northern Mexico, hunting down his old gang and doing good deeds – with the occasional town shoot-out and gambling binge to see him through – until he at last brings his former mates to justice and rides home to be with his family, settling into the life of a farmer.
Then the Bureau turn up at his doorstep, ready to take down the final member of Williamson's gang. Despite John's best efforts, he is out-manned and out-gunned, and we are left to watch with tragic inevitability as he makes his final stand from his barn, only to fall dead beneath a hail of bullets.
Of course a few years later son, Jack Marston, gets his revenge – but this is little consolation for the loss for one of the last true cowboys who we knew had genuinely redeemed himself.
7. Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII
So anyone who has played Final Fantasy VII knew this was coming, but if anything it actually made the ending sadder. Having escaped the clutches of Shinra and Hojo's genetic experiments, Zack tries to escape with a catatonic Cloud to Midgar.
As the pair approach the city barrier, their transport is descended on by a huge number of Shinra soldiers.
Watching Zack fight bravely against waves of enemy soldiers as he tries desperately to defend the lives of both Cloud and himself is all the more tragic because we know his heroic efforts are in vain. Despite the numbers he kills, Zack is eventually fatally wounded. As he lays dying, he passes his Buster Sword to a confused Cloud that is slowly coming out of his catatonic state.
What makes the ending all the sadder is knowing how quickly Cloud forgets him, how readily he assumes Zack's identity, and the effort it takes in FFVII to learn the identity of Zack and Cloud's true origins.
6. Mother 3
Mother 3 starts with the death of Lucas' mother, the disappearance of his twin brother, and abandonment by his father. Things can only get better right?
Well, no. After Lucas and his friends pursue and kill a mysterious masked man bent on breaking the seal of the Dark Dragon, it turns out the masked man was Lucas' twin brother all along. Despite stopping his brother, the Dark Dragon is revived anyway and proceeds to destroy the world, painfully and violently killing everyone in it.
Okay, so the game goes on to hint that Lucas utilised the Dark Dragon to rebuild the world - but it's a bit 'too little, too late' for the billions of people that just suffered an excruciating death.
5. Shadow Of The Colossus
Sword in hand and on the back off Agro, Wander travels the vast plain, one-by-one, killing each of the 16 Colossi in the hope that the mysterious Dormin can revive his maiden, Mono. Yet, as each Colossus falls, Wander's hair grows darker and skin becomes more pale.
By the time he slays the final Colossus, Wander is too late to realise he has been tricked by Dormin, and by killing the Colossi has fully restored the demon's power. Before Wander can react, his body is possessed by Dormin, forcing horns to sprout from his forehead.
Battled back by pursuing warriors, Wander is dragged into a pool along with Dormin, seemingly trapped, until Mono awakens to find a horned infant lying in the pool. Together with an injured Agro, Mono carries the baby away.
While the ending leaves some wiggle room for hope that Wander might redeem himself, and Agro doesn't die on the bridge like we thought he had, the player can't help but mourn for 16 Colossi that were slain. The ending gives new perspective; the Colossi were good, pure and protectors, while Wander was the evil that relentlessly murdered each one.
4. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
The final battle in MGS3 is sad enough, with Snake forced to kill his former friend and future namesake, The Boss. With her death comes the truth that she never betrayed her country, but was sent to recover The Legacy, a massive war fund originally setup by The Philosophers.
Yet, once Volgin fired the nuke, she knew she had to sacrifice her reputation in order to protect the reputation of the USA and prevent World War 3. As Snake inherits the title of Big Boss, he becomes disgusted with how the USA betrays its greatest hero, and we see the beginnings of Militaires Sans Frontières as he stands over The Boss' grave and salutes.
The Boss' sacrifice for peace leads to Zero and Big Boss forming The Patriots, which in time become corrupted. Zero creates the AI systems that control the world and fund the war economy, while Big Boss becomes too enraptured in his ideal of freeing soldiers from government abuse, eventually forming terrorist nation, Outer Heaven.
All in all, not the legacy she was hoping for.
3. The Walking Dead (Season 1)
Lee is the pseudo-father-figure to season 1 Clementine who proves to be both a leader and voice of wisdom for the fellow survivors, but more importantly, is Clem's protector.
This makes it all the more heartbreaking when Lee gets bitten. From this moment we know it is the beginning of the end for Lee, but we have to soldier on and find the now missing Clementine. After tracking her down and learning that some of our earlier actions had further reaching consequences than we had hoped, the ever-weakening Lee helps Clementine to safety.
As Lee collapses, clinging to life and barely able to keep his eyes open, he remains the strong guardian to Clem he had promised he would be, offering the tearful girl reassurances that she is ready and capable to survive without him. Her coming of age is reflected as we finally take control of Clementine instead of Lee, with our brutal first decision to be whether or not we kill the man that protected us throughout the entire game.
Whether the player shoots or leaves Lee to become a walker, the parting is poignant and lasting.
2. To The Moon
Johnny, an old man, lays unconscious and dying in his home. As part of his last will and testament he has paid for a corporation to come to his death bed and, in his final moments, implant memories to allow him to believe he fulfilled his lifelong wish of travelling to the moon.
Unfortunately, no-one knows why Johnny held this wish, and the doctors must work back through Johnny's memories until they can uncover the source of his wish.
After piecing Johnny's forgotten memories together and fulfilling their promise to create a memory where Johnny and childhood sweetheart, River, fly to the moon, the ending is actually one of tragedy, unfulfilled love and forgotten romance.
Whatever his final memories, the corporation is unable to change the lives Johnny and River actually lived, where they never connected with one another the way they could have.
1. Final Fantasy X
Halfway through a game of loveable characters and blooming relationships, hero Tidus finds out the unexpected: he's not real.
Rather, he and his city were the physical manifestation of a collective imagination by the population of the real Zanarkand. Ever the hero, Tidus, battles on, determined to save Spira from his father-turned-sea monster, Sin, and its puppeteer, the summoner, Yu Yevon.
By defeating not only Sin, but Yu Yevon, the team end the cycle of destruction, but in doing so, the sleeping Fayth can finally rest. As they pass over to the farplane, the team watch as other characters dependent on the Fayth cross over.
The aeons, Auron, and finally, Tidus. With emotional glances and a ghostly hug, Tidus passes through Yuna as he leaps into the farplane, high-fiving his father that stands in anticipation to welcome him.
--
What are your saddest video game endings of all time? Let us know in the comments!